Recruitment Discussion
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I feel we need to have this discussion on recruiting guys, and i would really like everyones imput on it if possible.
Over the past month or so we have had a LOT of members join, so many members that when we look at guild chat we haven't been sure of who people have been, whether they were new alts, or new members. This stopped us from getting to know a lot of our members whilst at the same time loosing the closeness part of the SSX.
I for one have stayed SSX all this time simply because i know you all (or the majority), we're a close group of friends and i love gaming with you all.
Because of all these new members joining people were starting to feel like it wasn't very SSX like, we usually like to be careful with the people we recruit, and be selective. So to help keep the closeness of the guild, help us be able to get to know our new members better i added the weekly recruitment limit.
Now even with this recruitment limit just look here on the forums at the amount of threads we've had with people wanting to join and people that HAVE joined. Every week since we have had this recruitment limit we have always reached the 4 members per week limit, and sometimes even had to reserve spaces for people for the following week.
Sure this is good for us having more members and we're gonna be able to do MC a lot sooner, but is this such a good thing?
Our aim was always to become an MC raidable guild but atm it feels as if we've trying to rush towards that goal rather than take our time.
I would rather us take even longer to be fully ready for raiding things like MC and have a guild where we're all good friends, everyone is SSX material.. Rather than just having aload of new members with people wondering "so who's so and so, a new member?" all the time. Some people feel more like strangers than being part of the same guild.
Another problem we have is our rogue situation. We have too many of them. If we keep recruiting more rogues we are going to turn into how some other guilds have got. We will have too many rogues wanting to do MC eventually and guildies are gonna get left out. It could turn into equipment based meaning we'd only take the rogues with the best equipment along. - I think we should put a stop on recruiting any more rogues full stop. Sure this may sound drastic and no its not just because i'm one of the rogues but because i don't want to see us get too many of one class and have people feeling left out. Sure even if they are SSX material we'd miss having them but in the long run its in their best interest i think. I know a few other people already think we should do this but i'd like to know everyone elses opinions as well.
IMO we need to crack down on our recruiting as a whole even more than we have just done with that recruitment limit
Take a look at some of the types of people we have in our guild recently, can we honestly say that they are the types of people we want in the SSX? Are they even SSX material in the first place?
Members that only like to help themselves but nobody else, will only go somewhere if it benefits themselves in some way. - Is this SSX material? No.
Members that would only do an instance if it benefits themselves and they get something out of it, if theres nothing that drops there for them they won't want to go. - Like the above, but is this SSX material? No.
Members that beg over guild chat and have even started whispering mods all the time begging for help with quests etc but the type of people as the above, that help nobody else but themselves but still expect to get help whenever they need it?. - Is this SSX material? No.
Members that like to shout and swear in caps whilst raiding with randoms making our guild look bad and embarrasing other members of our guild whilst out with them. "GET IN THE INSTANCE FOR ***** SAKE", "WHY THE **** BLAH BLAH".. Is this called for? Is this SSX material? No.
Just a few examples there..
I ain't gonna name any names but i'm sure some people will know the kind of people who i'm talking about here. Those types of people are not SSX material in my opinion and shouldn't even be with us i'm sorry to say. How are they helping our guild by being with us apart from adding another class be it a helpful class or not?
Would we rather have a 60 priest for example, that helps guildies, someone you can easyly approach, is SSX material and that everyone gets along with. Or would we rather have a 60 priest that is a greedy shit that will only ever go on guild runs if it may benefit himself, always swearing over guild chat, begs for help when he needs it but doesn't ever help anyone else but himself.
2 people there. I know i'd go for the first one obviously. Sure the second one is a 60 priest and would be useful for endgame guild stuff but we don't need him, he shouldn't be with us and he shouldn't have even be recruited in the first place! This is the whole point i'm trying to make in this thread is we need SSX material people with us, in small amounts. We don't need helpful classes being recruited in large amounts but that are not SSX material in large amounts. If we keep going like this i have a gut feeling that some of our long time members are going to leave us because of it and i don't want to see it get to that.
So we need to put a stop to it, these are some things we could do to try stop it:
- Stop recruiting any other class but healers and warlocks. - Help to maintain the closeness of our guild without having a ton of new people joining us all the time but focus on the classes we actually need instead. We have less people joining but we can make sure the needed classes that DO join us are SSX material.
- Lower the recruitment limit even more.
