DKP worries

Moderator: Global Moderators

DKP worries

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:09 pm

User avatar
Shoarmabob
Posts: 301
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
as the title says, I (and some others)am a little worried by the DKP system we currently use, not as much the system itself as the amount of DKP we get:

if we down razorgore, after an enitre night of playing (should go faster now, but still) we get 10 DKP ( 7 for the kill, 1 for attendance, 1 for being on time and one for staying through the end)

however, on a full MC run, we get 35 DKP (9*3 for bosses +5 for rag, +1 for attendance +1 for being on time +1 for staying through the end)

also, you might've noticed that there are about 3* the amount of people for MC than for BWL, because MC is on farm, and BWL is actually hard for us. each week, MCers will get 35 DKP, and BWLers will get 10 DKP (more if we down Vael, still not 35), meaning that when BWL is on farm (for the largest part anyways) the people who farmed MC for DKP will go BWL and outbid the people who actually WORKED for the epics. do you call it fair? because i dont :)

my proposition woulde be: heavily decrease both MC DKP gotten and the prices of MC items, so you can still use DKP gotten in MC for BWL, but you won't outbid BWLers very soon.

last, I'd like to say this post was not intended as a whine, i just wanted to bring this to your attention, and i'd like to hear your views :)
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:19 pm

User avatar
SSX-Ava
Posts: 691
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
Location: Yorkshire, UK
I wasnt aware there were bwl'ers and mc'ers

arent we all the same? pretty much.

infact there are very small differences in the people who attend both.
also the fact that we pretty much no longer raid with goe will reduce the amount of people that attend mc.


and if there were mc'ers wouldnt they have alot of tier 1 by now, stopping them bidding on a tier 2 piece if someone who hasnt got the tier 1 piece drops? :confused:

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:38 pm

User avatar
Shoarmabob
Posts: 301
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
with MC'ers i mean the people who farm MC
with BWL'ers i mean the people who do BWL, trying to figure the encounters out, basicly going through a lot of trouble to progress

also, you have to notice that we have problems filling up a raid for BWL, yet no troubles AT ALL with filling a MC raid, the difference is there. also there are people who do MC for DKP and wait with BWL untill we can farm it to claim ze goods, and tier1 aint great for casters (imo), i myself am going for random epics for the largest part of my equip, the epics anyone can bid on.
many things like weapons and rings are also not tier1, and FR equip, etc
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:51 pm

User avatar
Xelrash
Posts: 124
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 7:34 pm
Location: Holland
I agree with what Bob has to say, additionally I'm not able to play during the week and thus not able to gain the large amount of DKP other people doing MC get, I still have only a few epics and would love to have more tier 1 pieces so it would be great for somewone like me to have MC on a Sunday or something instead of during the week just once in a while.
It takes an army to kill a paladin.
It takes an army of paladins to kill anything..

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:56 pm

User avatar
SSX-Ava
Posts: 691
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
Location: Yorkshire, UK
Xelrash wrote:I agree with what Bob has to say, additionally I'm not able to play during the week and thus not able to gain the large amount of DKP other people doing MC get, I still have only a few epics and would love to have more tier 1 pieces so it would be great for somewone like me to have MC on a Sunday or something instead of during the week just once in a while.



http://www.shatteredstar.org/ssx/forums ... php?t=2633

:)

PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:57 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
SSX-Ava wrote:I wasnt aware there were bwl'ers and mc'ers

arent we all the same? pretty much.
You seem to misunderstand father, you see MC is planned during weekdays thus some people including Bob here, can only do the BWL runs (witch are worth few or on many runs no DKP) and not the MC runs (DKP madness!). Bob however does high-end instances 2 days a week, but doesn't even get half of what other people would get if they only played once a week. Some players may be able to come ot both thus gaining 45 DKP a week, bob however only gains 10 DKP a week and he only does 1 run less each week.
SSX-Ava wrote: and if there were mc'ers wouldnt they have alot of tier 1 by now, stopping them bidding on a tier 2 piece if someone who hasnt got the tier 1 piece drops? :confused:
Yeah if you'd go for sets... but sets suck for casters (or well IMO and Bob's opinion that is) real good epix are free for bid for everyone out there, also if your doing MC it doesn't mean you HAVE to bid on tier 1 epix. if the mage sets were good, I wouldn't get any arcanist I'd save my DKP for Netherwind instead. Why spend DKP on an epic you plan to replace as soon as soon as you get the chance? just a waste of DKP.

