Discussion: Inflation (long)

Moderator: Global Moderators

Discussion: Inflation (long)

PostPosted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 10:36 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Hey, this has been troubling me for some time, I believe we have a problem that should be looked at but I haven't really posted it untill now becouse I didn't know how to put it in words and I kinda feared people misunderstanding it.

Pardon my bad english ;<

The problem I speak of is Inflation.
I will begin by explaining a common MMORPG problem and a solution for it to later on compare it to the problem I think we have.

Gold
In WoW we use gold as a currency. For every mob we kill we get gold or items that are of value, we also get items of value by opening chests/picking herbs/mining etc...
Imagine a world without repaircosts, and free mounts and free epicmounts. Free respeccosts free reagents etc...
That world would be horrible, for every mob that is killed and for every herb etc collected, the amount of money circulating the WoW population will grow and grow and grow, the WoW community of players will nolonger 'lose' money they will only gain more and more, untill eventually greens are on the AH for 100G min bid simply becouse everyone has the gold to pay for these minor items, there's that much gold in circulation.
By forcing people to pay gold for repairs/reagents/respeccosts/auctions/ mounts Blizzard creates a 'moneysink'
I've made a little picture hoping it'll clear up the meaning of 'moneysink' more:

Image

As you can see the crane of money is an endless supply of gold witch unlike in the real world we have in WoW, if the hole (bottom) wouldn't be there to carry out all the water(gold), the sink would eventually flood. When more water is in the sink (with World of Warcraft players on a server) the amount of money owned by the players will be higher and AH prices will be higher due to the fact that people have more money to spend. Sink flooding = bad.

Similair to the gold system in World of Warcraft is the DKP system. There is an endless supply of DKP (bosses can get killed over and over again with no end). There is also always a supply of EPIX on witch the DKP can be spent, Epics are the DKPsink like repaircosts/reagents/mounts are the Moneysink. However at the current moment, the moneysink is imbalanced. More water (DKP) is entering the sink then leaving it. This will result in people gaining more and more DKP and thus DKP will be worth less (Inflation). And a green (or in this case inferior epic) would become worth 100 DKP where an old epic (superior epic) used to hardly be worth that much. Becouse of this eventually all items dropping in MC/BWL/AQ40/ZG/AQ20 will be maxbidded and eventually rolled for, except by the people who aren't very active on raids.
The demand for epics is still the same as first, the stock of epics has increased and the amount of DKP people have has also been increased. This should be no problem then however, the prices for the epix haven't changed. People are gaining more and more DKP and DKP continues to become worth less, but the prices are still the same. We are gaining more DKP then we spend and thus eventually the sink will flood.

Let's look at the different bosses in MC/BWL, howmuch DKP they bring to the players and howmuch they cost.

Let's start with MC, Lucifron.

Lucifron is worth 3 DKP (3*40=120DKP) A total of 120 DKP is added to the playerbase. Lucifron usually drops 2 epics, in this example one will be 20 DKP min and the other 30 DKP min. if both items go out for max bid a total of 100 DKP will be spend and players will have gained 20 DKP toomuch (becouse of the DKPsink). Only is Lucifron dropped 2 30 DKP min epics and they would both be maxbidded would the balance be alright. Ofcourse one must not forget about BoE epics that drop on a run. And weapons that drop from bosses can go for insane prices aswell. The problem however is, people are not maxbidding on these items. Aditionally players gain 2*40=80DKP every raid for being on-time. Though a good bonus it's a high amount of DKP earned without it being drained.
If Lucifron drops 2 items and they are 'disenchanted' the raid gains 120 DKP but loses 0, thus once again a large amount of DKP is added to the pool. Slowly more and more the amount of DKP in the sink is rising and rising becouse not enough DKP is being sucked out. This problem however has become even worse now that we've reached BWL.

