Disbanding the guild?
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
Magdalena
- Posts: 571
- Joined: Sat Jul 30, 2005 5:59 pm
- Location: Mannoroth, USA
You have many different types of players, that for different reasons gravitate more towards different aspects of the game and go through at vary different paces. For purposes of simplifying, I'm using only Hardcore and Casual here but there are many levels in between, each individual is different no matter how many you believe to share your opinions.
There are a couple of views that draw some very heated arguments from these two types of players. I'm not saying all or any of our guys say this out loud or even think it, these are the standard responses I've seen around WoW from these two groups, and no matter how slight of a degree one might think/say them, they drive a wedge into groups like SSX like nothing I've ever seen before in this game. Neither is bad or wrong per se except in the fact that they don't seem to accept the other group on any level.
First, the 'hardcore' members seem to already consider the casuals as lesser beings to some extent. They don't seem to take into consideration that sometimes even if the casuals have the desire to put as much into raiding, they may not have the ability to put that much time into it. Jobs, schedules, kids, wives, and all sorts of RL things put more limits on play time allowed for some than others. They shouldn't be punished or held back because of real life. If they're able to get on and just aren't working for it that's a different issue, but at least shown on the forums there's no allowance visible for these things.
Second, 'casual' members seem to think the above schedules should exclude them from having to help prepare equally for raids if they want to go. It isn't fair to ask others to pick up slack for you because you can't play as much, and it's not fair to ask the group to hold themselves back for you. Your schedule limitations means it's going to take you longer to get through things than the 'hardcore' group. Most understood this while leveling their characters, but seem to forget it once raid times come up.
In other places, some just enjoy different aspects of the game and that's their hold-up. If this is the case, respect those that enjoy a different portion of the game. If you're not into the raiding enough to put forth work to progress, let the group that is go and progress, only join them when you are prepared and wanting to work and help out and pull your own weight. If you enjoy raiding and going full force, understand there are other friends who don't. When they don't want to go, don't press because you need more people or need their class. If they don't want to go, they're likely not prepared and will just result in arguments. Respect one anothers boundaries and do what you like with those that like it as well. Host goofy events to bring all together once a week, but don't expect them to be a progress builder for one side or another. Have an instance on farm status? Turn it to a once a week drinking run... even if everybody isn't drinking, nobody expects great things from a bunch of drunks so it lightens the mood considerably.
As for raid requirements, my suggestion would be to make them just that... requirements to go on the raid not be a full part of a raid group. In this manner it will keep a stricter code on your raids but not have it affect being an equal member of the guild itself. The casuals should then understand they may have to skip one or two raids to spend that time gathering items they need to go on the next one and be useful if they still really want to go. These would be changing constantly depending on the raid, and those going to new content more regularly (the core group) might get priority on some items to keep momentum going. Keep the list up here... such as for MC you'll need x,y,z... for BWL you'll need x,y,z... etc.
If you don't have enough members prepped for doing the next tough instance, look in other places rather than casual members. Look for another group in the same boat and join up your 'core' members. Ensure you agree upon requirements. Most WoW guilds have these issues when starting a new instance, no matter how big or good they might seem. Have an agreement that you'll go with them to the last boss and work to get both guild's core members geared up to help the rest, about that time the casuals usually start wanting to go and the two core groups can split until ready for the next new instance.
Key is don't allow your hardcore group to provide materials for the casuals, and stop casuals immediately if they start asking for them to. Keep track constantly on who's attending the new instance/boss you're trying to get to, almost ignore attendance on farmed instances and bosses. Have a standard on dropping DKP value a certain % for each week after a boss goes on farm status and dropping the cost of their items the same % each week.
Separate the raids themselves rather than separating the people... most understand they take a certain amount of work to move forward, but it shouldn't change how you treat guildmates and shouldn't affect them outside of the raid itself.
These are just very rough ideas and opinions of mine alone, most likely they won't be used at all but thought I'd post for the off chance you guys might find something useful out of it. Not trying (nor could I) to tell you guys what to do or not do, just trying to come up with something that incorporates more than just the raiders or the casuals but keeps both able to be a part of a great group and answers some of the issues both might be having.
There are a couple of views that draw some very heated arguments from these two types of players. I'm not saying all or any of our guys say this out loud or even think it, these are the standard responses I've seen around WoW from these two groups, and no matter how slight of a degree one might think/say them, they drive a wedge into groups like SSX like nothing I've ever seen before in this game. Neither is bad or wrong per se except in the fact that they don't seem to accept the other group on any level.
First, the 'hardcore' members seem to already consider the casuals as lesser beings to some extent. They don't seem to take into consideration that sometimes even if the casuals have the desire to put as much into raiding, they may not have the ability to put that much time into it. Jobs, schedules, kids, wives, and all sorts of RL things put more limits on play time allowed for some than others. They shouldn't be punished or held back because of real life. If they're able to get on and just aren't working for it that's a different issue, but at least shown on the forums there's no allowance visible for these things.
Second, 'casual' members seem to think the above schedules should exclude them from having to help prepare equally for raids if they want to go. It isn't fair to ask others to pick up slack for you because you can't play as much, and it's not fair to ask the group to hold themselves back for you. Your schedule limitations means it's going to take you longer to get through things than the 'hardcore' group. Most understood this while leveling their characters, but seem to forget it once raid times come up.
