Disbanding the guild?
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
Brittfire
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Tue Dec 13, 2005 1:17 am
i like bobs idea, i dont see it as splitting the guild, just creating a stronger core of players that vouch FOR THEMSELVES that they'll be able to raid and those that, like me, that sometimes like to hide on an alt :P
in the end, the way raids are organised wont change much, just the knowledge that the raid will be capable of facing whatever its poised against.
in this respect, i'll most likly be considered a casual for the next month, then kick back into raiding mode. being the hunter with the second highest dkp earnt means that i've had to of been on a damn fair few raids.. and it would be nice to have a little comment next to my name saying if i'm ready to push forward.
also on this note, ashran (my gf) has spoken to me about her concern about the guild splitting or the ranks, on which, she would most definatly consider herself a casual, due to commitment of keeping horses, leading to low raid attendance, but also on viewing the idea of casual and hardcore, she liked this notion, due to the fact it probably wont affect her raid attendance much anyway...
in the end, its just a little marker to afirm what is already an unspoken rule, what would we do if we didnt invite the geared tanks becouse the other wanted to do it? much of what we do would be impossiable. so to say equility is what needs to be kept, then a great many thing will be lost, they'll always be those that are NEEDED by a raid to achieve its goals.
just give me my my tag and the kick in the ass in the right direction to get this ball rolling. just stop the political bicering, it never did anyone anygood, ever.
in the end, the way raids are organised wont change much, just the knowledge that the raid will be capable of facing whatever its poised against.
in this respect, i'll most likly be considered a casual for the next month, then kick back into raiding mode. being the hunter with the second highest dkp earnt means that i've had to of been on a damn fair few raids.. and it would be nice to have a little comment next to my name saying if i'm ready to push forward.
also on this note, ashran (my gf) has spoken to me about her concern about the guild splitting or the ranks, on which, she would most definatly consider herself a casual, due to commitment of keeping horses, leading to low raid attendance, but also on viewing the idea of casual and hardcore, she liked this notion, due to the fact it probably wont affect her raid attendance much anyway...
in the end, its just a little marker to afirm what is already an unspoken rule, what would we do if we didnt invite the geared tanks becouse the other wanted to do it? much of what we do would be impossiable. so to say equility is what needs to be kept, then a great many thing will be lost, they'll always be those that are NEEDED by a raid to achieve its goals.
just give me my my tag and the kick in the ass in the right direction to get this ball rolling. just stop the political bicering, it never did anyone anygood, ever.
TBC update
tomato ketchup will be a required reagent for feign death and rogues can apply huntersmark with a crayon!
tomato ketchup will be a required reagent for feign death and rogues can apply huntersmark with a crayon!
-
Shoarmabob
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
- Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
indeed, I never played other games with SSX, thanks for explaining that the mod system is a little different in WOW then :P
The thing is, though, that when i speak of a hardcore guild, or a hardcore section, i don't mean union/infamous/synergy style hardcore (meaning you have to have 90% attendance, the best gear available, people shout at you, you have to spec a certain way etc etc etc)
All I mean, is that people with the raider rank, will still be SSX, and will still have to uphold SSX values, and are still equal to casual rank members. The only thing the rank does, is showing where your interests lie at the moment, so mods know who to invite. It basically makes things easier for the one inviting people to raids, because you KNOW raider people will have all the stuff, and will give it everything they got.
This doesn't mean in any way that casuals are lazy, they just have other interests.
This also doesn't mean casuals will never get to raid, most likely they won't raid naxxramas or AQ, but hey, they did sign up to be a casual, and can switch whenever they want.
So basically my plan was this:
2 tabs, raiders and casuals
A raider can pick a few days on which he wishes to raid (he doesn't have to raid every day, noone could keep that up and it's supposed to be fun), on these days he is expected to turn up unless he said he couldn't make it a day or more before (or he has a valid excuse after, like his PC broke down or whatever), he is expected to have farmed all consumables needed for the raid on that day.
A casual won't get into a lot of raids, however he can do whatever he likes, he doesn't have to farm consumables and he doesn't have to turn up on certain days, so he has more freedom.
A person can switch between ranks at any time, by telling a classleader or a moderator he wants to switch.
I realise these 2 ranks indentify ourselves, which on the website says we shouldn't, but is a guildsplit better? I for one would most likely quit the game (if not, find another guild) if SSX decides to split itself to a real hardcore guild (synergy style) and a real casual guild. Why? because I do love the SSX, however, I, too can be considered casual: I can raid 2 days a week, and i don't even attend those 2 days every week, but wheb I show up, I show up well prepared and ready to raid. splitting the guild would force me into the casual guild, and yes, I would have fun there, for a while, but let's face it. I have 2 level 60's, several lvl 40+ alts and I've helped guildies with their instances a lot. There is very little to do in WoW except grinding and PvP (more grinding). While i DO enjoy PvPing with the guild, and helping guildies, i just can't see me playing WoW that long when the only thing left in the game is grinding and helping guildies. I've had several raidbreaks, because I got tired of it, I would enjoy just being casual, helping guildies or farming cash or potions, But I love raiding with you, there's just nothing that can quite compare to facing and beating a challenge with 39 good friends, and ofcourse the rush of that first bosskill.