Example:
Razorgore is worth 7(!!!) DKP (7*40=280DKP). Imagine RG drops 2 epics (min 40) and a zomgweapon (85 DKP min). This is pretty much the best case scenario since very valuable epics drop. Imagine all of the drops get max bidded (80+80+213=372DKP). Wow, thats 92 DKP drain and thus a pretty good DKP sink. However it is a very rare case scenario AND people have to max bid on every item to achieve this. Lucifron dropping 2 items that are disenchanted is about as common as this happening. Thus the DKP still isn't drained enough. Later on in BWL we'll find other bosses that are even worse. Firemaw/Ebonroc/Flamegor. Each of these are worth 6 DKP (6*3*40=720DKP) And all of them usually drop items worth 40 to 50 DKP min, to give the situation the benefit of the doubt they'll all drop 2 50 DKP min items. All these items are maxbidded. (6*100=600DKP)
Thats right, all the items that drop are worth a good amount of DKP, they've ALL been max-bidded (witch might not be so weird at the time but after we've run BWL for a while longer items will surely become disenchanted aswell) and still 120 DKP is gained. this is still excluding the DKP on-time bonus and Trashmob epics don't really apply here since the trashmobs themselves are actually worth DKP aswell.
Long story Short: We are (IMO) gaining more DKP then we can spend, thus toomuch DKP can be spend and all items will end up becoming max-bidded even if they're just slight upgrades for people becouse they CAN and have more then enough DKP to do it. this can already be seen in the smaller 20 man instances (ZG and AQ20) where the min bids are low and all the items that drop are going for max bid. This large amount of DKP gain will eventually lead too rolls for ALL items that drop, witch shouldn't be the case (I assume everyone can agree on that).

Now there are multiple ways too fix this problem.
A: Decrease the source (less DKP earned)
B: Increase the size of the drain (more DKP lost on items IE: higher min bids)
C: Dunno ;<

This is just what I've gathered and I believe this could really become a problem in the distant future, if not the near-future, this is just my opinion and I hope we can discuss it here in this thread and if people agree with me find a solution on this problem that we can all agree on.

I'm not trying to whine, please don't flame me for the things I say but feel free to critisize on what I've said if something isn't right.

Please, discuss.

PostPosted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 10:47 pm

User avatar
Caspae
Posts: 431
Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 6:50 pm
You definitely have a point , for sure... but changing this would create alot more work to have all the min bids and the site changed ... But if you got your points sorted , we perhaps should indeed change the min bids to a higher amount ..

SsX-Casp

PostPosted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 10:56 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Prizes for items have increased before (in MC bracers etc used to be 15 DP min and was raised to 20 DKP min, Other items were raised aswell like SoD and Mageblade form 50 DKP min to 65 DKP min) it shouldn't be toomuch of a problem to increase the amount of DKP for items, for example Set item bases could be changed to 40 DKP (boots/gloves/belt/bracers) to 50 DKP and 50 DKp (shoulders/pants) to 65 DKP and 55 DKP (head/Robe) to 70 DKp (though the head could just stay at its worth of 55 DKP since they drop alot and are already a pretty good DKPsink
Onyxia = 4 DKP (+2 on-time bonus)
6*40=240. 2 headpieces and 2 other random epics + Onyxia's head = 55+55+50+(27 to 70 average 48.5)+(27 to 70 average 48.5)= 257 min bid on items, 464max)(though items dropping from Onyxia are hardly ever maxbidded)
Other then that some random epics should probably have their value increased slightly aswell, but thats just my idea. I dislike the idea of reducing the amount of DKP earned becouse it would give those who currently have a high amount of DKP (including me) an unfair advantage compared too raiders with a current low amount of DKP.

PostPosted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 11:06 pm

User avatar
base
Posts: 524
Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 10:35 am
Location: wales uk
I have way too much dkp
Ryoko/Deluxe
InvadeSpace

PostPosted: Mon Mar 20, 2006 11:43 pm

firedancer
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
Location: Innsbruck, Austria
it is obvious what the reason is that ppl have too much dkp: the max bid rule. the dkp sink is to small and ppl can not get rid of dkp, as the max bid way to low. so the simplest way out of it is remove maxbid. here would be my probosal how to do it: between min bid and twice the min bid, ppl can bid any number. above twive min bid, it is only allowed to bid interger numbers of the min bid, e.g.,

- set piece with min bid 40 dkp:
allowed bids: any number between 40 -80
above only 120, 160, 200, ...

this would allow to get rid of dkp if ppl really want to have an item and guarantees that the dkp system has a self-regulating nature.

second, to get make the dkp system into a healty state again, make a unique step and half the dkp of every person.

in contrast, making prieces more expensive or reducing the dkp earned is really stupid as it only punished the ppl just starting raiding, or only comming randomly on raids.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 12:11 am

