Sorry.

Moderator: Global Moderators

Sorry.

PostPosted: Sat Apr 29, 2006 5:56 pm

noodlea
Posts: 33
Joined: Tue Nov 22, 2005 11:00 am
About 30 seconds i said something in guild chat that was more a little unpleasnt.

and im sorry.

but i have had enough.

i have played wow from day 1, i made my rogue, my /played is currently at 90 days in this time i have seen blizzrd nerf my class and "fix" it not a single buff change or efert to make them more fun to play. i have played basically every single tallent build that is not complete poo.

so then why i am so fed up, basically i dont find my class fun any more, i could go into how there "underpowered" ad how other clases are overpwoered" but as blizard say rogues are one of the most balanced classes in wow, so i can only assume that they are how blizzard want them to be.

when im not geting "you are out of range" you must behind/infront of your target messages, i generally get my kill in a battle ground, i then die about 30 seconds after. were is the FUN in this?

A rogue can completly stun lock a target in one on one pvp, giving the opponent no chance what so ever, however if the "stunlock" is broken and in mass pvp this happens more than often the odds are now massivly against the rogue , as it will only only take one instant cast slowing/rooting/fearing/charge stun to shaft a rogue, i mean ffs the amount of times ive deathcoild a rogue, feared him doted him and just run away is silly, even if he uses a pvp trinket, all ii have to do is get 6 yards away there is NOTHING they can do appart from sprint once every 5 mins, or shoot me with hiw bow.

I have been playing my warlock quite heavily in bg for a few days, and wearing cloth i have nealy as much armor and hp as the rogue with 10x the survivability. i dont get as many solo kills, however im less oppertunaty, reagent and timer based, and i have to carry a bag of soding soulshards. Warlocks are fun to play.

i have also played every single character in wow at level 60 alough not all of them are my characters, i still have a rough idea how to play them and i do fine in bg, the survivability of a rogue is just pethetic in mass pvp compared to every other class , boring frustrating and tedious are now what i thikn of when i think of rogue mass pvp.

Just because a rogue can use every single cooldown and kill almost any class in the game once imo doenst make them balanced rogues have been made lazily, blizzard want them to be an oppertunaty based killer, and they can think of no better way of doing this than giving them stupid cooldowns that peple whine about when you use them?

i dont expect people to understand, no one likes rogues due to the type of class they are.

final note, i didnt make a rogue to wait there at the back of a battle ground 1 shoting low hp clothis and geting about 2 contrabution points.

"so why dont you just stop playing"

Edit : Locks ftw

and again sorry for the more than unpleasnt language used in guild chat.

-matt.
Last edited by noodlea on Sat Apr 29, 2006 9:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.

PostPosted: Sat Apr 29, 2006 6:31 pm

User avatar
sam.freak
Posts: 402
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm
Location: under your desk
Don't worry about it, I have heard from many sides about the plight of Rogues. Here's hoping that the rogue talent/class review will make things better for you!
I loot Legendaries.

http://ctprofiles.net/1752

PostPosted: Sun Apr 30, 2006 3:32 am

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
This post on the US rogue forum sums it all up. He might whine & exaggerate about skills beeing broken, but about the general feeling of our utility / usefuness / capability... its ALL there & true to the last point.

I started out as a hardcore PvPer in my early days (actually pre BG introduction / --> world pvp)... had most fun in playing my class back then, but littl is left. The only thing that keeps me going is to give everything away for PvE (so i might actually benefit the raid to my outmost capabilities, which is still a joke compared to every other class) & PRAY for a well thought out class revamp. These days i find myself often sitting at the char creation screen... but i wont give in till i have seen if the class is *working as intended* or *restored to resemble the fun i had when starting out*.

Backstabber till weapon normalisation, Hemo about 4 months before it was hyped & lost its usefulness due to non-scaled dmg & outgearing, Procbuild before they removed chainprocing... no im not simply sick of my class, im sick of adepting to the latest nerf to keep my capability up, only to find myself sacrificing more & more in return. The amount of oldschcool rogues i had to see rerolling or quiting is frightening... & bitter, because they were my friends & the ppl with whom i pushed to the borders of my class.

You can take away EVERYTHIG from a rogue apart of 3 skills: ss & respectively backstab + snd + feint. We would still be able to do the job we are supposed to do on raids & prob not worse either. Oh the joy.

I lauged my ass off when i read this post on the eu forum. Pitty not a single one replying could grasp the sad joke, but i think you will noodle.

- edit -

BEST QUOTE EVER:
Re: What is left of the rogue class?

A bunch of grizzled, bitter veterans who once loved the class & have too much invested to give up, and a bunch of newbies who don't realize what they're getting into when they roll the class.

Oh, and shaman and paladin alts.

PostPosted: Sun Apr 30, 2006 10:06 am

Dodotorpedo
Posts: 777
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 6:16 pm
Sofia wrote:The only thing that keeps me going is to give everything away for PvE (so i might actually benefit the raid to my outmost capabilities, which is still a joke compared to every other class)
I can understand rogues don't have good crowd controll, no buffs and no supportive abillities. All they do is DPS. However together with hunters your the only two DPS classes with aggro reducing/resetting abillities and in for example BWL this is very important, I wonder howlong Ebonroc would take without rogues or hunters...