- Get rid of the recruitment limit but have every new recruit referred to either QD or myself before they are invited. - Solves the "SSX Material" problem most likely but it doesn't solve the large amount of members joining really. Also gives QD and I even more people to talk to that we already have.
What do we do?
Thoughts & Opinions on all of this please.
Over the past month or so we have had a LOT of members join, so many members that when we look at guild chat we haven't been sure of who people have been, whether they were new alts, or new members. This stopped us from getting to know a lot of our members whilst at the same time loosing the closeness part of the SSX.
I for one have stayed SSX all this time simply because i know you all (or the majority), we're a close group of friends and i love gaming with you all.
Because of all these new members joining people were starting to feel like it wasn't very SSX like, we usually like to be careful with the people we recruit, and be selective. So to help keep the closeness of the guild, help us be able to get to know our new members better i added the weekly recruitment limit.
Now even with this recruitment limit just look here on the forums at the amount of threads we've had with people wanting to join and people that HAVE joined. Every week since we have had this recruitment limit we have always reached the 4 members per week limit, and sometimes even had to reserve spaces for people for the following week.
Sure this is good for us having more members and we're gonna be able to do MC a lot sooner, but is this such a good thing?
Our aim was always to become an MC raidable guild but atm it feels as if we've trying to rush towards that goal rather than take our time.
I would rather us take even longer to be fully ready for raiding things like MC and have a guild where we're all good friends, everyone is SSX material.. Rather than just having aload of new members with people wondering "so who's so and so, a new member?" all the time. Some people feel more like strangers than being part of the same guild.
Another problem we have is our rogue situation. We have too many of them. If we keep recruiting more rogues we are going to turn into how some other guilds have got. We will have too many rogues wanting to do MC eventually and guildies are gonna get left out. It could turn into equipment based meaning we'd only take the rogues with the best equipment along. - I think we should put a stop on recruiting any more rogues full stop. Sure this may sound drastic and no its not just because i'm one of the rogues but because i don't want to see us get too many of one class and have people feeling left out. Sure even if they are SSX material we'd miss having them but in the long run its in their best interest i think. I know a few other people already think we should do this but i'd like to know everyone elses opinions as well.
IMO we need to crack down on our recruiting as a whole even more than we have just done with that recruitment limit
Take a look at some of the types of people we have in our guild recently, can we honestly say that they are the types of people we want in the SSX? Are they even SSX material in the first place?
Members that only like to help themselves but nobody else, will only go somewhere if it benefits themselves in some way. - Is this SSX material? No.
Members that would only do an instance if it benefits themselves and they get something out of it, if theres nothing that drops there for them they won't want to go. - Like the above, but is this SSX material? No.
Members that beg over guild chat and have even started whispering mods all the time begging for help with quests etc but the type of people as the above, that help nobody else but themselves but still expect to get help whenever they need it?. - Is this SSX material? No.
Members that like to shout and swear in caps whilst raiding with randoms making our guild look bad and embarrasing other members of our guild whilst out with them. "GET IN THE INSTANCE FOR ***** SAKE", "WHY THE **** BLAH BLAH".. Is this called for? Is this SSX material? No.
Just a few examples there..
I ain't gonna name any names but i'm sure some people will know the kind of people who i'm talking about here. Those types of people are not SSX material in my opinion and shouldn't even be with us i'm sorry to say. How are they helping our guild by being with us apart from adding another class be it a helpful class or not?
Would we rather have a 60 priest for example, that helps guildies, someone you can easyly approach, is SSX material and that everyone gets along with. Or would we rather have a 60 priest that is a greedy shit that will only ever go on guild runs if it may benefit himself, always swearing over guild chat, begs for help when he needs it but doesn't ever help anyone else but himself.
2 people there. I know i'd go for the first one obviously. Sure the second one is a 60 priest and would be useful for endgame guild stuff but we don't need him, he shouldn't be with us and he shouldn't have even be recruited in the first place! This is the whole point i'm trying to make in this thread is we need SSX material people with us, in small amounts. We don't need helpful classes being recruited in large amounts but that are not SSX material in large amounts. If we keep going like this i have a gut feeling that some of our long time members are going to leave us because of it and i don't want to see it get to that.
So we need to put a stop to it, these are some things we could do to try stop it:
- Stop recruiting any other class but healers and warlocks. - Help to maintain the closeness of our guild without having a ton of new people joining us all the time but focus on the classes we actually need instead. We have less people joining but we can make sure the needed classes that DO join us are SSX material.
- Lower the recruitment limit even more.
