Palas and a mageblade??

Moderator: Global Moderators

Should palas be able to bid on the Magebalde?

Poll ended at Sun Oct 23, 2005 12:28 pm

Yes
9
35%
No
17
65%
 
Total votes: 26

Palas and a mageblade??

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 12:28 pm

User avatar
NightDreams
Posts: 220
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 11:18 am
Location: Bristol, UK
Well after some talking yesterday i would just like to ask u all vote on the following.


Palas can already bid their dkp on this
http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?witem=17105


So why should they also be able to bid on this?
http://wow.allakhazam.com/db/item.html?witem=17103

Poll last 7 days so pls vote and add ur vies on this.

ND

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 1:16 pm

Mad Hatter
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 8:06 pm
if they are allowed to bid on the mage blade, how long is it till the hunters will be bidding on nightslayer?

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 1:46 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Mad Hatter wrote:if they are allowed to bid on the mage blade, how long is it till the hunters will be bidding on nightslayer?
They wouldn't be able to since it has a Rogue requirement.
However, i wouldn't wanna see no warrior or hunter rolling on stuff like the Core hound tooth, but thats just me.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 2:42 pm

Lightforge
Posts: 105
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
Location: In your house
I'd say wait with the poll till the paladin gets a revamp.. Who knows.. We might get a few more ranged spells to justify possesion of the mageblade.. I however, have no interest in it.
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 3:16 pm

Armed
Posts: 101
Joined: Sat Jul 16, 2005 1:33 pm
SSX-MS wrote: However, i wouldn't wanna see no warrior or hunter rolling on stuff like the Core hound tooth, but thats just me.
That dagger is an offhand dagger for you and for me aswell. All the daggers in MC are the rogue loot by default? Well, that means that the ONLY decent 1h weapon in MC left for warriors is Brutality Blade(some rogues even try to claim that aswell). I see why every rogue drools over perdition blade and gutgore ripper(I would never dream of taking those away from a rogue), but why all the fuss about an offhand when I use the EXACT same stats AND use the damage? I dont think that's fair tbh.

Sorry for the whine, but I'm just sick of all the prejudice that all warriors should use a 2h or learn2play.

[Edit] Oh, and I think pallys should be able to roll in the mageblade since they actually use the same stats as every other caster in MC(and protection specced pallies would probably wield it with a shield outside MC too).
Armed - 60 NE Warrior (Outland)
Khargol - 60 Troll Shaman (Daggerspine)
Sinh - 60 NE Facemelter (Outland)
Luciuz - 60 UD mage (Neptulon)
Piltim - 51Gnome Legstabber (Outland)
Bangbang - 28 NE Hunter (Outland)

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 3:32 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, and it is my opinion that it would go to a dagger specced rogue as priority. You can't really say i'm biased because i'm a rogue because i'm not a dagger rogue anyway i'm sword spec :p - Not saying a warrior shouldn't be able to bid on it at, like if no dagger rogue needed it. But if both a dagger specced rogue wanted to bid on it and a warrior wanted to bid on it i personally think it should go to the rogue.

Anyway this thread ain't a disgussion on the CHT. We already had this discussion ingame the last time you were talking to me about it. :p
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 4:32 pm

Thoran
Posts: 54
Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2005 5:58 pm
Location: Belgium
Very interresting... I didn't vote yet

Let's see, study the 2 cases.

Why prefer the mace? for the mana regen?
Why prefer the blade? for the 1% crit = free heal?

Hypothesis
1. mana pool 5000 with blade, 4940 with mace
2. gear 9 mana regeneration per 5 second
3. illumination talents 5 (1% crit = 100% chance free heal)
4. improved blessing of wisdom talents 5 (36 mana regeneration per 5 second)
5. flash of light last rank costs 140 mp
6. 5% case chance to make a critical spell
7. never stop to cast

Mace
mana_points = mana_pool + { mana_regeneration_term + free_spells - spell_cost } * time_in_second

mana_points = mana_pool + { (mana_regeneration / 5) + [ (5* mana_cost) / (100* casting_time) ] - (mana_cost / casting_time) } * time_in_second

mana_points = 4940 + { (50 / 5) + [ (5* 140) / (100* 1.5) ] - (140 / 1.5) } * t

y = 4940 + { 10 + 4.666 - 93.333 } * t
y= 4940 - 78.667 t

How many heal i have been able to cast ?

