No Rogues?

Moderator: Global Moderators

No Rogues?

PostPosted: Fri Aug 19, 2005 10:08 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
When I asked Inquisitor about this, he told me to ask you nicely, but we all know I'm not nice, so I'll go straight, no chaser.

What's with the Rogue selection of opportunity rule? There should be ways to regulate parties, even if by rotation only.

Subsequently, what if I and 20 other already existing SSX members decided to buy the game today, and all start Rogues?

Explanations please. The sticky doesn't quite cut it.

PostPosted: Fri Aug 19, 2005 10:19 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
We have a LOT of active high level rogues (more than any other class like i said). When we are doing the endgame instances all the rogues are going to want to take part, and so they should be able to. If we keep recruiting more rogues then people are gonna get left out whether we take it in turns or not - which taking it in turns will not work since we will all be gaining our dragonkill points. Rogues are gonna get left out. Why should us rogues have to rotate between one another and miss out when no other class does? We'll never get any of the equipment we need doing that.

We simply can't take every single rogue along to MC, recruiting more rogues makes it so people miss out on doing the instance and miss getting points they could usually get like any other class.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Fri Aug 19, 2005 10:22 pm

Inquisitor
Posts: 3411
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
Location: SSX
So you just aren't actively recruiting a rogue?

What if someone is really really cool, though?
No signature

PostPosted: Fri Aug 19, 2005 11:39 pm

User avatar
Futile Resistance
Posts: 1454
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 10:44 pm
Location: FL
Inquisitor wrote:So you just aren't actively recruiting a rogue?

What if someone is really really cool, though?
I thought about that as well... Maybe they'll end up rolling a new char? lol :sweat:

PostPosted: Fri Aug 19, 2005 11:43 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Anyone else against this whilst we're on the subject?... :sweat:
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 12:19 am

User avatar
dragonismydog
Posts: 8
Joined: Sun Jul 17, 2005 7:16 pm
So if i made a rogue you all would get mad at me? Not that i want to make one. I already have a lvl 26 or 27 mage and a lvl 14 or 15 paladin. But if i said that i wanted to make one would i get kicked out of the guild or something?