In other places, some just enjoy different aspects of the game and that's their hold-up. If this is the case, respect those that enjoy a different portion of the game. If you're not into the raiding enough to put forth work to progress, let the group that is go and progress, only join them when you are prepared and wanting to work and help out and pull your own weight. If you enjoy raiding and going full force, understand there are other friends who don't. When they don't want to go, don't press because you need more people or need their class. If they don't want to go, they're likely not prepared and will just result in arguments. Respect one anothers boundaries and do what you like with those that like it as well. Host goofy events to bring all together once a week, but don't expect them to be a progress builder for one side or another. Have an instance on farm status? Turn it to a once a week drinking run... even if everybody isn't drinking, nobody expects great things from a bunch of drunks so it lightens the mood considerably.
As for raid requirements, my suggestion would be to make them just that... requirements to go on the raid not be a full part of a raid group. In this manner it will keep a stricter code on your raids but not have it affect being an equal member of the guild itself. The casuals should then understand they may have to skip one or two raids to spend that time gathering items they need to go on the next one and be useful if they still really want to go. These would be changing constantly depending on the raid, and those going to new content more regularly (the core group) might get priority on some items to keep momentum going. Keep the list up here... such as for MC you'll need x,y,z... for BWL you'll need x,y,z... etc.
If you don't have enough members prepped for doing the next tough instance, look in other places rather than casual members. Look for another group in the same boat and join up your 'core' members. Ensure you agree upon requirements. Most WoW guilds have these issues when starting a new instance, no matter how big or good they might seem. Have an agreement that you'll go with them to the last boss and work to get both guild's core members geared up to help the rest, about that time the casuals usually start wanting to go and the two core groups can split until ready for the next new instance.
Key is don't allow your hardcore group to provide materials for the casuals, and stop casuals immediately if they start asking for them to. Keep track constantly on who's attending the new instance/boss you're trying to get to, almost ignore attendance on farmed instances and bosses. Have a standard on dropping DKP value a certain % for each week after a boss goes on farm status and dropping the cost of their items the same % each week.
Separate the raids themselves rather than separating the people... most understand they take a certain amount of work to move forward, but it shouldn't change how you treat guildmates and shouldn't affect them outside of the raid itself.
These are just very rough ideas and opinions of mine alone, most likely they won't be used at all but thought I'd post for the off chance you guys might find something useful out of it. Not trying (nor could I) to tell you guys what to do or not do, just trying to come up with something that incorporates more than just the raiders or the casuals but keeps both able to be a part of a great group and answers some of the issues both might be having.
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
I'm not going to repeat anything MS has written earlier on but I would like to state I agree with what he has said. I think people should take the time to read through what he wrote carefully and realise just what going ahead with the ''guild split'' and how it would affect the ssx.
If the idea ever looked as though it was going ahead, I think it would meet far more like minded people, like myself and a few others.
If the idea ever looked as though it was going ahead, I think it would meet far more like minded people, like myself and a few others.
Last edited by SSX-Ava on Fri Sep 01, 2006 10:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Magdalena, truly words of wisdom there <3
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
While awesome on paper, I wouldn't be so hard pressed to mark that as gold when it comes to how things happen practically.
No matter how you separate the raids, the raiders and the casual people, you're going to have a split no matter what. Splits are generally bad things no matter how you slice it. Any segregation that occurs between the definitions of "hardcore raider" and "casual" will simply split the people into two groups where one won't have time to even look at the other.
This is where the double edged sword kicks in of equality while creating almost certain animosity towards one another, because let's face it, some of those casuals would like to go the hardcore way, but are held up by other things which in turn in all cases that I've seen, they'll feel inferior for being stuck in a group they don't want to be in.
While all this niceness is going on, and it's just one example above while there are multiple dead-end walls that you might run into - you will all be under the same banner hating each others guts for whatever reasons - ranging from the fact that you belong to one group and not the other to simple personal issues you might have with another member.
That in turn, causes the crap to overflow here in various manifestations that we've seen throughout the years from people before this group even existed, and it's all a nice perpetuating mess that ultimately a few of us will have to clean up.
The SSX axioms as undefined as they are, purposely do not allow for any type of gamer to commit to a "Hardcore Raider" type of gaming, on any stretch of the imagination where a hardcore raider would benefit from such a playing style under the banner of the SSX.
In my opinion, any split, raid wise or guild wise, is not going to work and it will cheapen the name of the SSX as time goes on and as people separate from one another.
My suggestion to you is to start looking at things as they are. You don't have enough people to raid as much as some of you would want to, that much is obvious. Even some of those that can and want to, can't cut themselves out to the standard that is needed to achieve those goals.
Instead of doing any kinds of splits and divisions, I'd encourage you to find your balls and make some serious choices in accordance to the duty you owe to the SSX rather than a service to your own personal needs - meaning if you really need to raid right now and defeat Naxx and all that shit, you go somewhere where that is possible to achieve without creating an even bigger mess for people here.
There's nothing wrong with wanting more out of the game that you can't get here. But at the very least, do everyone a favor and pick what you want already and move on. If you want to raid, plenty of raiding guilds all ready and waiting for you to go to them so you can get that endgame that you wish. Go there, stay friends with the people in the SSX (Unless you have to break friendships here if you were to leave for something else in other guilds?) and get what you want.
Don't force people to feel like they can't cut it to your standard (which is fictitious anyway because SSX doesn't have those standards by itself) by making splits and differences, and let them do whatever they want within the boundaries that we hold primary here (unchallenged and unhindered friendship being one of them).
Just another view anyway.
No matter how you separate the raids, the raiders and the casual people, you're going to have a split no matter what. Splits are generally bad things no matter how you slice it. Any segregation that occurs between the definitions of "hardcore raider" and "casual" will simply split the people into two groups where one won't have time to even look at the other.