There is a different system I am thinking off. It would be very fair but too difficult to do (simply way too hard xP). So I'm not gonna bother posting it here xP.

Imagine you're working your ass off every week to progress in BWL and then you only get half of the epix somewone else is getting even though he was on less BWl runs then you becouse he's also doing MC during weekdays witch is worth 3 times as much... So he could get 3 times asmuch epics as you get.

Hope I cleared that up a bit xP

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:08 am

User avatar
Sondemon
Posts: 403
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Ok, first of all I want to say I'm almost dead atm, so friggin tired. But I have a few thoughts about this, hope I can make some amount of sense anyway.

You say ppl farm MC for DKP to spend in BWL, I say, if ppl who have say full might gear do NOT go to MC, or ppl who feel they have more or less everything they need from MC, ppl like that. If none of those go to MC, how the hell (sorry bout the language, adding some power into what I'm saying here..) will we manage in MC? Sure it'll take more for us to focus etc, but seriously, I like the way it is. And those ppl with the nice shiny gear already should get something for comming and helping the rest of us experience the game!
I was under the impression SSX was a guild for friendship, not a raidguild, saying something like "OMGWTF?! He gets teh more DKP then me!!!111" is in my opinion stepping on the line to becomming a lootwhore, sure I say I want eq too, I don't deny that but I enjoy raiding because we bring 35-40 ppl together, and work together, unite ourselves for a greater cause!

Earlier in my days of WoW, playing a horde on Warsong and after migration at Neptulon, I was in a guild which became a pure raiding guild. They have a system for BWL, they got DKP bonuses for helping out to come up with a system that worked to take down the bosses, and those who were there when the boss first went down got a nice little DKP bonus. Not a ton of it but still, it was a token of appriciation. I'm not 101% sure but I think they used some sort of 'time spent raiding' dkp system aswell.

One idea that popped up in my head right away is pretty stupid actually, probably reuires tons of extra job but still, it's an idea. One could go for seperate DKP's, one pool for MC, and one for BWL.
Not sure how that would work, I'm just tired and get nutty ideas atm..

Moving on..

Again, in my opinion, should we only raid on weekends, there will be others who won't be able to play, dunno what everyone is in the guild, but someone or some may have kids to take care of (Was like that when I played horde), or they have work on weekends.
And if we wanna do Onyxia, MC and BWL all in the weekends so everyone who work in the week can be there, we're gonna run into a few problems. First of all, what happens to those that don't get a spot in the raid? Who chooses who can go and not? Who will be the judge of that? And then we have the time issue, I reckon if we start our usual Ony / MC on the saturday, we're gonna start at say 3pm CET(!!Works for me anyway >.<), and we'll be done at like what, 8pm, add an hours break for dinner somwhere in there aswell, so say 9pm. Some ppl might wanna go out and take a drink or do whatever, I'd say the raiding stops there. And we spend all sunday doing BWL. And soon AQ will open, are we gonna random raid it like ZG when we manage to plow through BWL like we do with MC? (Still very tired and that last part doesn't really makes sense to me so keep that in mind when you comment on this..)

Last but not least, there will ALWAYS (afaik) be someone who doesn't like the system, imo this should be all about friendship, the ppl come first and the loot comes later. You're not gonna be able to come up with a flawless system, someone is bound to dislike some part of it, it'd be near impossible to satisfy everyone.