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 12:45 am

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
One hour session pertaining to the discussion.
[23:09] <BlackDove> WoW boys.
[23:09] <BlackDove> http://www.shatteredstar.org/ssx/forums ... 3852#13852
[23:15] <Judd-MGT> BD you seem to miss on crucial fact..
[23:15] <Judd-MGT> if 20 new players started playing as rogues it would take them atleast a month or two to get to the level where they would be an issue
[23:15] <BlackDove> The GM just set my level at 60
[23:15] <Judd-MGT> They are talking about invites of the lvl 60 chars for MC setup
[23:15] <BlackDove> Work from there
[23:15] <Judd-MGT> ain't gonna happen
[23:16] <BlackDove> We're back to square 1 by the way.
[23:17] <Judd-MGT> ?
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <Judd-MGT> BD you seem to miss on crucial fact..
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <Judd-MGT> if 20 new players started playing as rogues it would take them atleast a month or two to get to the level where they would be an issue
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <BlackDove> The GM just set my level at 60
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <Judd-MGT> They are talking about invites of the lvl 60 chars for MC setup
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <BlackDove> Work from there
[23:17] <BlackDove> [23:15] <Judd-MGT> ain't gonna happen
[23:17] <BlackDove> is meaningless to the point
[23:20] <Judd-MGT> well what about the fact that if you are ssx already you won't have to go through the recruit process..
[23:20] <Judd-MGT> so seems silly anyways
[23:20] <BlackDove> You do ingame.
[23:20] <BlackDove> I don't start out as SSX
[23:20] <SSX-MS> Posted a reply
[23:21] <Judd-MGT> but see you are changing your argument
[23:21] <EdGardner-MGT> I kinda agree with him asking the question
[23:21] <Judd-MGT> your point was what if curr SSX members bought the game and played
[23:21] <Judd-MGT> :)
[23:21] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> we have too many rogues
[23:21] <SSX-MS> yes we do anny
[23:21] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> if you make one then you will be left out of raids more often
[23:22] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> because we cant take a team of just rogues :/
[23:22] <Judd-MGT> The question is a good one.. his example lacks what the question is trying to acheive
[23:22] <SSX-MS> People have already started feeling left out of instances because we can't take every rogue that wants to take part along. We do it in MC we gonna have a lot of upset rogues.
[23:22] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> so us getting more isnt really a good idea
[23:23] <BlackDove> Someone explain to me how grouping works
[23:23] <SSX-MS> We had Mimiru (a rogue) join us recently. He LEFT his old guild because he was getting left out as a rogue because they had too many of them in the guild he was in and they were all better equipped than him.
[23:23] <Judd-MGT> (it isn't like people can't have alts that are not rogues... they just choose to stick to one char)
[23:23] <BlackDove> Only a limited amount of people go in a class?
[23:23] <SSX-MS> I dont want our guild to get that way where people get left out
[23:23] <EdGardner-MGT> 110[17:20] Judd-MGT: 101The question is a good one.. his example lacks what the question is trying to acheive
[23:23] <EdGardner-MGT> then help him ask it, I think we know what he's asking
[23:23] <EdGardner-MGT> ;)
[23:23] <BlackDove> Or is it a limited amount of people per group?
[23:23] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> no
[23:24] <BlackDove> Because your grouping argument is void if it's the latter.
[23:24] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you can take as many of any class as you want
[23:24] <SSX-MS> you can't take too many of 1 class along in a group our your group will just wipe.. simple
[23:24] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> but if you take a team with just one class you'll get wiped
[23:24] <SSX-MS> exactly
[23:24] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you need a balanced team
[23:24] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> and thus you cant take 40 rogues with you
[23:24] <BlackDove> [23:23] <BlackDove> Or is it a limited amount of people per group?
[23:24] <BlackDove> so it's that
[23:24] <BlackDove> okay
[23:24] <SSX-MS> eg. Lets say we have a 15 man group
[23:25] <Judd-MGT> limited amount of people.. and the raids are setup specifically to encourage diversity of the players
[23:25] <SSX-MS> you shouldn't really take more than 3 rogues in that group.
[23:25] <Judd-MGT> you can't go in as all rogues and win, nor vice versa any role in the game..
[23:25] <SSX-MS> 1. It will be unbalanced. 2. It will be unfair on the other rogues having even MORE rogues wanting the same equipment as them. 3. You will be a shit team
[23:25] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> except perhaps priests
[23:25] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> because they are oh so hard to kill
[23:25] <Judd-MGT> I still don't think you could do a full raid with only priests
[23:26] <SSX-MS> If we did carry on recruiting more and more rogues i would stop playing my class.....
[23:26] <SSX-MS> Because there would be no point in playing it, rogues are already the highest rolled class on the server :/
[23:26] <EdGardner-MGT> what if the person was a really really cool person?
[23:26] <EdGardner-MGT> that's my only objection
[23:26] <BlackDove> I was always under the impression we were about the people
[23:26] <BlackDove> Not about the way the game is played
[23:27] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> they would likely want to leave when tyhey see the situation
[23:27] <SSX-MS> you think they would like being left out of endgame raids because we already have enough of the class they play?
[23:27] <Judd-MGT> A person can have 8 chars on a server
[23:27] <SSX-MS> Even if they are a good person?
[23:27] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> no-one would join a group simply for people
[23:27] <Judd-MGT> if someone really wants a rogue, they should be willing to roll another char for the raids
[23:27] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you have to know you'dbe doing something too
[23:27] <BlackDove> [23:27] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> no-one would join a group simply for people?
[23:27] <BlackDove> What?
[23:27] <Judd-MGT> or atleast have aln
[23:27] <Judd-MGT> an alt
[23:28] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> to clarify BD
[23:28] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> I mean in an MMO
[23:28] <BlackDove> Me too
[23:28] <EdGardner-MGT> that's fair, I'd personally, be far more interested in you being up front, ie: we have alot of rogues, you join us as a rogue, you will get left out of endgame raids
[23:28] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you want to know you'll have things to do too
[23:28] <BlackDove> What Ed said
[23:28] <EdGardner-MGT> rather than barring people from entering
[23:28] <BlackDove> Rotation.
[23:28] <BlackDove> We did it for FS2
[23:28] <BlackDove> People wait
[23:28] <BlackDove> Tough shit
[23:28] <EdGardner-MGT> seems elitist
[23:29] <EdGardner-MGT> dunno
[23:29] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> and if you're not taking part in 3/4 runs due to there being too many of your class you'd get bored
[23:29] <BlackDove> This is ingame racial profiling - I don't like it.
[23:29] <SSX-MS> FS2 is kinda small compared to WoW...
[23:29] <EdGardner-MGT> that's a wee bit extreme
[23:29] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> exactly
[23:29] <BlackDove> It's extreme
[23:29] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you may have been able to do that for FS2
[23:29] <BlackDove> But it goes to the effect.
[23:29] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> but WoW is on a whole diffent size scale
[23:29] <BlackDove> You're allowing Molten Core to shake down the core of the entire community.
[23:29] <BlackDove> I don't like that.
[23:30] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> its endgame content........
[23:30] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> what everyone works to
[23:30] <Judd-MGT> MS, couldn't we just ask rogues to roll an alt?
[23:30] <SSX-MS> The entire reason why i said no more rogues is because if they do join us they're only gonna get left out of raids so how is that fair on them? Its in their best interest.
[23:30] <BlackDove> I don't care if you get $10 000 000 for finishing that dungeon in real life.
[23:30] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> its not just Molten Core, its all engame raids
[23:30] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> the same thing applies for all of them
[23:30] <Judd-MGT> it takes along time to get to 60 admittedly but atleast they would be busy rather than sitting.. :)
[23:30] <SSX-MS> I aint rerolling the class i've played since the day the servers went live :/
[23:31] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> same goes for Blackwing Lair, UBRS, LBRS, the list goes on
[23:31] <Judd-MGT> no I don't mean losing their main one
[23:31] <BlackDove> This is going to be your call Ed.
[23:31] <BlackDove> I don't like this.
[23:31] <Judd-MGT> Just leveling a secondary.. so that if all the slots are full they can join in another capacity
[23:31] <EdGardner-MGT> I think it's an extreme stance
[23:32] <BlackDove> I think it's exactly the line that should never be crossed.
[23:32] <EdGardner-MGT> to say "no more" without consideration for the personality, someone who joins anyway might be just the kinda buddy that you would want around
[23:32] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> I think its fair considering the rogue situation on Bladefist
[23:32] <SSX-MS> If we keep recruiting people that play a rogue as their main character, that are gonna get left out of raids simply because we already have more than enough. How is that fair on them at all??