This is where the double edged sword kicks in of equality while creating almost certain animosity towards one another, because let's face it, some of those casuals would like to go the hardcore way, but are held up by other things which in turn in all cases that I've seen, they'll feel inferior for being stuck in a group they don't want to be in.
While all this niceness is going on, and it's just one example above while there are multiple dead-end walls that you might run into - you will all be under the same banner hating each others guts for whatever reasons - ranging from the fact that you belong to one group and not the other to simple personal issues you might have with another member.
That in turn, causes the crap to overflow here in various manifestations that we've seen throughout the years from people before this group even existed, and it's all a nice perpetuating mess that ultimately a few of us will have to clean up.
The SSX axioms as undefined as they are, purposely do not allow for any type of gamer to commit to a "Hardcore Raider" type of gaming, on any stretch of the imagination where a hardcore raider would benefit from such a playing style under the banner of the SSX.
In my opinion, any split, raid wise or guild wise, is not going to work and it will cheapen the name of the SSX as time goes on and as people separate from one another.
My suggestion to you is to start looking at things as they are. You don't have enough people to raid as much as some of you would want to, that much is obvious. Even some of those that can and want to, can't cut themselves out to the standard that is needed to achieve those goals.
Instead of doing any kinds of splits and divisions, I'd encourage you to find your balls and make some serious choices in accordance to the duty you owe to the SSX rather than a service to your own personal needs - meaning if you really need to raid right now and defeat Naxx and all that shit, you go somewhere where that is possible to achieve without creating an even bigger mess for people here.
There's nothing wrong with wanting more out of the game that you can't get here. But at the very least, do everyone a favor and pick what you want already and move on. If you want to raid, plenty of raiding guilds all ready and waiting for you to go to them so you can get that endgame that you wish. Go there, stay friends with the people in the SSX (Unless you have to break friendships here if you were to leave for something else in other guilds?) and get what you want.
Don't force people to feel like they can't cut it to your standard (which is fictitious anyway because SSX doesn't have those standards by itself) by making splits and differences, and let them do whatever they want within the boundaries that we hold primary here (unchallenged and unhindered friendship being one of them).
Just another view anyway.
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
I hope you do realise what repercussions will emerge if a good number of our current "hardcore raiders" take this advice highly effecting what we currently may define as "casuals" and even those that enjoy raiding and wish to keep doing so under the SSX banner. From a practical point of view, if SSX-WoW keeps losing skilled hardcore players it will possibly end in a gdisband anyway or if it survives it will slowly but surely move in oblivion. It's a pity that few members have at heart enough what SSX managed to achieve its own way throughout the past year and a half.BlackDove wrote: Instead of doing any kinds of splits and divisions, I'd encourage you to find your balls and make some serious choices in accordance to the duty you owe to the SSX rather than a service to your own personal needs - meaning if you really need to raid right now and defeat Naxx and all that shit, you go somewhere where that is possible to achieve without creating an even bigger mess for people here.
There's nothing wrong with wanting more out of the game that you can't get here. But at the very least, do everyone a favor and pick what you want already and move on. If you want to raid, plenty of raiding guilds all ready and waiting for you to go to them so you can get that endgame that you wish. Go there, stay friends with the people in the SSX (Unless you have to break friendships here if you were to leave for something else in other guilds?) and get what you want.
May I also add that the hardcore members currently in SSX-WoW are playing a pivotal role in allowing this guild to be able to farm even the lowest difficulty 40-raid content such as MC and they do this in no search for personal interest. Several members keep going to instances where they need nothing in terms of loot but they go nonetheless to help out, to make the raid even possible to happen and what to they gain? Repair costs mostly, whining at and unfortuantely not one ounce of gratitude of doing this willingly unlike others who prefer bringing ungeared alts instead of a main which would contribute so much more.
Also, this suggestion from BD seems to put in black on white that all those leaving SSX-WoW to pursue endgame content that is denied to them by the direction SSX-WoW is taking, will still remain SSX and have the privilige to play under the SSX banner in other games whilst forming part of another guild in WoW. Am I understanding this correctly BD? Cos I think it's time we make this a tad more clear to all members.
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
Sounds good to me. If you can't sustain it by granting everyone what they want, or at least the good majority, you really should /gdisband if you don't want or aren't willing to make it work for everyone who remains. If that is true, then pretty much what everyone posted in this thread is a lie when they said "They'll stay SSX no matter what". If a community such as this one isn't priority for you, if you need a skilled player's money and time to fix your shit prior to being in a community such as this, I don't really see what you're doing here in the first place.Galador wrote:I hope you do realise what repercussions will emerge if a good number of our current "hardcore raiders" take this advice highly effecting what we currently may define as "casuals" and even those that enjoy raiding and wish to keep doing so under the SSX banner. From a practical point of view, if SSX-WoW keeps losing skilled hardcore players it will possibly end in a gdisband anyway or if it survives it will slowly but surely move in oblivion. It's a pity that few members have at heart enough what SSX managed to achieve its own way throughout the past year and a half.
Sounds like a drag to me. I'm sure they're happy to help and it's all good for the community and the generosity and flowers and bunnies are overflowing, but it just sounds to me like indigent are dragging them down. They want to do endgame, they want to get something out of their game other people can't provide for them. They want it so much in fact, they're willing to SPLIT the group into two to get the people who leech/don't want to do it, off their backs.May I also add that the hardcore members currently in SSX-WoW are playing a pivotal role in allowing this guild to be able to farm even the lowest difficulty 40-raid content such as MC and they do this in no search for personal interest. Several members keep going to instances where they need nothing in terms of loot but they go nonetheless to help out, to make the raid even possible to happen and what to they gain? Repair costs mostly, whining at and unfortuantely not one ounce of gratitude of doing this willingly unlike others who prefer bringing ungeared alts instead of a main which would contribute so much more.