User avatar
Stracius
Posts: 1471
Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2004 4:02 pm
Location: under the starry night sky
Dodotorpedo wrote:I dislike the idea of reducing the amount of DKP earned becouse it would give those who currently have a high amount of DKP (including me) an unfair advantage compared too raiders with a current low amount of DKP.
I agree. Doing this would only hurt the people that don't raid as often. Same with the idea of increasing the cost of items. I know, because I was one of the people who didn't raid very often :P . By choice, mind you, and some people don't even have that luxury in the game. It'd really hurt the casual players who don't have the time to spend raiding all the time.
Dodotorpedo wrote:Now there are multiple ways too fix this problem.
A: Decrease the source (less DKP earned)
B: Increase the size of the drain (more DKP lost on items IE: higher min bids)
C: Dunno ;<
Might I suggest
C: a % cut of current DKP across the board. i.e. everyone's DKP is reduced by 25%.

The people who would stand to lose the most would be the ones with the most dkp. But really, what the hell else are they going to do with it all? I don't think it would actually hurt them at all, if you think about it. Thoughts?

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 12:49 am

SSX-Andy
Posts: 374
Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 2:28 am
Or cap the maximum DKP a person can have, so that ppl are forced to use them and not just sit an wait for ages with their DKP stack growing.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 12:54 am

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
firedancer wrote:here would be my probosal how to do it: between min bid and twice the min bid, ppl can bid any number. above twive min bid, it is only allowed to bid interger numbers of the min bid, e.g.,

- set piece with min bid 40 dkp:
allowed bids: any number between 40 -80
above only 120, 160, 200, ...
Excuse me, but this idea is BRILLIANT!

- edit -
Btw dodo: dont worry, this post is hardly misunderstandable! And the issue is point of discussed ingame already... as more & more ppl see the problem, but noone made a post yet. Atm the math for our dkp earned / spent simply doesnt work, but the best solution i came up with, was to remove the cap. This would indeed screw the more casual players.

Im glad you made such a well founded & smart post dodo! And im glad aswell psy came up with an incredible simple way how to work around the problem!

Brilliant --> because dkp values are steady, but the economy isnt... and this idea adepts to it perfectly!

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 6:22 am

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
I wouldn't want to reduce the amount of dkp people earn, nor would i want to place a limit on the amount of dkp a person is allowed to have, and i certanly don't wanna get rid of max bids completely cos they're there for a reason.
firedancer wrote:here would be my probosal how to do it: between min bid and twice the min bid, ppl can bid any number. above twive min bid, it is only allowed to bid interger numbers of the min bid, e.g.,

- set piece with min bid 40 dkp:
allowed bids: any number between 40 -80
above only 120, 160, 200, ...
I think thats an excellent idea fire. :)
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 7:53 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
I find your argument completely undermined by the amount of arcanist we have disenchanted whilst it's been a massive upgrade to your character.

you abused the system that was setup not to be abused And now you pay for it.

FYI: With our current system problems the best change would be to reduce all MC bosses to 1 DKP Earned remove the ontime bonuses and PENALISE people who are not on time.

BWL: RG/Vael/Broodlord DKP value reduced to 3 ea.
Drakes reduced to 2.
Chromaggus and Nefarion maintain their current DKP Value.

Similarly;
Penalise those who are not 'ontime' at thorium point or onyxia's lair, or in future, cenarion hold.
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 8:54 am

User avatar
Stracius
Posts: 1471
Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2004 4:02 pm
Location: under the starry night sky
I dunno. I can't say I enjoyed the thought of being penalized for something that could end up being out of my control. Regardless, hope you guys find something that works out well, or modification, or none, whatever. A loot-based game was another of the small headaches I got and didn't want to deal with. Glad you guys have more fortitude than I ;)

and btw, I can't say I know what the situation with the inflation is (if any). My suggestion is only based on a solution proposed to a similar problem back when I played.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 9:08 am

User avatar
QuantumDelta
Posts: 1051
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:51 pm
Location: Bristol, England.
The DKP system SSX uses is unique, it had to be designed to use several mechanisms to ensure it was fair to everyone involved;

You had to look at the situation when the guild was originally starting MC and nothing has changed (cept for the scale);

I had more gear than anyone and I could easily command what gear I would pick up and unlikely not be stoppable by the other members simply because of my attendence level amongst other things so;

The system had to be designed to restrict and impeed *me* and anyone who might end up in my position in favour of the rest of the lesser active/more casual guild members.