Call me a raidwhore, but I only raid because it's the only way i can advance in the game (by conquering new content as well as gearing up my character). If I had to take a break from raiding to save SSX-WoW, I would, I wouldn't leave because of a lack of raids, but I would only keep playing for a few months maybe, after that I'd just get bored out of my mind.
The only thing I'm trying to do here, is make the game fun and fair for both the raiders and the casuals, by trying to get some progress going. Nobody likes doing the same over and over again. Also, the ranks will be completly equal to eachother, both will just be normal members, the only difference is that SSX member A focusses more on raiding, while SSX member B focusses more on just being casual (PvP, smaller instances, grinding, events etc). If a raider mocks a casual because he's a casual, he will be dealt with the same way as when a member now would mock another member.
they aren't ranks as much as showing where your interests lie and where you want to invest your time in.
Also, my idea doesn't really have anything to do with QD's list of requirements :P they're more like seperate ideas.
I hope I clarified it a bit, I don't want us to go truly "hardcore" just SSX hardcore (if that makes any sense
)
The thing is, though, that when i speak of a hardcore guild, or a hardcore section, i don't mean union/infamous/synergy style hardcore (meaning you have to have 90% attendance, the best gear available, people shout at you, you have to spec a certain way etc etc etc)
All I mean, is that people with the raider rank, will still be SSX, and will still have to uphold SSX values, and are still equal to casual rank members. The only thing the rank does, is showing where your interests lie at the moment, so mods know who to invite. It basically makes things easier for the one inviting people to raids, because you KNOW raider people will have all the stuff, and will give it everything they got.
This doesn't mean in any way that casuals are lazy, they just have other interests.
This also doesn't mean casuals will never get to raid, most likely they won't raid naxxramas or AQ, but hey, they did sign up to be a casual, and can switch whenever they want.
So basically my plan was this:
2 tabs, raiders and casuals
A raider can pick a few days on which he wishes to raid (he doesn't have to raid every day, noone could keep that up and it's supposed to be fun), on these days he is expected to turn up unless he said he couldn't make it a day or more before (or he has a valid excuse after, like his PC broke down or whatever), he is expected to have farmed all consumables needed for the raid on that day.
A casual won't get into a lot of raids, however he can do whatever he likes, he doesn't have to farm consumables and he doesn't have to turn up on certain days, so he has more freedom.
A person can switch between ranks at any time, by telling a classleader or a moderator he wants to switch.
I realise these 2 ranks indentify ourselves, which on the website says we shouldn't, but is a guildsplit better? I for one would most likely quit the game (if not, find another guild) if SSX decides to split itself to a real hardcore guild (synergy style) and a real casual guild. Why? because I do love the SSX, however, I, too can be considered casual: I can raid 2 days a week, and i don't even attend those 2 days every week, but wheb I show up, I show up well prepared and ready to raid. splitting the guild would force me into the casual guild, and yes, I would have fun there, for a while, but let's face it. I have 2 level 60's, several lvl 40+ alts and I've helped guildies with their instances a lot. There is very little to do in WoW except grinding and PvP (more grinding). While i DO enjoy PvPing with the guild, and helping guildies, i just can't see me playing WoW that long when the only thing left in the game is grinding and helping guildies. I've had several raidbreaks, because I got tired of it, I would enjoy just being casual, helping guildies or farming cash or potions, But I love raiding with you, there's just nothing that can quite compare to facing and beating a challenge with 39 good friends, and ofcourse the rush of that first bosskill.
Call me a raidwhore, but I only raid because it's the only way i can advance in the game (by conquering new content as well as gearing up my character). If I had to take a break from raiding to save SSX-WoW, I would, I wouldn't leave because of a lack of raids, but I would only keep playing for a few months maybe, after that I'd just get bored out of my mind.
The only thing I'm trying to do here, is make the game fun and fair for both the raiders and the casuals, by trying to get some progress going. Nobody likes doing the same over and over again. Also, the ranks will be completly equal to eachother, both will just be normal members, the only difference is that SSX member A focusses more on raiding, while SSX member B focusses more on just being casual (PvP, smaller instances, grinding, events etc). If a raider mocks a casual because he's a casual, he will be dealt with the same way as when a member now would mock another member.
they aren't ranks as much as showing where your interests lie and where you want to invest your time in.
Also, my idea doesn't really have anything to do with QD's list of requirements :P they're more like seperate ideas.
I hope I clarified it a bit, I don't want us to go truly "hardcore" just SSX hardcore (if that makes any sense
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
So who here would be "casual" and who here would be "harccore"?
The nice thing about being SSX and NOT SSC, is we have some luxury when it coems to definitions. We're not stuck in completely dogmatic definitions of who and what we are, sure there are some guiding principles, but even those have SOME wiggle room. So long as we're all doing it TOGETHER and we do it CAREFULLY, we can TRY just about anything.
If those attempts fail, we have to be ready to change again though, and we have to be able to recognize failures.