Yes, that has always been how it worked in every game, if those people choose to remain a part of SSX. The only extenuating circumstances were if you leave on bad terms or if you're kicked - then you're not going to be a part of SSX anywhere. But if you leave for another group because you aren't getting from the SSX what you want, and you can get it somewhere else - by all means, get out and we'll see you in some other game at some other time, when you see us fitting your gaming needs.Also, this suggestion from BD seems to put in black on white that all those leaving SSX-WoW to pursue endgame content that is denied to them by the direction SSX-WoW is taking, will still remain SSX and have the privilige to play under the SSX banner in other games whilst forming part of another guild in WoW. Am I understanding this correctly BD? Cos I think it's time we make this a tad more clear to all members.
Some of us prioritise SSX as a gaming need above everything else. In FFXI, I sacrificed all endgame willingly to remain in the SSX. There will be a good chunk of the game I will never experience because of my choice (and I play the game 8-12 hours a day). You know what? That's fine with me. SSX comes first to me rather than some NPC I need to kill in some dungeon. I know what's important to me and I stick with it.
Figure out what's important to you, and choose already.
Bear in mind however that this is just my view on the best course of action any man can take. If you have a conflicting opinion regarding my opinion, you don't even have to outline it, because yours truly really doesn't care. If you feel like a split, a hack or whatever else is the proper course of action in spite of all the reasons we've set forth on why some of us think it won't work - naturally do follow what you believe is right.
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
The plan is tailored to meet the different needs of the different type of players currently playing in SSX-WoW. It is an effort to make ends meet. I thought people would be supportive of at least trying it out before throwing the towel.BlackDove wrote:Sounds good to me. If you can't sustain it by granting everyone what they want, or at least the good majority, you really should /gdisband if you don't want or aren't willing to make it work for everyone who remains.
That's one way of seeing it. The other is that the current "leechers" will be at last affronted with what they want. In other wants, if a casual player wants to remain casual and not raid that much than it's entirely up to him, if he wants to be a part of a hardcore group of raiders then he must fulfill his duties and give his contribution. Is that such a strange notion?BlackDove wrote:They want it so much in fact, they're willing to SPLIT the group into two to get the people who leech/don't want to do it, off their backs.
Then you must have changed your mind when you said these words in:BlackDove wrote: Yes, that has always been how it worked in every game, if those people choose to remain a part of SSX. The only extenuating circumstances were if you leave on bad terms or if you're kicked - then you're not going to be a part of SSX anywhere. But if you leave for another group because you aren't getting from the SSX what you want, and you can get it somewhere else - by all means, get out and we'll see you in some other game at some other time, when you see us fitting your gaming needs.
http://www.shatteredstar.org/ssx/forums ... c&start=35
beacuse back then you had different views if Rikimaru should remain part of SSX or not after he left SSX for endgame raiding.
Once again there is another way of seeing things. What I fear was a factor in the downfall of SSX raiding achievements was that people were afraid of pushing themselves forward. People are happy to remain in their close circle they know well and they know they can master and are unwilling to push themselves further to test their actual skill, verify where they can get etc. Maybe it's cos they are afraid of failing, I don't know. SSX-WoW has achieved a lot throughout the past year. At one specific time, I think we were 3rd or 4th guild on the server wrt raid achievements and we managed that with no particular hard strict requiremnets but simply with having skilled, motivated, like-minded people. We never cared about server firsts or world firsts but there was a genuine wish to test our skill, push ourselves forward and see where we can get to. As long as it was plain sailing, many followed. Upon the first obstacles, the "pseudo-casuals" (it's so easy to hide under this tag when in reality you have other motives), "leechers" just stopped being online on particular days, were generally slacking etc. This is what disappoints me. It's not the lack of progress as such but knowing that we can do so much more but are unable to cos a good chunk of us prefer to sit back comfy and not pushing themselves. I find that very anti-SSX spirit.BlackDove wrote: SSX comes first to me rather than some NPC I need to kill in some dungeon. I know what's important to me and I stick with it. Figure out what's important to you, and choose already.
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
I don't really see much sense in that considering that the only reason you were 3rd or 4th was because QD was up and running things until he had a mental breakdown.
That ship has sailed. You are obviously not capable of maintaining the same level of control and guidance that he was able to (and in the end - he wasn't himself either able to). The reason there's a problem is because the current people who are supposed to be handling it can't take it anymore.
The whole rhetoric about "pushing yourself" and "being afraid to move forward" just simply sounds like pointless mastrubation on the topic to me. The only reason people pushed in the first place, is because they had soemone to push it for them, and then they all said "Ooooooh yeah, let's go follow QD". His back got broken in the process. Come the time for you to start pushing it yourselves - hey, let's do a split shall we? Not like anyone can balme you - the system in place is made impossible when you consider the long run. He couldn't do it forever, you wouldn't be able to either.
Bad news. Anything but to face the fact that you have to make a hard choice. I'm telling you - in my opinion (I feel so retarded for having to point out it's my opinion over and over) you will not be getting anywhere, and more people will be getting hurt and pissed off until you make those choices.
Also as far as this goes -
The way it works as we've seen through a number of examples though, is that you'll still be allowed to be a part of other groups even if you leave for endgame, hence - my phrasing in the post above. I am not the law here, and the majority has decided that it's okay to flip flop your values whenever it suits you. If that's how it is, then that's how it is, and that's how I wrote it is.
