is epic over epic rule outdated?
Moderator: Global Moderators
-
firedancer
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
- Location: Innsbruck, Austria
i know that recently the epic over epic rule has caused a lot of discussion. so i would like to rise this question in the forum whether this rule is still necessary. to start with let me remind why this rule is introduced at all:
- the epic over epic rule should guarantee that the guild gets continously well equiped, and not a few ppl collecting all good drops. this rule was introduced in a time where hardly anyone had some epics.
today, the situation has completely changed. most ppl raiding with us since the begining have more epics than they can wear in a single MC run, and a lot of tier 1 items become dissed as no one is biding for it.
on the other hand ppl which just raid with us for a few weeks, get very quick well equiped in MC and they dont need to rely on the epic over epic rule to get some equipement. (note for these ppl it is very hard to get out of negative dkp as there are so many drops)
so in my opinion the epic over epic rule is outdated today, and we should make a reasonable discussion whether we want to keep up this rule.
especially, i think it would be very fair to some long time SSX raiders in the guild: they helped a lot getting us through MC and they are the driving force pushing us through BWL. however these ppl, can hardly expect good drops from BWL due to the epic over epic rule.
i would propose to first have a bit discussion, and after some time a moderator sets up a poll with the following questions:
- epic over epic rule is outdated and lets get rid of it
- only drops in BWL are not subject to epic over epic rule, while drops from onyxia and rag still are.
- epic over epic rule is NOT outdated and should still be keep up
- i want to keep up epic over epic rule, as i personally get an advantage out of it.
Finally, we are supposed to be a guild of friends. so lets remove this rule and replace it with the behavior how friends behave with each other: with respect, dignity, and joy if someone gets a good drop.
PS: i am aware that i do have now nearly full set of arcanist, and I would profit from dropping the epic over epic rule. however, i promise that if this rule drops i will not roll on any tier 2 set for the few months to show that it is not personal greed why i want to change the rule.
- the epic over epic rule should guarantee that the guild gets continously well equiped, and not a few ppl collecting all good drops. this rule was introduced in a time where hardly anyone had some epics.
today, the situation has completely changed. most ppl raiding with us since the begining have more epics than they can wear in a single MC run, and a lot of tier 1 items become dissed as no one is biding for it.
on the other hand ppl which just raid with us for a few weeks, get very quick well equiped in MC and they dont need to rely on the epic over epic rule to get some equipement. (note for these ppl it is very hard to get out of negative dkp as there are so many drops)
so in my opinion the epic over epic rule is outdated today, and we should make a reasonable discussion whether we want to keep up this rule.
especially, i think it would be very fair to some long time SSX raiders in the guild: they helped a lot getting us through MC and they are the driving force pushing us through BWL. however these ppl, can hardly expect good drops from BWL due to the epic over epic rule.
i would propose to first have a bit discussion, and after some time a moderator sets up a poll with the following questions:
- epic over epic rule is outdated and lets get rid of it
- only drops in BWL are not subject to epic over epic rule, while drops from onyxia and rag still are.
- epic over epic rule is NOT outdated and should still be keep up
- i want to keep up epic over epic rule, as i personally get an advantage out of it.
Finally, we are supposed to be a guild of friends. so lets remove this rule and replace it with the behavior how friends behave with each other: with respect, dignity, and joy if someone gets a good drop.
PS: i am aware that i do have now nearly full set of arcanist, and I would profit from dropping the epic over epic rule. however, i promise that if this rule drops i will not roll on any tier 2 set for the few months to show that it is not personal greed why i want to change the rule.
-
Galador
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
- Location: Malta
There are pros and cons for this rule as with every other rule I guess.
The pros are obvious - intended mainly to avoid the creation of 2 distinct groups - the hardcore best geared raiders and the poorly equipped less frequent raiders. A distinction that would not benefit the guild at large as that would make the guild heavily dependant on the availability of a specific group of people online as opposed to having a larger and more homogenised equipped group.