It does work both ways, though. If you want to raid, you damn well better put the effort into it, your friends are counting on you. If you fail your friends, you fail, period. So far, I like the idea of seperate positions inside the guild that can be fluidly changed better than any full on split (because I personally believe that if you split, it will end up being for good, that's just the way these things work out).
So, what do you really think, are you interested and WILLING to raid? or are you really just fine with the way things are? Probably should be a poll...
The nice thing about being SSX and NOT SSC, is we have some luxury when it coems to definitions. We're not stuck in completely dogmatic definitions of who and what we are, sure there are some guiding principles, but even those have SOME wiggle room. So long as we're all doing it TOGETHER and we do it CAREFULLY, we can TRY just about anything.
If those attempts fail, we have to be ready to change again though, and we have to be able to recognize failures.
It does work both ways, though. If you want to raid, you damn well better put the effort into it, your friends are counting on you. If you fail your friends, you fail, period. So far, I like the idea of seperate positions inside the guild that can be fluidly changed better than any full on split (because I personally believe that if you split, it will end up being for good, that's just the way these things work out).
So, what do you really think, are you interested and WILLING to raid? or are you really just fine with the way things are? Probably should be a poll...
No signature
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Want ppl to answer here, or want to see a poll up?Inquisitor wrote:So who here would be "casual" and who here would be "harccore"?
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
Himico
- Posts: 32
- Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 2:30 am
Not read all posts but I did read some of bobs post about ranking inside the guild, casuals and raiders. Thats a good idea, especially for a guild like SSX to be able to stick together and have this great community and yet fulfil some of the members need to actually have some raiding and to push it and try to achieve goals within the guilds more "hardcore" side.
If you want to get somewhere you have to have limits, rules and try to push it to the edge. And Im quite sure a guild like SSX can handle it and yet be a 'family guild'. People enjoy each others company, and can talk about everything and have discussions so everyone can make their own valid point and have their say. That, IMO, is one of the hardest and the best part to achieve in a guild.
Dont let the guild fall apart, and dont force the people who love this guild to leave just because they actually want to do some progress, people are actually paying for this game to do more then chatting you know<3.
SSX is a great guild, try to make it better for all kind of gamers, not only casuals =).
If you want to get somewhere you have to have limits, rules and try to push it to the edge. And Im quite sure a guild like SSX can handle it and yet be a 'family guild'. People enjoy each others company, and can talk about everything and have discussions so everyone can make their own valid point and have their say. That, IMO, is one of the hardest and the best part to achieve in a guild.
Dont let the guild fall apart, and dont force the people who love this guild to leave just because they actually want to do some progress, people are actually paying for this game to do more then chatting you know<3.
SSX is a great guild, try to make it better for all kind of gamers, not only casuals =).
-
Eolas
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2006 7:43 pm
- Location: Malta
A lot of what has been said here shows how strongly knit ssX community is in its majority. After reading more I am more in favour of the dual tag system rather than a split - that way 'casuals' and 'raiders' can still do stuff together such as pvp, help with quests and other stuff. They are still ONE guild.
Also it should be relatively easy to change tags as people can be raiders for a period of time and casuals at other.
Also it should be relatively easy to change tags as people can be raiders for a period of time and casuals at other.
"Do unto others what you have them do to you" - Jesus
-
Lightforge
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
- Location: In your house
Words of wisdom these.Himico wrote:people are actually paying for this game to do more then chatting you know<3.
SSX is a great guild, try to make it better for all kind of gamers, not only casuals =).
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|
-
Kon
- Posts: 1528
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
- Location: USA
Well, just spent a good 15 minutes reading this thread, and realized I had just read the first page.
I am not on Outland or EU, and my WoW subscription has run out, but I still feel I should comment now, and as there are 106 replies, I assume that most of the actual Outland members have already posted their thoughts. So here goes.
The guild should, not under any circumstances, be disbanded. I think we all agree on this.
I am 100% for throwing out scheduled raids and the DKP system. We should simply organize on-the-spot raids if enough people want to do something. Loot should be distributed using the good old Need/Greed Dice system that may I remind you is built into the game to prevent fights over loot. On Mannoroth we schedule raids, but we do not have DKP and we just use the dice. There has not been one argument over loot.
Many people may leave because of this, but so be it. It is important to remember that you do not have to be in the SSX to be a friend of the SSX. There is also no reason for two tags. If you only care about loot, you shouldn't be in the SSX. I realize some people who are SSX are also into hardcore raiding. If you are looking for hardcore raiding and progression, you may leave and join a hardcore raiding guild. I'm sure you will still keep in touch with your friends in the SSX. If we did go to two tags, the raiding guild would inevitably bring in tons of bad people, who would tarnish the reputation of the SSX.
Also, whenever a noob asks a question, no matter how stupid, please answer. If you are not in an instance or questing in a group, and someone asks for help, go help them.
IMO the SSX should be the epitome of "casual" and friendly in WoW.
The guild should, not under any circumstances, be disbanded. I think we all agree on this.