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 12:46 am

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
[23:32] <EdGardner-MGT> it's not fair ms
[23:32] <BlackDove> AT least it'll be their choice
[23:33] <BlackDove> They'll join knowning that.
[23:33] <EdGardner-MGT> that's the difference
[23:33] <BlackDove> But at least they'll join.
[23:33] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> and then likely leave....
[23:33] <BlackDove> So?
[23:33] <EdGardner-MGT> anyway, I don;t think this is going to kill us, and I am not mad or anything
[23:33] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> because they will have little to nothing to do with guildies when capped
[23:33] <SSX-MS> Who's gonna join a guild that they can't do endgame instances with? no1...
[23:33] <EdGardner-MGT> just want to understand it
[23:33] <BlackDove> I don't really see why you would want people to join FOR that reason MS
[23:33] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> so BD....
[23:33] <EdGardner-MGT> and i need to get on an airplane soon
[23:34] <EdGardner-MGT> try not to kill each other
[23:34] <EdGardner-MGT> and, before you start arguing and flaming eachother
[23:34] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you want a system which encourages people to join, use the guild till they cap, then leave to find a guild where they can do engame content?
[23:34] <Judd-MGT> but BD, you haven't dedicated 2 months to reaching that end game point
[23:34] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> thats not a good system.....its really not
[23:34] <EdGardner-MGT> consider what the other side is saying, we spent alot of time talking about "what does it mean to be ssx?"
[23:34] <Judd-MGT> trust me.. everyone who is level 60 is looking for a guild to do MC
[23:34] <Judd-MGT> and end game raids
[23:34] <Judd-MGT> because they ahve to be done as a guild/group..
[23:34] <Judd-MGT> it was how the game was designed
[23:34] <BlackDove> And so it's my fault that you pushed 1yourself1 to get to somewhere that's impossible when it comes to our standards?
[23:35] <BlackDove> Doesn't make sense to me.
[23:35] * SSX-MS thinks he should never have said anything...
[23:35] <EdGardner-MGT> please see above
[23:35] <EdGardner-MGT> and let it go for a couple hours
[23:36] <EdGardner-MGT> I think i know what you are trying to do
[23:36] <Judd-MGT> The hard part is damned if we do, damned if we don't...
[23:36] <EdGardner-MGT> I think you MAY be going about it in a slightly wrong way (please note emphasis on MAY)
[23:36] <BlackDove> The discussion is done for me - I was explained all I needed to know. Answer is a resounding NO from my end. I'm just one voice however, so you can choose to ignore it, but it's still NO. End.
[23:36] <SSX-MS> We've already had people join our guild because they got left out of other big guilds for having too many of the same class, i'd hate to see our guild get that way and it will if we dont stop recruiting them as we already have enough as i've said. :/
[23:37] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> indeed
[23:37] <EdGardner-MGT> or I suppose you could keep trying to make points
[23:37] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> there are points to support both points of view
[23:37] <SSX-MS> You guys should actually see bladefist, it is FULL of rogues. Tons of them...
[23:38] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> personally I think you really need to see the situation before you can understand why we're doing it
[23:38] <EdGardner-MGT> anny: dismissing the concern isn't addressing it
[23:38] <BlackDove> Ehhhhhh
[23:38] <EdGardner-MGT> DO NOT TELL ME I HAVE TO BE THERE TO UNDERSTAND IT
[23:38] <BlackDove> Anubis IIRC
[23:38] <EdGardner-MGT> period
[23:38] <BlackDove> That's what Risen said
[23:38] <EdGardner-MGT> ever
[23:38] <EdGardner-MGT> exactly
[23:38] <BlackDove> I hate him for that.
[23:38] <BlackDove> Never say that to me please.
[23:38] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> uh, sorry
[23:39] <EdGardner-MGT> we can have a civil conversation about this without resortingto that
[23:39] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> wasnt intended to offend
[23:39] <EdGardner-MGT> I understsand you have a problem, and i understand you are trying to sove it amicably for people
[23:40] <SSX-MS> I did put this idea forward in the thread i made before i went ahead with it and nobody posted any strong objections
[23:40] <EdGardner-MGT> I even understand WHY you are doing it
[23:40] <SSX-MS> but i go ahead and now ppl do :/
[23:40] <EdGardner-MGT> I just don;t know that I personally agree with the exact approach
[23:40] <EdGardner-MGT> and am voicing my concerns
[23:40] <BlackDove> The way I see it, you're obsessed with effectivness over the core principles. Afraid that if you don't do it the way it's most effective, you will not be able to do it at all, and you're willing to sacrifice core principles in order to remain effective.
[23:40] <EdGardner-MGT> apologies for yelling
[23:40] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> I apologise for offending
[23:41] <EdGardner-MGT> accepted
[23:41] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> and your apology for yelling is also accepted
[23:41] <SSX-MS> not effective..
[23:41] <SSX-MS> Simply because i don't want people feeling left out.
[23:41] <EdGardner-MGT> and that is a noble goal
[23:41] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> more like sensible instead of effective BD
[23:42] <EdGardner-MGT> I have to go to the airport now, I'll see if I can get a connection down there while i wait