The Layout I was given was roughly;

The system must be there to enable to allow people who have put in more
work to have a statistically better chance of acquiring their items.

The system must be there to prevent those who have put more work into the raids to gain *all* of the loot (=require maxbid of an acceptably low level that gives casuals and lesser actives a chance to bid quite early on items).

Everyone had to start with 0 points.

There needed to be a sufficiently structured way to deal with everyone starting on 0 points (Negative bids / rolls).

There needed to be a limit to where DKP hording would stop playing benefit (this point is; where your DKP value goes above that of the max bid of the items which you are saving for, and from that point on the people you had previously an advantage over start gaining on you until you are once again =equal= - this situation is not unequal) to the person hording these points. -- This allows the ability to DKP Save for maxbidding on an item but does not 100% garantee you the item.

Epic over Epic was instringiently enforced on me dispite me feeling that it wasn't quite sensible, it had it's merits so I backed it in the end.

Here's the thing;
More and more people are coming into the position where I was when we started raiding = they are not aware of all of these factors as well.
.........HOWEVER - There are still a significant amount of warriors, rogues, mages, paladins, and priests who seriously need the system as it is.

/shrug
"Then, to hide their frailty, they hurt those who are kind.
I whisper farewell to this ugly world and dance nimbly with brilliant wings of red."

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 10:00 am

User avatar
Galador
Posts: 259
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 1:07 pm
Location: Malta
QuantumDelta wrote:FYI: With our current system problems the best change would be to reduce all MC bosses to 1 DKP Earned remove the ontime bonuses and PENALISE people who are not on time.

BWL: RG/Vael/Broodlord DKP value reduced to 3 ea.
Drakes reduced to 2.
Chromaggus and Nefarion maintain their current DKP Value.

Similarly;
Penalise those who are not 'ontime' at thorium point or onyxia's lair, or in future, cenarion hold.
Agree completely - suggested the same thing in magechnnel yday when dodo was speaking about the "problem". Hope these suggestions will be implemented.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 10:56 am

User avatar
Xelrash
Posts: 124
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 7:34 pm
Location: Holland
I agree with QD (rimes xP)
It takes an army to kill a paladin.
It takes an army of paladins to kill anything..

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 3:33 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
QuantumDelta wrote:I find your argument completely undermined by the amount of arcanist we have disenchanted whilst it's been a massive upgrade to your character.

you abused the system that was setup not to be abused And now you pay for it.
If you'd give me those arcanist for free, I'd probably disenchant them for the Large Brilliant shards (no nexusses back then) since my blues were better at the time ;/. But thats just a matter of opinion. In my sight however the color of an item is meaningless, only it's stats. Mind you this was before Arcanist got boosted to being a normal set instead of a slight magister upgrade. I don't see why I'd let Arcanist get disenchanted if I wanted them due to the fact that I haven't had less then 300 DKP for... 3 months or something? Also the current boosted Arcanist is still not very good compared to the epics and blues I currently have. But thats just my opinion anyway.
FireDancer wrote: - set piece with min bid 40 dkp:
allowed bids: any number between 40 -80
above only 120, 160, 200, ...

this would allow to get rid of dkp if ppl really want to have an item and guarantees that the dkp system has a self-regulating nature.

second, to get make the dkp system into a healty state again, make a unique step and half the dkp of every person.

in contrast, making prieces more expensive or reducing the dkp earned is really stupid as it only punished the ppl just starting raiding, or only comming randomly on raids.
I like this idea, however we should keep in mind it would make it very hard for casual raiders to get very popular items like Mageblade before hardcore raiders. It's a very good idea to create a bigger drain for the DKP.
QuantumDelta wrote: FYI: With our current system problems the best change would be to reduce all MC bosses to 1 DKP Earned remove the ontime bonuses and PENALISE people who are not on time.

BWL: RG/Vael/Broodlord DKP value reduced to 3 ea.
Drakes reduced to 2.
Chromaggus and Nefarion maintain their current DKP Value.