I am 100% for throwing out scheduled raids and the DKP system. We should simply organize on-the-spot raids if enough people want to do something. Loot should be distributed using the good old Need/Greed Dice system that may I remind you is built into the game to prevent fights over loot. On Mannoroth we schedule raids, but we do not have DKP and we just use the dice. There has not been one argument over loot.
Many people may leave because of this, but so be it. It is important to remember that you do not have to be in the SSX to be a friend of the SSX. There is also no reason for two tags. If you only care about loot, you shouldn't be in the SSX. I realize some people who are SSX are also into hardcore raiding. If you are looking for hardcore raiding and progression, you may leave and join a hardcore raiding guild. I'm sure you will still keep in touch with your friends in the SSX. If we did go to two tags, the raiding guild would inevitably bring in tons of bad people, who would tarnish the reputation of the SSX.
Also, whenever a noob asks a question, no matter how stupid, please answer. If you are not in an instance or questing in a group, and someone asks for help, go help them.
IMO the SSX should be the epitome of "casual" and friendly in WoW.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."
-
sam.freak
- Posts: 402
- Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
- Location: under your desk
The thing I liked about being in SSX was our ability to raid things that, and do so with less drama and restrictions than other guilds. We were friends, we had a TON of fun, our capabilities were challenged and we overcame adversities constantly.
That being said, I love everyone in this guild. Every single member that joined us in the last year was judged against a very tough set of criteria, and for the most part (there's always some exceptions) they settled in well.
Like I, who joined the guild before those criteria were quite as stringent (and I still don't know if I had gotten in had I gone through the membership process as it is today) acclimated (sp?) also.
However, as much as I like the people in the guild, I play this game to beat it. Just like any game I play. I am currently working the Auction house to accumulate cash for myself. I have tons of resistance gear that I had made / bought for dkp which is now for the most part gathering virtual dust in the bank. I have concerned myself with the abilities of my class and with strategies for encounters for countless hours.
I have become Class leader (by no means a position compareable to Moderator imho) because I wanted to impart my knowledge to the other guildmembers that share the class I play and love, and I can only say I'm goddamn proud of them. I can say that SSX has the most knowledgeable and capable Paladin squad on Outland.
A paladin by default is a supporting class. We are more or less unkillable when we are solo, but we really shine when we are in a group. I don't have any significant alts nor do I have any intention to start one.
So where am I to go from here? I have achieved a lot, both for myself and I like to think for the guild. I have been present in all but a few first boss kills this guild has achieved, it's what I play this game for. But the guild doesn't need me for the content being tackled anymore. I could see that on the twin emperors kill, and I could see that on last night's BWL run.
I've got about 50-odd Molten Core runs under my belt, and about 20 or so BWL clears. I have done every other instance in the game at least as often, or in the case of Strat Baron while I was farming it to become exalted with Argent Dawn, three times a day for two months, give or take a few.
IF SSX stops doing high end content I will have no choice to either stop playing WOW or find another guild that does. Yes that sounds egoistic, and it most likely is, but I'm not paying 12 euro a month for a glorified chatroom.
That being said, I love everyone in this guild. Every single member that joined us in the last year was judged against a very tough set of criteria, and for the most part (there's always some exceptions) they settled in well.
Like I, who joined the guild before those criteria were quite as stringent (and I still don't know if I had gotten in had I gone through the membership process as it is today) acclimated (sp?) also.
However, as much as I like the people in the guild, I play this game to beat it. Just like any game I play. I am currently working the Auction house to accumulate cash for myself. I have tons of resistance gear that I had made / bought for dkp which is now for the most part gathering virtual dust in the bank. I have concerned myself with the abilities of my class and with strategies for encounters for countless hours.
I have become Class leader (by no means a position compareable to Moderator imho) because I wanted to impart my knowledge to the other guildmembers that share the class I play and love, and I can only say I'm goddamn proud of them. I can say that SSX has the most knowledgeable and capable Paladin squad on Outland.
A paladin by default is a supporting class. We are more or less unkillable when we are solo, but we really shine when we are in a group. I don't have any significant alts nor do I have any intention to start one.
So where am I to go from here? I have achieved a lot, both for myself and I like to think for the guild. I have been present in all but a few first boss kills this guild has achieved, it's what I play this game for. But the guild doesn't need me for the content being tackled anymore. I could see that on the twin emperors kill, and I could see that on last night's BWL run.
I've got about 50-odd Molten Core runs under my belt, and about 20 or so BWL clears. I have done every other instance in the game at least as often, or in the case of Strat Baron while I was farming it to become exalted with Argent Dawn, three times a day for two months, give or take a few.
IF SSX stops doing high end content I will have no choice to either stop playing WOW or find another guild that does. Yes that sounds egoistic, and it most likely is, but I'm not paying 12 euro a month for a glorified chatroom.
-
Brittfire
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Tue Dec 13, 2005 1:17 am
quiz sumed it up with the term "fluid"
can we atleast give this a trial period?
can we atleast give this a trial period?
TBC update
tomato ketchup will be a required reagent for feign death and rogues can apply huntersmark with a crayon!
tomato ketchup will be a required reagent for feign death and rogues can apply huntersmark with a crayon!