[23:42] <BlackDove> Hmm
[23:42] <BlackDove> I'm a commie
[23:42] <BlackDove> I can't believe I'm actualyl going to say this.
[23:42] <BlackDove> actually*
[23:43] <SSX-NF> hi
[23:43] * BlackDove sets mode: +oo SSX-NF Winbrian
[23:43] <EdGardner-MGT> anyway
[23:43] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> c ya Ed, have a good flight :)
[23:44] <BlackDove> It should be the people's choice if they're going to be left out or not. If it breaks effectivness, as in, people start leaving because they're unable to do the end dungeons - in my view, tough deal. Bye.
[23:44] <BlackDove> This place shouldn't be about the final dungeon.
[23:44] <BlackDove> It should be about people, at least that's my view on it.
[23:44] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> but......
[23:45] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> you tell people you cant do endgame conent and they say thats fine and join
[23:45] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> they take advantage of the guild to get to 60
[23:45] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> then leave
[23:45] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> thats really really unfair to the guild
[23:45] <BlackDove> Okay.
[23:45] <BlackDove> Time for better recruiting standards?
[23:46] <EdGardner-MGT> which, I think it was they are after
[23:46] <EdGardner-MGT> now i really have to go
[23:46] <EdGardner-MGT> bye :)
[23:46] <BlackDove> BYEZ.
[23:46] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> if they've been told about the guild from eithin they'll know we help our own a lot
[23:46] <SSX-MS> cya ed
[23:46] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> c ya Ed
[23:46] <Judd-MGT> that is what they did BD.. they said no rogues.. ;)
[23:46] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> indeed
[23:46] <BlackDove> I meant personality wise.
[23:46] <BlackDove> Not technically.
[23:46] <Judd-MGT> on the flip side though, what did you do in NC to do the highend dungeons?
[23:46] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> it gets rid of the issue
[23:46] <Judd-MGT> did you just take only APUs?
[23:46] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> NC had highend dungeons? lol
[23:46] <BlackDove> QD got all of the people, just like this.
[23:46] <BlackDove> I got into the game.
[23:46] <Judd-MGT> or did you have to share the burden with PPUs and APUs
[23:46] <BlackDove> I kicked them all for being asses.
[23:47] <SSX-MS> NC is a lot different because you can take as many as 1 class into an NC dungeon as u want. Theres no limit. In WoW no more than a certain number of people can even enter the instance so even if we wanted to invite every rogue along we couldn't because the game doesn't allow it.
[23:47] <BlackDove> NC dungeon = OP war
[23:47] <BlackDove> It's the same thing almost.
[23:48] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> its not
[23:48] <BlackDove> Suddenly people were terrified that MORALS are being upheld, so they left when I got there.
[23:48] <BlackDove> Maybe I handled it wrong.
[23:48] <SSX-MS> eg. Upper blackrock spire for instance. The instance has a max of 15. No more than 15 can enter the instance at the same time.
[23:48] <Judd-MGT> but you still had to have a balance betwene your players.. you can't win an op war without sufficient capability
[23:48] <BlackDove> Maybe QD invited the wrong people.
[23:48] <BlackDove> Maybe it was both.
[23:48] <BlackDove> Doesn't really matter.
[23:48] <BlackDove> We refrained from having those kinds of rules though.
[23:48] <BlackDove> I can just imagine FF's rules today.
[23:48] <BlackDove> "ONE OF YOUR CHARACTERS HAS TO BE A PPU!"
[23:49] <BlackDove> Which would probably be the same thing, considering the monk-fest NC is today.
[23:49] <BlackDove> There's your comparison to be honest.
[23:49] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> its not.....
[23:49] <SSX-MS> we also have to think about grace of elune as well.
[23:49] <SSX-MS> We do all our endgame instance with GoE. They have rogues too.
[23:49] <BlackDove> [23:48] <Judd-MGT> but you still had to have a balance betwene your players.. you can't win an op war without sufficient capability
[23:49] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> In NC PPUs are used because they kill all else, you take an army of PPUs to an op war you win
[23:49] <BlackDove> Again
[23:50] <BlackDove> Effectivness over Principles
[23:50] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> In WoW if you took an army of rogues to a dungeon you would be wiped across the instance
[23:50] <BlackDove> You're trying to be capable. I think you're using the wrong means to go about it.
[23:50] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> and yeah, GoE have to be considered too. We cant say that all rogues on this run are ours as it wouldnt be fair to them
[23:50] <SSX-MS> I'm just trying to be fair on the current rogue members that we already have.
[23:50] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> thus the number of rogues running is narrowed further and the waiting list grows
[23:51] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> which really isnt fair at all
[23:51] <BlackDove> hehe
[23:51] <BlackDove> "whenever someone starts worrying about what's fair for me, I start wondering about what's in it for them"
[23:52] <SSX-Anubis_SWAT4> oh how this would be so much better if we were on a balanced server lol
[23:52] <SSX-MS> ..
[23:52] <BlackDove> We can agree to disagree.
[23:52] <BlackDove> But we still disagree.
You can see both sides of the coin there hopefully.

