DKP System and Drop Values review!

Moderator: Global Moderators

PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 11:51 pm

User avatar
Brittfire
Posts: 291
Joined: Tue Dec 13, 2005 1:17 am
wat riki and mip said

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 1:15 am

Janell
Posts: 61
Joined: Sat Jan 14, 2006 3:53 am
You can't have a perfect dkp system that fits all needs, either hardcore raiders will profit, or the casuals will. What would fit us most, is something in between. Removing maxbids or making them very high is therefore not an option imo.

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 9:45 am

User avatar
Linkie
Posts: 461
Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2005 12:50 pm
Location: The Netherlands, Haarlem
i didnt really saw anything that was wrong with the DKP system but i liked the second rule more then the first cause that way

when a good dagger drops and lets say ... Riki wants ir and i want it to but i need it more ... then riki can just trow a overbid in and win ... doesnt seem fair to me imo but ... that is just me :P
WoW:
NE Rogue LvL 60 Called Linkie

GW:
Eli/Mon LvL 8 Called Sakura The Small

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 11:01 am

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Zaranna wrote: Ofc, that means there won't be any changes with neutral items though, but isn't it the class items we are talking mostly as the problem here?
I don't like to sound selfish but I do have a few problems with our current DKP system (and have made several posts about it in the past) and I am happy that they are being adressed, but my problems have nothing to do with Set items, I'm not the only one, not everyone in the guild just wants their complete class set.

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 2:42 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
NightDreams wrote:If we use the system Myself, Dreamer and Ava spoke about and which Dreamer and me spoke to u about then it will solve the problem.

Bloodfang gloves = 40min atm max is 80 under the new system it would be 160 which would let people think about bidding something other then max as it would cost alot. The non hard core raiders or the people with low dkp would still be able to pick up teir 1 no problem and the teir 2 parts which people already have.
Yes they will have to wait for the golves but they cant expect to get something that every hardcore raidere wants if they are willing to put the time and effoert in.

As when it comes down to it WE ARE a raiding guild, we are a large guild yes but still a raiding guild. Just look at what we do each night raid.
Look at what happened when we took a break people moaned that they wanted to raid and tryed to makes some raids.
Doesnt it make more sense that the people who raid more, have more dkp which means they will get the drops they want more but since we are not giving as much dkp now for runs peoples level of dkp will balace out by using this. Rather then having to keep lists of who lost what roll and then making them roll again.

Now that entirely depends.

Your system is "more fair" to the "hardcore" raiders, to the people there every run, as it allows them to muscle on bids, and penny bid people, your system is also "more fair" to anyone like you, and me, who have their entire set already.
Your system is entirely less fair to anyone who is just finishing up on their MC Level gear (Warrior/Warlock/Druid/Mages to some degree/Paladins to some degree and hunters due to drops) 'it will make people think more' - and turn them into far more selfish and DKP Stingy bidders, the way union went, it slowly effects the way the guild looks at raid drops.

Take the druids yesterday for example, Chalan maxbidding the chest when he didn't have to, if maxbids were to open up so much stuff like that wouldn't happen.

The point with the overbid (BTW the overbid ends up with the same end value maxbid as your suggestion, so the only reason you could possibly not want this is so that you can pennybid on items overpeople who want them but aren't in as comfortable situation as you) is that you either spend the standard or you spend A LOT.
And nothing in between.

This still allows the 'more hardcore' raiders in the guild to spend the DKP in a hefty way, but it MAKES SURE they spend it in a hefty way and that if they ARE going to shut out the casuals - which is what you are suggesting will allow them to do, it will cost them a lot more.

By nature this is balanced out by the fact that the hardcore people will be going BWL (Higher DKP) and AQ40 (Extremely good DKP), and the more casual will mostly be in MC / ZG / AQ20.

If WE ARE a raiding guild, I should really start re-writing some rules.
Perhaps you should start talking to the members who WERE in raiding guilds see about the different cultures and guidelines, objectives and rulesets.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 5:12 pm

User avatar
NightDreams
Posts: 220
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
Location: Bristol, UK
Yes people will be able to muscle bid (which will cost them alot but will mean less rolling) or penny bid so that they can save themselves some dkp but as i said since MC and BWL doesnt really give much dkp compared to cost of items these days that wont really matter.
Also with ref to myself i have maxed bid 5 from 6 DS parts from BWL and never that i remember penny bidded on anything.
As for being less fair as i pointed out since MC gives so little dkp now they will have a hard time out bidding people on bwl loot weather or not we up it anyway. This is just an idea to give the bids a more intresting and larger scale so that people will have to roll less, which atm is a hugh problem for us.

And if u had read what i said about overbid is that i had nothing against it, the only down side i see to that is as above we have gone from giving to much to to little dkp for things now imo, so if someone does overbid they will take a long time to get enough points to bid on something else without going into -dkp
As for ur remake about talking to other people from raiding guilds i have done. And from what they have said our current dkp system needs to be redone.
Lies can be good, If they are put to good use.