I'm gonna end it here before I get too far off the subject..
But I wanna say it a few more times, whine about DKP = lootwhore? Looks a bit like it to me actually =/ And those who do question it, I really don't dislike you, and I fully understand that you want in on the action aswell, but I wouldn't like all the raiding to be on weekends, I like it the way it is, ok we could cut down on the hours, set a cap at like 2am CET or something..

'Nuff said, g'night!

Sondemon//Chalan
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!

"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:24 am

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
Bob is totally right, ive known this for a while but have been exploiting it :P ... now you go and spoil all my ez DKP bob :)

and, as ive said before: the only fair system is for DKP to be based on the time spent raiding
Last edited by Chill on Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:36 am

Sanne
In my opinion, just use 2 different DKP systems for MC and BWL.

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:41 am

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
Sanne wrote:In my opinion, just use 2 different DKP systems for MC and BWL.
unfair: people who have worked there arse of in MC can just get ownage epics from BWL for none of the work


(edit:premptive response, no, maybe in big guilds but we dont have enough members for it to work like that)
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 4:54 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Anyone who attends MC who refuses to attend BWL should, in my personal oppinion, be banned, from MC, and probably ZG too.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 5:29 am

Armed
Posts: 101
Joined: Sat Jul 16, 2005 1:33 pm
QuantumDelta wrote:Anyone who attends MC who refuses to attend BWL should, in my personal oppinion, be banned, from MC, and probably ZG too.
I agree, this is something the guild itself should be able to control somewhat. It's the same if someone refuses to join BWL/onyxia/MC just to go AV/AB(if we need them). It's just plain greedy to not come to BWL cause of repair costs and potentially no loot.
Armed - 60 NE Warrior (Outland)
Khargol - 60 Troll Shaman (Daggerspine)
Sinh - 60 NE Facemelter (Outland)
Luciuz - 60 UD mage (Neptulon)
Piltim - 51Gnome Legstabber (Outland)
Bangbang - 28 NE Hunter (Outland)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 6:28 am

User avatar
Alderik
Posts: 85
Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 5:33 am
Location: Sweden
speaking of ZG... when are we doing it next? ^_^

oh, had some point about ZG too =) Not alota ppl think its worth spending time there cuz the no dkp gain... so why not give a little dkp for the run but still NOT allowing dkp use inside ZG anyway. No need for very much dkp just like 1 dkp for boss kill, 1 for raiding ect. That way alota ppl whould wanna come and we can really begin calling it a farm for good items and maybe some small amount of dkp? (just a thought ^_^ )

anyway... WHO DOSENT WANNA DO BWL RAISE THEIR HANDS!? *aims water gun* I mean c'mon! bwl is so exiting those who dont like it is mental! (no offence xD)
<< swe >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 8:42 am

User avatar
Shoarmabob
Posts: 301
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
Sondemon wrote: But I wanna say it a few more times, whine about DKP = lootwhore? Looks a bit like it to me actually =/ And those who do question it, I really don't dislike you, and I fully understand that you want in on the action aswell, but I wouldn't like all the raiding to be on weekends, I like it the way it is, ok we could cut down on the hours, set a cap at like 2am CET or something..

'Nuff said, g'night!

Sondemon//Chalan
I cant really respond in a large post as i have to go to school in a moment, but first of all: you can like the loot, the progress and the guild at the same time. I love SSX and i would stay here even if we stopped raiding. i LOVE making progress in BWL, because it's new and the encounters are new and hard! but i'd also like to get some ZOMGEPIX for my hard work and repaircosts doing RG or vael or whatever, but as it is now, people doing MC get more DKP (spendable IN BWL aswell) than those who do all the work. IMHO that's not really fair now is it ;p

and ehm, i never said anything about weekday raiding sweetie :)
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 9:06 am

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
For my part:

1. I love working on hard encounters, thats where i have most fun ingame, always has been & always will be. And i pitty everyone who misses out on this, because once the place is on farm... it will never be as exciting.

2. I have no problem to pass on loot in favor of a guildie. Try to talk it out with the mates of your class, who wants which drops & what is top priority. It benefits the raid anyway, thats part of the teamplay.