- Get rid of the recruitment limit but have every new recruit referred to either QD or myself before they are invited. - Solves the "SSX Material" problem most likely but it doesn't solve the large amount of members joining really. Also gives QD and I even more people to talk to that we already have.
What do we do?
Thoughts & Opinions on all of this please.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
I for one have noticed over the last few days really that alot of people on the guild list i dont even know who they are.
Also the new members we have recieved recently 'some' of them dont help anyone but themselves im sorry to say

i dont want us to become a huge guild where people dont know each other and i feel it is heading that way at the moment.
Also the new members we have recieved recently 'some' of them dont help anyone but themselves im sorry to say
i dont want us to become a huge guild where people dont know each other and i feel it is heading that way at the moment.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
I agree with you 100% A few of you know I havent been exactly happy with certain issues recently, most of which are now thankfully resolved, and recruitment is one of them. The last week I havent played much, but I highly doubt the situation has changed since I took a break. It felt to me like we had far far too many recruits, it seemed like an endless stream of people were pouring into the guild and I found myself wondering whether some of them were being adequately scrutinised to determine whether or not they were SSX material. To be honest my feelings on this and a few other issues which I wont discuss here are part of the reason why I took my break from WoW.
To be frank, the guild is in a bad state at the moment in my eyes. The recruiting limit isn't doing as good a job as I'd hoped it would, there are those people within the SSX who simply aren't SSX material (not speaking of anyone in particular, Im just sure they're there), and our close knit community is being lost. We really need to resolve this situation as soon as possible. Clean up the guild as it were.
Therefore I propose that any and all recruiting should be halted for a set period of time (I'll leave that time to be debated). This period of time where we are gaining no new members can be used to allow us all to get to know the members we have without more constantly pouring in, allow us to rebuild the close knit community we used to have. It would also allow us the time to let those who are not SSX material to show themselves and be shown the exit door. It would give us the time to restore the guild from the mess that it is in now.
Once the problems have been sorted the guild can debate the recruitment issue either here or in IRC. Lengthily debate it. We dont want to finish fixing the problems to have them all return due to a badly thought out recruitment system being introduced simply because people want their friends in the guild. Hopefully this will allow us to work out a system that minimises the issues of the present.
Thoughts?
To be frank, the guild is in a bad state at the moment in my eyes. The recruiting limit isn't doing as good a job as I'd hoped it would, there are those people within the SSX who simply aren't SSX material (not speaking of anyone in particular, Im just sure they're there), and our close knit community is being lost. We really need to resolve this situation as soon as possible. Clean up the guild as it were.
Therefore I propose that any and all recruiting should be halted for a set period of time (I'll leave that time to be debated). This period of time where we are gaining no new members can be used to allow us all to get to know the members we have without more constantly pouring in, allow us to rebuild the close knit community we used to have. It would also allow us the time to let those who are not SSX material to show themselves and be shown the exit door. It would give us the time to restore the guild from the mess that it is in now.
Once the problems have been sorted the guild can debate the recruitment issue either here or in IRC. Lengthily debate it. We dont want to finish fixing the problems to have them all return due to a badly thought out recruitment system being introduced simply because people want their friends in the guild. Hopefully this will allow us to work out a system that minimises the issues of the present.
Thoughts?
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I strongly think we should do what anny has suggested.
Stop recruiting new members altogether whilst we get to know some of the new members we already have, and let the people that don't act like SSX material either prove themselves to be, or leave. If we keep recruiting even if it was just myself sending the invites we are still getting members and the current issue we have will still not go away.
Okay this isn't gonna get us doing MC raids any quicker by doing this but i don't care, i don't want to see this issue get any worse than it already is and has been and by recruiting even more people (even SSX material people) isn't gonna help matters.
-Halt our recruiting for a while. 100% agree!
Stop recruiting new members altogether whilst we get to know some of the new members we already have, and let the people that don't act like SSX material either prove themselves to be, or leave. If we keep recruiting even if it was just myself sending the invites we are still getting members and the current issue we have will still not go away.
Okay this isn't gonna get us doing MC raids any quicker by doing this but i don't care, i don't want to see this issue get any worse than it already is and has been and by recruiting even more people (even SSX material people) isn't gonna help matters.
-Halt our recruiting for a while. 100% agree!
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
A wise man just said:
[10:32] Kahn: only recruits should be people worthy of your friends list
[10:32] Kahn: only recruits should be people worthy of your friends list
No signature
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
thats just one of the many quotes i unfortunately had to write towards one member after we started to massrecruit...Sofia wrote:...