The cons are as firedancer described above - still maybe dissing a tier 1 and getting from time to time some Nexus Crystals (so needed for high enchants and so costly on AH) wouldn't be that bad! :-)
I am open for both ways tbh though I think keeping the rule for now would be fairer for those that skipped bidding on some tier 1 and waited and are still waiting for tier 2. Maybe we could consider keeping the rule or altering it by giving a penalty DKP to those who have tier 1 and bid on tier 2 such that players can still bid epic over epic whilst keeping the poorly equipped at a slight advanatge.
e.g. Player A has Arcanist Belt. Netherwind Belt drops. Player B doesn't have Arcanist Belt. Both A and B can bid but A will have say a -5 or -10DKP penalty malus to favour B's bid and A will only win the item if he is ready to invest extra DKP (which A as a hardcore raider can afford to spend but B probably can't).
Might be complex to put into practice but its sort of a balance between keeping the rule and abandoning it.
Just some of my thoughts. What do you think?
The pros are obvious - intended mainly to avoid the creation of 2 distinct groups - the hardcore best geared raiders and the poorly equipped less frequent raiders. A distinction that would not benefit the guild at large as that would make the guild heavily dependant on the availability of a specific group of people online as opposed to having a larger and more homogenised equipped group.
The cons are as firedancer described above - still maybe dissing a tier 1 and getting from time to time some Nexus Crystals (so needed for high enchants and so costly on AH) wouldn't be that bad! :-)
I am open for both ways tbh though I think keeping the rule for now would be fairer for those that skipped bidding on some tier 1 and waited and are still waiting for tier 2. Maybe we could consider keeping the rule or altering it by giving a penalty DKP to those who have tier 1 and bid on tier 2 such that players can still bid epic over epic whilst keeping the poorly equipped at a slight advanatge.
e.g. Player A has Arcanist Belt. Netherwind Belt drops. Player B doesn't have Arcanist Belt. Both A and B can bid but A will have say a -5 or -10DKP penalty malus to favour B's bid and A will only win the item if he is ready to invest extra DKP (which A as a hardcore raider can afford to spend but B probably can't).
Might be complex to put into practice but its sort of a balance between keeping the rule and abandoning it.
Just some of my thoughts. What do you think?
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
think maybe the removal of the rule is in order now we are progressing through bwl, it served its purpose in mc/ony but i cant see it working very fairly in bwl Oo.
maybe a removal or an alteration to the rules is in order
-- a shot in the dark here, but the rule was set up so not 1 person could get heavily geared up over another but wont that happen to the people who dont have tier 1? they will be walking around in bloodfang whilst the people who have helped us progress from the very begining are in nightslayer
seems a little odd to me -.-
maybe a removal or an alteration to the rules is in order
-- a shot in the dark here, but the rule was set up so not 1 person could get heavily geared up over another but wont that happen to the people who dont have tier 1? they will be walking around in bloodfang whilst the people who have helped us progress from the very begining are in nightslayer
-
base
- Posts: 524
- Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
- Location: wales uk
Have to agree with Ava on this one, I'm not greedy, but this rule is starting to not make sense now.
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace
InvadeSpace
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I agree, i think its time we removed it completely.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
sam.freak
- Posts: 402
- Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
- Location: under your desk
Seconded.
I still wanna see QD in full judgement first, but the next set will be mine
I still wanna see QD in full judgement first, but the next set will be mine
-
Meline
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
- Location: Stockholm/Sweden
Completely agree with ava. I wrote my thoughts on the other thread I started before I could see this onea shot in the dark here, but the rule was set up so not 1 person could get heavily geared up over another but wont that happen to the people who dont have tier 1? they will be walking around in bloodfang whilst the people who have helped us progress from the very begining are in nightslayer seems a little odd to me -.-
And gala: The people who saved for the tier 2 sets HAVE dkp and if they don't then they havn't been on raids which leads to no tier 2. Simple
The rule has served it's purpose but if we keep it longer it will just hurt us.
-
Dodotorpedo
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Tier 2 epics are expensive for a reason. It wouldn't be very fair if the hardcore raiders would get all the epics becouse they simply always have more DKP. Currently however we get this problem:
Say Rogue A and Rogue B are on the same BWL raid and Bloodfang bracers drop (40 dkp min)
Rogue A, the mega-active rogue already got the nightslayer bracers so can't bid
Rogue B has 7 DKP becouse he was on one Onyxia runs ones, he gets the bracers for min bid and gets set back to -33 DKP.
