an issue for me
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
Meline
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
- Location: Stockholm/Sweden
Ok, just a question, if you did understand that I was playing on milko, would you think it was ok, what would you say? Wouldn't you be kind enough to pass the gloves for him?
Meline - 60 Human priest (Outland)
Buttran - Lvling, cute gnome lock (Outland)
Coldrey - 60 UD rogue (Grim Batol)
Rolling skills /300.
Buttran - Lvling, cute gnome lock (Outland)
Coldrey - 60 UD rogue (Grim Batol)
Rolling skills /300.
-
Arche
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
I've been reading the topic over and over again. Indeed it shows one thing very clearly. Miscommunication leads to irritation.
Still, I wouldn't mind if I was put in the situation. I know some people invest lots in guild progression in end game instances. Also I know that relative newcomers strive from this. I don't judge these people for it.
But I can't help but get a feeling of ungratefullness. This of course doesn't mean you are, don't get me wrong.
In Utopia this would be fair:
All the people from get geared by higher levels to the same point where they are. Then every player gets every instance one time a month. Maybe twice if they're lucky. This would however create a situation where guild progression is seriously halted.
I get my Adrenaline kick from helping with first kills with the guild. This HAS to include people like Milko to be top geared. Weighing the amount of dkp, time spend, help with endgame, assisting other guildies, I think he does deserve it even if he's not there.
This however leads to a fragile discussion point. Because you don't know if people are online or not, or play on each other or not. The soul reason that this leaked out is because people tried to inform others about Meline logging on Milko.
Maybe I'm a bit old fashioned (I am getting old :<). I think that people who do much good in the guild, are entitled to a little evil.
Still, I wouldn't mind if I was put in the situation. I know some people invest lots in guild progression in end game instances. Also I know that relative newcomers strive from this. I don't judge these people for it.
But I can't help but get a feeling of ungratefullness. This of course doesn't mean you are, don't get me wrong.
In Utopia this would be fair:
All the people from get geared by higher levels to the same point where they are. Then every player gets every instance one time a month. Maybe twice if they're lucky. This would however create a situation where guild progression is seriously halted.
I get my Adrenaline kick from helping with first kills with the guild. This HAS to include people like Milko to be top geared. Weighing the amount of dkp, time spend, help with endgame, assisting other guildies, I think he does deserve it even if he's not there.
This however leads to a fragile discussion point. Because you don't know if people are online or not, or play on each other or not. The soul reason that this leaked out is because people tried to inform others about Meline logging on Milko.
Maybe I'm a bit old fashioned (I am getting old :<). I think that people who do much good in the guild, are entitled to a little evil.
-
Himico
- Posts: 32
- Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 2:30 am
Ive already said it once, if Milko was playing Milko Id be very happy for him and congratulate him - take it however you want to.Meline wrote:Ok, just a question, if you did understand that I was playing on milko, would you think it was ok, what would you say? Wouldn't you be kind enough to pass the gloves for him?
-
Rinoa
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Oct 28, 2005 10:29 pm
- Location: Beverwijk, The Netherlands
Imho, make a CLEAR rule for this matter. With the new raid scheme we have I can imagine people having troubles with there attendance, what if for example I had to work each saturday night, it would mean for me that I can never ever go to BWL anymore. I could see in this situation that it would be allowed to have someone playing my char, cause I never can be there else.
About the whole part with Ruaque, it was her right to bid on the boots, even though she promised she wouldn't. I take it as a serious offence and I just won't trust her again/anymore, shame for her. It's something between her and me, so you don't have to comment on it. I'd rather just say and post it then hold it in my head and let the thought go it's own free will
. (it's not about the item, I care about friendship and trust, and if these things are present, things like this should just NOT happen.).
In my opinion, having 7/8 of tier 2 is just very hatefull, you have to log in every single time for an instance because you can miss it out one single week where they will drop. This is having a serious effect on my social life, because I hardly dare going out on days where BWL is farmed because theres a small chance the boots might drop. True, it's only a game, but it's a game that effects much of my real life due to playing, so I tend to get as much as possible out of it
. I can understand why someone would let someone else play on there account, but the keyword in this whole scheme is COMMUNICATION. If the person who played milko's account would have explained everyone what was up, about that he did 9 weeks of runs without drops and stuff, I'm sure people would have passed and would have been helpfull, cause it's also a part of friendship
.
