at last..... (pala summery for 1.9)

Moderator: Global Moderators

at last..... (pala summery for 1.9)

PostPosted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 2:37 pm

User avatar
Integra
Posts: 120
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 11:58 pm
Location: Rijnsburg, Netherlands
pala's at the the toplist now. here the list off thing thay may come. i hope u find the info usefull. let 1.9 be there quick. maby some of the stuff is usefull. my pala is only lvl 15 so :p dunno much about the stuff ~~ the bookstuff looks nice like in WC3 i hope u see a pala really open the book and cast it.

We have now summarized the Paladin class concerns posted in all three European Paladin forums. The Paladin class concern summary has been forwarded to the developers, and as promised, it is now also posted here for your viewing pleasure.

If you by any chance have not read the paladin class concerns thread, then you can find it here:
http://forums-en.wow-europe.com/thread. ... #post31994

------------------------------------------------


Main Concern:

The class is considered boring to play, because people feel it is a class that is mostly suited for PvE. This may be due to the fact that Paladins do not really have a button smashing combat style like some other classes do. They cast a seal, judge, recast a seal, stun, and let combat go. Players feel that all a paladin can do is to stay alive, and not much else. They feel the class does not provide enough damage, and because of that, in addition to the heavy survival skills, the class often looses gained aggro, which often leads to attacks on cloth wearing classes.

Paladins feel that they are hated by others. Mostly because the class are considered boring to play, but also because the paladin does not do much damage, often loses aggro and is not so efficient in PvP. Other classes often think of the paladin as useless and irritating.

Paladins are so much of a hybrid class that is virtually impossible to specialise. Players feel that it is not clear what Blizzard want with the Paladin class, and as a result, players feel lost with an undefined and incomplete class.

Paladins are felt to have serious problems in diversity. Many skills are felt inappropriate in 90% of their usual situations, thus making Paladins unable to use anything else but a few seals plus the Stun.

Combat:
Low DPS.

Replace some defensive abilities with more offensive skills (more melee damage, more strength, DPS burst spells)

Remove some survivability, and replace it with specialisation skills (depending on the choices on the talent tree (either more healing, more melee damage or more spell damage)

Random/luck based DPS.

DPS is too much based on luck and players feel it is uncontrollable. Make DPS more controlled similar to the Warriors rage system, or the rogues combo system.(Maybe make seal of command add damage over time instead of chance based damage)

An additional melee move that allows the Paladin to make a high damage blow. This blow has a slow cool down before it can be used again (similar to the Hunters raptor strike, or like the Shamans earth shock)

Seals.

Change some of the seals so that they are more useful for PvP

Change some seals into strikes

Remove the seal system and replace it with an offensive damage and/or magic system

Healing.

Paladins feel that their flash heal is frustrating to use. They want it to either heal more, or be faster to use.

Ranged attack capabilities.

Currently Paladins have no option to fill the ranged-slot, ie: Throwing daggers, etc. See: *Suggestions

Buffing.

Paladins buffs are only 5 minutes which makes buffing a group quite tedious. Make the buffs last 10 minutes and double the mana cost.

Spells:
Blessing spells have too short a duration

Increase duration of the spells/buffs at the cost of additional mana.

A spell requiring a reagent that can buff a group of people at once.

Make some buffs/spells more general to remove some micromanagement. (too many different buffs/spells are considered frustrating in raids with many players)

Slowing effects:
Not good enough capabilities to stop or slow down enemies running away

Hammer of Wrath is good, but players would rather have a more efficient slowing effect that causes no damage.

Add additional ranged attack skills.

Create a skill that pulls the target to the caster.

Talents:
Talent trees do not make enough variation to the class as a whole

Make the talent trees more specialised:

- Holy specced paladins are better healers.

- Protection specced are better tanks.

- Retribution specced paladins are better fighters/damage dealers.

- Make the class feel less like a hybrid, but more as a choice of specialisation (see above)

Other suggestions:

The Paladins McDonalds gear isnt much appreciated.

Players usually prefer the old Lightforge design and demand it back.

Dwarf Paladins would like to have a Ram as Mount instead of a Horse.

Mana transfer skill to make the class a better support class for cloth wearing classes. (similar to the Shamans mana spring totem)

Different weapon skills depending on different talent trees.

More armour sets that compliment a PvP build instead of a PvE build. Also keeping in mind that there is hardly any Plate armour with +Intellect, making mana pools pretty shallow.