Lootwhore, as there seem to be some confusion = someone who claims everything even over the friends he plays with - no communication, shaking his fist out of envy, no teamplayer

There is nothing wrong in the sole wish to improve his char, with patience & communication you can sort this out without the need of dkp AT ALL.

Wishful thinking i know.

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 9:34 am

User avatar
Unimatrixx
Posts: 141
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 2:51 am
Location: Zeeland
I'm not able to join often too, but i think you should care less about minor raid attendence as we(ssx) can't maintain everybody's demands. It just ain't possible to make the perfect schedule to make everybody happy.

Dkp things are fine the way they are atm, changing it will make problems in the future or cause conflicts with other people. But disagreeing with you will automaticlly make me or other look epic horny.. The post and replies of this thread gave me a flashback of a month ago when we took the raid brake.

//Just woken up, grammar might suck.

+ Who doesnt like BWL ? I mean, its way more fun that MC nowadays.
Assumption is the mother of all f*ckups.

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 11:18 am

firedancer
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
Location: Innsbruck, Austria
to be honest:

did you all become insane. this is the most stupid post i have read in a long time. first i agree with Sondemon, that what we are talking here is epic greed. and i am shocked to see how ppl in guild have allready become so greedy.

first bob you are completely illogical: if ppl go for MC and do not join in BWL, how can they ever bid on a drop in BWL?

second: many ppl enjoy having MC raids, as they dont have so much time. for example, i could only attend one BWL raid, as i had to work hard, but managed to attened some MC runs, as they are quick and during weekdays. so stop INSULT ppl who have also a RL, and cant attend BWL raids.

third: if you only play BWL for epics you probably should better stop playing.

fourth: i would even say that ppl doing MC should get more DPK. because a lot of the players really dont need anything from MC anymore, but do run there for fun and for helping the other not so well equiped guild mates. i appreciate this a lot and it should also be rewarded.

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:37 pm

User avatar
saMaN
Posts: 72
Joined: Wed Aug 24, 2005 7:17 pm
Location: Devon uk
I think bob has a point, for example myself and dodo having done MC from the start have reasonable gear and so pass on the majority of Mage drops in MC. While some of the other mages (clarice, galador) who have only just recently started raiding with us tend to roll on loot in MC. Therefore there dkp will, as it is now, always be in the negative even when we progress through bwl.

I think perhaps some of the tier 1 stuff's dkp should be lowered.
(mage tier 1 stuff is crappy neway)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 12:50 pm

User avatar
Drongnel
Posts: 283
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2005 7:35 pm
Location: near Brighton
I think it is totally unfair to call the people on this post loot whore's & what-not, they have a fair point, lets put it in really basic terms.....

MC = easy & fairly stress free run, lots of dkp, very few death's so cheap repairs & even some cash off of some of the boss's.....tbh i nearly always finish up in the cash after repairs, also apart from rag you can get away using the combat mana & healing pots from the hall of champions (cheap & only need knight to get) whereas in BWL you really need the decent pots & need specialist kit & enchants (speed enchant on boots, nifty stopwatch, rocket boots etc for hunters in the raz fight & i imagine there are similar things for other class's).... &
fourth: i would even say that ppl doing MC should get more DPK. because a lot of the players really dont need anything from MC anymore
This makes no sense to me as i would think that (& from my experience) the people in BWL are going to be mainly the same people who have been running MC for longest, what it come's down to is people running MC over BWL get much more for their time & some unscrupulous people may seek to take advantage of this, not to say there solutions are right or even if there is a easy solution but i do not feel it's fair to flame them (Also please note that as the fellowship is no more Im not gonna get much raid chances either way & would like to consider myself impartial here)
'I Thought what i'd do is i'd pretend to be one of those deaf-mutes'

Drongnel 60 Dorf hunter (Miner/Engineer)
Ank 38 Gnome mage (Engineer/Tailor)
Dinkl 38 Gnome rogue (Skinner/Leatherworker)
Tamburlaine 22 Dorf Pally (Miner/Blacksmith)
Fayed 20 Nelf Drood (Enchanter/Skinner)

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 1:10 pm

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
firedancer wrote:to be honest:
first bob you are completely illogical: if ppl go for MC and do not join in BWL, how can they ever bid on a drop in BWL?
case study:
Jim goes to MC/Ony and gets 40 dkp
Dan goes to razorgore 3 nights in a row, wiping every night, assuming DKP for merit -- he scores 30 DKP

the next day Jim and Dan go BWL, kill Razorgore and [Untamed Blade] Drops.