QD is too bossy sometimes & for myself, i am often a fool who rushes in head over... HM on the other hand takes it more easy, considers all sides before he takes action & it is actually his sensitive way that makes him a great guildfounder! (we have no actual leader in ssx, just mods)
We try to establish an environment where you can rely on your mates & simply like playing with the members... thats not about endgamecontent, raids nor goldfarming... its about earning trust & respect! Endless discussions about something the majority of ssx simply disagrees & starting to insult my friends is no proper way to earn this trust.
... noone is forced to be part of our guild!
sincerely
- Sofia
you know my opinion on this topic & i simply cant repeat it here
*goes fishing with her dnd sig rather than helping ppl out as she used to*
-
Blue Star
- Posts: 227
- Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 12:16 am
- Yahoo Messenger: theoneilluminati
- Location: Bonny Dundee!
I agree on the Rogue restriction - WoW has an unhealthy image of it being Rogue or nothing outside of the game.
Everything else, I don't really know enough to respond right now.
Everything else, I don't really know enough to respond right now.
-
base
- Posts: 524
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
- Location: wales uk
Stopping or slowing new guild members coming into the guild will not solve the problem of attracting not so desirable people into the guild. That will happen or not happen regardless of the rate of intake, it will just happen more if the intake rate is more.
Now, we already have an intake limit, and new members have to follow a procedure to join, the purpose being to make sure new members understand what ssx is all about, and to have some sense that the person does actually want to join, by going through that procedure.
I will note however, that you will not stop somebody from joining ssx simply by introducing these procedures, as somebody who wants to join, for whatever reason, will follow the protocol and become a guild member. You will get bad eggs, this is unavoidable, and is part of any growing organization, and especially one that occurs online.
I believe we have the leadership and camaraderie to overcome and deal with any of these issues no matter if we have 1 new member a week or 20, personally - i am not in favor of any further reductions in intake at this stage. This will change however once we are going to MC on a regular basis and getting to know each other more and more.
I think these points should be considered before we take any action.
We are becoming a recognizable force on bladefist, people want to join us for this success, many of these people will fit in with our ideals and playstyle.
It takes time to get to know people - I don't believe new faces detract from the guild, and while i enjoy the closer aspect of the relationship between players (oo0 err) in this guild compared to others i've been in, I don't want to live in a cocoon either.
You will not stop bad eggs from joining, it will happen, we can deal with it.
If you really are worried about this then we should be more active in getting to know our new members, surely the easiest way to feel more comfortable with new people, is to talk to them and play alongside them.
There will come a time when it will be wise to stop recruiting all but the very best people and players, but lets not penalize ourselves and get into a rut where only the people we currently know are good and everybody else = bad. Yeah we had a few assmonkeys - but we're still going strong
Don't let them get you down.
Now, we already have an intake limit, and new members have to follow a procedure to join, the purpose being to make sure new members understand what ssx is all about, and to have some sense that the person does actually want to join, by going through that procedure.
I will note however, that you will not stop somebody from joining ssx simply by introducing these procedures, as somebody who wants to join, for whatever reason, will follow the protocol and become a guild member. You will get bad eggs, this is unavoidable, and is part of any growing organization, and especially one that occurs online.
I believe we have the leadership and camaraderie to overcome and deal with any of these issues no matter if we have 1 new member a week or 20, personally - i am not in favor of any further reductions in intake at this stage. This will change however once we are going to MC on a regular basis and getting to know each other more and more.
I think these points should be considered before we take any action.
We are becoming a recognizable force on bladefist, people want to join us for this success, many of these people will fit in with our ideals and playstyle.
It takes time to get to know people - I don't believe new faces detract from the guild, and while i enjoy the closer aspect of the relationship between players (oo0 err) in this guild compared to others i've been in, I don't want to live in a cocoon either.
You will not stop bad eggs from joining, it will happen, we can deal with it.
If you really are worried about this then we should be more active in getting to know our new members, surely the easiest way to feel more comfortable with new people, is to talk to them and play alongside them.
