Lo all you great peeps,
I just have to say this, I don't think the raid invites are handled the right way right now. People do not know wether they will get an invite or not and many might/will be dissapointed or even angry when they are not.
Incidents have been seen in the guild chat before and tonight it happened to me. Of course I didn't make a big deal out of it in the guild chat and I'm not gonna sit here and point fingers but I believe we do need to find a solution to this problem (yes I fermly believe this to be a huge problem).
I blew off a party that I actually would have loved to be at, BUT I wanted to down Rag with you guys even more, so I blew it off. And then I don't get invited... I even wait for 2 hours (QD is late), then talk to him and wait another 45 min, only to then find out, the raid is going without me.
Anyone who can maybe understand how I felt? Again I'm not blaming anyone I'm just saying this can't be this way!
Ok, suggestion for a solution:
- Everyone who wants to go on a raid run (wichever it might be) needs to post on the forums (special Raid thread), telling that they want and can join!
- That has to be done min 3 days before the raid
- The day after (2 days before Raid) a list will appear with the 40 names that will be in the raid
- These 40 peeps HAVE to be there (I think minus DKP if you're not there) becasue you said you would be there!
- The others, NOT on the list, know that they can still get an invite by being online (if one of the original 40 doesn't show up), BUT they don't count on it !!
- This way no one can get mad last minute AND this hole thing can actually be planed better in advance I believe...
I really do want to point out again that I think a "punishment" should be set up for people that say they want to go and then they don't show, because it is just not friendship to take someones "place" in the raid and then not even show...
Looking forward to oppinions about this...
// Ice
Raid invites - leave as it is?
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
Ice
- Posts: 43
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2005 1:30 am
- Location: Sweden
Winners never quit, quitters never win!
-
Tickle
- Posts: 52
- Joined: Mon Sep 26, 2005 10:40 am
- Location: Sweden
My brothers guild (Proeliatoris) uses sign up on forums system. 2-3 days before raid starts leader create a thread with topic (for example) MC friday 30/8. And then people simple just reply the thread with /sign and leader puts them up on a list.
But i got no problems with the way we got it now, i mean if we should use the "sign on the forums" system it could be unfair, i mean the ones who signs first gets spots. Maybe you are on football training when the sign thread starts and when you come home they dont need anymore of your class.
as i said i got no problems tbh with the way we have it now, if invite starts at 20:00 i log on atleast 30 mins before invite starts (if im not already online
) and i just wait. If i dont get invite i do something else, if i get invite i play!
But i got no problems with the way we got it now, i mean if we should use the "sign on the forums" system it could be unfair, i mean the ones who signs first gets spots. Maybe you are on football training when the sign thread starts and when you come home they dont need anymore of your class.
as i said i got no problems tbh with the way we have it now, if invite starts at 20:00 i log on atleast 30 mins before invite starts (if im not already online
How can you not love a gnome?
-
Lightforge
- Posts: 105
- Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 12:19 pm
- Location: In your house
Furthermore, we are 2 guilds who goes together ;(
In GoE this topic is also argued about all the time. Due to the requirements and limited amount of players that can be in the instance Id say that the invites can never be 100% fair.
In GoE this topic is also argued about all the time. Due to the requirements and limited amount of players that can be in the instance Id say that the invites can never be 100% fair.
No.. I didn't know about the set when I made the character! :|
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Your absolutely right!
What you dont know is, that we mods thought about some kind of signup for quite a long time. The latest incidents however prove your point & i find a solution for this problem needs to be stressed.
I kinda like your idea of ppl posting if they will be available (or better when they are not available) & the raidorganisers can put a functional raid together out of this pool. --> the pool wont be too big, since there arent many ppl who havent been invited to MC by now... but the point to KNOW if your going to be invited rather than sitting there for HOURS (no joke), along with the raids beeing set up faster & the invites beeing more transparent is valid!
- edit -
not a first come first serve basis
responsible raidorganisers are always needed to put a working raid together
What you dont know is, that we mods thought about some kind of signup for quite a long time. The latest incidents however prove your point & i find a solution for this problem needs to be stressed.
I kinda like your idea of ppl posting if they will be available (or better when they are not available) & the raidorganisers can put a functional raid together out of this pool. --> the pool wont be too big, since there arent many ppl who havent been invited to MC by now... but the point to KNOW if your going to be invited rather than sitting there for HOURS (no joke), along with the raids beeing set up faster & the invites beeing more transparent is valid!