Summary of the opposing view:

It's against the motto, if we even have such a thing. "SSX is about people" isn't true with a rule like that. I know it's hard to find balance. I know it's hard to do the final dungeon. I know.

But when you introduce a rule like this, you shift the focus from recruiting being judged by who people are to what people play. Someone could be a really great person, and their access would be denied here because of this... pardon me, but childish rule.

This wasn't okay when there were five of us and we were playing war, and you didn't want Billy to be on your team because he's fat, and it's not okay now.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 1:48 am

User avatar
Kon
Posts: 1528
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
Location: USA
Not letting rogues into the guild is perhaps the biggest mistake we have made this year. If a guy wants to join the guild, and he turns out to be a good person, he or she is let into the guild. No if's, and's or but's about it. They also have the right to leave the guild.

When they ask to join why not tell them that they will probably have to wait a long time to do MC? If they really cared as much as you do about the endgame equipment, they have that oppertunity to walk away before they join, and an infinite number of oppertunities afterward . Like BD said, if they don't want to wait, tough luck. Also those kind of people are the ones I thought Bladefist was cracking down on.

The other idea of having them make an alt is bearable (KJ said people take 2 months getting to level 60? How about 4 months to get to level 28? Again, I'm in no hurry,) but it's still extreme in my opinion. This 'What about Grace of Elune' approach, It doesn't matter it just adds more people to the waiting line. Again quoting BD, we need to stick to our values rather than doing whats most effective. More importantly, We aren't here to max out our stats and equipment in World of Warcraft, we are here to have fun! The people that focus their rules and beliefs upon the game of the moment aren't the ones that last eight years or more, like the Shattered Star have.
Now shut up and play.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 2:01 am

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
While you do have a point BD, it isn't really as fair a rule to potential members as some would say it should be, lifting the rule would also be unfair.

Lets say rogues apply and say that they don't mind dreadfully long queues for engame content and they are invited into the guild. Lets say the number of rogues in the guild continues to swell, recruits are happy with the situation so they join. Has anyone considered the rogues already in the guild? People who've been a part of the guild and helped as much as they can for a while now? Have they been asked whether they would mind a massive queue on endgame content?