Paladins sometimes prefer the Warriors set instead of the Paladins set as they rely on Agility more than on Intellect. Also, Spirit is under classed in players minds, so theyd rather make more critical strikes to compensate for the poor luck based combat.

Paladins feel class sets should take players talent specialisation into account, i.e.: More intellect on Holy Paladins set, more Attack Power on Retribution Paladins set, etc.

Make spells targeted for Undeads only, to compensate for the fact that Undeads are now immune to some of the Paladins spells, making them extra dangerous for a Paladin.

A Divine light spell that blinds the enemy for 5-10 seconds plus de-selects any targeted enemies (unable to acquire new target while blinded?), similar to the flash bang effect from Counter Strike.

Ranged Slot items:
Introduce Class-specific "Ranged Slot" Items. For Paladin, for example, that would be Prayer books, (The Paladin in WarCraft III carried around a 2-Hand Hammer and a book). These could exist with different attributes, starting at level 20:

(Green) Tattered Prayer Book of the Eagle
+6 Stamina
+6 Intellect

(Green) Scarlet Prayer Book of Healing
Healing done by Spells and Effects increased by up to 25.

(Blue) Baldurs Book of Holy Light
+5 Intellect
+5 Stamina
+5 Spirit
Increases Holy Damage Done by Spells and Effects by up to 20.

(Purple) Uther's Divine Book of Prayers
+10 Intellect
+10 Stamina
Increases Healing and Damage done by Spells and Effects by up to 30.
Use: Fills you with the Divine Strength of Uther increasing your Strength by 30 for 15 Seconds. 30 minutes cooldown.

Make these books able to shoot holy damage, lower DPS than wands but fair enough for Paladins. This would solve many unable to catch up running players issues.

The developers have reviewed the paladin class concerns summary we sent them and they wanted to convey to you the general approach they will be taking, in respects to the revision paladins will be receiving in 1.9.


The developers will be looking into providing more controllable DPS for the paladin. This is a concern that is brought up by many players and the designers will look to devise methods to give paladins more options in combat and base combat damage less on "luck"

Blessing Durations have been brought up time and again. Usually it is in the context of raid dungeons, with paladins disappointed in the fact that most blessings do not have a very long duration. Once they have completed buffing the raid party, they must recast all buffs. The developers are quite concerned about making blessings more effective for a raid setting.

A large part of the paladin review should consist of adjusting the Seal/Judgment mechanics. This should touch on a number of points, such as efficiency and the "fun factor"

And, of course, no class revision would be complete without a talent review. They plan on going over these again to provide better balance for the class.

The developers will go over the class concerns summary and will possibly incorporate the suggestions as the game mechanics or time permits. Not all of the suggestions are viable, however they took interest to some of them.

In case you have not read the Paladin class concerns summary that we sent to the developers, you can read it here:

http://forums-en.wow-europe.com/thread. ... #post47062
Pierce me with swords, rend me with claw and fang. As i die a legend will be born for another generation to fallow.

Lucia -60- lock
Aeris -60- Priest
Integra -60- Hunter
Lunarcry -60- Druid
Brenda -60- Paladin
ZapDragon -Lvling- Mage

PostPosted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 5:07 pm

Lightforge
Posts: 105
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
Location: In your house
That info has been up for several weeks ;(
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|

PostPosted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 7:40 pm

User avatar
Integra
Posts: 120
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 11:58 pm
Location: Rijnsburg, Netherlands
ow lol i founded it just this morning :/ my bad i saw 10/20 on post day so thought it was today
Pierce me with swords, rend me with claw and fang. As i die a legend will be born for another generation to fallow.

Lucia -60- lock
Aeris -60- Priest
Integra -60- Hunter
Lunarcry -60- Druid
Brenda -60- Paladin
ZapDragon -Lvling- Mage

PostPosted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 8:58 pm

Lightforge
Posts: 105
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
Location: In your house
No worries! Us paladins will get our satisfaction soon enough!!!

...

I hope!
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 1:01 am

User avatar
Integra
Posts: 120
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 11:58 pm
Location: Rijnsburg, Netherlands
untill then 1 big mac plz. and extra fries.
Pierce me with swords, rend me with claw and fang. As i die a legend will be born for another generation to fallow.

Lucia -60- lock
Aeris -60- Priest
Integra -60- Hunter
Lunarcry -60- Druid
Brenda -60- Paladin
ZapDragon -Lvling- Mage

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 10:12 am

The Baron
Posts: 124
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:58 pm
Location: SSX CMU OMGWTFBBQ
Summary of the original post:

"PALAS ARE NOT UBER ENOUGH LIKE THEY WERE IN WC3 FIX PLZ KTHXBAI"

Paladins are not an offensive class. Period! Stop complaining about DPS! You're a defensive buff/emergency tank class! That's the intended role! Do priests suck in PvP because they can't kill anything? More specialization? This is nuts! Absolutely insane! YOU'RE DEFENSIVE BUFFERS!

