[Devil's Advocate]If he did not regret it, why edit the applications to Proeliatoris and Synergy when he thought they wouldnt be found?
To be sure they wouldn't be found, rather than just think it? Because he got turned down?
[/Devil's Advocate]
Moderator: Global Moderators
[Devil's Advocate]If he did not regret it, why edit the applications to Proeliatoris and Synergy when he thought they wouldnt be found?
Both, hopefully. I can only speak for myself though :PInquisitor wrote:Which side can live with a negative result?
Of Course, if anyone else that doesn't play WoW would like to vote as well as to whether or not you think Siolith should be given another chance or not, please feel free to vote. We're all SSX afterall.Stracius wrote:Sorry if I'm poking my nose in what some might feel isn't my business, but I feel that as a SSX member it is my business. Even if I'm not a WoW player.
Sioliths persistent engagement here shows that he cares. I cant tell if its genuine either, but at least he is here unlike Shadow & Baz. Over the last 2 days Siolith made clear that he WANTS to be SSX & thats reason enough for me to give him a trial & go from there.Inquisitor wrote:Siol, I don't know you, which is a shame, but, I have been doing this online thing for 20 years, and I can count on one hand the number of times one of these apologies has been genuine.
Prove me wrong. Stay, and stay for the right reasons.
I was taken in once, and it disgusts me that I fell for it. I will NOT be taken in again.firedancer wrote:it is time for us to show what friendship really is: it includes to give some one a second chance and be generous. and he deserves a real second chance where he has some time in the guild to show that he wants to be with us.
Thats one thing I wont argue with. He does indeed seem to want to be a part of the guild. It is the interpretation of WHY I will argue with.Sioliths persistent engagement here shows that he cares. I cant tell if its genuine either, but at least he is here unlike Shadow & Baz. Over the last 2 days Siolith made clear that he WANTS to be SSX & thats reason enough for me to give him a trial & go from there.
Have you read anything of what I have said?Anubis wrote: The only reason he wants to be SSX now is because his other choices won't accept him and he doesn't want to be guildless. That is no reason to want to be a part of this guild.
Its not a judgement about the rules, those guidelines are above the mere vote done here & for a reason ofc. But its a judgement about your trust in someone who apperently lost this privilege & it implies some risk. He is a person however sitting behind his screen & whatever illusions he had of beeing in a *leet* guild or about us kicking him if he cant attend all raids (sounds like bs, nm)... a trial along with a raidban for some time until trust is partly restored, is fair imo.Anubis wrote:Each and every one of you is sending a message. If its a no its a message for some discipline within the guild. To not let rulebreakers get away with it. If its a yes then its a 'the rules dont matter'.
I have read all that everyone has said over the course of these two threads, and I have seen thats what you have said.siolith wrote:Have you read anything of what I have said?Anubis wrote: The only reason he wants to be SSX now is because his other choices won't accept him and he doesn't want to be guildless. That is no reason to want to be a part of this guild.
I said I applied to other guilds because I thought that I wasn't gonne be welcome here. and I also said that after talking to QD I know that I would have wanted to stay even if another guild had accepted me.
Ofcourse it is. but you are telling everyone that I'm only here because I didn't get to join the other guilds.Anubis wrote:I have read all that everyone has said over the course of these two threads, and I have seen thats what you have said.siolith wrote:Have you read anything of what I have said?Anubis wrote: The only reason he wants to be SSX now is because his other choices won't accept him and he doesn't want to be guildless. That is no reason to want to be a part of this guild.
I said I applied to other guilds because I thought that I wasn't gonne be welcome here. and I also said that after talking to QD I know that I would have wanted to stay even if another guild had accepted me.
However seeing and believing are two different things. Just because I have read everything you have said does not mean I believe it.