Jim, having spent one night, 6 hours, raiding, bids his 40dkp
Dan. having spent three nights, twenty hours raiding, bids his 30dkp

Jim Wins.
Jim beats Dan to a razorgore-only drop, that he has been working his arse off to get, because Jim did one night in MC.

You see the problem?
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 1:31 pm

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
Chill wrote:
firedancer wrote:to be honest:
first bob you are completely illogical: if ppl go for MC and do not join in BWL, how can they ever bid on a drop in BWL?
case study:
Jim goes to MC/Ony and gets 40 dkp
Dan goes to razorgore 3 nights in a row, wiping every night, assuming DKP for merit -- he scores 30 DKP

the next day Jim and Dan go BWL, kill Razorgore and [Untamed Blade] Drops.

Jim, having spent one night, 6 hours, raiding, bids his 40dkp
Dan. having spent three nights, twenty hours raiding, bids his 30dkp

Jim Wins.
Jim beats Dan to a razorgore-only drop, that he has been working his arse off to get, because Jim did one night in MC.

You see the problem?
Yea, I see a problem.


With your post.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 3:14 pm

User avatar
Meline
Posts: 130
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
Location: Stockholm/Sweden
I think things are just fine as they are now. I mean HOW can you NOT want to do bwl?
BWL=where teamwork and individual skill really matters. It is a challenge. For me repair cost does not matter. I had nearly 15g repair costs the last RG attempts, but the feeling after we downed him beats those crappy 15g by far. Now the only pieces I can get from trancendance are the robe and the shoulders (due to the epic over epic rule). Do I stop doing bwl for that? No. I run bwl simply because I want a challenge and not the ordinary MC walk in the park :rolleyes:

We could give a first kill bonus for every boss in bwl. I know that in union they gave 20dkp for every first kill and they have a dkp system quite similar with ours. That would motivate some ppl to go for bwl, but really I don't see anyone in the guild NOT wanting to go bwl. All have been there when they are needed. :thumb:

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 4:26 pm

User avatar
Shoarmabob
Posts: 301
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 3:08 pm
Location: Haarlem, Netherlands
firedancer wrote:to be honest:

did you all become insane. this is the most stupid post i have read in a long time. first i agree with Sondemon, that what we are talking here is epic greed. and i am shocked to see how ppl in guild have allready become so greedy.

first bob you are completely illogical: if ppl go for MC and do not join in BWL, how can they ever bid on a drop in BWL?

second: many ppl enjoy having MC raids, as they dont have so much time. for example, i could only attend one BWL raid, as i had to work hard, but managed to attened some MC runs, as they are quick and during weekdays. so stop INSULT ppl who have also a RL, and cant attend BWL raids.

third: if you only play BWL for epics you probably should better stop playing.

fourth: i would even say that ppl doing MC should get more DPK. because a lot of the players really dont need anything from MC anymore, but do run there for fun and for helping the other not so well equiped guild mates. i appreciate this a lot and it should also be rewarded.
hmkay: first point: if you have gone on BWL runs lately, you might've noticed there aren't as much people willing to go BWL as there are people willing to go MC. Now it might have something to do with RL, there are probably people who indeed cant come to BWL, but there are also people who just won't come, dunno why, maybe they like MC better than BWL, or MAYBE, just MAYBE they dont want to spend 10g+ on repairs while gaining nothing from it., or maybe some other reason, i dont know!

second point: i WAS NEVER EVER insulting people in my post okay? i hate insulting people, especially when they are MY FRIENDS (_everyone_ in SSX is my friend) the post was about the DKP system that allows people to do MC for the DKP, and then when BWL is on farm, use that DKP TO OVEBID those who worked for BWL. also, if you cant come in the weekends (BWL) then my solution won't hurt you, now will it?