I tend to agree with Feitan too, if you want things like this not happening, make up some strict rules for ventrilo, maybe even raidchat so that communications are clear and everybody reads them, instead of cutting trough the spam. As you might have noticed, I haven't been much on ventrilo lately, I tend to talk the much and screw over other people with it so either I'm just shutting up or I don't even bother to log it anymore.
If rules would be made, with possible exceptions, or a chance in our raiding scheme (make it different every week for example, so if you can't come on one day, you won't miss the instance you want every week).
About the whole part with Ruaque, it was her right to bid on the boots, even though she promised she wouldn't. I take it as a serious offence and I just won't trust her again/anymore, shame for her. It's something between her and me, so you don't have to comment on it. I'd rather just say and post it then hold it in my head and let the thought go it's own free will
In my opinion, having 7/8 of tier 2 is just very hatefull, you have to log in every single time for an instance because you can miss it out one single week where they will drop. This is having a serious effect on my social life, because I hardly dare going out on days where BWL is farmed because theres a small chance the boots might drop. True, it's only a game, but it's a game that effects much of my real life due to playing, so I tend to get as much as possible out of it
I tend to agree with Feitan too, if you want things like this not happening, make up some strict rules for ventrilo, maybe even raidchat so that communications are clear and everybody reads them, instead of cutting trough the spam. As you might have noticed, I haven't been much on ventrilo lately, I tend to talk the much and screw over other people with it so either I'm just shutting up or I don't even bother to log it anymore.
If rules would be made, with possible exceptions, or a chance in our raiding scheme (make it different every week for example, so if you can't come on one day, you won't miss the instance you want every week).
-
Feitan
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:00 am
All i see, is justification or making the deed transaction seem fair and right, but theres the essence of it not always being applied as well.
Fairness is consistency, if there was this. enivid would have had Trans, rinoa his boots and losty would get his boots if they dropped even thou i have higher dkp and i might want them!.
Are you saying my dkp is inferior to that gained by losty and if my amount might transcend his that he should get it anyway?
We have a history and we know the unfairness in it you'v felt this m8 and iv known it and iv repented for it and i know the wrongness of it.
Little evil is needed yes it is but this was just wrongness not even evil or good.
This was Certain Officers and Meline deciding on it and expecting everyone to hear the pronouncing of it and everybody being cool with it.
If they were or not is not the problem its that they just skipped out a key affected person here.
As for my posts here its coz i saw this situation <censored> trice and not 1 was the same.
If they were i'd might even find some fairness of evil in it. (doubt it)
Everyone of them was different, Rinoa got (*) by ruaque or so i heared, its not my care or any of my bussiness but hey this is what i get thrown in the face with.
I read the line in warrior chat that Wrath is assigned to Losty, oh sure this is no problem.......? but uhm might you want to ask everyone before doing something this forcefull? or did i suddenly now end up in a dictoriate that my work and dkp points mean nothing when it comes to Officer or power calls.
And then there was NW gloves. which is clarified more then enuf.
Im just a honest and plain simple guy i express my dismay when i see it amount more then it should be.
Judge me for saying whats on my mind hate me for it or like me for it, that is your call and opinion il abide by it and accept and maybe even respect it.
All i ask is the same.
Fairness is consistency, if there was this. enivid would have had Trans, rinoa his boots and losty would get his boots if they dropped even thou i have higher dkp and i might want them!.
Are you saying my dkp is inferior to that gained by losty and if my amount might transcend his that he should get it anyway?
We have a history and we know the unfairness in it you'v felt this m8 and iv known it and iv repented for it and i know the wrongness of it.
Little evil is needed yes it is but this was just wrongness not even evil or good.
This was Certain Officers and Meline deciding on it and expecting everyone to hear the pronouncing of it and everybody being cool with it.
If they were or not is not the problem its that they just skipped out a key affected person here.
As for my posts here its coz i saw this situation <censored> trice and not 1 was the same.
If they were i'd might even find some fairness of evil in it. (doubt it)
Everyone of them was different, Rinoa got (*) by ruaque or so i heared, its not my care or any of my bussiness but hey this is what i get thrown in the face with.
I read the line in warrior chat that Wrath is assigned to Losty, oh sure this is no problem.......? but uhm might you want to ask everyone before doing something this forcefull? or did i suddenly now end up in a dictoriate that my work and dkp points mean nothing when it comes to Officer or power calls.