- edit -
not a first come first serve basis
responsible raidorganisers are always needed to put a working raid together
-
Ice
- Posts: 43
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2005 1:30 am
- Location: Sweden
As Sofia pointed out, I didn't mean "who signs first, comes first"
We all know almost a week ahead wich Raids are going to be and that way you will have several days to sign up for it. Then out of all the ppl that are signed the Raid leader(s) choose whoever is to come...
And I really don't know about the rest of you, but I sure sometimes do wonder on wich parameters the choices are made. What does it take to get and invite, or better why choose someone over someone else...
I mean I won't be chosen over Illandria or Thoran (ever I believe) and that is fine with me, but I do wonder what it takes to get the invites. Be a preferred by QD? Or what be a good player? And who decides that... and so on...
I for once thing just love the big raids, they are the main reason for me to continue the game. To play as a team with 40 others, where 1 misstake can whipe the hole lot... I think that is exiting. Now if I feel that way and I want to go on every raid (wich some people always will) then I need to know what it takes to become one of the people that gets an invite. See what I mean?
And please don't tell me now that SSX is not about being a core player, it's all about the friendship, because I do think so TOO !! I do not want to climb the ranks, get famous or anything like that, I just want to do what I like the most in this game... (Hope I don't get missunderstood on this)
We all know almost a week ahead wich Raids are going to be and that way you will have several days to sign up for it. Then out of all the ppl that are signed the Raid leader(s) choose whoever is to come...
And I really don't know about the rest of you, but I sure sometimes do wonder on wich parameters the choices are made. What does it take to get and invite, or better why choose someone over someone else...
I mean I won't be chosen over Illandria or Thoran (ever I believe) and that is fine with me, but I do wonder what it takes to get the invites. Be a preferred by QD? Or what be a good player? And who decides that... and so on...
I for once thing just love the big raids, they are the main reason for me to continue the game. To play as a team with 40 others, where 1 misstake can whipe the hole lot... I think that is exiting. Now if I feel that way and I want to go on every raid (wich some people always will) then I need to know what it takes to become one of the people that gets an invite. See what I mean?
And please don't tell me now that SSX is not about being a core player, it's all about the friendship, because I do think so TOO !! I do not want to climb the ranks, get famous or anything like that, I just want to do what I like the most in this game... (Hope I don't get missunderstood on this)
Winners never quit, quitters never win!
-
Chill
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
decent of you to post on the forums and not make a fuss in any case. im dont feel to strongly about the way it is atm ... but then ive never really been "stung" by not getting an invite.
Id have no problem with a signup on forums system, i check the forums several times a day.
Id have no problem with a signup on forums system, i check the forums several times a day.
-
Sofia
- Posts: 536
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
The raids are put together in order to kill the bosses. This implies a certain number of certain classes with the proper gear, skill & EXPERIENCE.
However, its not like we have an infinite number of players like bots to serve the raid. Quite the opposite infact... we can put a standard raid together who kicks ass, but are running short on encounters like ragnaros, because we dont have enough well geared / skilled / experienced players of a specific class.
Thus we ARE trying to bring newblood on every raid, in order to get those ppl insight / experience & gear ofc.
- edit -
One thing though, remember that we worked hard to come to this point & the core has been lv60 for several months, prepairing the raids & working on the guild environment to keep it as the ssx we know & at the same time to prepair the guild for those encounters we are taking on now. There has been much effort behind all this & several ppl literally worked their ass off. Keep that in mind when your asked to sit back for a week.
- edit again -
why not put a list up afaik & if someone cant come, either post it or point it out ingame... replacement is done, tata
Wouldnt want to have all this too firm, because you can always make an agreement or something ingame.
However, its not like we have an infinite number of players like bots to serve the raid. Quite the opposite infact... we can put a standard raid together who kicks ass, but are running short on encounters like ragnaros, because we dont have enough well geared / skilled / experienced players of a specific class.
Thus we ARE trying to bring newblood on every raid, in order to get those ppl insight / experience & gear ofc.