-
Zebohraath
- Posts: 34
- Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 12:58 am
- Location: Hudiksvall, Sweden
Well...where do I start?
The second post for my part in this thread, and this one will be my last.
I have read this thread over and over again, and for each time I read it, I think I don't belong here.
---------------------------------------------------
"World of Warcraft - A new type of chatroom for the rich ppl, who have enough money to spend 12euro/month on it. You can see it as a replacement of the "oldschool-forums/IRC". Now you can create your own 3d-char and sit around by a campfire in the capitals of the world and chat with eachother. Occasionally when you get bored of it, you could always go and help others with their quests. It's always fun with SM for the 321'th time. Why explore new things? So why don't you go and buy it and play it for some years?"
---------------------------------------------------
Yes this is abit silly. Infact it's childish, but I see no other way of describing what I've read so far in this post. I get so confused of some parts that I have nothing to say else but:
Play the god damn game and go figure out why ppl have left and why we are having our current issues!
Some ppl that have posted in this thread doesnt seem to know this game at all. nothing....
WARNING!!!!!! WE ARE NOT A RAIDING GUILD!!!! WARNING!!!!
Then why does soo many ppl complain about not getting spots in the raid??
Then why are there issues about loot?
Then why is there often (note: often) 20 ppl online @19.00 and by 19.50 we have 40+?
"PPL comes online that time cause of work/school" go and hide behind a tree. hmmmm, can it be the raiding-times??????
We are/have always said that we are not a raiding guild.....but I say we are, no matter how much you are trying to prove it otherwiswe.
I seriously think that if we are not a raiding guild, we should remove our DKP-site and do UBRS for fun the rest of our wow time.
I play games for fun, thats my reason 1 for playing.
When playing with good ppl, ppl you can share the experiences with, ppl you just like very much, the game becomes 10x as fun.
I like the ppl in Wow-ssx so much. Wow is just a small part of my gaming atm, SSX is way more. I've spent many nights on vent having fun with you guys, and I've also spent many days, doing some pvp/instance or just having a chat with you.
This post may be the last thing I do in my wow-ssx time, and for that I am sorry. But something has to be done quickly if I'm going to continue with you guys.
(The post by QD is a great idea and I support it to 100%)
This has nothing to do about you, but about the game.
I'm sick and tired of it atm and can't stand another month of no progress.
Then I will quit this game for sure or change guild.
This game has nothing more to offer than endgame instances for many ppl, it's either quit, go for 14 (lol) or go raiding.
And when I first saw the movies from Naxx, it was like omg frigging cool! Something new to the game again!
But if we go with "well, we should take a raidbreak and see who are truly ssx material", thats just crap tbh
I would like to see things work out for us, but as we are falling apart more and more for each day cause of ppl getting bored, I doubt it.
The second post for my part in this thread, and this one will be my last.
I have read this thread over and over again, and for each time I read it, I think I don't belong here.
---------------------------------------------------
"World of Warcraft - A new type of chatroom for the rich ppl, who have enough money to spend 12euro/month on it. You can see it as a replacement of the "oldschool-forums/IRC". Now you can create your own 3d-char and sit around by a campfire in the capitals of the world and chat with eachother. Occasionally when you get bored of it, you could always go and help others with their quests. It's always fun with SM for the 321'th time. Why explore new things? So why don't you go and buy it and play it for some years?"
---------------------------------------------------
Yes this is abit silly. Infact it's childish, but I see no other way of describing what I've read so far in this post. I get so confused of some parts that I have nothing to say else but:
Play the god damn game and go figure out why ppl have left and why we are having our current issues!
Some ppl that have posted in this thread doesnt seem to know this game at all. nothing....
WARNING!!!!!! WE ARE NOT A RAIDING GUILD!!!! WARNING!!!!
Then why does soo many ppl complain about not getting spots in the raid??
Then why are there issues about loot?
Then why is there often (note: often) 20 ppl online @19.00 and by 19.50 we have 40+?
"PPL comes online that time cause of work/school" go and hide behind a tree. hmmmm, can it be the raiding-times??????
We are/have always said that we are not a raiding guild.....but I say we are, no matter how much you are trying to prove it otherwiswe.
I seriously think that if we are not a raiding guild, we should remove our DKP-site and do UBRS for fun the rest of our wow time.
I play games for fun, thats my reason 1 for playing.
When playing with good ppl, ppl you can share the experiences with, ppl you just like very much, the game becomes 10x as fun.
I like the ppl in Wow-ssx so much. Wow is just a small part of my gaming atm, SSX is way more. I've spent many nights on vent having fun with you guys, and I've also spent many days, doing some pvp/instance or just having a chat with you.
This post may be the last thing I do in my wow-ssx time, and for that I am sorry. But something has to be done quickly if I'm going to continue with you guys.
(The post by QD is a great idea and I support it to 100%)
This has nothing to do about you, but about the game.
I'm sick and tired of it atm and can't stand another month of no progress.
Then I will quit this game for sure or change guild.
This game has nothing more to offer than endgame instances for many ppl, it's either quit, go for 14 (lol) or go raiding.
And when I first saw the movies from Naxx, it was like omg frigging cool! Something new to the game again!