Lordy. I want to post the Learn 2 Play thing so badly...

Oh, and:
Dwarf Paladins would like to have a Ram as Mount instead of a Horse.
And if I had a Gnome warlock instead of a human warlock, I'd want a Felmechanostrider. But you don't see me complaining, do you?

"Set bonuses based on talent builds?" :smack:

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 12:10 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
The Baron wrote:Summary of the original post:

"PALAS ARE NOT UBER ENOUGH LIKE THEY WERE IN WC3 FIX PLZ KTHXBAI"

Paladins are not an offensive class. Period! Stop complaining about DPS! You're a defensive buff/emergency tank class! That's the intended role! Do priests suck in PvP because they can't kill anything? More specialization? This is nuts! Absolutely insane! YOU'RE DEFENSIVE BUFFERS!

Lordy. I want to post the Learn 2 Play thing so badly...

Oh, and:
Dwarf Paladins would like to have a Ram as Mount instead of a Horse.
And if I had a Gnome warlock instead of a human warlock, I'd want a Felmechanostrider. But you don't see me complaining, do you?

"Set bonuses based on talent builds?" :smack:
Die -.-
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 3:45 pm

User avatar
base
Posts: 524
Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
Location: wales uk
Good luck

I'm still waiting for them to evaluate the druid class based on our concerns and concern summery.
Second on our list was lack of equipment, quests and specific epic weapons.

If they think a low % drop on one of the hardest outdoor dragon raid bosses is enough for the druids, they are quite mistaken.
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 8:06 pm

The Baron
Posts: 124
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:58 pm
Location: SSX CMU OMGWTFBBQ
QuantumDelta wrote:Die -.-
Are you saying I'm wrong? Cause... I'm not. Palas are not Warriors, which is what all the tanking stuff implies. Palas are not Priests, which some of the healing stuff implies. Palas are not Rogues, which all the DPS complaints imply. Palas are Palas, and they are priest/warrior hybrids with a focus on defensive capabilities. Not ubertanks, not healing monsters, not DPS masters.

The comments about "survivability?" That's the entire point of Paladins. They are supposed to increase the chances of the entire party to survive, whether it's through a bit of emergency tanking, basic healing, or buffs. I agree that Blessings need to last longer, simply because it sucks for parties (and everybody always forgets to put Blessing of Wisdom back on). But talent trees not offering enough variation? I mean, let's see what I can do as a 'lock:

Affliction: A few useful curse improvements. Nothing huge. Can't really be used as a main talent tree effectively.

Demonology: Useful skills later on, like master demonologist, and fel stamina is awesome. Soul Link is pretty uber. But once you get to raids, the effectiveness of this build decreases considerably (or so I've heard from my Warlock buddy who is half-Felheart half-Nemesis equipped).

Destruction: Ruin. It's not nerfed. 'Nough said.

I got retooled in... 1.7? I still don't have epic weapons, a tier 2 epic set that doesn't suck, or anything like that. I still don't have "variation" between my talent trees. They're still primarily focused on curses, bonuses to pets, and bonuses to my ranged attack skills. What my skills do is focus on my class's intention, which is master debuffer and secondary ranged DPS fellow.

PostPosted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 10:11 pm

Lightforge
Posts: 105
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
Location: In your house
The Baron wrote:Blah blah blah
Blizzard wrote:Class Role
Paladins are the consummate knights in shining armor, meant to be in the thick of things. Their defensive abilities allow them to stand toe to toe with monsters and take a beating - they are tanks overall. This is not the sole purpose of a Paladin, of course; their auras, seals, heals and resurrection spells give them the chance to act as a support healer. We're not telling you how to play the game- one of the fascinating practices of this genre is the ingenuity exercised by the players every day!
And neither should you. ;(
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|

PostPosted: Sat Oct 22, 2005 3:11 am

User avatar
sam.freak
Posts: 402
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: under your desk
The Baron wrote: Are you saying I'm wrong? Cause... I'm not. Palas are not Warriors, which is what all the tanking stuff implies. Palas are not Priests, which some of the healing stuff implies. Palas are not Rogues, which all the DPS complaints imply. Palas are Palas, and they are priest/warrior hybrids with a focus on defensive capabilities. Not ubertanks, not healing monsters, not DPS masters.