There will come a time when it will be wise to stop recruiting all but the very best people and players, but lets not penalize ourselves and get into a rut where only the people we currently know are good and everybody else = bad. Yeah we had a few assmonkeys - but we're still going strong
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace
InvadeSpace
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
think we still have bad eggs within the guild at the moment and as we are recruiting so many ppl they are going un-noticed ;/
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
we didnt kick a single person yet: they all left, but not until they did something terrible wrong & knew the kick was comingbase wrote: Yeah we had a few assmonkeys - but we're still going strongDon't let them get you down.
imo we shouldnt restrict the joining numbers... at all... BUT: we should take more time recruiting rather than signing up every member that crosses our path... if every member had to run any instance with ssx for example, it may have some inpact on the *bad eggs rate* ... & some mods still add members not even registered here
edit: oh we have a splendid kicking tool... the silence rank! high efficient in *not kicking ppl but make them leave the guild* <3 silence rank
Last edited by Sofia on Thu Aug 18, 2005 4:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
base
- Posts: 524
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
- Location: wales uk
Hmm I don't think thats the case, however, nobody is doing anything about those members, and for sure, nobody is talking to them directly, asking them what they want from the guild and what they think they can contribute to it.think we still have bad eggs within the guild at the moment and as we are recruiting so many ppl they are going un-noticed ;/
The way we treat new members shouldn't just be to invite them and then moan about them in moderator chat until they mess up and are kicked/leave. Or taunt them as we did with tophen for example until tempers flare.
It's not good enough to sit back and let things develop into a bad state, and when people leave say "oh well, we don't want that kind of person anyway", that excuse can only work so often.
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace
InvadeSpace
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
ryo, you added some really good points to this discussion...
-
QuantumDelta
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
- Location: Bristol, England.
This weeks non-alt recruitment stands at 3 people out of those who stil remain.
ACTUAL Invites, stands at five.
Including alts we've recruited in the region of 9 people.
If I am going to recruit someone, it's going to be someone like Chill, he's been on my buddy list for months and he's a great bloke.
What SSX don't need:
Inflexibility.
What SSX Need:
A Personal touch.
It's easy for me or MS to turn around andsay no, however, a recruit NUMBER is a painful and unrealistic thing.
We end up recruiting people like heated, while, people like Aliwoo are still (patiently) waiting to join the guild? It bites.
We had a few funny/weird stories with the two recruits that left, both were legit reasons and weren't actually problems with our guild.
As for our current recruits:
The "Recruitment" number limit has not been satisfactory to me, people think it's protection for our recruitment, that it will allow the low number of recruits to be absorbed into OUR culture, but that's so completely wrong.
Is Anny the same as myself?
Is the same kind of SSX member as we recruited for the FS2 division?
Nope, he's his own unique self and he brings something and adds it to the guild.
THAT'S something to focus on "Adding" to the guild.
Over the past month or so, we've had 17 people join us bar act's little bit of fun.
Seventeen?
One over the recruitment limit for that period?
I do not see people here having a problem with the number.
Simply the quality.
Quality only comes down to one thing.
TIME.
You wont find time just by putting a number on the amount that can join:
Look at the way signups normally go, for example most of the people who were signed up last week entered on our forums saturday, sunday, monday.
Same with this week.
How is THAT Productive in terms of a limit?
These people are taken in, in the same maner as any zerg recruitment.
The number is not the problem.
It's the maner.
If you look at the members ready for MC thread you are going to see what classes we need no more members of.
Tophen was in the guild long enough, always begged for help, never gave it.
Now I don't mind naming and shaming.
If it means we LOSE members to fix our problems that's fine.
I also really, really, don't mind having to sit down to talk to EVERY recruit a moderator sees if I have to.
The referal system would basically be the same as always:
Moderators go through the recruitment process, and once they are done, the recruit is refered to myself or MS.
This is simply because I feel that the numbers game is ABSOLUTELY WRONG.
It's not because I don't trust our moderators (If I didn't, they wouldn't be moderators now, would they? we'd have like two mods and I'd still be GM), it's because it's another form of controlling our recruitment hopefully to get a little more quality out of ..maybe even the same people... -> It just gives them a perspective change and adds the same level of service to all recruits.
To add to that:
Any recruits that MS or I would pick up, would be refered between ourselves.
It basically goes back to the old system that BD and I used to use.
Two moderators referal is needed to sign someone up.
It was a great system... and the FS2 group was a great group, even if they weren't that active in SquadWars bar myself, BD Fahd and Lighty.
ACTUAL Invites, stands at five.
Including alts we've recruited in the region of 9 people.
If I am going to recruit someone, it's going to be someone like Chill, he's been on my buddy list for months and he's a great bloke.
What SSX don't need:
Inflexibility.
What SSX Need:
A Personal touch.