Think about it. Why should the rogues rotate on instance runs when no other class in the guild has to? How would you feel if you were constantly being left out and due to that unable to get points/equipment from engame content? How would you feel if you were unable to participate in 9/10 of all guild group content just because more and more people of your class were joining the guild? You would be missing out, you would get bored, possibly even leave the guild. It would unfair to each and every person currently in the guild who plays a rogue if we lifted that rule, said 'all rogues welcome'. What would you tell them? Roll an alt and spend several months capping them if you want to take part in any endgame content?

We all play the game for fun, rogues and non-rogues, and getting left out of game content when no-one of another class is being made to do so or having to take it in turns to participate when no other class is having to queue isn't fair. People will just go join another guild where they can take part in game content. People who have helped our guild and people in it for a long time. Its simply not fair.

"SSX is about people" - Too true, unfortunatly as I see it its impossible to please everyone here. Either potential rogue recruits or current rogue members will be annoyed. This can only be resolved with the situation fair to one side. You think it should be fair to potential members, I think it should be fair to current members. Unfortunatly there is no place in between, its one extreme or the other and one side will come out unhappy.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 2:29 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
It's just not realistic, and it's cruel, to ask more people of that class to come into the guild when we are stretching our resources to kit out the CURRENT Rogues, getting the rest geared up to Molten Core Status will be difficult enough as it is.

If an Outstanding Candidate did apply I would still consider allowing them into the guild however they WOULD be advised of the problem, and perhaps rolling an alt would be suggested.

I am impressed that many members (some of which are rogues some of which are not) have already taken to rolling alts to cover our problems in end game, and I applaud this.
Don't think that has gone unnoticed people. ;)

Recruiting more rogues at this point would be harming the current membership, and those are the people I care about.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 2:41 am

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
It wouldn't hurt anyone if you did simple rotation with the overextended class, be it items or dungeons.

New people could always be told that if you play a rogue, you'll need to stand in line.

That's just one of the options. No current membership would be harmed. That point is void.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 2:42 am

User avatar
esd
Posts: 986
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 2:25 am
Location: Somewhere
A person is a person. It's them that's joining, rogue, non-rogue, pumpkin, whatever.

Denying them access to the SSX because of their game's character's race, skill set, profession, whatever, flows against what it is to be SSX.
""I like my women like I like my coffee. In a plastic cup.""

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 3:36 am

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
BlackDove wrote:New people could always be told that if you play a rogue, you'll need to stand in line.

That's just one of the options. No current membership would be harmed. That point is void.
To establish a queue like this would just be another way to *be as fair as possible* on one hand & *drive newcomers away to get it under control again* on the other hand... at the cost of every member of this class.

I dont want to see a steady flow of newcomers joining the guild, getting frustrated about the circumstances & leaving in the end. Its cruel as QD said.

Fair is to be straight & tell them: No! More members of this class would harm the guild & in the end would harm you too.

A line needs to be drawn & exceptions will be made as always.

I would wish we had reached the point of beeing more selective with invites, like now with the rogue class, with all other classes as well. It brings us closer to the point where recruitement is limited to ppl on your friendslist like suggested in other threads.

my 2c
Last edited by Sofia on Sat Aug 20, 2005 11:02 am, edited 1 time in total.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 7:49 am

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
QuantumDelta wrote:It's just not realistic, and it's cruel, to ask more people of that class to come into the guild when we are stretching our resources to kit out the CURRENT Rogues, getting the rest geared up to Molten Core Status will be difficult enough as it is.
QuantumDelta wrote:Recruiting more rogues at this point would be harming the current membership, and those are the people I care about.
Exactly.

It wouldn't hurt anyone if you did simple rotation with the overextended class
I'm sorry but why should the rogues, some of which have been in the guild since the day it was founded. Be made to rotate and get left out when no other class is being made to? How is that fair?

Why should we screw over our current rogue members even more than we are doing already? Recruiting more people that play rogues as their main character is going to do that, it has already started and i wanted to put a stop to it before it got even worse. I'm thinking of our members here!
Why make our rogue members have to rotate between each other to do instance runs? And if we recruit even more rogues that rotation is gonna get bigger and bigger.. How is that fair? How are any of our rogues supposed to enjoy the endgame content with the SSX like that? No other class is gonna be made to do it, why the rogues?
Okay even if we explained all this to the rogues wishing to join, how many of them do you think would actually join knowing they're not gonna be needed in our guild because we already have enough of the class they play? Hardly any. It is unfair to recruit them, unfair on the recruit himself and our current members.