The comments about "survivability?" That's the entire point of Paladins. They are supposed to increase the chances of the entire party to survive, whether it's through a bit of emergency tanking, basic healing, or buffs.
Have you ever played a paladin? Probably not, judging from your post.

What you write there is all pretty nice and all, but you're totally without a clue about the capabilities of a paladin.

Yes, I can outdamage mages and possibly even rogues, however, only in UD instances.

Yes, I can outheal priests in UBRS. This is quite dependant on gear, and I'm mostly running around in cloth then.

Yes, I can hold aggro indefinitely in a small group with JoFury and consecration.

However:

I'm not grouped 24/7.

I'd like to have a (solo) PvP fight that doesn't take ages.

I usually do about 200 dps with a frickin EPIC 59 dps 2-hander when I'm fighting against non-UD mobs. My warrior friend does slightly less than that at level 39 with a one-hander.

We've got talents like Holy Strength - but that talent is in the holy tree, which is supposed to make us better healers.

We have exactly 2 offensive, direct damage spells, Hammer of wrath and Consecration. HoW I'm pretty happy with, and it solved a couple problems I had when playing solo, but the only use for consecration is to keep hostiles from bandaging and to root out hidden ones. It places a debuff on the unit, so you can only stack it up to 16 times (since 1.8). Highly useless when raiding in PvE and a joke in PvP. Our other offensive spells and some of our seals don't work in PvP (see Exorcism, Turn Undead and SoJustice).

Blizz made a great class with the paladin that suffers from a great drawback, we can't use it as we want to. We're handicapped by arbitrary restrictions that hold us back, whether they be itemization issues (which has certainly improved with the new gear they introduced with the latest patch), skill or talent issues.

I suggest you might want to try actually READ what you're responding to.
I loot Legendaries.

http://ctprofiles.net/1752

PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2005 12:30 am

User avatar
Alderik
Posts: 85
Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 5:33 am
Location: Sweden
I'm just gonna be simple, I'v played every class exept hunter at lvl 60, all trees ect ect.

HYBRIDS CLASS!!!11one!

(Class Basic?)
Druids, Shamans, Paladins.
ALL FREAKING HYBRIDS! And that's basic, all of them can be used to do ANYTHING they feel like, even a shaman can be tank when Enchantment specced...

(Instance's)
Paladins ARE a very GEAR BASED CLASS, and so are the other hybrid's too, but pala's are at the top. In instance's they just need to use other gear to be good at another thing. Druids Shapeshifts. (Shammys make's a lollipop with frost shock...)

(PvP)
Druid's and Paladin's can win most battles no? (I won't even mention shammys...) Well, it's often about SKILLS and smart's in playing you'r class. Pala whining about dps? Get goblin Engineering and you got a fine boost, or use the seal's in a smart order to get +holy dmg? Druid just Bind, shapeshift, run, nuke, nuke, run, bind, nuke? Often anyway, but that's player's choice as a Druid can be Balanced or Feral to basicly kill some leaper gnome a**

BASICLY, it's all about the skills of the player.
Doubt me? I'll post a freaking link backing most of my stuff by blizzard Normal info! :P
<< swe >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>

PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2005 12:34 am

User avatar
Alderik
Posts: 85
Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 5:33 am
Location: Sweden
/mad-mad mode off?

just got a little mad about some ppl that just make claims they know some class, and when you acculy have read the blizzard NORMAL (freaking) Info about the class, its prolly way off. so just BROWSE AND LEARN! :smack:

/ending
<< swe >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>

PostPosted: Mon Oct 24, 2005 1:08 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Baron;

60.
Skill.
Eq.
Experience.
A Paladin at 60.

All on PvP Server please.

Then bow out like you should.

Nothing wrong with being a defencive class, I love that kinda role and I signed on for what a Paladin actually is HOWEVER: The fact that Paladins have (realistically) only one correct way to fight every fight, which makes them SO TERRIBLY Predictable in HIGH END AND SKILLED PvP We can never win because our opponent controls 200% of what we do.

The only EVEN SLIGHT exception to this is the engineer Paladin, because he has a few other options, but even then, they can easily be countered by a similar: engineer.

The fact that I WTFPWN 95% of Bladefist is really cool.

The problem that I GETWTFPWNT by anyone AT my skill and equipment level (READ: NOT ABOVE) = SUCK.

Almost every class in the frickin game can Dictate when and where a paladin will activate an ability once they've learnt them well enough.

The only one that cannot (Still....) is druids.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”