It's easy for me or MS to turn around andsay no, however, a recruit NUMBER is a painful and unrealistic thing.
We end up recruiting people like heated, while, people like Aliwoo are still (patiently) waiting to join the guild? It bites.
We had a few funny/weird stories with the two recruits that left, both were legit reasons and weren't actually problems with our guild.
As for our current recruits:
The "Recruitment" number limit has not been satisfactory to me, people think it's protection for our recruitment, that it will allow the low number of recruits to be absorbed into OUR culture, but that's so completely wrong.
Is Anny the same as myself?
Is the same kind of SSX member as we recruited for the FS2 division?
Nope, he's his own unique self and he brings something and adds it to the guild.
THAT'S something to focus on "Adding" to the guild.
Over the past month or so, we've had 17 people join us bar act's little bit of fun.
Seventeen?
One over the recruitment limit for that period?
I do not see people here having a problem with the number.
Simply the quality.
Quality only comes down to one thing.
TIME.
You wont find time just by putting a number on the amount that can join:
Look at the way signups normally go, for example most of the people who were signed up last week entered on our forums saturday, sunday, monday.
Same with this week.
How is THAT Productive in terms of a limit?
These people are taken in, in the same maner as any zerg recruitment.
The number is not the problem.
It's the maner.
If you look at the members ready for MC thread you are going to see what classes we need no more members of.
Tophen was in the guild long enough, always begged for help, never gave it.
Now I don't mind naming and shaming.
If it means we LOSE members to fix our problems that's fine.
I also really, really, don't mind having to sit down to talk to EVERY recruit a moderator sees if I have to.
The referal system would basically be the same as always:
Moderators go through the recruitment process, and once they are done, the recruit is refered to myself or MS.
This is simply because I feel that the numbers game is ABSOLUTELY WRONG.
It's not because I don't trust our moderators (If I didn't, they wouldn't be moderators now, would they? we'd have like two mods and I'd still be GM), it's because it's another form of controlling our recruitment hopefully to get a little more quality out of ..maybe even the same people... -> It just gives them a perspective change and adds the same level of service to all recruits.
To add to that:
Any recruits that MS or I would pick up, would be refered between ourselves.
It basically goes back to the old system that BD and I used to use.
Two moderators referal is needed to sign someone up.
It was a great system... and the FS2 group was a great group, even if they weren't that active in SquadWars bar myself, BD Fahd and Lighty.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I would be for QDs suggestion of having every recruit referred to himself or me first before they get invited even though it gives us both more work to do but BEFORE we do that i still think we should put a short halt on recruiting whilst we clean out some of the people in the guild that still shouldn't even be in with us. "Clean house" as Quiz put it on IRC earlyer.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
I have my reservations about the referral system. It may have worked for FS2 back in the day, but would applying it to WoW really work? While FS2 may have been popular its nothing compared to the scale of how popular WoW is. Would you and MS really be willing to sit there each and every day and spend the majority of your online time talking to potential recruits and getting to know them well enough? It would take the fun out of the game.
Then again it may be worth a try, but I agree with MS. If it is implemented we should certainly have a period where all recruiting is halted to 'clean house'. We simply cant sort out those already in the guild when masses more are joining.
Then again it may be worth a try, but I agree with MS. If it is implemented we should certainly have a period where all recruiting is halted to 'clean house'. We simply cant sort out those already in the guild when masses more are joining.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
What i think would be a good idea to do:
Stop recruiting altogether for a set time whilst the mods come up with a list of members that they know aren't SSX material. The people that beg for help, never help anyone else but themselves, people with bad attitude problems etc. The people that shouldn't be IN our guild. > We show these people the door and then we get on with recruiting maybe as QD has suggested.
I agree with anny again, "We simply cant sort out those already in the guild when masses more are joining."
Stop recruiting altogether for a set time whilst the mods come up with a list of members that they know aren't SSX material. The people that beg for help, never help anyone else but themselves, people with bad attitude problems etc. The people that shouldn't be IN our guild. > We show these people the door and then we get on with recruiting maybe as QD has suggested.
I agree with anny again, "We simply cant sort out those already in the guild when masses more are joining."
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
aye i think a 'clean house' is needed at the minute ;/
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
Referrals will work, you just have to start with a core your trust, and not be afraid to say no, or toss someone when, even though referred, prove to be something unsavory.
No signature
-
NightDreams
- Posts: 220
- Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
- Location: Bristol, UK
Pure and simple the members of the guild need to look at themselves and see if they really beleive they want to be here and if they are willing to help.