Next boss:
Rogue A, the mega-active rogue already for Nightslayer belt while Rogue B doesn't, Rogue B currently stands on -33 DKP but now he ALSO gets the belt for min bid, witch puts him too -73 DKP.
This can go on forever if the other active rogues already have full nightslayer, but now we drop the rule and lets see:
Rogue A has 300 DKP for being very damn active, he already has the tier 1 bracers and the next bracers drop.
Rogue B only has 7 DKP from an ony run. Fair enough the other rogue should get it.
Some time passes.
Rogue B, the casual rogue has been on a fair few MC/BWl runs and has gained 50 DKP. Bloodfang Belt drops.
Rogue A simply bids 80 DKP, wins the belt, Rogue B gets nothing.
Next drop, Rogue A max bids again B gets nothing. Eventually Rogue B will FINALLY be able to catch up with rogue A and max bid 1 item, after that he's back to 0.
Dropping this will simply end up getting lots and lots of epics to 1 person.
My suggestion:
We keep the DKP system, but you can only get an item by epic over epic rule if you have the min bid for it. So at situation 1 Rogue A would still get the bracers he deserves, but Rogue B won't have such a hard time catching up to him.
Lemme know what you think about my suggestion, I serieusly think this could solve our problems atm.
Oh and before you think 'daeron has mucho dkp and no arcanist he just wants neth min bid!' (witch you shouldn't be thinking couse I'll cry ;'( ) Just so you know, I'm only interested in 2 netherwind pieces atm anyway, and I don't really care if they'd cost 40 DKP more.
I don't care if you drop the rule, but it would be unfair to those of us who can't attend to every raid and max out DKP. I hope my idea would solve that problem
Think it over, I hope this would be a good sollution for both active and unactive raiders.
Thank you for your time :P
Say Rogue A and Rogue B are on the same BWL raid and Bloodfang bracers drop (40 dkp min)
Rogue A, the mega-active rogue already got the nightslayer bracers so can't bid
Rogue B has 7 DKP becouse he was on one Onyxia runs ones, he gets the bracers for min bid and gets set back to -33 DKP.
Next boss:
Rogue A, the mega-active rogue already for Nightslayer belt while Rogue B doesn't, Rogue B currently stands on -33 DKP but now he ALSO gets the belt for min bid, witch puts him too -73 DKP.
This can go on forever if the other active rogues already have full nightslayer, but now we drop the rule and lets see:
Rogue A has 300 DKP for being very damn active, he already has the tier 1 bracers and the next bracers drop.
Rogue B only has 7 DKP from an ony run. Fair enough the other rogue should get it.
Some time passes.
Rogue B, the casual rogue has been on a fair few MC/BWl runs and has gained 50 DKP. Bloodfang Belt drops.
Rogue A simply bids 80 DKP, wins the belt, Rogue B gets nothing.
Next drop, Rogue A max bids again B gets nothing. Eventually Rogue B will FINALLY be able to catch up with rogue A and max bid 1 item, after that he's back to 0.
Dropping this will simply end up getting lots and lots of epics to 1 person.
My suggestion:
We keep the DKP system, but you can only get an item by epic over epic rule if you have the min bid for it. So at situation 1 Rogue A would still get the bracers he deserves, but Rogue B won't have such a hard time catching up to him.
Lemme know what you think about my suggestion, I serieusly think this could solve our problems atm.
Oh and before you think 'daeron has mucho dkp and no arcanist he just wants neth min bid!' (witch you shouldn't be thinking couse I'll cry ;'( ) Just so you know, I'm only interested in 2 netherwind pieces atm anyway, and I don't really care if they'd cost 40 DKP more.
I don't care if you drop the rule, but it would be unfair to those of us who can't attend to every raid and max out DKP. I hope my idea would solve that problem
Think it over, I hope this would be a good sollution for both active and unactive raiders.
Thank you for your time :P
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
Sounds fine to me dodo.Dodotorpedo wrote:Say Rogue A and Rogue B are on the same BWL raid and Bloodfang bracers drop (40 dkp min)
Rogue A, the mega-active rogue already got the nightslayer bracers so can't bid
Rogue B has 7 DKP becouse he was on one Onyxia runs ones, he gets the bracers for min bid and gets set back to -33 DKP.