4940 - 78.667 t = 0
t = 4940 / 78.667
t = 62.8 seconds, means 62 / 1.5 = ~ 41 flash of light spells

Blade
mana_points = mana_pool + { mana_regeneration_term + free_spells - spell_cost } * time_in_second

mana_points = mana_pool + { (mana_regeneration / 5) + [ (6* mana_cost) / (100* casting_time) ] - (mana_cost / casting_time) } * time_in_second

mana_points = 5000 + { (45 / 5) + [ (6* 140) / (100* 1.5) ] - (140 / 1.5) } * t

y = 5000 + { 9 + 5.6 - 93.333 } * t
y= 5000 - 78.733 t

How many heal i have been able to cast ?

5000 - 78.733 t = 0
t = 5000 / 78.733
t = 63.5 seconds, means 63 / 1.5 = ~ 42 flash of light spells

So the blade is better only for mana, but now for healing done: 15 bonus, 43% efficiency on flash (?) = 6.45 more hp healed per flash of light spell, in total, 270.9 more hp healed when out of mana

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 4:56 pm

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
let tier 1 set drop rate be equal.

now over 40 runs of a MC boss, assuming the same people run every time, and each boss drops 3 epics each person will come out with 3 epic set items, Which is fair.

Now where the problem lies is when there are items which are not earmarked for a certian class, in this example the mageblade. In this paper I'll write a rundown of the molten core bosses and what each class stands to gain from them

Code: Select all

Staff of Dominance (50.00)
Azuresong Mageblade (50.00)
Arcanist Robes (25.00)
Cenarion Vestments (25.00)
Giantstalker's Breastplate (25.00)
Blastershot Launcher (50.00)
Nightslayer Chestpiece (25.00)
Breastplate of Might (25.00)
Robes of Prophecy (25.00)
Felheart Robes (25.00)
Sulfuron Ingot
Lawbringer Chestguard (25.00)
Earthfury Vestments (25.00)
Aged Core Leather Gloves (15.00)
Talisman of Ephemeral Power (25.00)
Quick Strike Ring (25.00)
Obsidian Edged Blade (40.00)
Fire Runed Grimoire (30.00)
Flameguard Gauntlets (15.00)
Magma Tempered Boots (15.00)
Mana Igniting Cord (15.00)
Sabatons of the Flamewalker (15.00)
Deep Earth Spaulders (20.00)
Flamewaker Legplates (20.00)

from SSX site
Now this post is already bigger than i wanted it to be so the below value may be a little off, but it should still fit

Lets look at athe obvious drops and there values

Code: Select all

Mage: 
Arcanist Robes (25) 
Total: 25DKP

Code: Select all

Pally:
Lawbringer Chestguard (25)
Magma Tempered Boots (15) 
Total: 40 DKP

Code: Select all

Warrior
Breastplate of Might (25)
Total 25 DKP

Code: Select all

Warlock: 
Felheart Robes (25) 
Total: 25 DKP

Code: Select all

Rogue:
Nightslayer Chestpeice (25)
Total: 25 DKP

Code: Select all

Priest:
Robes of Prophecy (25)
Total: 25 DKP

Code: Select all

Druid:
Cenarion Vestments (25)
Total: 25 DKP

Code: Select all

Hunter:
Giantstalker Breastplate(25)
Blastershot Launcher(50)
Total: 75 DKP
So there we have the obvious drops from the boss. Most classes only have there set items which they can claim as their own only, there afew fluctuations but that can be expected from the random variation in bosses, now we will look at the numbers in the sort of system where you can roll if it will be of great use to your class, even if it isnt soley earmarked for your class (im leaving out the hunter weapon because it would just take the piss for a rogue to bid against a hunter for it.
To summarise at this point in the analysis its pretty fair all round and nothing to worry about.