- edit -
One thing though, remember that we worked hard to come to this point & the core has been lv60 for several months, prepairing the raids & working on the guild environment to keep it as the ssx we know & at the same time to prepair the guild for those encounters we are taking on now. There has been much effort behind all this & several ppl literally worked their ass off. Keep that in mind when your asked to sit back for a week.
- edit again -
why not put a list up afaik & if someone cant come, either post it or point it out ingame... replacement is done, tata
Wouldnt want to have all this too firm, because you can always make an agreement or something ingame.
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
Okay, so say we do signups on the forums. That doesn't change the fact that there will still be more people online at raid times than what we need, and all of them will most likely wanna come. You can't guarentee people a place on a raid, theres only a few people we always take if we can because we "need them, as i keep saying.
Tbh, whether this thread has a point or not, i'm just fed up of the general whining from people when they don't get on a raid. Nothing personal to you ice. At this time i'm not gonna post anything longer because i am slightly pissed off at everything right now, sorry.
Tbh, whether this thread has a point or not, i'm just fed up of the general whining from people when they don't get on a raid. Nothing personal to you ice. At this time i'm not gonna post anything longer because i am slightly pissed off at everything right now, sorry.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Ice
- Posts: 43
- Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2005 1:30 am
- Location: Sweden
I can understand you very well MS, you and many others have, as Sofia said, put an enormous amount of effort behind this and I really wish to thank you and the others for that!
I don't take your post personal either, but I think you did missunderstand the point of my post... I'm not whining about not getting invited, what I want to change is the fact that I spent 3 hours waiting for an invite that never came... Also QD, you knew I wanted to go since yesterday, why not /w me and say we have no space for you? Why not say ANYTHING at all, but I have to see on the guild page that you all are in MC? Anyways, if I knew like yesterday that I wouldn't be invited, then no problem, I had gone to my party, or done other group stuff or whatever.
So not being invited is not really the point of this thread, but how can we make it easier for people to plan their lives? MS, again you have done a terrific job (with the others) and know I admire you for it, but as you said it yourself, you're tired of the "bitching around" about the invites...
= Doesn't that tell you we might have to change something? It can't be like this every week-end, and as we grow this will get worse..
That's the only reason I brought this up, take a problem by the horns when it appears, not when it gets out of hand...
I don't take your post personal either, but I think you did missunderstand the point of my post... I'm not whining about not getting invited, what I want to change is the fact that I spent 3 hours waiting for an invite that never came... Also QD, you knew I wanted to go since yesterday, why not /w me and say we have no space for you? Why not say ANYTHING at all, but I have to see on the guild page that you all are in MC? Anyways, if I knew like yesterday that I wouldn't be invited, then no problem, I had gone to my party, or done other group stuff or whatever.
So not being invited is not really the point of this thread, but how can we make it easier for people to plan their lives? MS, again you have done a terrific job (with the others) and know I admire you for it, but as you said it yourself, you're tired of the "bitching around" about the invites...
= Doesn't that tell you we might have to change something? It can't be like this every week-end, and as we grow this will get worse..
That's the only reason I brought this up, take a problem by the horns when it appears, not when it gets out of hand...
Winners never quit, quitters never win!
-
Chill
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
Yeah ive got Ice's back on this. It sucked that he didnt get invited and he quietly made a well thought out - not whiney - constructive post on the forums, and that should be commended
-
Dodotorpedo
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
hmmmmz... for example:
Post 1:
QD: Friday: Luci till Golemag, 17GMT
Saturday: Majordomo/Ragnaros, 15GMT
post 2:
Guyz0r: Priest: available friday/saturday (66 fire res)
Post 3:
Guyz0r2: Druid available Friday
Post4:
somewoneelsez0r: Mage available Saturday (98 fire res)
If you sign up for Satyrday you should show your fire resistance imho
Post 5:
QD: Friday group will consist of: (list)
Saturday group will consist of: (list)
Easyer said then done though, Planning the entire raid from this far before it starts could be hard I geuss, I like Ice his idea though, not that I'm really unsatisfied with the invites as they are goign now but it probably sucks to as Ice said, cancel a party to come and then not be allowed to.