My suggestion:
We keep the DKP system, but you can only get an item by epic over epic rule if you have the min bid for it. So at situation 1 Rogue A would still get the bracers he deserves, but Rogue B won't have such a hard time catching up to him.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Scorpius
- Posts: 673
- Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 12:19 pm
- Location: Ass End of the Universe
You could also use common sense, Oh wait....... 
Power Corrupts, Ultimate Power is Fun.
-
firedancer
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
- Location: Innsbruck, Austria
just a short reply to Daeron: the casual rogue can allways get tier 1 items to a low amount of dkp. but i agree he will have a hard time to get tier 2. but on the other hand if he is a casual raider, should he get equally amount of tier 2 as the hard core raider?
go back 6 months in time, when we started MC, and compare it with now. maybe in 6 months time, the same happens with bwl and the tier 2 set will be dissed. so essentially it means, ppl which want to have tier 2 now, have to pay a lot of dkp, but the "casual rogue" will also get his tier 2, he just has to wait a bit longer.
maybe i am wrong, but well equiped means for me good items. you see daeron at yourself, that you have a lot of non-epic, which you think are better then epic items. in my opinion it is now possible for every one to go to MC and get well equiped. the rule may guarante that casual players get tier 2, but i dont think the rule is necessary to get the guild well equpied. (edited)
go back 6 months in time, when we started MC, and compare it with now. maybe in 6 months time, the same happens with bwl and the tier 2 set will be dissed. so essentially it means, ppl which want to have tier 2 now, have to pay a lot of dkp, but the "casual rogue" will also get his tier 2, he just has to wait a bit longer.
maybe i am wrong, but well equiped means for me good items. you see daeron at yourself, that you have a lot of non-epic, which you think are better then epic items. in my opinion it is now possible for every one to go to MC and get well equiped. the rule may guarante that casual players get tier 2, but i dont think the rule is necessary to get the guild well equpied. (edited)
Last edited by firedancer on Fri Feb 03, 2006 5:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Alderik
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 5:33 am
- Location: Sweden
I dont think we should entierly "remove" this rule, just make it better and change it so that we are all happy, like addjusting it to bwl ect :]
And I think we should make some rule about weapons also tbh :| donno tho, but like a guy with epic weapon and much dkp gets another epic thats like 10dmg more, rather then a guy with low dkp but blue weapons? :| That whould annoy me even more than losing every set piece in-game tbh, weapons are also important ya know o_O like not making the "epic over epic rule" but there has to be SOME bounderies regarding weapon bids imo. o_o
And I think we should make some rule about weapons also tbh :| donno tho, but like a guy with epic weapon and much dkp gets another epic thats like 10dmg more, rather then a guy with low dkp but blue weapons? :| That whould annoy me even more than losing every set piece in-game tbh, weapons are also important ya know o_O like not making the "epic over epic rule" but there has to be SOME bounderies regarding weapon bids imo. o_o
<< swe >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
Alderik wrote:And I think we should make some rule about weapons also tbh :| donno tho, but like a guy with epic weapon and much dkp gets another epic thats like 10dmg more, rather then a guy with low dkp but blue weapons? :| That whould annoy me even more than losing every set piece in-game tbh, weapons are also important ya know o_O like not making the "epic over epic rule" but there has to be SOME bounderies regarding weapon bids imo. o_o
we tried this at the very begining but there WERE so many complications and arguments aka tickle.... :|
and it will just create the same problem as we are having now. a long time raider cant get a epic 2h in bwl cos he got one months ago in mc.
it would be for the best to just leave weapons/rings/necks/trinkets/not set pieces out of epic over epic.
and imo drop epic over epic on set pieces also -.-
-
Riccko
- Posts: 398
- Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 10:36 am
- Location: MSN ssxbimbo@hotmail.com
It would be nice to have an epic, to epic over epic with as i dont often getthink maybe the removal of the rule is in order now we are progressing through bwl, it served its purpose in mc/ony
the chance to get any.
would that also mean reinstating noti if he wanted re-aply
I am of the opinion that my life belongs to this community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to do for it whatever I can.