But if we go with "well, we should take a raidbreak and see who are truly ssx material", thats just crap tbh
I would like to see things work out for us, but as we are falling apart more and more for each day cause of ppl getting bored, I doubt it.
Vilse i Pannkakan
-
Lightforge
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
- Location: In your house
Two good posts above(Kanes and Zebos should anyone else have posted while im writing), I share the exact same feelings as both of you. As a gamer I want to get the most out of games or else it will just become trivial and tedious.. If we are all so good friends and buddies here then why doesn't everyone use IRC and Vent when they log on and socialize, like Zebo says people are on when its 19.50 and people only use vent when we are pvping or raiding leaving little time for that good chit chat you never really get to do.
Some of the best talks ive had with people has been on vent when people are just idling and some of the best times I've had in this guild, which prolly goes for a lot of other people, has been when we progressed in instances...
Once again.. People should take a look at this game and then really analyze what this game has to offer... And if we dont do the things the game has to offer.. Then as Zebos quote said and as Kane pointed out; theres not much point in paying money for a chatroom though I have no objections to people that do.. Not when there are better alternatives(vent etc). It's up to people how they want to play the game but playing a game and then play it with everything it has to offer Isnt Hardcore... It only is if you make it that way. Does it really destroy the SSX values if we go and have fun in places we haven't been to before?
Some of the best talks ive had with people has been on vent when people are just idling and some of the best times I've had in this guild, which prolly goes for a lot of other people, has been when we progressed in instances...
Once again.. People should take a look at this game and then really analyze what this game has to offer... And if we dont do the things the game has to offer.. Then as Zebos quote said and as Kane pointed out; theres not much point in paying money for a chatroom though I have no objections to people that do.. Not when there are better alternatives(vent etc). It's up to people how they want to play the game but playing a game and then play it with everything it has to offer Isnt Hardcore... It only is if you make it that way. Does it really destroy the SSX values if we go and have fun in places we haven't been to before?
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|
-
Meline
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
- Location: Stockholm/Sweden
The above 3 posts just say my thoughts.
It is the way this game works. If we don't progress and experiance new things it's just a 3d chatroom. It's not worth 12 euros/month. If nothing is done most ppl will quit playing/change guild to actually PLAY the game, not just idle in IF and talk.
I actually think it's better to have two ranks than two guilds, it would be much easier and fair.
If you look at it it would only help us pick up the slack. How SSXy is it the way we have it now? 25 ppl working their asses off to help the guild, and then we have a fair amount of leechers that go undetected/or we can't do anything about it.
And the bigtime SSXers that don't play the game can't really understand how it works imo, and "stopping raiding to see who's SSX material" won't solve any problems at all. It would just hurt the guild very much.
Tired, bed.
It is the way this game works. If we don't progress and experiance new things it's just a 3d chatroom. It's not worth 12 euros/month. If nothing is done most ppl will quit playing/change guild to actually PLAY the game, not just idle in IF and talk.
I actually think it's better to have two ranks than two guilds, it would be much easier and fair.
If you look at it it would only help us pick up the slack. How SSXy is it the way we have it now? 25 ppl working their asses off to help the guild, and then we have a fair amount of leechers that go undetected/or we can't do anything about it.
And the bigtime SSXers that don't play the game can't really understand how it works imo, and "stopping raiding to see who's SSX material" won't solve any problems at all. It would just hurt the guild very much.
Tired, bed.
Meline - 60 Human priest (Outland)
Buttran - Lvling, cute gnome lock (Outland)
Coldrey - 60 UD rogue (Grim Batol)
Rolling skills /300.
Buttran - Lvling, cute gnome lock (Outland)
Coldrey - 60 UD rogue (Grim Batol)
Rolling skills /300.
-
Krissie
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 8:41 am
- Location: Norway
Lets start working! Get the fun back!
I totally agree with those that have posts above me..
I totally agree with those that have posts above me..
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
I am really glad that people like Meline, Zebo, LF, Kane have expressed their feelings upon the matter in such an open and honest way. It seems that there is a general consensus upon the matter from the majority in SSX-WoW since by large the discordant posts originate mainly from SSX that are not playing WoW atm. If an official poll is needed, I suggest we put one up ASAP - we have discussed this for some time and it's high time we stop talking and start acting. TBC is, give and take, 2 months away and if we want to cover some terrain by that time we need to start acting fast.
-
Ivriniel
Well, first off, sorry Inq for posting here, even tough you asked "outsiders" not to. I do feel however, that i can add something productive/informative to this discussion, if you disagree, i guess you have a delete button.
So who am i? I am Ivriniel, Officer in Sinisters. Now i ask you to please ignore the fact i am from a guild that "stole" 3 of your "core" members, as i merely point out i am Officer in a raiding guild as it might help to understand my point of view, and my experience i have with guild "direction" problems.
A little history about the guild might help to, it was a merger from two guilds of friends, that wanted todo MC back in like April or June last year. Over time we did develop away from the more friends type of guild, to a more hardcore raiding guild. We did however manage to keep most of our friends, and i still quiet enjoy to do 20mans and other stuff with them, when they have time to actually play.