Post 1:
QD: Friday: Luci till Golemag, 17GMT
Saturday: Majordomo/Ragnaros, 15GMT
post 2:
Guyz0r: Priest: available friday/saturday (66 fire res)
Post 3:
Guyz0r2: Druid available Friday
Post4:
somewoneelsez0r: Mage available Saturday (98 fire res)
If you sign up for Satyrday you should show your fire resistance imho
Post 5:
QD: Friday group will consist of: (list)
Saturday group will consist of: (list)
Easyer said then done though, Planning the entire raid from this far before it starts could be hard I geuss, I like Ice his idea though, not that I'm really unsatisfied with the invites as they are goign now but it probably sucks to as Ice said, cancel a party to come and then not be allowed to.
-
Magdalena
- Posts: 571
- Joined: Sat Jul 30, 2005 5:59 pm
- Location: Mannoroth, USA
I'm on Mannoroth so you guys definitely won't get much comment on whether choices are right or wrong as I'm not there to see it. However, something the leaders might want to look into that might make their jobs a LOT easier is a mod called guild event manager. I haven't tested this latest version yet, however it wouldn't do you any good if I did since I'm not on an EU server. What the previous version we worked with did:
Allowed the raid leader to set up an event everyone can get to, set up how many people can join, the min and max of each class, etc.
Everyone can go to the UI and sign up for the events, if there is already enough of their class, they are notified they will be on a 'standby' in case someone of their class drops before the raid etc. They can also remove themselves ahead of time if something comes up.
At the time of the raid, the person that set the event up can send invites to those that made the raid at the touch of one button.
It can be used by two guilds or more that are in an alliance since it creates its own channel to work off of (you can password this channel).
Here would be my suggestion on how to use it. Leaders pick a channel and password at the begining of each week. Tell those you really need more what it is on say Monday and have them sign up first. Then on Tuesday post it as your message of the day for everyone else. Just a suggestion, go by whatever time frame you wish just have it known what this time frame will be.
Here is the link for the latest version to test out and see how you like it...
http://www.wowguru.com/ui/guild-event-manager/
Hope this helps you guys out.
Magdalena
60 Warrior - Mannoroth (US)
Here would be my suggestion on how to use it. Leaders pick a channel and password at the begining of each week. Tell those you really need more what it is on say Monday and have them sign up first. Then on Tuesday post it as your message of the day for everyone else. Just a suggestion, go by whatever time frame you wish just have it known what this time frame will be.
Here is the link for the latest version to test out and see how you like it...
http://www.wowguru.com/ui/guild-event-manager/
Hope this helps you guys out.
Magdalena
60 Warrior - Mannoroth (US)
-
Dodotorpedo
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
That system is first come first serve though... that's not very fair imho. In you tuesday example I'd be pretty screwed since I'm home late on tuesday xD.Magdalena wrote:I'm on Mannoroth so you guys definitely won't get much comment on whether choices are right or wrong as I'm not there to see it. However, something the leaders might want to look into that might make their jobs a LOT easier is a mod called guild event manager. I haven't tested this latest version yet, however it wouldn't do you any good if I did since I'm not on an EU server. What the previous version we worked with did:
Allowed the raid leader to set up an event everyone can get to, set up how many people can join, the min and max of each class, etc.
Everyone can go to the UI and sign up for the events, if there is already enough of their class, they are notified they will be on a 'standby' in case someone of their class drops before the raid etc. They can also remove themselves ahead of time if something comes up.
At the time of the raid, the person that set the event up can send invites to those that made the raid at the touch of one button.
It can be used by two guilds or more that are in an alliance since it creates its own channel to work off of (you can password this channel).
Here would be my suggestion on how to use it. Leaders pick a channel and password at the begining of each week. Tell those you really need more what it is on say Monday and have them sign up first. Then on Tuesday post it as your message of the day for everyone else. Just a suggestion, go by whatever time frame you wish just have it known what this time frame will be.
Here is the link for the latest version to test out and see how you like it...
http://www.wowguru.com/ui/guild-event-manager/
Hope this helps you guys out.
Magdalena
60 Warrior - Mannoroth (US)
-
Chill
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
i have THE BEST idea for signups
we all go to the explorers hall in IF... and whoever shouts the loudest and spams the much gets an invite, and we stand there until the raid group is full. simple!
we all go to the explorers hall in IF... and whoever shouts the loudest and spams the much gets an invite, and we stand there until the raid group is full. simple!
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
Sorry about my previous whiny post on here, this issue is summin that the moderators are going to be discussing when we have a meeting this week. 
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