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
notinou regardless of the pants wasnt right for us, it wasnt just 1 thing that led to him being kicked.
(and i said it served its purpose in mc/ony, times have moved on since then)
Hes happy in nulli, its perfect for what he plays for.
(and i said it served its purpose in mc/ony, times have moved on since then)
Hes happy in nulli, its perfect for what he plays for.
Last edited by SSX-Ava on Fri Feb 03, 2006 5:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Sondemon
- Posts: 403
- Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 2:20 am
- Location: Stockholm, Sweden
Imo, this won't be an issue really, not that big of a one anyway. I have raided for one month now, I've gotten 7 MC drops, 5 cenarion set pieces. All for relativly low bids, nothing much over min bid. If I didn't buy the two non-cenarion, I could have had the full set now with the DKP I have (I have roughly 90 dkp atm). So I have attended maybe 90% of the raids since I started raiding. But say if a new whatever class comes along, he starts raiding MC and Ony, can only attend 50% of the raids, 1-2 months till he gets full tier1 set isn't that bad, now is it? (If the items should drop that is) Just my thought about the first post, moving on..(note for these ppl it is very hard to get out of negative dkp as there are so many drops)
What Galador thinkgs about the penalty is not a good idea, I just don't like it. There are much better ways to sort this out.
Ava has a point with his shot in the dark, I don't say we should put all gear on a few ppl, but we can't forget those ppl who put time and effort into the guild, who take time from their irl life (if they have any :P) to help out during raids (like last night when we downed Vaelastrasz and yelled on ppl to get on their mains and get their arses to BWL).
Dodo writes that one should have to have atleast enough DKP to minbid for an tier2 to get it through epic over epic rule, good thought, might work, I like it. I don't get what you wanna say tho, with the examples under "some time passes", if the rogue that plays hardcore and always attends raids wants to maxbid the tier2 items, let him for gods sake. He spends his DKP and in that speed he will soon be out of DKP thus being on the same lvl as the casual player. And this hardcore rogue, he plays alot, spends time in BWL gaining experience, shouldn't he then get something for it? Imo the casual player should try to attend mostly mc first and gear up there, getting cheap tier1 items..
I know we have many of some classes, and few of some, and for some reason, us few druids, seem to get all the loot (keep hearing ppl making comments on it over vent all the time down in MC :P) But still, I'd say go for tier1 first and make sure you can stay alive, then you can progress for tier2 in BWL, unless you have equal eq from other places, dunno how good pvp gear is, but higher ranked gear is something I keep seeing on ppl in MC/BWL from time to time..
Hope I made some sense, else you can just smack me in the game..
//Chalan
There is a cow level, and it's called MULGORE!
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
"I can still hear the laughter echo, and the taste of blood in my mouth.."
-
Chill
- Posts: 271
- Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
drop the rule once were at nef i reckon
good timing for it
good timing for it
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"
-
Alderik
- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue May 03, 2005 5:33 am
- Location: Sweden
Aha, I dident know the full reason for this, tnx ^^SSX-Ava wrote:we tried this at the very begining but there WERE so many complications and arguments aka tickle.... :|
and it will just create the same problem as we are having now. a long time raider cant get a epic 2h in bwl cos he got one months ago in mc.
it would be for the best to just leave weapons/rings/necks/trinkets/not set pieces out of epic over epic.
and imo drop epic over epic on set pieces also -.-
And ya, Drop the epic over epic in bwl but keep it in MC and Ony tbh cuz like bloodfang helm/pants rogue bidding NS in MC over a lower equipped is not something i want to see :]
<< swe >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>
Alderik 60 Warrior
Gabriela 58 Warlock
Illindeen 58 Priest
<< Bladefist >>
-
Meline
- Posts: 130
- Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
- Location: Stockholm/Sweden
Dodo then the casual rogue should aim for tier 1 epics first. If you are a hardcore player who has 100% attendance imo you have the right to get the tier 2 epic before the casual rogue if you have the dkp. If the casual rogue has attended on 50% of the raids he should be very happy with tier 1. Rewarding the casual player with tier 2 and the hardcore player with tier 1 is just not logical.
