Ambush wrote: But then again, its to early to tell, once HDTV's become a must in every home, then we'll find out the winner of this battle
PS 3 Games
Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators
-
Ambush
- Posts: 489
- Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2005 5:37 pm
- Location: Canada
"Ambush, You Have deceived us! I'm gonna hunt you and your ship to the ends of the universe!" --SSC-Fahd "Ham Chronicles"
-
Lee
- Posts: 137
- Joined: Tue Dec 28, 2004 5:53 pm
and combo disks hd dvd bluray gluePadishar wrote:Quick Update:
Seems the HD-DVD vs BluRay war has taken an unexpected turn for the better.... HD-DvD/BluRay Combo Player
for relativley low cost 360 owners can grab the addon and watch a selection (not huge by any means) of HD content movies. considering the purchase of hd ready tellies without actually having an HD source...this could have been a market deciding factor, had the publishers shipped as many movies they could in the format all over the place. the example i would think of is the inferior mp3 got all over the place (freely in most cases) and people supported it even though there are better encryptions about.
have to agree with BD though, having 6+ gb of crap (whether game data or space for movie encyption) is a very substantial difference. Film-wise you can see the 'boxiness' of a lower bit rate dvd let alone lesser movie...the quality of a single film on a bluray disc has the potential for 1080i (i is the higher than p ??) with plenty of space for extra goodness. (as much as i still eyeball sony for its endless proprietry memory cards/data store/encryption and the whole rootkit debacle) -i''ll pretend it's all LG instead.... go LG, make everyones products more affordable
Edit: removing tag, and...
"Last night, the HD DVD Promotion Group proudly claimed some 175,000 HD DVD players were sold in the US by 5 January this year. An impressive number for a totally new format, but one eclipsed by the 475,000 Blu-ray ready PlayStation 3s Sony sold in the period between the console's 17 November launch and Christmas Day." 08/01/2007
Eeks.
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
P (progressive scan) is higher than I (interlaced) in terms of resolution.
For the record, the 360's HD addon player improves, substantially, the sharpness of existing DVD's and HD DVD's are stunning on even a 1080i TV.
So, users get benefits from it even without a large library of content. I assume the same is true of hte BR players, that they will improve the regular DVD playback in a noticeable way.
Netflix started shipping HD and BR versions of disks, so the content for both platforms is coming.
And BlueFlames takes all the fun out of this stuff
For the record, the 360's HD addon player improves, substantially, the sharpness of existing DVD's and HD DVD's are stunning on even a 1080i TV.
So, users get benefits from it even without a large library of content. I assume the same is true of hte BR players, that they will improve the regular DVD playback in a noticeable way.
Netflix started shipping HD and BR versions of disks, so the content for both platforms is coming.
And BlueFlames takes all the fun out of this stuff
No signature
-
SoulSeeker
- Posts: 299
- Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 8:02 pm
- Location: Scotland
Betamax was better quality than vhs but the consumer decided betamax fate.
-
firedancer
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
- Location: Innsbruck, Austria
let me just shortly summarize how i understand the different formats.Inquisitor wrote:P (progressive scan) is higher than I (interlaced) in terms of resolution.
For the record, the 360's HD addon player improves, substantially, the sharpness of existing DVD's and HD DVD's are stunning on even a 1080i TV.
first, if you quote 1080i or (p) you leave out the frame rate (fps)
coventionally it is written behind, i.e., 1080i60 for an american TV.
1080i60 : 60 times per second half of the picture, i.e., 30 full pictures
in a second
1080p60: 60 times the full picture in a second.
now if you watch a movie, you should be aware that the movie was
filmed on 24 fps, which is much lower than 60. so the "best" data you
can create from a movie is actually 1080p24 (i.e., 24 full pictures per
second, which is actually less data as you can transmit in a 1080i
format). if you convert it to 1080i60 or even 1080p60 you add just more
redundant pixels by repeating the same information from the 1080p24
source.
so i dont think it does at all matter whether you watch a HD DVD on a
1080i or 1080p television, they both contain the same information from
the original source (1080p24) just with more or less redundant
information. in the end it will be important what you TV does with your
information. (most tv's recieving a 1080i60 signal convert it anyway to
1080p60 by just showing each full picture twice.)
the only difference i see is if you play a game, where the actual fps can
be really 60. then it is probably a improvement to have a 1080p60 tv;
in all other situations as watching TV or movies it does not matter at all.
that is my conclusion after reading a bit about the different formats, but
i am happy if someone can prove me wrong.
-
requiemdreamer
- Posts: 500
- Joined: Sun May 29, 2005 12:16 am
- Location: CNY
Nintendo Wii FTW? 
(US) Mannoroth Server
Warlock: Requiemdream
Shaman: Saeglopur
The imprisoner of souls into tiny little purple gem things.
Warlock: Requiemdream
Shaman: Saeglopur
The imprisoner of souls into tiny little purple gem things.
-
BlueFlames
- Posts: 465
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
- Location: SSX Vault 12
The official SSX buzzkill, right here.And BlueFlames takes all the fun out of this stuff.
-
Padishar
- Posts: 1713
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:15 pm
- Location: Next Door
I think there is a 1080e standard out now as wellInquisitor wrote:P (progressive scan) is higher than I (interlaced) in terms of resolution.
For the record, the 360's HD addon player improves, substantially, the sharpness of existing DVD's and HD DVD's are stunning on even a 1080i TV.
So, users get benefits from it even without a large library of content. I assume the same is true of hte BR players, that they will improve the regular DVD playback in a noticeable way.
Netflix started shipping HD and BR versions of disks, so the content for both platforms is coming.
And BlueFlames takes all the fun out of this stuff
A side note for those that can't afford either HD-DVD or BluRay player atm, but still wish to get the most out of their DVD's...
You can buy a DVD-Upscaler (many R easily under $70) to upscale all yer DVD's to 1080i