Code: Select all

Mage: 
Staff of Dominance (50)
Azuresong Mageblade (50)
Arcanist Robes (25) 
Talisman of Ephemeral Power (25)
Fire Runed Grimore (30)
Mana Igniting Cord (15)
Total: 190DKP

Code: Select all

Pally:
Lawbringer Chestguard (25)
Magma Tempered Boots (15) 
Azuresong Mageblade (50)
Talisman of Ephemeral Power (25)
Flamewaker Legplates (20)
Obsidian Edged Blade (40)
Flameguard Gauntlets(20)
Total: 195 DKP

Code: Select all

Warrior
Breastplate of Might (25)
Obsidian Edged Blade (40)
Flameguard Gauntlets(20)
Quick Strike Ring(25)
Total 110 DKP

Code: Select all

Warlock: 
Staff of Dominance (50)
Azuresong Mageblade (50)
Felheart Robes (25) 
Talisman of Ephemeral Power (25)
Fire Runed Grimore (30)
Mana Igniting Cord (15)
Total: 190DKP

Code: Select all

Rogue:
Nightslayer Chestpeice (25)
Quick Strike Ring(25)
Aged Core Leather Gloves(15)
Total: 65 DKP

Code: Select all

Priest:
Robes of Prophecy (25)
Staff of Dominance (50)
Talisman of Ephemeral Power (25)
Fire Runed Grimore (30)
Mana Igniting Cord (15)
Total: 145DKP

Code: Select all

Druid:
Cenarion Vestments (25)
Quick Strike Ring(25)
Aged Core Leather Gloves(15) (feral)
Total: 65 DKP

Code: Select all

Hunter:
Giantstalker Breastplate(25)
Blastershot Launcher(50)
Quick Strike Ring(25)
Total: 100 DKP

Okay so the bosses have different chances of dropping things for different classes, thats normal. what we need to look at is what the implication of these numbers is.

1) With both Staff of Dominance and Azuresong Mageblade valued at 50DKP each this is a very caster heavy boss
As such Caster classes arent screwed over as much by paladins being able to roll on their items ToeP, Mageblade etc. Paladins only beat mages by 5 DKP.
Warriors however are the real losers in this matchup -- most of their items can also be rolled on by a paladin -- but there isnt an abundance of warrior only items so the value for a paladin for this boss is roughly double that of a warrior

2) Rogues seem to really lose out here, but that may be because of the lack of a high DKP-value dagger dropping , the items added to the second data set, Quick Strike Ring is shared between 3 other classes and Aged Core Leather Gloves are shared with Druids (nice feral eq. fyi) so rogues have it pretty bad, anythign with attack power, agility and strength a feral druid can roll on, and for rings/trinkets hunters and dps warriors too


Now lets do a real life example of the implications of this. lets assume we have are going to run Golemagg 40 times.

For simplicity's sake we will assume it is the same 40 raiders every time and they all start with 50DKP

Lets say the first 5 drops were very caster oriented with afew set items thrown in.

The mages, warlocks and Paladins will compete for azuresong mageblade this comepetition will drive the price up as they all spend their DKP

Ermm...... i was gonna do some maths here and try and prove that paladins shouldnt be allowed to roll on it, but from the way its going its looking like they *should* be able to roll on it so im just gonna quit while im ahead

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 4:58 pm

User avatar
base
Posts: 524
Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
Location: wales uk
I suggest making it more expensive in DKP for a paladin to get than a mage.
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 4:59 pm

User avatar
Arche
Posts: 223
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2005 8:36 pm
So what's the verdict then Thoran :D ;).

I'm not sure what to vote. The Atmosphere inside the raids are most important for me. So I'd only vote to benefit that... but I can't see which choice would be best for that.... :(

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 5:07 pm

User avatar
sam.freak
Posts: 402
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: under your desk
Thoran, you're nuts.