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 5:32 pm

User avatar
Galador
Posts: 259
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
Location: Malta
NightDreams wrote:And from what they have said our current dkp system needs to be redone.
They probably think in terms of a hardcore raiding guild - if we ever decide to become one I tend to agree with them (our dkp system is a very poor system for a hardcore raiding guild)

However we are quite a unique guild in this respect. Why do I say so? Simply because whereas in other guilds the main raid composition changes very little everyday (members are obliged to have a high raid attendance) - our raids' composition changes quite significantly over a week of raids. We have a mix of people - some try to be there everyday, others take a more casual approach.

The inevitable result of this is that the guild's loot is distributed (in varying amounts) over a considerably wide player range (something that in other guilds does not happen).

And that is why our DKP system has to be different - simply cos we are different from the run of the mill raiding guild.

I do agree with you Mip that a free bidding system is more exciting and interesting than the standard min-max-overbid one but one has to analyse the repercussions QD pointed out.

A balance is hard to find but the overbid rule is imo a step in the right direction.

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 5:58 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
NightDreams wrote:As for ur remake about talking to other people from raiding guilds i have done. And from what they have said our current dkp system needs to be redone.
I would submit that they are comparing our system to theirs and seeing it for what it is, not a hardcore raiding guild's system, they seeing it as flawed for that reason. We are not a hardcore raiding guild and should never become so (imo). Our DKP System shouldn't give off the impression that we are.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 8:14 pm

User avatar
NightDreams
Posts: 220
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
Location: Bristol, UK
I didn't say we are a hardcore raiding guild, just that we are a raiding guild which we are. I asked them about their dkp system and spoke to them about ours.
I admit some dkp systems used by hardcore guilds wouldnt work for us i dont doubt that, just that our system needs looking at.
Mip
Lies can be good, If they are put to good use.

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 1:41 am

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
we are a pretty hardcore raiding guild whether we like it or not. its a fact, cant be changed just because we "dont force specs" doesnt mean that were not, its an increasing trend, cf. items beings distributed based on 'good for the guild'
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 3:46 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Chill wrote:we are a pretty hardcore raiding guild whether we like it or not. its a fact, cant be changed just because we "dont force specs" doesnt mean that were not, its an increasing trend, cf. items beings distributed based on 'good for the guild'
No Enforced Specs.
No Attendance Management.
No DKP Punishments.
No Item Restrictions between classes.
No Enforced Main/Alt policy.
No Item / Experienced based application requirements.
No Level Requirement.
No Guild contribution requirement (materials for flasks/etc).
No Raid based "guild discipline" - Guild based Raid Discipline though.
No Hardcore Skewed DKP System.



The guild raids because they can and, because they enjoy it, they don't raid to;

A) LOL EPIX (Okay one or two people need continual slapping).
B) Get World/Server firsts.

There are no raiding guilds I know of that take votes over whether to continue or not, or take votes on whether to go on to another instance or not.
There are no raiding guilds I know of that don't punish people who leave early on a run in one way or another.

/shrug.

I really can slap some raiding rules on the raids if you all want it, but yea chill if loot is the only thing you care about sure we're pretty hardcore we get a lot of loot and we share it out 'fairly responcibly' (see; no TOEPs going to hunters or drillborers going to paladins).
However these items COULD go to these classes - just that the people in the guild are reasonable enough that they don't ask for it, or don't want it for just novelty purposes when others could actually use it quite significantly.
(Though I regret having a TOEP now the trinket nerf is here, I so rarely use it because I have other slightly more useful trinkets that don't go on a shared cooldown +1000 to healing spells used to be pretty imba though :)


The Net DKP of the guild has been dropping for a while now and only two people (the serial low roller and dyna who never bids on much at all) have +600 DKP.
In terms of actual economics to introduce new, higher caps at a point in time where things are already in a decline is far more damaging than what you are suggesting.
Unless your objective is one thing, and one thing alone;
Removing maxbids completely.

Which is essentially what this is, and what it comes down to, and what it will lead to, is those whom are not fortunate or able enough to raid with us regularly, but want to, eventually, will find themselves getting one item every 2 months - on extremes (basis; current priest gain vs priest spending).

The Overbid will force people to weigh up exactly what they are doing before they hit enter.
Sofia wrote:About time. And a good solutions in the long run, as these rules will always cope to the economical situation.
Which is what you have to aim for.
Our system is unique on bladefist in being that it is the only system that was designed custom based for the guild that's using it, all of the others have been based on or designed around zero sum or the original EQDKP system guides.
Neither such systems would be even remotely useful in our guild with such a mix and match of playing culture unless you heavily wanted to shut one of those out.

And the side that would /always/ be shut out - would be the casuals.