I'm gonna be honest here. As a rogue it is awful enough finding random groups to do instances with OUTSIDE of the guild because of the rogue overpopulation. If it gets the same in our guild which it has already started to, as i said we have more than enough already. Then what is the point in continuing to play?

-As i keep saying. Recruiting more and more rogues and making all the rogues take it in turns to do instances is simply not fair. It damages the current rogue membership, it upsets the rogues that have been with us a long time, it totally screws them over in general. A lot of people joined our guild because they wanted a nice friendly guild to play with that will eventually do endgame content together, they can't get that with a lot of other guilds because of the "too much of 1 class" problem, they get left out, so our guild was perfect for them in that respect. If the same thing happens with SSX a lot of our current rogue members are going to get upset and probably leave, all for the sake of recruiting more and more rogues... Thats screwed up in its-self.


We all should get on IRC sometime this weekend if possible to discuss this. I feel very strongly about this and i'm not willing to recruit more and more rogues into our guild at the expense of our current members. Things have been heading that way and it has already started to upset current membership slightly, i'm not prepaired to let the problem get even worse by recruiting more rogues.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 8:52 am

User avatar
SSX-Ava
Posts: 691
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
Location: Yorkshire, UK
i think the rogue situation is currently unfair as it stands. I have noticed wen oraganising raids that alot of rogues get left out and other classes get to go on every run ;/. I think we shouldnt just never recruit rogues, if the rogue is really cool then he shud be allowed to join. I'm more concerned for the rogues in the guild rather then the ones not even in the guild they have voiced theor concerns to me recently and i think we need to deal with it.
Its not fair if rogues have to rotate, whilst other classes like me (warrior) will be present on every run. If i was in the same position as alot of rogues are facing in the near future i wouldnt be happy at all.
Its about looking after the current members and not leaving them out. Also i dont think alot of members would stick around if we were going to conitnue to inv lots of rogues the way we are doing and i dont want too see members leave.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 2:37 pm

User avatar
Kon
Posts: 1528
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
Location: USA
If your not going to let rogues join, even if they know about having to wait, just don't recruit at all, thats whats fair.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 3:08 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Any Current SSX members who sign up would be suggested to take up other classes....druids priests warlocks all of which would be heavily valued.

Rather than just another rogue...

The guild itself is really working very hard to correct the imbalances already and like I said it's really impressive.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 3:48 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
BlackDove wrote:It wouldn't hurt anyone if you did simple rotation with the overextended class, be it items or dungeons.

New people could always be told that if you play a rogue, you'll need to stand in line.

That's just one of the options. No current membership would be harmed. That point is void.
As I have already explained in my last post, it WOULD hurt current rogue members if we did a much larger scale rotation. As I said, new people could be told and agree to the long queues, but the current rogue membership who have helped and assisted the guild, as QD said in some cases since the guild was founded, would be pushed into even longer queues for any and all game content. They would leave due to this, people who have helped both the guild as a whole and individual guildies a lot, people who are SSX material and have proven it over time.
It would harm the guild as a whole and it would hurt individual members of that class.

QD is absolutely correct when he says:
Recruiting more rogues at this point would be harming the current membership, and those are the people I care about.
EDIT -
SSX-MS wrote:If we carry on recruiting more rogues i won't leave the SSX like other rogues would i would just leave the game as i'm not prepaired to play like that and i'm not prepaired to reroll to a different class when i have been a rogue member of the SSX since the day the guild was founded.
That certainly makes our point. The person in the Guild Master position (basically head of the guild) leaving the guild and/or the game would CERTAINLY harm the guild and the membership. And I wouldnt blame him for leaving, getting to do game content once every few months (provided that we keep doing runs once a week as we have been) would irritate anyone. I can certainly see very many people leaving due to that. And a substantial amount of people leaving the guild is certainly harming the guild.
Last edited by Anubis on Sat Aug 20, 2005 4:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 3:48 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Imagine this..

Molten Core one day per week. Think it would be fair to make our current rogue members rotate between one another to go to Molten Core just so's we can recruit more and more rogues into the guild, and for that rotation to get even bigger and bigger? Every other class like Ava has said will get to go on every single run with their friends, but the rogues are made to take it in turns on a list that is forever getting longer. - That is not fair at all and no rogue is gonna be happy with it. It will get like that if we carry on inviting them to the guild.