That ship has sailed. You are obviously not capable of maintaining the same level of control and guidance that he was able to (and in the end - he wasn't himself either able to). The reason there's a problem is because the current people who are supposed to be handling it can't take it anymore.
The whole rhetoric about "pushing yourself" and "being afraid to move forward" just simply sounds like pointless mastrubation on the topic to me. The only reason people pushed in the first place, is because they had soemone to push it for them, and then they all said "Ooooooh yeah, let's go follow QD". His back got broken in the process. Come the time for you to start pushing it yourselves - hey, let's do a split shall we? Not like anyone can balme you - the system in place is made impossible when you consider the long run. He couldn't do it forever, you wouldn't be able to either.
Bad news. Anything but to face the fact that you have to make a hard choice. I'm telling you - in my opinion (I feel so retarded for having to point out it's my opinion over and over) you will not be getting anywhere, and more people will be getting hurt and pissed off until you make those choices.
Also as far as this goes -
No I haven't changed my mind. My personal opinion is that you're not much of worth as a person if you choose something that I find meaningless in opposition to what the SSX is and what it stands for. It stands to simple logic for me that if you choose Naxx or any of that crap over your friends, there's something <censored> wrong with you. However that is my opinion and my alone.Then you must have changed your mind when you said these words in:
http://www.shatteredstar.org/ssx/forums ... c&start=35
beacuse back then you had different views if Rikimaru should remain part of SSX or not after he left SSX for endgame raiding.
The way it works as we've seen through a number of examples though, is that you'll still be allowed to be a part of other groups even if you leave for endgame, hence - my phrasing in the post above. I am not the law here, and the majority has decided that it's okay to flip flop your values whenever it suits you. If that's how it is, then that's how it is, and that's how I wrote it is.
Last edited by BlackDove on Sat Sep 02, 2006 11:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
SoulSeeker
- Posts: 299
- Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 8:02 pm
- Location: Scotland
achievement
pushing
These are all words which to me depict a body of people trying to push eachother to the limits of their ability,SSX-WoW didnt used to be like that,we were new, QD had the experience of which he shouted alot but not through hate but coz i believe he wanted to make us happy in his sick twisted way:Pprogress
A noob called Ava who frequently in pm would worry about bosses and we had jokes, we had bets ... things didnt go right ..alot , we were learning at our own pace ..it was a guild, a friendly exciting time.We didnt really care about Epics they were these wierd purple things which everytime one dropped it was amazing no matter what it was.... a time of excitment.... then GoE was invited to not so much help well perhaps but to let others share ssx and its ability to goto endgame instences.
More and more success..bred more epics..more greed,jealousy,fights,bikkering etc .. To bring us up to present day, a faction within ssx-wow 'want' to be 'the' best ..'the' elite, to have what they used to have in other guilds.
I for one if a split happens willbe in the casual guild sometimes raiding..sometimes helping lower levels trying to get to endgame readyness,getting to know eachother and joking,laughing becoming a team,trying to uphold SSX ideals.....and yes SSC ideals which although nowadays i'm not so strict with, i still try and uphold.
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
Honestly, thank God for that simply becuase judging what people are worth and not worth is pretentious to say the least and surely not in line of the SSX-Friendship we should all endorse. A true friend never dwells in the illusion that he may judge what another fellow member is worth or not.BlackDove wrote:My personal opinion is that you're not much of worth as a person if you choose something that I find meaningless in opposition to what the SSX is and what it stands for. I am not the law here...
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
I'm not turning this thread into a crusade that argues why I'm right and why you're wrong.Galador wrote:Honestly, thank God for that simply becuase judging what people are worth and not worth is pretentious to say the least and surely not in line of the SSX-Friendship we should all endorse. A true friend never dwells in the illusion that he may judge what another fellow member is worth or not.
You got my input, I'm out of this thread, this is your problem to deal with anyway, and it would be stupid of me to force feed any of my solutions to what won't affect me in the end anyway.
As far as my judgement cast over anyone goes - pretentious it may be but that doesn't make it any less accurate.
I'm done.
-
Krissie
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 8:41 am
- Location: Norway
This guild is special!
The one thing that makes it special and unique from others,is that its room for all!
Here you dont get kicked if you wanna for example, pvp for a while,if youre going inactive,wanna lvl a new char or got things in real life that needs you for a period of time, or simply just need a break..
People can dissapear for a long time, and still be in the guild!
Now some in the guild wanna progress, wanna see how far they can come in this game. Wouldnt it be the right thing to support this and them, its just different interests? Those that wanna try this just have to work harder, its just a choice each and one have to make,and give what it takes! It would be sad to see these people leave or go inactive,when it was a dream to do with SSX, they would just make us proud, because they achieved what they wanna..
As i see this guild as one big united family,where it is room for all! So lets give it a try, let all members go for there dream, and lets do it under SSX name, that we love, that we wanna be a part of!
When i saw the disbanding topic, i got sad, and i was until i read what QD wrote, then i got hope, and i really, really hope we could try this!
So many great people here that i dont wanna see offline, that loved the game, but they just dont play because there is nothing new to experience, but they stay, for the guild, they dont wanna leave SSX!
Let there be room for all, let all try and do what makes the game fun, with this leaders, and with all those great people in this guild, there is something that we can do!
The one thing that makes it special and unique from others,is that its room for all!
Here you dont get kicked if you wanna for example, pvp for a while,if youre going inactive,wanna lvl a new char or got things in real life that needs you for a period of time, or simply just need a break..
People can dissapear for a long time, and still be in the guild!