The people who are always on the raids make a lot happen in the raids but these people have to realise - they still, would not be raiding if it were not for the people they are trying to screw over.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 5:55 am

User avatar
Eolas
Posts: 120
Joined: Sun Jan 22, 2006 7:43 pm
Location: Malta
QD wote
Our system is unique on bladefist
OMG I've been tricked to having migrated on Outland.................!!!!!!! :) <3

Seriously though, my 2c on all this - I am proud to be a member of SSX not cause we are pro or anything (which I feel we are too) but because in the guild there are genuine people who make playing the game and raiding worthwile. Loot is just an added bonus.

Keep the spirit of SSX guys - dont introduce raiding rules that undermine such a spirit.

Regarding the DKP system I can't comment much, me and my perennial negative or thereabouts DKP, but from what I've seen till now the system is fair and the new overbid system looks set to solve a problem for those who really need certain items.

Keep up the good work mods! Members they (the mods) are not perfect (who is? lower your hand QD! :P), but let us appreciate what these guys do for us in terms of guild rules, raid setups, raid techniques and strategies, and helping us get a good endgame experience as well as improve our gear.
"Do unto others what you have them do to you" - Jesus

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 11:51 am

User avatar
Sondemon
Posts: 403
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Eolas wrote:Seriously though, my 2c on all this - I am proud to be a member of SSX not cause we are pro or anything (which I feel we are too) but because in the guild there are genuine people who make playing the game and raiding worthwile. Loot is just an added bonus.

Keep the spirit of SSX guys - dont introduce raiding rules that undermine such a spirit.
Can't say it better myself
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!

"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 2:13 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
QuantumDelta wrote: No Enforced Specs.
No Item Restrictions between classes.
Yes we do. Maybe not half as much as 'raiding guilds'. But people are still forced into specs and certain items. That is if they want to come on raids.

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 2:48 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
Dodotorpedo wrote:
QuantumDelta wrote: No Enforced Specs.
No Item Restrictions between classes.
Yes we do. Maybe not half as much as 'raiding guilds'. But people are still forced into specs and certain items. That is if they want to come on raids.
I can only speak for my own class, but with us thats not the case.

I'm specced with Arms (which Im constantly told by Ava means my head needs looking at :p ) and so are several other warriors I believe. Thats the least ideal warrior spec suitable for raiding (Prot being first, then Fury), but we're still invited on raids. Spec doesn't matter for us.

It shouldn't, in my opinion, matter for any other class either....
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 3:20 pm

User avatar
Sondemon
Posts: 403
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Afaik, hunters have to be marksmanship specced to be allowed on raids. But as I rarely play my hunter and he's not at raiding lvl, I don't know for sure.
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!

"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 3:31 pm

User avatar
Caspae
Posts: 431
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 6:50 pm
Sondemon wrote:Afaik, hunters have to be marksmanship specced to be allowed on raids. But as I rarely play my hunter and he's not at raiding lvl, I don't know for sure.
Nope , were not forced to be MM , even though its not a bad spec , I just <3 keeping both pvp and pve open and a 31 Survival and 20 MM build kinda suits that :)

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 4:21 pm

User avatar
Brittfire
Posts: 291
Joined: Tue Dec 13, 2005 1:17 am
we just dont spec BM for the reason its mostly useless in raids :cool:

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 4:30 pm

User avatar
Drongnel
Posts: 283
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 7:35 pm
Location: near Brighton
Well mainly we just don't BM spec :p
'I Thought what i'd do is i'd pretend to be one of those deaf-mutes'

Drongnel 60 Dorf hunter (Miner/Engineer)
Ank 38 Gnome mage (Engineer/Tailor)
Dinkl 38 Gnome rogue (Skinner/Leatherworker)
Tamburlaine 22 Dorf Pally (Miner/Blacksmith)
Fayed 20 Nelf Drood (Enchanter/Skinner)

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 4:42 pm

User avatar
Caspae
Posts: 431
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 6:50 pm
But it is t3h pro grinding method though :P the first 5 points are ok too but id have to lose scatter shot or sth else in SV so ill pass ;)

Flowing off-topic tho :P

PostPosted: Tue May 09, 2006 6:56 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
I wasn't talking about hunters or warriors (not mages either btw)

PostPosted: Wed May 10, 2006 8:51 am

User avatar
Linkie
Posts: 461
Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2005 12:50 pm
Location: The Netherlands, Haarlem
Sondemon wrote:
Eolas wrote:Seriously though, my 2c on all this - I am proud to be a member of SSX not cause we are pro or anything (which I feel we are too) but because in the guild there are genuine people who make playing the game and raiding worthwile. Loot is just an added bonus.

Keep the spirit of SSX guys - dont introduce raiding rules that undermine such a spirit.
Can't say it better myself
idd nicely said :eek:
WoW:
NE Rogue LvL 60 Called Linkie

GW:
Eli/Mon LvL 8 Called Sakura The Small

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”