My math isn't good enough to understand this all, nor did I even try. (but if I did I think you forgot to factor in that crit heals heal a higher amount than normal heals, but that might be just me)

However, as the poll stands now, it doesn't look like pallies are going to be able to roll on it anyway. However: When the aurastone hammer dropped the first time, we weren't allowed to roll on it either, only druids and priests iirc. Also, on yesterdays run I had Damagemeters running, and according to this I had a crit percentage (over the entire run) of 12%.

Edit: oh, and I'm happy enough to wait for mine until all the mages and locks have got theirs.
Last edited by sam.freak on Sun Oct 16, 2005 5:11 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I loot Legendaries.

http://ctprofiles.net/1752

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 5:08 pm

Thoran
Posts: 54
Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2005 5:58 pm
Location: Belgium
To think about this made me think about:

What worths mana regeneration gear versus critical gear ? in extenso What worths critical gear ?
There is a high relationship between this and the kind of spell used.
If you use flash of light, mana regeneration will probably be better for your mana. If you use more holy light, then crit gear will prolly be better.

Formula
mana_regeneration_per_second = mana_bonus_per_second_from_free_heal
mana_regen / 5 = %_crit_total * mana_cost / casting_time

Example
flash of light last rank costs 140 mp
y = (1* 140) / (100* 1.5) = 0.933, means 0.933*5 = 4.666 mana regen gear
if talented
y = (1* 123) / (100* 1.5) = 0.82, means 4.1 mana regen
You see now that crit gear has an higher efficiency with spells wich cost more mana
For holy light last rank 580 mp
y = (1* 580) / (100* 2.5) = 2.32, means 11.6 mana regen

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 5:18 pm

Thoran
Posts: 54
Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2005 5:58 pm
Location: Belgium
Arche wrote:So what's the verdict then Thoran :D ;).
I didn't vote yet ;)

We need to think about this seriously
1. the mageblade is better than the mace for paly
2. what about dkp for each class / time req to equip all raid (we need to look more at the post of Chill) and even more all drops ? ^^
=> verdict no idea atm

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 5:38 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Am I the only one that thinks TEoP is crap for a paladin?
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Sun Oct 16, 2005 7:25 pm

User avatar
Dreamer
Posts: 139
Joined: Thu Apr 21, 2005 5:49 am
Can use, but imo is not intended to be used by. Magic damage dealers first please.

EM EM OH!
Proel

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 5:03 am

User avatar
sam.freak
Posts: 402
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: under your desk
QuantumDelta wrote:Am I the only one that thinks TEoP is crap for a paladin?
Uh, no, not alone at all. In fact I wouldn't even want it for free. I think steady > burst. I'd rather heal more over a longer time than a lot in a short time - if I do my job well I don't need that kind of "Oh Frigg" item.

Also, spell power pots are prolly cheaper. (gimme a flask of spell power for Rag next week please).
I loot Legendaries.

http://ctprofiles.net/1752

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 9:23 am

Thoran
Posts: 54
Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2005 5:58 pm
Location: Belgium
I've voted no, for 2 reasons: 1. the virtual mana regen from blade works only if you cast, not the case of the mace; 2. the blade is designed for mage/warlock (according to the name), so it must be wiser to let it to them, when enough of them will have dominance staff or blade, palys will be able to do bid (?)

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 10:04 am

firedancer
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
Location: Innsbruck, Austria
hm, some ppl allready tried to calculate a lot, so i will not add some calculations. here what is important in my opinion:


a) we should equip the guild continouisly with epics --- i.e., each class and every player.

b) so the question is: how many good weapons drop for pallies and mages in MC? how many mages and pallies participate on average on a run?

c) we have to avoid that in some future we have to disenchant some nice pally weapon, because every pally wears mage blade, while all mages still run around with Cookies fire tooth.

so here is a proposition: can a pallies list all nice pallie weapons dropping in MC with %. and the same with the mages.

/sum % pally weapon === ?
/sum % mage weapon === ?


without having these numbers i can not vote :(.

btw, any other class interested in mage blade? if yes, we have too had this class too in the calculations.