And then there was NW gloves. which is clarified more then enuf.
Im just a honest and plain simple guy i express my dismay when i see it amount more then it should be.
Judge me for saying whats on my mind hate me for it or like me for it, that is your call and opinion il abide by it and accept and maybe even respect it.
All i ask is the same.
Banshou issai,
Kaijin to Nase.
Kaijin to Nase.
-
Feitan
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:00 am
And just for the record, i dont want wrath boots losty <3 you deserve them and can have them and this is called your luck of understanding from others but it shouldnt be forced or taken granted. its a gift from friends above the need of friendship and respect.
Banshou issai,
Kaijin to Nase.
Kaijin to Nase.
-
Arche
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
The reason we started with these actions was because Avator got undergeared for tanking Chrommagus.
My first and only real argument I ever had with Avator was that you couldn't ASK people to not bid. For the simple reason that you PUT people in the position to hurt you because they want something they like.
We've found an agreement within there. People shouldn't be asked, because they shouldn't be put in the position to HURT people because they WANT something. I feel the same with Rinoa asking Ruaque. I felt the same with Tickle asking me to pass on Spinal Reaper.
When I said I wouldn't, he pulled out old rules out of the epic of epic box. This got a lot of people in our guild mad, and made it even so that Tickle was unable to function as a warrior in our guild, simply out of lack of trust.
I agree with Feitan and Himico on certain things. I think however it should still be able for certain people to get easier access to items. This should however be more strict. Rules should be put up in how and when people should get this privalige.
Naxx= Dreadnaught for Ava+Armed first imo.
And for those that want to ask. I'm not telling you if I'm bidding on anything, I feel that I'm not allowed :P And I hate you for putting me in a position where I can hurt you :P
My first and only real argument I ever had with Avator was that you couldn't ASK people to not bid. For the simple reason that you PUT people in the position to hurt you because they want something they like.
We've found an agreement within there. People shouldn't be asked, because they shouldn't be put in the position to HURT people because they WANT something. I feel the same with Rinoa asking Ruaque. I felt the same with Tickle asking me to pass on Spinal Reaper.
When I said I wouldn't, he pulled out old rules out of the epic of epic box. This got a lot of people in our guild mad, and made it even so that Tickle was unable to function as a warrior in our guild, simply out of lack of trust.
I agree with Feitan and Himico on certain things. I think however it should still be able for certain people to get easier access to items. This should however be more strict. Rules should be put up in how and when people should get this privalige.
Naxx= Dreadnaught for Ava+Armed first imo.
And for those that want to ask. I'm not telling you if I'm bidding on anything, I feel that I'm not allowed :P And I hate you for putting me in a position where I can hurt you :P
-
Rinoa
- Posts: 165
- Joined: Fri Oct 28, 2005 10:29 pm
- Location: Beverwijk, The Netherlands
For the record, I didn't ask her, she said it herself in the hunterchannel. The subject boots came up and Eolas said : "I will pas on them", ruaque then said"Afcourse we will pass on them, it's your last part". I never asked anyone to pass for me.We've found an agreement within there. People shouldn't be asked, because they shouldn't be put in the position. I feel the same with Rinoa asking Ruaque. I felt the same with Tickle asking me to pass on Spinal Reaper.
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
We've had calls like that made before. For warriors that is, or I should say, tanks. To gear up tanks so we can progress. Just wanted to point that out, you didn't know this, because you've never seen it happen. I won't say it's either right or wrong here. Just saying how we've dealt with it before.Feitan wrote:I read the line in warrior chat that Wrath is assigned to Losty, oh sure this is no problem.......? but uhm might you want to ask everyone before doing something this forcefull? or did i suddenly now end up in a dictoriate that my work and dkp points mean nothing when it comes to Officer or power calls.
As for the topic of this discussion. Again, I felt it was rather clear that Meline was going on Milko. Sure I saw it in the officers chat, so I can't really say how much was said about it in raidchat after that cuz I tend to not remeber if things are said in both chats / where it was said. I do remeber it being mentioned on vent tho.
It will be talked about, it will be discussed. And instead of throwing things in eachothers face, discuss it please, constructive ideas etc.. It doesn't help to yell and fight, I know ppl are upset. But this is a first time this is brought up as a problem, so please, help us deal with it instead of flaming eachother.