Now some in the guild wanna progress, wanna see how far they can come in this game. Wouldnt it be the right thing to support this and them, its just different interests? Those that wanna try this just have to work harder, its just a choice each and one have to make,and give what it takes! It would be sad to see these people leave or go inactive,when it was a dream to do with SSX, they would just make us proud, because they achieved what they wanna..
As i see this guild as one big united family,where it is room for all! So lets give it a try, let all members go for there dream, and lets do it under SSX name, that we love, that we wanna be a part of!
When i saw the disbanding topic, i got sad, and i was until i read what QD wrote, then i got hope, and i really, really hope we could try this!
So many great people here that i dont wanna see offline, that loved the game, but they just dont play because there is nothing new to experience, but they stay, for the guild, they dont wanna leave SSX!
Let there be room for all, let all try and do what makes the game fun, with this leaders, and with all those great people in this guild, there is something that we can do!
-
Shoarmabob
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
- Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
A split may be somewhat extreme, but maybe like have 2 ranks?
a hardcore and a casual rank.
If you "sign up" for hardcore rank, you'll be invited to raids before casuals, but you are expected to turn up when you sign for a raid, and you are expected to have consumables etc. for the fight. also, when you ask for you hardcore rank, you have to tell your CL on which days you can be available (in my case that'd be fridays and saturdays), the CL can then maybe put it in the officer note. you will be expected to turn up on those days though, unless you tell your CL you won't be available.
as a casual you'll get invited to raids if you want to and there's not enough hardcore rank members online, and you'll be able to enjoy the game a little more casual.
"hardcore" rank would not mean you would have to have like a 90% raid attendance, like some hardcore guilds do, it would just mean you will have all your stuff needed to raid.
This way hardcorers wouldn't feel any better than casuals because they're in the same guild, just a different "rank" (one not higher than the other)
there wouldn't be a communication issue, and there wouldn't be any segregation (spelling? xD) as we'll all be in the same guild still, the ranks are just to show what your focus is at the moment, raiding, or other things.
Also there wouldn't be a need for any new mods, so there won't be a risk of the casuals (or the hardcore for that matter) being lead by unsuited mods as MS said.
Ofcourse, you can switch between the ranks whenever you feel like it.
if you want to experience new content, you as your CL or a mod to give you hardcore status.
If you have raided for a while and need a break or have some other issues, you can just switch to casual.
This was my idea, remember it's just an idea and I hope you like it :P
a hardcore and a casual rank.
If you "sign up" for hardcore rank, you'll be invited to raids before casuals, but you are expected to turn up when you sign for a raid, and you are expected to have consumables etc. for the fight. also, when you ask for you hardcore rank, you have to tell your CL on which days you can be available (in my case that'd be fridays and saturdays), the CL can then maybe put it in the officer note. you will be expected to turn up on those days though, unless you tell your CL you won't be available.
as a casual you'll get invited to raids if you want to and there's not enough hardcore rank members online, and you'll be able to enjoy the game a little more casual.
"hardcore" rank would not mean you would have to have like a 90% raid attendance, like some hardcore guilds do, it would just mean you will have all your stuff needed to raid.
This way hardcorers wouldn't feel any better than casuals because they're in the same guild, just a different "rank" (one not higher than the other)
there wouldn't be a communication issue, and there wouldn't be any segregation (spelling? xD) as we'll all be in the same guild still, the ranks are just to show what your focus is at the moment, raiding, or other things.
Also there wouldn't be a need for any new mods, so there won't be a risk of the casuals (or the hardcore for that matter) being lead by unsuited mods as MS said.
Ofcourse, you can switch between the ranks whenever you feel like it.
if you want to experience new content, you as your CL or a mod to give you hardcore status.
If you have raided for a while and need a break or have some other issues, you can just switch to casual.
This was my idea, remember it's just an idea and I hope you like it :P
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
-
Dodotorpedo
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
I agree with Bob's idea, being 1 guild is simply more usefull becouse you don't have to type /1 every time you want to talk in guildchat and don't automatically leave the channel when logged in on another computer. Guildchat also allows you to link enchanting recipes (with mats) and other items ofcourse.
I think making 2 guilds would split the casual and hardcore members away form eachother more then having 2 ranks in 1 guild.
Edit: also every time somewone would have to be swapped from casual to hardcore or the other way around you'd have to leave the guild and get invited in the other one, if you have lots of alts you'll know it's sometimes hard to find a mod and this would save some trouble.
I think making 2 guilds would split the casual and hardcore members away form eachother more then having 2 ranks in 1 guild.
Edit: also every time somewone would have to be swapped from casual to hardcore or the other way around you'd have to leave the guild and get invited in the other one, if you have lots of alts you'll know it's sometimes hard to find a mod and this would save some trouble.
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
I dislike the whole "hardcore" titel of it, can't we call it raider and casual? :P
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Dodo, I think the split idea is about still using the same guild name, for everyone, but have 2 new ranks, one called raider/hardcore whatever is chosen, the other casual, and then just promote / demote to whatever is needed
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
Shoarmabob
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
- Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
Ofcourse, hardcore was just the term used in this thread so i used it in my exampleSondemon wrote:I dislike the whole "hardcore" titel of it, can't we call it raider and casual? :P
then why was there this talk about segregation and elitism? because we basically already have people working hard for raids, but they're not acting superior to non-raiders or anyone else, and the guild is still a whole, I don't think there's any bias when it comes to for example PvP groups, or instance groups.Sondemon wrote:Dodo, I think the split idea is about still using the same guild name, for everyone, but have 2 new ranks, one called raider/hardcore whatever is chosen, the other casual, and then just promote / demote to whatever is needed
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
-
QuantumDelta
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
- Location: Bristol, England.