Edit: Removing the rule won't make all the hardcore players get full tier 2 in no time. That's why we have the maxbid rule.
Edit: Removing the rule won't make all the hardcore players get full tier 2 in no time. That's why we have the maxbid rule.
-
Dodotorpedo
- Posts: 777
- Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Casual raiders will also be coming with us to BWL and seeing all the good items going down, they should have a good chance of getting some.
Personally I don't care about epic over epic at all, feel free to remove them but I had this idea a while ago and I posted it seeing it might be usefull.
We could scrap the entire epic over epic rule, or we could try out my idea and see what happens after some time. It will atleast stop new raiders from getting too many of the items the hardcore raiders would want.
Also you say they should go get the tier 1 first. Well I might not speak for everyone, but I for example think netherwind is atleast double as good as arcanist and if I for example started raiding now(and I'd want full netherwind), I wouldn't like getting out bid for the first few months on tier 2 becouse some other people all still stacked up with DKP from MC/BWL. Sure they worked to get that DKP but I wouldn't have had the CHANCE to get some DKP ;P. And theirs always the classchannel to talk stuff over with eachother about an item, for example is mage A wants item X very badly but can't get it becouse of the epic over epic rule, he could just talk it over with Mage B and I'm sure they can work something out if for example Mage B already got a tier 2 item that week or the week before that, we're not a raiding guild that also happen to be friends, we're a guild of friends that happen to be raiding
We'll see what happens, epic over epic will eventually get scrapped I assume, possibly by the time we reach Chromaggus. Some people want it to stay for now some people want it to dissapear, let's meet somewhere in between
.
Personally I don't care about epic over epic at all, feel free to remove them but I had this idea a while ago and I posted it seeing it might be usefull.
We could scrap the entire epic over epic rule, or we could try out my idea and see what happens after some time. It will atleast stop new raiders from getting too many of the items the hardcore raiders would want.
Also you say they should go get the tier 1 first. Well I might not speak for everyone, but I for example think netherwind is atleast double as good as arcanist and if I for example started raiding now(and I'd want full netherwind), I wouldn't like getting out bid for the first few months on tier 2 becouse some other people all still stacked up with DKP from MC/BWL. Sure they worked to get that DKP but I wouldn't have had the CHANCE to get some DKP ;P. And theirs always the classchannel to talk stuff over with eachother about an item, for example is mage A wants item X very badly but can't get it becouse of the epic over epic rule, he could just talk it over with Mage B and I'm sure they can work something out if for example Mage B already got a tier 2 item that week or the week before that, we're not a raiding guild that also happen to be friends, we're a guild of friends that happen to be raiding
We'll see what happens, epic over epic will eventually get scrapped I assume, possibly by the time we reach Chromaggus. Some people want it to stay for now some people want it to dissapear, let's meet somewhere in between
-
QuantumDelta
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
- Location: Bristol, England.
I will make this clear, btw.
If this rule drops, if there is any contention over loot and there is a problem;
Masterlooters' discretion > *.
AND PEOPLE WILL DEAL WITH THAT.
If this rule drops, if there is any contention over loot and there is a problem;
Masterlooters' discretion > *.
AND PEOPLE WILL DEAL WITH THAT.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
-
sam.freak
- Posts: 402
- Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
- Location: under your desk
There's also another thing: With AQ opening there will be less time to go around and raid. Yeah, doing MC and Ony and BWL is nice now, but I for one don't see myself going to MC much longer anymore -- because there's nothing there for me, but also because there just isn't the time and money (repairs/potions/whatever) to do EVERY major instance every week. It also makes sense to open up MC slots for new raiders, so by me (for example) not going there's a spot for a new paladin getting geared up.
Anyway, just a thought.
Anyway, just a thought.
-
QuantumDelta
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
- Location: Bristol, England.
we will probably drop MC if we begin AQ and get BWL on farm.
We may drop MC anyway.
We may drop MC anyway.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
-
sam.freak
- Posts: 402
- Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
- Location: under your desk
Aw hell naw not until everyone has their tier 2 legs 
-
QuantumDelta
- Posts: 1051
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
- Location: Bristol, England.
No.sam.freak wrote:Aw hell naw not until everyone has their tier 2 legs
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."