Caping the amount fo people we take in would solve anything imo.
What needs to be done is to try and spead more time talking to the person before they join.
As i have said many times to the mods and even in guild chat, i may be a mod but i try to do as little as recruting as possible.
Why u ask the answer is simple, it all comes from the kind of person i am.
I am a solo player i enojy playing the game by myself and like the fact that i am able to do alot of things by myself in game.
I will lead if needs be but am more then willing to let others try to run the show.
This does make me alittle bit set aside from other mods who enjoy grouping with lots of different people and in some cases like to lead.
Dont get me wrong im willing to help people if they ask but when is comes to recruting i would much rather leave it to someone who enjoys or who has had made experance of doing it then i.
Imo if heads have to roll let it be done, we all know what can come if we sit back and do nothing and i do not what to see the problems of the past return to haunt us.
ND
Caping the amount fo people we take in would solve anything imo.
What needs to be done is to try and spead more time talking to the person before they join.
As i have said many times to the mods and even in guild chat, i may be a mod but i try to do as little as recruting as possible.
Why u ask the answer is simple, it all comes from the kind of person i am.
I am a solo player i enojy playing the game by myself and like the fact that i am able to do alot of things by myself in game.
I will lead if needs be but am more then willing to let others try to run the show.
This does make me alittle bit set aside from other mods who enjoy grouping with lots of different people and in some cases like to lead.
Dont get me wrong im willing to help people if they ask but when is comes to recruting i would much rather leave it to someone who enjoys or who has had made experance of doing it then i.
Imo if heads have to roll let it be done, we all know what can come if we sit back and do nothing and i do not what to see the problems of the past return to haunt us.
ND
Lies can be good, If they are put to good use.
-
Kon
- Posts: 1528
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
- Location: USA
As I said earlier today, recruiting should be closed except to people that are invited in by existing members. The kind of people you put on your friends list and who you know are SSX material. Finally, put these people up for refferal to two mods.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."
-
SSX-Andy
- Posts: 374
- Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 2:28 am
A lot of good points have been made in this thread.
I joined and stayed with SSX because it was a guild that had the same ideal as me; ie that friendship and closeness are more important than being "leet". I don't mind waiting before heading down to MC if it means that once we get down there I will be there with 39 people I know, trust and who Im glad to call friends. Just running run after run isnt the goal with the game for me, the goal is to have fun.
I'm all for starting with a clean house, even if it means that some gets kicked out. We are starting to become a known (or somewhat known) guild and we need to take a bit of time to figure out where we want to go and how we want to be seen. Do we want to be known as the leet guild that kick ragnars ass every other night, or do we want to be known as the guild with the helpful friendly players that always have time for a bit of fun?
I know what I want, and I'm sure that most of us want the same thing. It does take time to talk to and get to know the recruits, but if we (meaning MS and QD
) dont take the time, how can we keep the guild friendship based?
I joined and stayed with SSX because it was a guild that had the same ideal as me; ie that friendship and closeness are more important than being "leet". I don't mind waiting before heading down to MC if it means that once we get down there I will be there with 39 people I know, trust and who Im glad to call friends. Just running run after run isnt the goal with the game for me, the goal is to have fun.
I'm all for starting with a clean house, even if it means that some gets kicked out. We are starting to become a known (or somewhat known) guild and we need to take a bit of time to figure out where we want to go and how we want to be seen. Do we want to be known as the leet guild that kick ragnars ass every other night, or do we want to be known as the guild with the helpful friendly players that always have time for a bit of fun?
I know what I want, and I'm sure that most of us want the same thing. It does take time to talk to and get to know the recruits, but if we (meaning MS and QD
-
SSX-Killjoy
- Posts: 778
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 6:17 pm
- Yahoo Messenger: Killjoypg
- Location: SSX - CG, AZ
Sorry, just had to point out one thing.but if we (meaning MS and QD Smile ) dont take the time,
It should be the joy of everyone in the group to get to know the new recruits. If the system were working perfectly, then by the time they were turned over to QD and MS for final approval, the whole group could vouch for them. Of course that is a bit of a pipe dream as not everyone plays at the same time or as the same amount of time to dedicate to getting to know people. But still, it should be on the shoulders of all those who are already SSX members to get to know those who have become or want to become SSX players.
It's a family thing, ya know?
================================
I will be forever Shattered Star, but only as an
EXILE can I find peace in this lifetime.
================================
I will be forever Shattered Star, but only as an
EXILE can I find peace in this lifetime.