Shoarmabob wrote:
then why was there this talk about segregation and elitism? because we basically already have people working hard for raids, but they're not acting superior to non-raiders or anyone else, and the guild is still a whole, I don't think there's any bias when it comes to for example PvP groups, or instance groups.
I for one sure do see those people becoming frustrated as time goes on though.
Most rather than argued or forged a way have left or semi-quit the game though.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
-
Shoarmabob
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
- Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
yeah, that's why we should spread the load over everyone with hardcore/raider/whatever ranksQuantumDelta wrote:Shoarmabob wrote:
then why was there this talk about segregation and elitism? because we basically already have people working hard for raids, but they're not acting superior to non-raiders or anyone else, and the guild is still a whole, I don't think there's any bias when it comes to for example PvP groups, or instance groups.
I for one sure do see those people becoming frustrated as time goes on though.
Most rather than argued or forged a way have left or semi-quit the game though.
with a raider rank you will get spots on raids, but they come at the price of having to farm.
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
but maybe like have 2 ranks?
a hardcore and a casual rank.
From my previous post, from the forums and from the site.that's why we should spread the load over everyone with hardcore/raider/whatever ranks
with a raider rank you will get spots on raids
"We dont have ranks, numbers or positions to identify ourselves with"
Tis just repeating what i've already said but non of these ideas fit in with what we're supposed to be about.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
Ok...I guess at this point its fine for wider SSX members to chime in. Where to begin...
I guess the whole 'Raid Guild' issue is as good as any. Honestly, I took one look at that list of criteria and thought 'Are you serious?'. Its like the list is openly trying to go against what the SSX stands for.
"People will be expected to be specced for PvE performance as primary"
"People will be expected to maintain a minimum of at least 1 progression raid per week"
"Alts are either to be kept guildless, or in the casual guild (preference for obvious reasons)."
In fact, the only criteria that don't deserve contempt in that list are a and b, and they're the ones that go without saying.
Since when did the SSX stand for a guild where the 'higher ups' dictate to people how they must play. 'Conform to these rules or you don't raid with us', the SSX is not about that. Its about friendship, and having fun in the game you play. Forcing people to play a certain way, and basically forcing them to stick to one class for good just so that people can progress more in raids is certainly not about 'having fun', its about 'We want this, you will comply or you dont raid with us. If you don't want to go and never raid seriously again in the casual guild because you arent welcome here.'
As for friendship, Im sure that imposing labels upon people is really going to make the world a friendlier place. Forcing people to choose a 'casual' tab just because they don't want to spend their entire WoW lives raiding constantly is really going to make people look up to you as a friend. Or not. Its most likely to breed the exact opposite. People will be as good as labelled 'not good enough' because they can't live up to your requirements, then dumped into a guild that will never challenge the majority of the endgame content that WoW has to offer. The same goes for everyone under level 60. Really doesn't promote any form of friendship. Again, going against what the SSX is.
The WoW guild was built and maintained always standing above others by showing we're a community of friends rather then just a group of people who are only together so they can raid BWL every day. The website reflects that, as MS pointed out, and recruitment reflects that. Basically, if you implement this policy you may as well scrap the website, as forming a hardcore raiding guild goes against everything the group has ever stood for. As for recruitment, the result will be people who care less about community than they do about getting the most raid invites they can in a week. It would not be possible to continue our current line of recruitment, because the guild itself would have changed fundamentally, and half of what was relevant would no longer be relevant. How can you turn people down based on a 'How important are raids to you?' answer that indicated they only cared about raids when that is the flag that half of the guild are sailing?
I said on IRC the other day it would be like changing the entire foundations of the guild. There is no need for that. The foundations of the guild are solid, it stands for the right things and the right principles. It is the interior that needs changing, how things work inside. Leave the principles of the guild alone. If you change them, you wont be SSX.
Implementing such a plan as this is far far lower down on the list of preferable solutions that /gdisband. You're SSX, that means you stand for something. If you're willing to throw away all that we are just so that you can progress further in raids you shouldn't be here. Period.
I guess the whole 'Raid Guild' issue is as good as any. Honestly, I took one look at that list of criteria and thought 'Are you serious?'. Its like the list is openly trying to go against what the SSX stands for.
"People will be expected to be specced for PvE performance as primary"
"People will be expected to maintain a minimum of at least 1 progression raid per week"
"Alts are either to be kept guildless, or in the casual guild (preference for obvious reasons)."
In fact, the only criteria that don't deserve contempt in that list are a and b, and they're the ones that go without saying.
Since when did the SSX stand for a guild where the 'higher ups' dictate to people how they must play. 'Conform to these rules or you don't raid with us', the SSX is not about that. Its about friendship, and having fun in the game you play. Forcing people to play a certain way, and basically forcing them to stick to one class for good just so that people can progress more in raids is certainly not about 'having fun', its about 'We want this, you will comply or you dont raid with us. If you don't want to go and never raid seriously again in the casual guild because you arent welcome here.'
As for friendship, Im sure that imposing labels upon people is really going to make the world a friendlier place. Forcing people to choose a 'casual' tab just because they don't want to spend their entire WoW lives raiding constantly is really going to make people look up to you as a friend. Or not. Its most likely to breed the exact opposite. People will be as good as labelled 'not good enough' because they can't live up to your requirements, then dumped into a guild that will never challenge the majority of the endgame content that WoW has to offer. The same goes for everyone under level 60. Really doesn't promote any form of friendship. Again, going against what the SSX is.