Edited: ok, i collected the good weapons for mages.

Elemental Mage staff BoE item (i personally dont like it)

Staff of Dominace drop rate 18% by golemag

Azuresong Mageblade drop rate 18% by golemag, and Fire Runed Grimoir drop rate 16 % different mobs

so in total there are 2 very nice mage weapons with in total 36% drop chance. but we have to share the blade with warlocks, dont know which class is interested in the staff too.
Last edited by firedancer on Tue Oct 18, 2005 12:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 10:53 am

PJ
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2005 9:22 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Oh dear, is this really a such a big issue? Just curious, what paladin wants this blade? Ive seen three paladins post here, neither of them interested. Then again, the paladins that want it might be scared of posting here ;)

Is this a discussion over nothing or is there some claims in paladins wanting them?

And another way to look at it, well, as some casters seems so mightily upset about this sure, let them keep their toy swords, thought this was a game about fun :thumb:

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 1:56 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
PJ wrote:Just curious, what paladin wants this blade? Ive seen three paladins post here, neither of them interested.
Thats true, which palla/s actually wants it btw? :p
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 4:58 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Aurastone for me, but to be quite honest I don't know who would want Azuresong.

Staff of Domi Pwns it so horrendously even WITH Fire Runed Grimoire...
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 7:19 pm

User avatar
Dreamer
Posts: 139
Joined: Thu Apr 21, 2005 5:49 am
SSX-MS wrote:Thats true, which palla/s actually wants it btw? :p
Looks to me like this is another one of those wow "would like to have for the sake of it" things. Something that wouldnt offend people to give away, and that has a few points of utility less would do just as well for pallys imo. The Red Party ventrilo agrees, and we forbid any capitalist paladins from bidding on said itam! ;)
Proel

PostPosted: Mon Oct 17, 2005 7:38 pm

User avatar
SoulSeeker
Posts: 299
Joined: Fri Sep 03, 2004 8:02 pm
Location: Scotland
I dont want the mageblade but ... what other weapon item will be decided for the paladin by actual non paladins.

I voted yes even tho i dont want it ....just coz its my right to roll on an item i 'might' want.

PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2005 2:46 pm

User avatar
Shoarmabob
Posts: 301
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
QuantumDelta wrote:Aurastone for me, but to be quite honest I don't know who would want Azuresong.

Staff of Domi Pwns it so horrendously even WITH Fire Runed Grimoire...
2 words: damage gear! :p

melee classes can increase their damage output by simply buying/finding a better dagger/sword/whatever.

casters do not have this luxury.

now SoD has 70 +dmg with spellpower enchant
same with azuresong, however, in AV you can get a +shadow dmg book (same with fire i think....) that gives ANOTHER +34 shadow damage.
so with SoD you have 70 +dmg in weaponslots,
with mageblade, you have 104. might not look like much but, it is xD

i voted no btw, since pala's can get aurastone, which is almost as good, while this is (imo) by FAR the best casterweapon, though SoD is arguably just as good :p

PostPosted: Tue Oct 18, 2005 3:34 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Shoarmabob wrote:
QuantumDelta wrote:Aurastone for me, but to be quite honest I don't know who would want Azuresong.

Staff of Domi Pwns it so horrendously even WITH Fire Runed Grimoire...
2 words: damage gear! :p

melee classes can increase their damage output by simply buying/finding a better dagger/sword/whatever.

casters do not have this luxury.

now SoD has 70 +dmg with spellpower enchant
same with azuresong, however, in AV you can get a +shadow dmg book (same with fire i think....) that gives ANOTHER +34 shadow damage.
so with SoD you have 70 +dmg in weaponslots,
with mageblade, you have 104. might not look like much but, it is xD

i voted no btw, since pala's can get aurastone, which is almost as good, while this is (imo) by FAR the best casterweapon, though SoD is arguably just as good :p
The best WARLOCK weapon, SoD >>> Mageblade for Mages

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”