================================
-
SSX-Rain
- Posts: 36
- Joined: Fri Mar 04, 2005 3:51 pm
- Location: Stockholm
Why not do just that (atleast the mods) have a thread called friends that we all could add and play with for some time OR start a channel called "insert cleaver namer here" that ppl could join and we could talk there.
We could throw the channel invite to ppl we like...
Just a thought!
We could throw the channel invite to ppl we like...
Just a thought!
//
Rain
EvE Online - Kitana Rainstorm
WoW EU @ Bladefist - RETIRED
70 Rainstorm Night Elf Huntress
70 Evenstar Night Elf Priestess Tailoring/Enchanting 300/300
70 Bladesong Night Elf Warrior
70 Rainfall Night Elf Rogue
70 Stormseeker Night Elf Druid
70 Rainforce Dranei Shaman
70 Katalina Human Paladin
70 Katala Human Mage
70 Eventide Human Warlock
Rain
EvE Online - Kitana Rainstorm
WoW EU @ Bladefist - RETIRED
70 Rainstorm Night Elf Huntress
70 Evenstar Night Elf Priestess Tailoring/Enchanting 300/300
70 Bladesong Night Elf Warrior
70 Rainfall Night Elf Rogue
70 Stormseeker Night Elf Druid
70 Rainforce Dranei Shaman
70 Katalina Human Paladin
70 Katala Human Mage
70 Eventide Human Warlock
-
Gryphon
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 11:33 am
- Location: Under the rug...
Well, I've been SSX since it's inception, and SSC for some time before that. When I came back to WoW, I was a bit overwhelmed, I knew the odd name here and there and no one else.
To be honest I'm P/O'd. Not at any one individual, not really anyone really. It's the atmosphere. I Know next to no one anymore, anyone who knows me from NC will know what I'm like on the clan chats, I get involved, I comment - and sometimes I'm just plain random, but I'm there and having a laugh.
I can't do that in WoW - For one I haven't been able to get to know any one new recruit over any others, none have tried to get to know me, except a few. Whats even worse, and what I feel is the worst thing I've ever said in relation to the SSX - Some people just make me feel plain F****d off.
They don't talk - they don't IRC, they don't read the forums. They don't bother with anyone. May sound a tad militant, but I don't like it. I'm in agreement with Dan here, something needs to be done, because I'm getting a bit sick of the way things are going, the one purpose of the SSX is friendship, and I don't see a lot of it anymore.
To be honest I'm P/O'd. Not at any one individual, not really anyone really. It's the atmosphere. I Know next to no one anymore, anyone who knows me from NC will know what I'm like on the clan chats, I get involved, I comment - and sometimes I'm just plain random, but I'm there and having a laugh.
I can't do that in WoW - For one I haven't been able to get to know any one new recruit over any others, none have tried to get to know me, except a few. Whats even worse, and what I feel is the worst thing I've ever said in relation to the SSX - Some people just make me feel plain F****d off.
They don't talk - they don't IRC, they don't read the forums. They don't bother with anyone. May sound a tad militant, but I don't like it. I'm in agreement with Dan here, something needs to be done, because I'm getting a bit sick of the way things are going, the one purpose of the SSX is friendship, and I don't see a lot of it anymore.
ESO - EU - Ebonheart
Jalfrezi - Khajit DK/Destro
Peeks-Through-Windows - Argonian Templar/Resto
Jalfrezi - Khajit DK/Destro
Peeks-Through-Windows - Argonian Templar/Resto
-
SoulSeeker
- Posts: 299
- Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 8:02 pm
- Location: Scotland
Most of the ppl i've joined up to the guild i've been in a team with..thus u get to see an insight into how they play etc..greed...help...humour...style...only after the quest is over do i approach them.
What i hate is a pm saying ' can u talk to xyz as i'm busy' well perhaps u are busy but i dont know them and i'm not goona give them a how to join ssx speach without seeing them in action first.I hate this can u join my grannysaunitiesuncleboyfriendscousan type stuff.
Be selective ..watch ..listen ...approach them if thier interested contact QD or MS then tell them how to join.
What i hate is a pm saying ' can u talk to xyz as i'm busy' well perhaps u are busy but i dont know them and i'm not goona give them a how to join ssx speach without seeing them in action first.I hate this can u join my grannysaunitiesuncleboyfriendscousan type stuff.
Be selective ..watch ..listen ...approach them if thier interested contact QD or MS then tell them how to join.