Now i am not sure about your numbers, but for Sinisters, we have around 110 accounts in the guild:
- 10ish or so inactive or only log on to chat
- 40ish core raiders
- 30ish members
- 20ish friends
We do differentiate between these people with ranks, with different "rights and duties". We have Friend, Member and Raider rank.
It's kinda simple raiders are those who join progress raids, and have invite priority on BWL and AQ40 farm, this is done to allow the raiders to gear faster, and to make sure they do have the gear for progress.
This does not mean non raiders can't develop their characters with gear, because the only limitation we have on bids is that if a raider bids a certain amount (roughly 2 weeks worth of dkp) they win over normal members.
In reality, we do BWL, MC and AQ40 with a mix of members and raiders, as one group and have fun and gear pretty much goes to everyone who wants it.
Members help out in Naxx progress as needed too, and i think we all enjoy to see something different.
There are different ranks, that allow us to help progress with gear, the ranks don't exist to create a "2 class society".
As long as everyone realizes what it is about, there is no problem for either casuals or raiders, it's all about what the members make from the rules.
Now why do i post this here?
Simple, 10 months ago we were really really similar to how SSX seems to be today. We had alot of members, everyone joined everything. As you seem to have it to, there were people who simply have alot more play time than others and invest alot of that time into raiding preparation. This lead to conflicts, similar to what seems to be going on in SSX now. Over time we developed the above rules, which now allow us to have fun and beat encounters in naxxaramas, with minimal loss of friends. We lost about the same amount of raiders to "more hardcore" raiding guild than we did lose friends to rl.
In the end it's some simple rules, which don't hurt casuals to much in what pve they can experience, but leaves room for the raiders with more time/interest to develop their characters and experience the newest content.
I understand that simply copying rules wouldn't solve anything, but i hope this gives you some insight, in how other guilds deal/dealt with similar problems, as this kind of problem seems to be bound to happen to every wow guild, it's just in the nature of the game.
This is also a heads up, there is light at the end of the tunnel. It is a long way to find the light, and a lot of work (which preferably is not just on QD's shoulders :P), but it is worth it. From what i can see from the outside and from chats with people that i know, i'd say it's simply time for some more people in SSX to step up, and get the "work" done.
A gdisband wouldn't just sadden you as the SSX community, people on outland do care about the guild community.
WoW is a game, and people need to be able to play it their way to enjoy it. It's best played with friends tough
I wish you good luck in your future adventures, and sorry for the break in.
Ivriniel
So who am i? I am Ivriniel, Officer in Sinisters. Now i ask you to please ignore the fact i am from a guild that "stole" 3 of your "core" members, as i merely point out i am Officer in a raiding guild as it might help to understand my point of view, and my experience i have with guild "direction" problems.
A little history about the guild might help to, it was a merger from two guilds of friends, that wanted todo MC back in like April or June last year. Over time we did develop away from the more friends type of guild, to a more hardcore raiding guild. We did however manage to keep most of our friends, and i still quiet enjoy to do 20mans and other stuff with them, when they have time to actually play.
Now i am not sure about your numbers, but for Sinisters, we have around 110 accounts in the guild:
- 10ish or so inactive or only log on to chat
- 40ish core raiders
- 30ish members
- 20ish friends
We do differentiate between these people with ranks, with different "rights and duties". We have Friend, Member and Raider rank.
It's kinda simple raiders are those who join progress raids, and have invite priority on BWL and AQ40 farm, this is done to allow the raiders to gear faster, and to make sure they do have the gear for progress.
This does not mean non raiders can't develop their characters with gear, because the only limitation we have on bids is that if a raider bids a certain amount (roughly 2 weeks worth of dkp) they win over normal members.
In reality, we do BWL, MC and AQ40 with a mix of members and raiders, as one group and have fun and gear pretty much goes to everyone who wants it.
Members help out in Naxx progress as needed too, and i think we all enjoy to see something different.
There are different ranks, that allow us to help progress with gear, the ranks don't exist to create a "2 class society".
As long as everyone realizes what it is about, there is no problem for either casuals or raiders, it's all about what the members make from the rules.
Now why do i post this here?
Simple, 10 months ago we were really really similar to how SSX seems to be today. We had alot of members, everyone joined everything. As you seem to have it to, there were people who simply have alot more play time than others and invest alot of that time into raiding preparation. This lead to conflicts, similar to what seems to be going on in SSX now. Over time we developed the above rules, which now allow us to have fun and beat encounters in naxxaramas, with minimal loss of friends. We lost about the same amount of raiders to "more hardcore" raiding guild than we did lose friends to rl.
In the end it's some simple rules, which don't hurt casuals to much in what pve they can experience, but leaves room for the raiders with more time/interest to develop their characters and experience the newest content.
I understand that simply copying rules wouldn't solve anything, but i hope this gives you some insight, in how other guilds deal/dealt with similar problems, as this kind of problem seems to be bound to happen to every wow guild, it's just in the nature of the game.