3rd point: i play BWL for the progress we make, for the bosses we defeat after the hard work (it's the greatest feeling in WoW for me), for being and playing with the ones i like, my friends, and yes, for epics. who of you can look me in the face and tell me they farm MC every single week, for no items or DKP? the only people i can think of are ava, who's just needed, QD who is also (sort of) needed, and MS because he's a great guy. there might be more dont feel offended if i didn't name you. sure you might do it for fun (so do I, when i get the chance) however, it does get boring sometimes, when the lockchannel is quiet, when I'm tired, sure I'm helping my guildies with it, but i'd like atleast SOME reward for my effort i have no problems helping my guildies through a 2 hour UBRS run, but a 9 hour MC run is a little too far for me, call me an egoistic idiot if you like, thats just li'l me's opinion.
what's wrong with wanting loot?
nothing
it's not wrong until people want it SO MUCH that they start to snap at their friends, scream at raidleaders for not inviting them, never helping anyone because they only care about epics.

4th point: sure they help the lesser equipped guildies, true, but I've been at the last couple of BWL raids, some lasted untill 3:00 AM (CET) which is VERY late (for me) we tried and tried and tried some more and FINALLY we got razorgore (i wasnt there, it was too late for me). RG costed me hours of my time, a lot of gold in preparation and repairs, farming time for soulshards. what You're saying is that because people that help their guildies in MC, they should be better rewarded than those who help their guild in BWL?
you're right about one thing though, the people who do MC to help their guildies, people like ava and QD, they should be rewarded for their efforts, thats why i asked for your views. to make my plan better, or to remove it or whatever, i just wanted to hear you opinions about my idea

also, you tell me to stop insulting those who have a life (where did i do that btw?), yet you call me an idiot for posting this.
i asked for views about my idea, because i thought it wasn't fair, but the way it looks now, if you just open your mouth about ANYTHING endgame, it makes you a "lootwhore" a "no-lifer" an idiot "a selfish bad guildy" that's the message i got from some of your posts, and, i must say I'm dissappointed, i thought this forum was for posting ideas and issues, but if this is what happens when i do it, then i'll just shut up next time...

it was just an idea, QD's idea would also be good imo, or meline's idea of DKP.

EDIT:
firedancer wrote: first i agree with Sondemon, that what we are talking here is epic greed.
sorry to disappoint you, i have quite enough epics at the moment (I'm wearing 5 of them if I'm not mistaken) it's not only ME we're talking about, its not like I'm the only person who can't come to MC, this is about fairness of the DKP system we use...
do you call it fair to work hard and get less "pay" than someone who basically is able to sleep through MC and just press one or two different buttons in the whole run?
sure the problem has to do with epics, but that doesn't mean I'm "zomgteh elitist epixwhore zomg" it means i detected a little (IMO) flaw in the plan, and wanted to see what you people thought of it.
i dont have enough DKP to bid on a lot of items anyway, most people have more DKP than me, and those people also do BWL, i just don't like the idea of someone who hasn't been to BWL once getting on one of our farmruns and claiming items from people who worked hard for the progress we made, understand where I'm coming from?

i don't know who you are, firedancer, but you hurt me with your post, and i think you misunderstood my original post entirely...