Rinoa mentioned making some strict rules about vent and raidchat. Well Rinoa, we've already asked ppl to keep the vent a bit more focused on the current fight / boss etc during raids, since we're raiding and we are in the highlvl raid channel. I don't feel a need to bring this down to raidchat aswell, ppl wanna have fun, we're not hardcore raiders, we do progress well and we have downed twin emps. But we also have fun when we raid! Remeber the good old days? A certain MT of ours trying to run over a certain priest with Golemagg? I still smile thinking about those times on vent. Now I lost the line, and don't know what else to bring up, so I'll end it here. And I hope the negativity ends, and the good ideas are brought up!
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
Arche
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
Suggestions:
- Do not talk about loot outside anyone except your classleader. This leaves out a lot of tension.
- Maybe restrict these things to Druid, Paladin, Priest and Warrior class
- Create a announcement protocol, or a voting one.
- Do not talk about loot outside anyone except your classleader. This leaves out a lot of tension.
- Maybe restrict these things to Druid, Paladin, Priest and Warrior class
- Create a announcement protocol, or a voting one.
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Ouch Mel, you hit feits weak spot. Littl low.
Can get tiresome if you have to fight back the same rumours & assumtions again & again. Ive been there only a a cupple times, but on those few union runs the distribution has been fair & square. Old story now. Lets just say if your responsible for the *shiny & e-peen* of 40+ppl... someone will get pissed off sooner than later.
About the topic: Uhm, there are some things you have to consider which cant be regulated with rules, but with appropriate communication, teamwork & tact of everyone. The warr are a good example... dkp are dkp, but it doesnt stop there... thats as far as the system can cope the circumstances, but its not enough. Actually what Arche said. Talk it out, find a way which benefits the guild most without hurting guildies. Part of the teamwork.
My 2c, but thats some thin ice.
This isnt only about a pair gloves from a boss on farmstatus which will be obsolete in the very close future, but still. /shrug
Can get tiresome if you have to fight back the same rumours & assumtions again & again. Ive been there only a a cupple times, but on those few union runs the distribution has been fair & square. Old story now. Lets just say if your responsible for the *shiny & e-peen* of 40+ppl... someone will get pissed off sooner than later.
About the topic: Uhm, there are some things you have to consider which cant be regulated with rules, but with appropriate communication, teamwork & tact of everyone. The warr are a good example... dkp are dkp, but it doesnt stop there... thats as far as the system can cope the circumstances, but its not enough. Actually what Arche said. Talk it out, find a way which benefits the guild most without hurting guildies. Part of the teamwork.
My 2c, but thats some thin ice.
This isnt only about a pair gloves from a boss on farmstatus which will be obsolete in the very close future, but still. /shrug
Last edited by Sofia on Sun Jul 23, 2006 11:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
Rinoa wrote:I take it as a serious offence and I just won't trust her again/anymore, shame for her.
As i said above in the thread and as well to you earlier this afternoon dude, with all the other hunters saying they would pass for you i wouldn't be surprised if Ruaque felt uncomfortable and pressured in that situation when she originally said she would pass too, if she was thinking on bidding on them herself.Rinoa wrote:For the record, I didn't ask her, she said it herself in the hunterchannel. The subject boots came up and Eolas said : "I will pas on them", ruaque then said"Afcourse we will pass on them, it's your last part". I never asked anyone to pass for me.
Only other thing i'll say which i haven't already said is to learn to forgive & forget. And ofc for people not to make deals with loot as i've said above and i've said in the past as well. If people hadn't have been discussing loot and offering to pass in the first place it would have never happened.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Arche
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
Indeed, most important, learn to forgive and forget. Although it was a good thing that this subject was braught upon and talked about.
-
Feitan
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:00 am
How is that a weak spot when all i am
is a weakness 
Anyhow, chal that was an example. and as youv shown yourself a failing of explenation and instruction.
Now am i bitching or throwing on it no, why mention it? because its coherant.
No flaming no dirt throwing this is purely to get things in the open so they can be adressed and solved.
You can say it aint hardcore pve nor did i really expect that with earnest.
Do i hope for it? hell yeah can the guild make it that far yup yup, but not with the slack and the demotivation that gets rung throu time to time due to certain calls.
Am i in any place or right to say or call upon them? i can mention them i cant force change i cant demand change but i can ask softly change?