The WoW guild was built and maintained always standing above others by showing we're a community of friends rather then just a group of people who are only together so they can raid BWL every day. The website reflects that, as MS pointed out, and recruitment reflects that. Basically, if you implement this policy you may as well scrap the website, as forming a hardcore raiding guild goes against everything the group has ever stood for. As for recruitment, the result will be people who care less about community than they do about getting the most raid invites they can in a week. It would not be possible to continue our current line of recruitment, because the guild itself would have changed fundamentally, and half of what was relevant would no longer be relevant. How can you turn people down based on a 'How important are raids to you?' answer that indicated they only cared about raids when that is the flag that half of the guild are sailing?
I said on IRC the other day it would be like changing the entire foundations of the guild. There is no need for that. The foundations of the guild are solid, it stands for the right things and the right principles. It is the interior that needs changing, how things work inside. Leave the principles of the guild alone. If you change them, you wont be SSX.
Implementing such a plan as this is far far lower down on the list of preferable solutions that /gdisband. You're SSX, that means you stand for something. If you're willing to throw away all that we are just so that you can progress further in raids you shouldn't be here. Period.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
esd
- Posts: 986
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 2:25 am
- Location: Somewhere
My tuppence:
Splitting the guild? No problem. Wouldn't be the first game we've had more than one squad in.
Having entrance requirements based on skill, equipment and/or ability to dedicate time? Totally un-SSX-like. That's not what we do here.
Splitting the guild? No problem. Wouldn't be the first game we've had more than one squad in.
Having entrance requirements based on skill, equipment and/or ability to dedicate time? Totally un-SSX-like. That's not what we do here.
""I like my women like I like my coffee. In a plastic cup.""
-
Shoarmabob
- Posts: 301
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
- Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
I don't quite understand though, what's the difference between moderators and classleader ranks, and casual and raider/hardcore ranks?
classleader and moderator ranks also define who you are, and they are as different from nonCL's/mods as casuals are from raiders, or am I mistaken?
EDIT:
they don't have to spend all their free time raiding with us, just the days they told their Classmentor (in other words, the days they want to raid)
ofcourse it's just an idea, and It's not set in stone (we might not do it at all)
EDIT 2:
also, in reply to Anny, like i said, you don't have to devote all your time to raids, just the days YOU want to raid, we only expect you to be there, at those days, furthermore, we shouldn't judge by spec, but by performance.
If we notice someone's performing not as good as other, equally geared people of the same class, we'd have a chat with them and see what could be done to increase this performance. This may seem a bit unSSXy, but you have to remember that you can't raid naxxrammas for example, with 8 priests not healing anything.
classleader and moderator ranks also define who you are, and they are as different from nonCL's/mods as casuals are from raiders, or am I mistaken?
EDIT:
that wasn't our idea (or well alteast not my idea) at all: my idea means that people "sign up" for the raider rank. they will be expected to farm everything necessary for the raid, help with potions etc. they tell their classmentors at which days they can usually raid, and they are expected to turn up at those days. Should they not be available on one such a day because of RL issues they notify their classmentor a day or so ahead.My tuppence:
Splitting the guild? No problem. Wouldn't be the first game we've had more than one squad in.
Having entrance requirements based on skill, equipment and/or ability to dedicate time? Totally un-SSX-like. That's not what we do here.
they don't have to spend all their free time raiding with us, just the days they told their Classmentor (in other words, the days they want to raid)
ofcourse it's just an idea, and It's not set in stone (we might not do it at all)
EDIT 2:
also, in reply to Anny, like i said, you don't have to devote all your time to raids, just the days YOU want to raid, we only expect you to be there, at those days, furthermore, we shouldn't judge by spec, but by performance.
If we notice someone's performing not as good as other, equally geared people of the same class, we'd have a chat with them and see what could be done to increase this performance. This may seem a bit unSSXy, but you have to remember that you can't raid naxxrammas for example, with 8 priests not healing anything.
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY
-
firedancer
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
- Location: Innsbruck, Austria
you just touched one very subtle problem in WoW-Eu [andShoarmabob wrote:
classleader and moderator ranks also define who you are,
and they are as different from nonCL's/mods as casuals are
from raiders, or am I mistaken?
evidently you did never play other games with SSX]. since i
started playing wow and joined on Bladefist, the WoW-Eu group
had the tendency to interpret equality in a famous way:
Every one is equal, but some are more equal [animal Farm, Orwell].
in all games i played so far with SSX except WoW, the equality
between player was much stronger. there was allways an mod
rotation, or it was clear that every one is a mod. so there was
never a difference between players. that was completely different
in WoW from the beginning, (e.g., it took me 35 lvl's before
someone decided that i am now worth to be a member ---
althought i was a "moderator" in other SSX games.)
also moderator rotation, was nothing ever considered or did
we ever make a vote about it. there was a big advantage in
this sort of "equality" that the guild could progress much faster,
and i think it would never have achieved such big things without it.
but in my opinion it is also one of the main reason we have
the problems now. ppl in WoW-Eu are no aware, that actually
they really are supposed to be equal, that every one
has to care about the guild and to take responsability.
in that sense, i have to completely agree with MS, ava and
anny. a guild split violates what SSX stands for. i personally
could only imagine a guild split resulting in a casual SSX guild
taking care for ppl, but slowling converting the guild towards
SSX standards: all are equall, moderators are rotating or all
are moderators, 2 ppl vouche for new members; and a hard
core "non SSX" guild. [we own this allready to Ed, else he
gets a full time job in taking care with guild problems in WoW.]
the hard-core guild then does no longer to care about SSX
standards and recruit ppl only for raid progress --- the only
difference is that the hard-core guild consists of a lot of SSX
members, which for a moment have "higher" goals than fun
and friendship.