-a hurt bob :(
Last edited by Shoarmabob on Sat Jan 21, 2006 12:30 pm, edited 2 times in total.
is it a bird?
is it a plane?
NO!
IT'S SUPERBOB! HERE TO SAVE THE DAY

PostPosted: Fri Jan 20, 2006 4:30 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
I see many people here are saying: Why would people farm only MC over BWl they should get kicked anyway blablabla. I don't know any people that farm only MC for mass DKP and that is IMO not the problem at all.
The problem is for those people who can't raid during weekdays, but work their asses whenever they get a chance to raid, should be getting 2/3 of the DKP is they're doing 2 out of the three runs, instead of 1/4th DKP or sometimes even 0 DKP like now. This is the only problem IMO. Myself? I am able to attend to about 30% of the weekly MC raids (that is if you stay till 4 to pwn rag oO) otherwise I can stay longer maby even 100% like this week. I already got a very large stack of DKP saved up and by the time I've run through it we'll prolly have half of BWL on farm status anyway so I'll be gaining lots of DKP there so it really is no problem to me at all, however think about the example I just gave, the people who for example only have about 20 DKP right now and can't do MC and get hardly any reward for their effords.
Sondemon wrote: You say ppl farm MC for DKP to spend in BWL, I say, if ppl who have say full might gear do NOT go to MC, or ppl who feel they have more or less everything they need from MC, ppl like that. If none of those go to MC, how the hell (sorry bout the language, adding some power into what I'm saying here..) will we manage in MC?
I am one of those people who pretty much have all their epix from MC, yet still I attended to the raids that didn'' get us any DKP, why? becouse I LOVE raiding with you guys, even though MC does grow old after a while it is mostly the fact that 40 people get together thats the best part + the lock and mage channel get busy with some fun chatty and interesting discussions xP. Something we can afford to do on these casual easy runs but not on BWL runs, thus I'll never stop doing MC even if it's worth 0 DKP.
Sofia wrote: 1. I love working on hard encounters, thats where i have most fun ingame, always has been & always will be. And i pitty everyone who misses out on this, because once the place is on farm... it will never be as exciting.
I completely agree, why get more epix? why improve your character? (accept for PVP xP) to be able to work together and down new bosses ofc! (or atleast for me xP).
If all bosses were suddenly on farm and easy to do it'd just be the same as MC is now, but MC = casual day. BWL = some action. Whats fun in WoW without some action? :(.
Firedancer wrote: to be honest:

did you all become insane. this is the most stupid post i have read in a long time. first i agree with Sondemon, that what we are talking here is epic greed. and i am shocked to see how ppl in guild have allready become so greedy.

first bob you are completely illogical: if ppl go for MC and do not join in BWL, how can they ever bid on a drop in BWL?
First of all, let's not flame the OP and stay constructive okay? :/

Bob said and I quote:
Shoarmabob wrote:also, you might've noticed that there are about 3* the amount of people for MC than for BWL, because MC is on farm, and BWL is actually hard for us. each week, MCers will get 35 DKP, and BWLers will get 10 DKP (more if we down Vael, still not 35), meaning that when BWL is on farm (for the largest part anyways) the people who farmed MC for DKP will go BWL and outbid the people who actually WORKED for the epics. do you call it fair? because i dont Smile


Thats how people who did MC will be bidding on drops in BWL.
Firedancer wrote: fourth: i would even say that ppl doing MC should get more DPK. because a lot of the players really dont need anything from MC anymore, but do run there for fun and for helping the other not so well equiped guild mates. i appreciate this a lot and it should also be rewarded.
This is simply impossible, based on the simple idea of economy. If we do this we'd be handing out more DKP then is being spent, thus everyone will end up with enough DKP to max bid items far more often and MC/BWL will become mostly just rolling for epix.

See:

If we kill Lucifron for example, the raid will gain a total of 120 DKP.
2 items will drop, often with around a base value of minus 25.
Thus every lucifron kill 120 DKP is gained and 50 to 100 DKP is lost.

The input of DKP should remain to about averagely between min and max bid of the items to make sure the 'dkp economy' remains stable. As you see here more DKP is gained form Lucifron then spent but that is often made up by the high DKP prices items from Golemag/Domo/Rag, BoE epix and the occasional third epic on an average 2 epic bosskill.

As I said before, it hardly matters to me as a person and I don't really care, but I do care about the people that hardly gain anything through this.

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”