So did anyone else other than Sl33py, Ava and myself pick up a copy of this?
Despite some of the negativity it has received I'm happy to say this is the GOTY as far as I'm concerned. Not disappointed in the slightest but then I didn't go in expecting it to be something different.
Mafia 2 has a very well told story (whilst the usual for mob flick fans) delivered with superb voice acting, likeable characters, wonderful music and a beautiful, highly detailed 40s/50s open world to
support the story. If you go into the game expecting there to be countless activities to do in the city outside of the main story like pointless side missions which probably wouldn't impact the main story anyway or bowling, pool etc like SR2 or GTA4's playgrounds then you may be disappointed. It's very linear in comparison but it's supposed to be that way, same with Mafia 1. That being said I've never felt restricted whilst I've been playing or that the city being as detailed as it is and exploring that, being pointless. Like Mafia 1 when you complete one mission (chapter) you're immediately onto the next so it's like one continuous story. So whilst driving home from a job (or before you head there) you can spend that time to explore, go buy clothes, stock up on weapons/ammo, crush or export cars for cash, rob stores, fill up on petrol/get your car washed or upgraded etc. The game doesn't tell you to go do these things (unless its part of a mission) but it feels totally natural to choose to stop by some place on my way home, or go wreck havoc for a bit.
If you do decide to go rob some stores or have a shootout during this time, try not to get yourself killed and go change your plates/clothes before you head to your main destination to trigger the save. Like M1 there is no manual save, it does this automatically at checkpoints and at the beginning/end of a chapter. I did read some people complaining about these being spread too far apart and them having to retry them was becoming annoying but tbh I think they're making an issue there where there isn't one, unless they suck at the game or something because I've not found this a problem at all and I'm playing on hard. So if you die whilst robbing or whatever, you die and go back to the last checkpoint. You don't appear outside a city hospital or anything silly like that, which in a Mafia game would be ridiculous. (You go to the hospital with severe gunshot wounds and the first thing they're gonna do is call the cops on your arse, even says that in the game heh).
As said before it's a very story driven game so there's a lot of dialogue and cutscenes, again, like Mafia 1. Sometimes I've wished for a little more action like "I'd rather be playing this combat out as gameplay rather than watching a cutscene of it" but when you do get to the combat parts it's fantastic. There's a lot of driving again too but I love that (playing simulation). The city is so immersive and feels very alive (has some scripted moments which add to that but they don't stand out like a sore thumb). I really enjoy driving to locations cos of that, taking in the scenery and everything and it really encourages me to roleplay as if I'm really Vito so I always stick to the speed limit unless I need to speed up for a job rather than driving around like a mad man and same with being on foot. I'll walk everywhere rather than run, cept when I have to. The Driving (and damage) mechanics have been perfect and have really added to the immersion and realism because of this, for me at least. [I can understand Anny liking the arcade style of the old GTA titles and hopefully Mafia2's "normal" driving option rather than simulation one will be better for that, though obviously not the same. But tbh I don't think having driving like that would fit in a story driven mafia game like this anyway. Have a serious story but then driving all over the place heh] Anyway the roleplaying I speak of has really added to my enjoyment, especially in the beginning of the game (and when you're carrying the suitcase as you need to walk then anyway). Come to think of it I've never felt like doing that in other similar games, I always run/drive fast (but carefully) everywhere. Never even consider "would Vito really be driving like a lunatic at this point?..." hehe.
Might post some more at some point and some pics too but I shall look forward to reading everyone else's comments (if others did indeed get a copy too) and hopefully be positive ones too!.
Awesome game.
[Edit - Few more pics

]
And for anyone who wants, here's the two main menu backgrounds (without the text). Been using one as my wallpaper.