I know some rogues would leave the guild if it got that bad, why would they even wanna stay? We all play for fun and that is not fun at all it is cruel. How often are individual members going to get to go on runs like this? Once every few months like, and it would get even worse if we're not even gonna stop recruiting them. 4 more rogues into the guild, thats another 4 people our rogues have to rotate with.. - I'm sorry but thats a pee take.
If we carry on recruiting more rogues i won't leave the SSX like other rogues would i would just leave the game as i'm not prepaired to play like that and i'm not prepaired to reroll to a different class when i have been a rogue member of the SSX since the day the guild was founded. Going a bit too far maybe but as quoted, we play for fun and i don't find it fun playing a class which is already overpopulated but making it exactly the same inside our own guild, sorry.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Sat Aug 20, 2005 5:43 pm

User avatar
NightDreams
Posts: 220
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
Location: Bristol, UK
I think putting a ban on having more rogues join the ssx is not the way. As it has been said i feel that any rogues looking to join should be told about our problem.
Then it is down to them if they wish to continue with joining.
I understand the problem with having to many rogues means u guys will have to wait longer for your drops but u do have to remember if MC runs will be set at a time some people may not be able to make that time for every run or may wish to do other things some times.
When it comes down to it we will need more of each class then we would be able to take to the core anyway. As if we only have 40 lvl60s what happens when somone is not online for the night or is ill, on holiday or busy doing soemthing else in wow.
I feel we just need to be more careful on who we let join.

PostPosted: Sun Aug 21, 2005 12:49 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
SSX-MS wrote:Imagine this..

Molten Core one day per week. Think it would be fair to make our current rogue members rotate between one another to go to Molten Core just so's we can recruit more and more rogues into the guild, and for that rotation to get even bigger and bigger? Every other class like Ava has said will get to go on every single run with their friends, but the rogues are made to take it in turns on a list that is forever getting longer. - That is not fair at all and no rogue is gonna be happy with it. It will get like that if we carry on inviting them to the guild.

I know some rogues would leave the guild if it got that bad, why would they even wanna stay? We all play for fun and that is not fun at all it is cruel. How often are individual members going to get to go on runs like this? Once every few months like, and it would get even worse if we're not even gonna stop recruiting them. 4 more rogues into the guild, thats another 4 people our rogues have to rotate with.. - I'm sorry but thats a pee take.
If we carry on recruiting more rogues i won't leave the SSX like other rogues would i would just leave the game as i'm not prepaired to play like that and i'm not prepaired to reroll to a different class when i have been a rogue member of the SSX since the day the guild was founded. Going a bit too far maybe but as quoted, we play for fun and i don't find it fun playing a class which is already overpopulated but making it exactly the same inside our own guild, sorry.
Thing is if we do get the members up, we'll be able to do MC every day.
(Until we start to clear it in a day anyway heh).
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Sun Aug 21, 2005 1:10 am

User avatar
Blue Star
Posts: 227
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 12:16 am
Yahoo Messenger: theoneilluminati
Location: Bonny Dundee!
I can see both sides of the coin.

On the one hand, I can see BD's & Ed's views that barring Rogues limits who can join and goes against some of the things we stand for (although a side not that comparing it to racial profiling is a little extreme, BD!).

On the other, the fact is that taking up all the Rogues that apply isn't viable. The vast number of Rogues in the game has led to a Rogue-centric style of play (and makes me wish to see a nerf in them in the future). And considering the vast amount of class-specific (and often soulbound) items, outfitting every Rogue just ain't gonna happen - It's either that either the stuff will be split evenly and everyone will suffer as a result (bad) or the stuff ends up in the hands of a handful of people, breeding elitism (even worse).

Focusing on high-end content shouldn't be a reason for guild policy. But with the months of work that many of the Exiles have done, it is something to aim towards.

We need a cull, plain & simple. And after that, be a little more careful on who we recruit. As for Ed's point on one really cool guy, I'd agree that most we should go for is restricting rather than banning. To quote Pulp Fiction:
Vincent: Ah, so by that rationale, if a pig had a better personality, he would cease to be a filthy animal. Is that true?
Jules: Well we'd have to be talkin' about one charmin' <censored>' pig. I mean he'd have to be ten times more charmin' than that Arnold on Green Acres, you know what I'm sayin'?
An SSX member shouldn't be defined by their class, and that's on both sides - Just as much as we shouldn't necessarily differ the recruitment chances of two people because of different classes, if an applicant really wants to be with us they should be willing to switch classes if it benefits the guild (with the support of the guild throughout of course).

PostPosted: Sun Aug 21, 2005 12:08 pm

User avatar
SoulSeeker
Posts: 299
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 8:02 pm
Location: Scotland
Keep recruiting ssx material ...have 2 (two) MC raid grps :) sounds simple prob bad idea etc etc ...as for my opinion this situation could happen for any class in wow...

Contradictingmy opening sentence ...ssx wow is like a business which is growing too fast ....lets consolodate ..take stock and work with the resources and ppl we have.

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”