Your call your ball your bullet and arrow whats it gonna be ? me or the bullseye
Anyhow, chal that was an example. and as youv shown yourself a failing of explenation and instruction.
Now am i bitching or throwing on it no, why mention it? because its coherant.
No flaming no dirt throwing this is purely to get things in the open so they can be adressed and solved.
You can say it aint hardcore pve nor did i really expect that with earnest.
Do i hope for it? hell yeah can the guild make it that far yup yup, but not with the slack and the demotivation that gets rung throu time to time due to certain calls.
Am i in any place or right to say or call upon them? i can mention them i cant force change i cant demand change but i can ask softly change?
Your call your ball your bullet and arrow whats it gonna be ? me or the bullseye
Banshou issai,
Kaijin to Nase.
Kaijin to Nase.
-
NightDreams
- Posts: 220
- Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
- Location: Bristol, UK
Since the hunter problem has been said about i will comment on it.
Rinoa only needed the DS boots fpr full 8/8 DS and has been after them for some time, however Rua who won them last night has been after them for even longer and has lost them twice, once to a hunter who should of really used more commen sense on the item rather then bidding on it due to it being teir 2. And has admitted that it was a mistake at the time to bid.
This said Rua had the dkp to max bid, Rinoa was in -dkp and had used his last DKP on the DS bracers and an UTB this was his choice however doing so took him into -dkp.
Also Rinoa was not playing his hunter last night and it was played by someone else. This i was told before the raid started i told him i disliked people doing this, as it can make problems as it has done so here.
I did ask him had he checked with the hunters with the DKP was it ok for him to take them as it was the last part he needed. He told yes he had checked and they said they would pass.
Many, many times i have said in the hunter channel NOT to make deals no matter how much u trust the other hunters NOT to do it. People change their minds all the time and tbh people are free to do so.
If Rinoa had the dkp then there may not of been a problem however he didnt, he was in -dkp so Rua bidded max as she wanted the boots just as much as him.
Rua used the DKP she had earned to take the boots which she has lost twice and is now at 6/8 DS.
Was this fair or Rua maybe, was it fair of Rinoa to ask for people to pass even though he was already in -DKP maybe it was.
However it has happened now and rua has her boots which i am gald to see after how long she has had to wait for them however i do feel sad that Rinoa was not able to get his full 8/8 DS but its done now and i hope people have learned from it.
I trust Rua and i trust Rinoa but i think in this case both had good reasons to do what they did.
The problem of people playing someones account when they are not around is being looked at tomorrow at the Mod meeting. An account of this meeting like all the other meetings we have had will be posted on the forums.
If anyone has something they would like brought up at the meeting feel free to let me know.
Any other questions pls ask.
Mip
Rinoa only needed the DS boots fpr full 8/8 DS and has been after them for some time, however Rua who won them last night has been after them for even longer and has lost them twice, once to a hunter who should of really used more commen sense on the item rather then bidding on it due to it being teir 2. And has admitted that it was a mistake at the time to bid.
This said Rua had the dkp to max bid, Rinoa was in -dkp and had used his last DKP on the DS bracers and an UTB this was his choice however doing so took him into -dkp.
Also Rinoa was not playing his hunter last night and it was played by someone else. This i was told before the raid started i told him i disliked people doing this, as it can make problems as it has done so here.
I did ask him had he checked with the hunters with the DKP was it ok for him to take them as it was the last part he needed. He told yes he had checked and they said they would pass.
Many, many times i have said in the hunter channel NOT to make deals no matter how much u trust the other hunters NOT to do it. People change their minds all the time and tbh people are free to do so.
If Rinoa had the dkp then there may not of been a problem however he didnt, he was in -dkp so Rua bidded max as she wanted the boots just as much as him.
Rua used the DKP she had earned to take the boots which she has lost twice and is now at 6/8 DS.
Was this fair or Rua maybe, was it fair of Rinoa to ask for people to pass even though he was already in -DKP maybe it was.
However it has happened now and rua has her boots which i am gald to see after how long she has had to wait for them however i do feel sad that Rinoa was not able to get his full 8/8 DS but its done now and i hope people have learned from it.
I trust Rua and i trust Rinoa but i think in this case both had good reasons to do what they did.
The problem of people playing someones account when they are not around is being looked at tomorrow at the Mod meeting. An account of this meeting like all the other meetings we have had will be posted on the forums.