Similarly;
Penalise those who are not 'ontime' at thorium point or onyxia's lair, or in future, cenarion hold.
I agree with the idea that the on-time bonus should be removed since it adds an imbalance to the system, penaltys might actually get people out of Ironforge within half an hour after their invites. But I'm not too sure I'd like the idea of giving people 'DKPfines'.

As for reducing the DKP gained from MC and Blackwing lair, though it would fix the DKPdrain problem people with currently a high amount of DKP will suddenly see the worth of that DKP double in value (if not more) and those who are casual and have a little amount of DKP would find it hard to ever gain up on these people that are stuffed with DKP. If DKP gained from bosses is reduced I feel we should probably have a % reduction on everyones DKP aswell, people low on DKP wouldn't have thatmuch problem catching up on the higher DKP-holders then.

If the DKPflood is already bad enough to couse lots of max bids in MC/ZG/AQ20 now, just imagine when items in BWL get disenchanted and the amount of DKP flooding in will continue. We might enter AQ40 with a raid full of people with 500+ DKP. Hope we can find a solution to this problem before it the DKP gets stacked to abnormal proportions.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 6:42 pm

User avatar
Meline
Posts: 130
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2005 4:20 pm
Location: Stockholm/Sweden
As I see it now you don't earn your items. You get them by having luck with the dice.

As many said before one of the problems is the maxbid rule. It is way too low.
Imagine this: we remove it.
You say: That will hurt the casual people.
Example: I have 500 dkp and the 2 favourite items for me drop. I REALLY want them so I spend 250 dkp on each. I get the items I want and I have 0 dkp. Then it gives the casual players a good chance to get items why I don't have dkp. Every player has favourite items. If you have earned 500 dkp you should be able to spend them in whatever way you want.

About the dkp cap: And how would you get rid of your dkp when we have a free for all roll system when an item drops?

The reducing of the dkp with %: And that would penalize the players who have been most active and worked their asses off.

DKP is a way to reward the players who have struggled and lost money to actually kill bosses and get them on farm. As it is now you can't use your dkp in a proper way.

Maybe I'm extra "bitchy" in that issue because I've had 500+ dkp for months now and the dice really isn't my friend. I see people with 1 dkp over maxbid roll higher and with the frequency of priestdrops we have ALL priests have the maxbid of pretty much every item that drops.

The removing of the maxbid would result in a slighter gearup for the most active players, but this does not mean that the casuals won't get any items. But that's what dkp is all about, right? To reward the players for their activity.
Meline - 60 Human priest (Outland)
Buttran - Lvling, cute gnome lock (Outland)
Coldrey - 60 UD rogue (Grim Batol)
Rolling skills /300.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 7:13 pm

User avatar
Magdalena
Posts: 571
Joined: Sat Jul 30, 2005 5:59 pm
Location: Mannoroth, USA
Unfortunately no loot system is ever going to be perfect. They all have their flaws no matter how well you plan ahead. The only thing you can do is handle them the best you can when they come along.

On Mannoroth we don't use DKP, which I know doesn't seem an option for your group... from reading the current concern though there is one aspect you might be able to somehow implement... we call it the "lootless wonder"... what it does for our system is if a person goes through 10 raids without receiving anything, the next item for their class is defaulted to them. For ours it is because though we use a percentage cut-off with a rolling system, some people are just inherantly unlucky.
Perhaps something on the higher end for someone who keeps gaining DKP but never spending it, reaching a certain amount of times of this or a certain DKP amount would trigger a cut of a certain percent of their total points. This would keep the new people having the same ability but also keep an encouragement for others to use their DKP before they start losing it... don't make the percentage so big that they wouldn't still have a slight advantage, but big enough they wouldn't want to just lose it...

Just an idea, there may be downfalls I don't see to it that you do, but thought I'd toss it out there... I've never used DKP so don't know the entire impact something like that would have...

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 7:27 pm

User avatar
Dreamer
Posts: 139
Joined: Thu Apr 21, 2005 5:49 am
Meline wrote:As I see it now you don't earn your items. You get them by having luck with the dice.

As many said before one of the problems is the maxbid rule. It is way too low.
Imagine this: we remove it.
You say: That will hurt the casual people.
Example: I have 500 dkp and the 2 favourite items for me drop. I REALLY want them so I spend 250 dkp on each. I get the items I want and I have 0 dkp. Then it gives the casual players a good chance to get items why I don't have dkp. Every player has favourite items. If you have earned 500 dkp you should be able to spend them in whatever way you want.