This is also a heads up, there is light at the end of the tunnel. It is a long way to find the light, and a lot of work (which preferably is not just on QD's shoulders :P), but it is worth it. From what i can see from the outside and from chats with people that i know, i'd say it's simply time for some more people in SSX to step up, and get the "work" done.
A gdisband wouldn't just sadden you as the SSX community, people on outland do care about the guild community.
WoW is a game, and people need to be able to play it their way to enjoy it. It's best played with friends tough
I wish you good luck in your future adventures, and sorry for the break in.
Ivriniel
-
Eolas
- Posts: 120
- Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2006 7:43 pm
- Location: Malta
Thanks Ivriniel for your input. Much appreciated the fact you took your time and posted.
"Do unto others what you have them do to you" - Jesus
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
andIt seems that there is a general consensus upon the matter from the majority in SSX-WoW since by large the discordant posts originate mainly from SSX that are not playing WoW atm.
Don't say consensus to me. And:25 ppl working their asses off to help the guild, and then we have a fair amount of leechers that go undetected
since by large the discordant posts originate mainly from SSX that are not playing WoW
This post came directly from conversations with people who DO play WoW "atm," I just posted it.
That, frankly, is one of the reasons I exist here. If you have a problem with us butting in, get over it, that's how it works here. You represent the rest of us in the game, whether we play or not, we have a stake in it.
I understand very well how it works. I don't have to play a particular game to see there are mixed feelings on this issue amongst those who do play. I am not insulting you intelligence by telling you how many decades I have been dealing with people, so I can be damn sure I can see patterns in behavior, so don't insult mine by telling me I "have to be there" because its not true, and if you think it is, YOU need a break. I spent an inordinate amount of time talking with people who DO play so I can get a reasonable sense for real alternatives. Sondemon, Ava, QD, Mip, etc etc etc. I make sure I have some clue.And the bigtime SSXers that don't play the game can't really understand how it works imo
Yes, you need a poll. You have 25 people and apparently some undetermined number of the rest are leechers, which makes what, at least 50? Hardly consensus. Defining "most" as the group you currently share an opinion with is dangerous.
It does sound like you SHOULD try something. That split within the guild seems a sensible suggestion, using the ranks. Just do it with eyes wide open, and KNOW what the consequences of your actions are. There's alot of "I love this place because of the people" vibe going on here. Preserve that.
It sounds like Sinisters has a workable model, start with that.
No signature
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
Just to make things clear from beforehand, will the poll be open to those in SSX-WoW or to all SSX independant of which group they currently come from?Inquisitor wrote:Yes, you need a poll.
I agree - the same model, or something somewaht similar, is also what Nulli Secundus uses, afaik.Inquisitor wrote: It sounds like Sinisters has a workable model, start with that.
-
esd
- Posts: 986
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 2:25 am
- Location: Somewhere
I don't think there's a way to make it WoW-specific. Best that we can do is put the poll in Members to prevent non-SSX voting in it, I believe.Galador wrote:Just to make things clear from beforehand, will the poll be open to those in SSX-WoW or to all SSX independant of which group they currently come from?
""I like my women like I like my coffee. In a plastic cup.""
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
The question has to be something like "What do you want ouf of this in WoW" and people who don;t play WoW won't have an opinion. I can enforce that and make people behave. If you make a broader, "should we do this rank thing" expect people who do not play to have an opinion.
Again, thats just the way this works here. Get with Sonde, craft the question, I'll post it.
Again, thats just the way this works here. Get with Sonde, craft the question, I'll post it.
No signature
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
I wasn't asking if there is actually a way to do it but rather who should vote or not, there is an important difference there.esd wrote:I don't think there's a way to make it WoW-specific. Best that we can do is put the poll in Members to prevent non-SSX voting in it, I believe.Galador wrote:Just to make things clear from beforehand, will the poll be open to those in SSX-WoW or to all SSX independant of which group they currently come from?
Call me naive but I believe that if it were agreed that only SSX-WoW members should vote I have faith that other SSX from other groups would respect and abide by that becuase since we claim that SSX is about friendship that is what a real friend would do.
That said, I understand that there are various arguments as pro and con why the poll should be open only to SSX-WoW members on one hand and why it should be open to all of SSX on the other with valuable arguments on both sides, so discussing that would probably takes another 4 pages of forum
-EDIT-
Just saw Inquisitor's last post. Never mind me
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I wouldn't wanna see polls being made that are restricted to specific groups, we're all supposed to be SSX here and all our opinions should count depending on the question.. But i sharn't argue about it. 
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
Well, for questions like "What do you want to do in WoW?" it seems kinda pointless for me, for instance, to reply 
So, like I said, I think its fine, depending on the question.
So, like I said, I think its fine, depending on the question.
No signature
-
Plovske
- Posts: 468
- Joined: Mon Sep 19, 2005 7:59 pm
- Location: Mayrhofen, Austria
i feel the same way zebo.
Asfor what i think. people need to look for themselfs what they realy want in the game. make it clear what they want.
asfor myself. i want to explore more of the game.
Asfor what i think. people need to look for themselfs what they realy want in the game. make it clear what they want.
asfor myself. i want to explore more of the game.
enjoy!