However if you look at whats needed for a raid, you can pretty much dump rogues (except for the supression rooms) and replace them with other classes, DPS isn't that important, tanks and healers however are. But I don't see how this could be fixed, I don't see any way in witch rogues would remove debuffs such as curses and magic, and how would a rogue buff other players? Sap used to be a usefull abillity but you can't sap dragons... and if you could polymorph and banish are still better since they can be recast at any time and don't take you out of stealth.

Seeing how rogues are based completely on DPS they should be the highest DPS class in the game imo, not only do they not have buffs like Arcane Int or backups like Soulstone or a concussive shot, they also have to be in melee range of their targets.

Buff rogues.

PostPosted: Sun Apr 30, 2006 4:49 pm

Scorpius
Posts: 673
Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 12:19 pm
Location: Ass End of the Universe
Only thing I want in a rogue is 3 points in SAP........ :lol:
Power Corrupts, Ultimate Power is Fun.

PostPosted: Tue Jun 13, 2006 8:13 am

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Rogue CM replies given in this thread on the us-rogue-forum.
Drysc wrote:The review will mainly be focused on talent changes and improvements, and I think that a lot of the concerns can be addressed solely through them. Keep in mind that 1.12 is a ways off though still, but I think were in pretty good shape for when we do ramp up for the changes in the rogue class.
Drysc wrote: I don't think the rogue class is broken, and neither do the designers. Repeating hyperbole is not an accurate portrayal of a class, and I'm exhausted from seeing the term used.

I think with some appropriate changes the class can be improved, but I believe that some player expectations for what changes may occur are too high. I also believe that a majority of players know the class, and can appropriately voice reasonable concerns, hold reasonable conversations, and propose reasonable suggestions.

Some of you are just completely crazy though.
Drysc wrote:
We only offer DPS. That's it. Do you grasp that?
Considering that is the core role of the rogue class, which we still do and still do well, of course. Regardless of other classes approaching that damage output, that does not suddenly "break" the class. Nor do any of the other things you mentioned.

If my car loses some of its high end and other cars were beginning to catch up, a windshield wiper flew off, etc. would I say its broken? No, its not on the side of the road piston-sticking-out-of-the-hood completely unusable, it just needs a bit of a tune-up. That is what a review is meant for. Im exhausted of seeing unreasonable words used in absolute terms when there are no absolutes present. We can have a logical discussion (as many here are obviously capable of), or you can claim that the class is completely unusable and I can easily ignore you.
Drysc wrote:
As a rogue though, it is very disheartening when another class with more utility to the raid also approaches and many times surpasses our main role. It is not hyperbole to suggest that it is similar to a druid or hunter pet tanking as well or better than the main tank of a raid. The main tank would certainly find himself asking what is my role if my main job is suddenly overshadowed by some other class that can do it as effectively or even better.

This is the betrayal the rogues feel, our main role suddenly being minimalized by a class that can not only out damage us, but can throw on a sword and board and fill in another role. Or overshadowed by a class that stays at range, not requiring the massive amounts of healing to keep them up, think mana efficiency here, while also providing raid buffs, or raid utility.

Can we still output good damage? Yes. Can we bring ANYTHING else to the table? No, not really. Can other classes approach or surpass our damage? YES. Do they bring anything else to the table? YES. If you can not see the irony of this situation and understand that if this keeps up, the rogue class is heading to obsolescence. Obsolete may be hyperbole, but sometimes hyperbole is necessary to make a very important point that someone refuses to acknowledge.
You misunderstand me then. The points you brought up, just now, I fully acknowledge. It's posts like yours that I am willing to read and reply to. It presents a reasonable explanation of an issue in a fairly reasonable fashion.

The posts claiming the class is completely unusable, completely obsolete, lacks the ability to provide fun or enjoyment from the game, I don't acknowledge. I can see full well what is trying to be sold, and I don't buy it
Ok.

PostPosted: Tue Jun 13, 2006 8:37 am

User avatar
Linkie
Posts: 461
Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2005 12:50 pm
Location: The Netherlands, Haarlem
ohw k =D i am looking forward to patch 1.12 :P GIEV IT FAST =D
WoW:
NE Rogue LvL 60 Called Linkie

GW:
Eli/Mon LvL 8 Called Sakura The Small

PostPosted: Wed Jun 14, 2006 2:57 pm

Janell
Posts: 61
Joined: Sat Jan 14, 2006 3:53 am
I totally agree, it's also the reason i more or less stopped playing my rogue. Should get some changes indeed.

PostPosted: Thu Jun 15, 2006 4:01 pm

User avatar
Sofia
Posts: 536
Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 10:36 pm
Ive split the rest off this post... lets keep the mushrooms out.

Back to the topic.

Same post from the us-forum just c/p on the eu-forum & it gets the blue tag aswell:kinda funny
Vaneras wrote: Blue tagged :-)

Even though the original post of this thread is a copy/paste from the US forums, I still think that it deserves to be blue tagged. It is well written, constructive and quite relevant.

I have seen many of these concerns posted before by other players in various threads, but this thread seems to sum them up pretty well. I would like to say that these things have also been forwarded to the developers.

I would like if I were able to tell you more about what is being done to address your concerns, but it is still too early to say since I do not yet have information about the upcoming Rogue revamp.
There is light at the end of the long *cough* tunnel...

Return to “=EU= World of Warcraft- Outland”