About the dkp cap: And how would you get rid of your dkp when we have a free for all roll system when an item drops?

The reducing of the dkp with %: And that would penalize the players who have been most active and worked their asses off.

DKP is a way to reward the players who have struggled and lost money to actually kill bosses and get them on farm. As it is now you can't use your dkp in a proper way.

Maybe I'm extra "bitchy" in that issue because I've had 500+ dkp for months now and the dice really isn't my friend. I see people with 1 dkp over maxbid roll higher and with the frequency of priestdrops we have ALL priests have the maxbid of pretty much every item that drops.

The removing of the maxbid would result in a slighter gearup for the most active players, but this does not mean that the casuals won't get any items. But that's what dkp is all about, right? To reward the players for their activity.
I can see the point, but if you have 500 dkp, and the person who wants the item bidding against you has 81dkp... will you really bid 250? or just 82? :p

The maxbid system is there to ensure that people with a certain level of attendance can get a certain number of items. With 500 dkp you can max bid most of a set, if it were to drop. The guy with 81 can only max bid one item. So in the mass drop spree that may come some day, the highest points WILL benifit you, in the way it was origionally intended. (It may happen some day for priests, prolly while I'm on this break;/ )

As for minus dkp, it would just make more work for me and ava to deduct it from people. Plus its not really the answer for us as a guild anyway, too much goes on.
Proel

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 8:08 pm

firedancer
Posts: 286
Joined: Mon Jan 03, 2005 12:58 am
Location: Innsbruck, Austria
ok. let us say this straight. the dkp system we used failed. i am against some minor corrections to try to fix it, but rather some fundamental steps.
QuantumDelta wrote:
The system must be there to prevent those who have put more work into the raids to gain *all* of the loot (=require maxbid of an acceptably low level that gives casuals and lesser actives a chance to bid quite early on items).

i agree that this should be possible. but i would say from beginning, i was the opinion that the max bid rule does not help in this point. the reason, is that ppl which raid actively can not get rid of their dkp, and finally can bid on everything. therefore, the max bid rule is very counter intuitive and is the source of all problems.


an alternative approach is to let the active raiders really loose their dkp, such that even casual raiders can bid, as the active ones are most of the time near 0 dkp. this is the idea of the above proposed system:
you can more than max bid, but it must substantially
reduce the amount of dkp.



finally, to avoid ppl hording dkp, just impose two additional rules:
- first, for beeing allowed to bid in BWL, you need to be
properly equipped allready. for e.g., you need to have
5 tier 1 pieces or equivalent epic pieces.

- second, the raid leader can enforce ppl to take loot if they
can not show a better item.



and to dodo:
i am really disappointed from you. there have been several times during our raiding times, where i beat you in stats/FR/hp. and i am only wearing arcanist. so depending of the boss we fight, arcanist is an extremely good set. if you think your blues are better, than you are just a noob which has not yet learned that the game is not only +dmg, but sometimes requires some flexibility of the players. arcanist set and other pieces can make you really powerfull in some situations, and would help the guild as a whole if you would not be such ignorant.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 9:30 pm

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
Yeah.. im a little alarmed at DKP at the moment

back when i started my break if someone had over 100 DKP... it was pretty impressive and you knew theyd get the next thing they wanted

I left with a round 60DKP iirc and that was enough to maybe get me a peice of netherwind

what alarms me now is that everyone else had 300DKP each -- possibly some imbalance in BWL dkp values, but theres no way i can compete with that

And if we
QD wrote: BWL: RG/Vael/Broodlord DKP value reduced to 3 ea.
Drakes reduced to 2.
Chromaggus and Nefarion maintain their current DKP Value.
I think thats going to cripple me, while everyone else has alot of "cheap" DKP


Its an imperfect situation, and i dont have a solution, i just thought id give some input to the PTB.



finally
Firedreamer wrote: and to dodo:
i am really disappointed from you. there have been several times during our raiding times, where i beat you in stats/FR/hp. and i am only wearing arcanist. so depending of the boss we fight, arcanist is an extremely good set. if you think your blues are better, than you are just a noob which has not yet learned that the game is not only +dmg, but sometimes requires some flexibility of the players. arcanist set and other pieces can make you really powerfull in some situations, and would help the guild as a whole if you would not be such ignorant.
this post is a)wrong 2)condacending
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 9:42 pm