If anyone has something they would like brought up at the meeting feel free to let me know.
Any other questions pls ask.
Mip
Lies can be good, If they are put to good use.
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Heh, all this just remembered me of a certain egghead (<3 Heffi). Guess dkp is dkp, but it aint easy to build a bridge if someone isnt even certain where to go.

-
Feitan
- Posts: 31
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:00 am
Fascination for old german dictating genocidal short men, and no sense of what one wants :P oh yeah good old times.
Problems are to be shown and solved and im sure they will. elsewise chaos will triumvate and thats /dance
nah but in all normal sense this was <censored> up
and its pretty clear why and im sorry to say i havent seen a single reason to tell me that any of the cases was like OH OKAY fair and understandable.
There are necesities but as you said its not a hardcore pve guild nor with any rules for them.
How can any say theres one of those now like Amfg.... x) thats called hypocracy :P <3
Things need to add up, make that happen and complaints will die away.
And love will rise x) - love is in the air <3 jouni billy mattias jess johan marcus even grumpy mipp and lars! minilosty and all the ppl here .
This wasnt about any person this was about the bussiness part and the inconcistency and unfairness of it :>
Anyhow its on the table and how will it be eaten and which way will it come out? frontdoor or backdoor :>
Let time tell us (chop chop plx :x ) patience is no virtue sometimes :P <3
Problems are to be shown and solved and im sure they will. elsewise chaos will triumvate and thats /dance
nah but in all normal sense this was <censored> up
There are necesities but as you said its not a hardcore pve guild nor with any rules for them.
How can any say theres one of those now like Amfg.... x) thats called hypocracy :P <3
Things need to add up, make that happen and complaints will die away.
And love will rise x) - love is in the air <3 jouni billy mattias jess johan marcus even grumpy mipp and lars! minilosty and all the ppl here .
This wasnt about any person this was about the bussiness part and the inconcistency and unfairness of it :>
Anyhow its on the table and how will it be eaten and which way will it come out? frontdoor or backdoor :>
Let time tell us (chop chop plx :x ) patience is no virtue sometimes :P <3
Banshou issai,
Kaijin to Nase.
Kaijin to Nase.
-
Himico
- Posts: 32
- Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 2:30 am
When it comes to tanks etc the situation is different, we progress with our tanks and their gear, which is why the MT and the OT _always_ get priority over others, its unfair at start - it really is. but without them we cant get any further. but that doesnt go for all other classes.Arche wrote:I think however it should still be able for certain people to get easier access to items.
Ive been warrior, DPS warrior in another guild, and I accepted and respected our MT to get all tanking loot, Its not like I cant tank in blues? And by the time you've reached Naxxramas even dps warriors should have some tanking loot from either mc/bwl/zg.
but you cant put priorities on any other member, thats not fair and how are you supposed to raid if all the members who are treated differently from the core members stopped raiding. whats the point if you'd have no chance of getting an item if its already pre-determied that its going to one specific person if it drops?
thats why a DKP system exist, if you are there and if you want it you can bid - thats also where guild spirit comes in. if you knew someone wanted it more then anything else, im quite sure 95% of the people would pass. some people are more opened then others about their wants.
If its going to be run like that in this guild, then why do we even have DKP? since its the officers and the master minds behind the guilds that decide who deserves what?
I like a lot of people in this guild and the atmosphere so dont get me wrong, but I aint going to be toyed like that. Even if not everyones a serious raider or a serious gamer, I sure know that I am. I played this game to have fun, to enjoy it with people and to succeed with goals I share with others. Thats what Im paying for, thats what Im working for.
-
Arche
- Posts: 223
- Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
To quote Quantumdelta:
"Our DKP system is flawed and CAN be abused."
People should also be able to use their dkp to buy (for example) Giantstalker belts, and sell them on the auction house. This however would benefit the guild with absopositively nothing
The DKP system has been made to create order in disorder. It should not be looked upon as an absolute perfect system, but as a guideline.
The Officers call was given, and accepted. Tomorrow there will be a modmeeting deciding if this will be able to happen again. And I'd like to vouch my vote to yes.
"Our DKP system is flawed and CAN be abused."
People should also be able to use their dkp to buy (for example) Giantstalker belts, and sell them on the auction house. This however would benefit the guild with absopositively nothing
The DKP system has been made to create order in disorder. It should not be looked upon as an absolute perfect system, but as a guideline.
The Officers call was given, and accepted. Tomorrow there will be a modmeeting deciding if this will be able to happen again. And I'd like to vouch my vote to yes.
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
Since nobody is paying attention to me, I'll post again, then lock it 
It strikes me that this could have been avoided if folks had known, generally, and at least the other eligible people informed in /tell or /w or whatever its called in WoW.
Communication goes a long way. And its really easy to do. It happened, it sounds like it wasn't malicious, probably fair to the person who actually got the gear, and generally not a bad thing. I somehow doubt it will be the last time those particurlar bits will drop.
I don't much care for DKP type systems, i am a need before greed kinda guy, but that doesn't often scale in a community as large as this one, so I understand WHY you need DKP.
Make sure people know, and if they weren't paying attention to you when you told them, that's a different problem.
OVERCOMMUNICATE.
Let the mods discuss it, by all means, but don't tear yourselves apart over it.
It strikes me that this could have been avoided if folks had known, generally, and at least the other eligible people informed in /tell or /w or whatever its called in WoW.
Communication goes a long way. And its really easy to do. It happened, it sounds like it wasn't malicious, probably fair to the person who actually got the gear, and generally not a bad thing. I somehow doubt it will be the last time those particurlar bits will drop.
I don't much care for DKP type systems, i am a need before greed kinda guy, but that doesn't often scale in a community as large as this one, so I understand WHY you need DKP.
Make sure people know, and if they weren't paying attention to you when you told them, that's a different problem.
OVERCOMMUNICATE.
Let the mods discuss it, by all means, but don't tear yourselves apart over it.
No signature
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Oh dear, quiz beat me to it. Well he said in short exactly what i just wrote down a littl bit more eleborated. HF in talking it out in tomorrows meeting & make sure to keep it civil. 
-------
The dkp system IS the first priority when it comes to distribution, but its flawed & not always fair. Officers (or masterminds, kek) in ssx dont get a say at all, they hold responsibility for many things, but not the power to dictate.
There are times when its sensitive to branch out of the narrow dkp path, but thats business of the class / persons involved. Read: im not talking about deals. Thats part of beeing in the loop i guess, but it wouldnt & shouldnt be done if not everyone is content with it. Take our mages: prob the most close bond bunch in ssx-wow if you want to splinter the guild in some subgroups.
Before AQ20 was patched they completely figured out who wants which book & in which order mages will receive it. Their concern was solely for the benefit of the guild in total, so irrespective of who went to AQ20... the books were distributed. It didnt matter, because all involved were content with this & agreed. There was no, lets say someone who skips AQ20 because hes the first to get frostbolt 9 anyway... no hassle about spots in a 20man raid to get a chance on the bookdrop & once you get it youll never set a foot in there ever again. Ill come to the point, dont worry (
)... its the teamwork without any ulterior motive. An AQ20 is thrown together, ok... lets see who actually wants to run it... if there are more than enough, fine lets talk it out... if the raid at 2am is short on mages, fine ppl will still tag along because they dont let guildies down.
Give them a chance. Loot in general or any drop, regardless, can in no way match a group of ppl who trust each other, but its the best way to destroy it. The only problem here is the ever so infamous lack of communication.
-------
The dkp system IS the first priority when it comes to distribution, but its flawed & not always fair. Officers (or masterminds, kek) in ssx dont get a say at all, they hold responsibility for many things, but not the power to dictate.
There are times when its sensitive to branch out of the narrow dkp path, but thats business of the class / persons involved. Read: im not talking about deals. Thats part of beeing in the loop i guess, but it wouldnt & shouldnt be done if not everyone is content with it. Take our mages: prob the most close bond bunch in ssx-wow if you want to splinter the guild in some subgroups.
Before AQ20 was patched they completely figured out who wants which book & in which order mages will receive it. Their concern was solely for the benefit of the guild in total, so irrespective of who went to AQ20... the books were distributed. It didnt matter, because all involved were content with this & agreed. There was no, lets say someone who skips AQ20 because hes the first to get frostbolt 9 anyway... no hassle about spots in a 20man raid to get a chance on the bookdrop & once you get it youll never set a foot in there ever again. Ill come to the point, dont worry (
Give them a chance. Loot in general or any drop, regardless, can in no way match a group of ppl who trust each other, but its the best way to destroy it. The only problem here is the ever so infamous lack of communication.