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
firedancer wrote: and to dodo:
i am really disappointed from you. there have been several times during our raiding times, where i beat you in stats/FR/hp. and i am only wearing arcanist. so depending of the boss we fight, arcanist is an extremely good set. if you think your blues are better, than you are just a noob which has not yet learned that the game is not only +dmg, but sometimes requires some flexibility of the players. arcanist set and other pieces can make you really powerfull in some situations, and would help the guild as a whole if you would not be such ignorant.
Arcanist is a good set, but not good enough IMO and I do indeed believe blues have been and still are better (selective blues ofcourse) and You can't get more then 185 fire resistance with just Arcanist. Yes stats are higher and yes maby I'm just a +dmg n00b but thats for me too decide if I think my current gear is a good balance between damage and stats (witch yes I do) I should be allowed to think that and share that opinion with people without being flamed.
Ricardo wrote: Dearon what is this for bullshit post...Dont rune it for evrybody becouse you already got your shit ,..

Anonymous guild member..
If your an annomynous guildmember thats just flaming people and giving no good reason for it then maby SSX isn't the place for you?



I expected to get flamed for posting this but I felt that it was nessesairy to say this at the time, thats how I felt at the time incorrect or not it's my opinion I'd like to have a say in things without getting my head flamed off. It's not like I'm saying: this is how it is I'm right everyone else is wrong. I've opened it for discussion so I could hear what other people thought about it aswell and this has influanced my opinion allot. Your flames however have no value to me and only discourage me to make posts on these forums or start general conversations in lets say Guildchat.
Lets not flame people for saying whats on their minds shall we? Perhaps respect freedom of speach. This isn't the official WoW forums for crying out loud.

Edit:
Ricardo wrote: yes true true





-=
60 priest bladefist
60 lock bladefist
60 roque bladefist =-
Whats with the fake sig? Trying to give a hint to who you are. I'd rather you just say who you are instead of perhaps making me imagine wrong people or perhaps your trying to say your somewone your not.
Last edited by Dodotorpedo on Tue Mar 21, 2006 10:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 11:18 pm

User avatar
sam.freak
Posts: 402
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: under your desk
Zomg Technology!

21st century FTW!

Edit: To add something to the discussion, the problem here really was/is the quality/quantity of loot we get. We get DKP for a boss, but no-one needs his drop? Diss the items. We create currency with no backing behind it (IRL it would be gold/bonds/land/pigs, here it is equipped items).

We get a Cenarion in MC, but no one needs it. It disses into 2 shards. Therefore each of these shards should be worth DKPforboss * Peopleinraid / numberofshards = ValueforNexusshardsinDKP, not 1 dkp.

There is a solution (kinda) to this problem, it's a proper 0-sum system. That means the value of the item is deducted from the player who gets it, and that every player in the raid gets DKPItemValue/Peopleinraid added to their total. However, under this system there is no attendance dkp value, and there is also no bidding. The item in question goes to whoever 1) has the most dkp 2) can use it (class items/armour sets) 3) actually wants the item (passing is perfectly acceptable, also he might already have it etc.)

A better description can be found here: http://forums.elitistjerks.com/index.php?showtopic=5386
Last edited by sam.freak on Tue Mar 21, 2006 11:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I loot Legendaries.

http://ctprofiles.net/1752

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 11:24 pm

User avatar
Unimatrixx
Posts: 141
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 2:51 am
Location: Zeeland
I think this is a matter with no solution that fits for everybody tho, maybe we should throw up a poll for this. Long live democrazy ;p
Assumption is the mother of all f*ckups.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 21, 2006 11:28 pm

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Unimatrixx wrote:I think this is a matter with no solution that fits for everybody tho, maybe we should throw up a poll for this. Long live democrazy ;p
Ever tried to roll for the ony head or the heart of hakkar? I suppose i know how the poll will turn out -.-

- edit -
The flame is cute :lol:

PostPosted: Wed Mar 22, 2006 1:00 am

SSX-Andy
Posts: 374
Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 2:28 am
The 0-sum system of elitist jerks seems to have its points. Its a bit late now, so dont have time to go through it all, but at least it doesnt have the problem of more DKP in than out.

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”