Slandering the Dead

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

Slandering the Dead

PostPosted: Sat Jun 03, 2006 2:43 am

BlueFlames
Posts: 465
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
Location: SSX Vault 12
I try to view Bill O'Reilly as light comedy. If you ever watch his show and think of it as self-satire, it actually starts to make a whole lot more sense than if you pretend he's being serious. Bill-O does silly things like arguing with expert guests about who knows more about the guests' specialties. When you see Bill-O doing something like that, you're either going to chuckle or have an aneurysm, and I prefer getting a laugh to having an early run-in with my mortality.

I have a hard time laughing when Bill tries to turn 139 murdered US soldiers into war criminals, and I can feel my blood pressure rising when, given the opportunity to apologize, he refuses to so much as acknowledge the error. What's more, FOX News, instead of rightly firing Bill O'Reilly for heinously slandering honorable men, alters their transcripts to make his record appear spotless. Apparently the, "We support our troops," line has an expiration date in some media outlets.

That's the short version anyway. Keith Olbermann went into more detail in Countdown last night. Here's the video of the story as long as the link still works. The transcript follows....
OLBERMANN: Abraham Lincoln did not shoot John Wilkes Booth. Titanic did not sink a north Atlantic iceberg. And FOX News is neither fair nor balanced. These are facts intelligible to all adults, most children, and some of your more discerning domesticated animals. But not, as the third story on the COUNTDOWN prove yet again, not to Bill-O.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

STEWIE GRIFFIN, BABY, FAMILY GUY: COUNTDOWN presents Factor Fiction, wherein we catch that bastard Bill OReilly lying again. Oh wait, no hold still. Allow me to soil myself on you. Victory is mine!

(END VIDEO CLIP)

OLBERMANN: The guilty pleasure offered by the existence of Bill OReilly is simple but understandable, 99 times out of 100, when we belly up to the Bill-O bar of bluster, nearly every time we partake of the movable falafel feast he serves us nothing but comedy, farce, slapstick, unconscious self-mutilation, the Sideshow Bob of commentators forever stepping on the same rake, forever muttering the same grunted, inarticulate surrender, forever resuming the circle that will take him back to the same rake. The Sisyphus of morons, if you will. But this is the 100th time out of 100. It is not funny at all. Bill OReilly has, for the second time in under eight months, slandered at least 84 dead American servicemen. He has turned them again from victims of the kind of atrocity our country has always fought against into perpetrators of that kind of atrocity. He has made these Americans into war criminals. They are dead and have been dead for 61 years. They cannot defend themselves against OReilly. We will have to do it for them.

Last October Bill OReilly railed against a ruling that more photos from the infamous Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq might be released. His guest on his program was Wesley Clark. Clark is a retired four-star general, was for four years supreme allied commander of NATO in Europe. First in his class at West Point, wounded in Vietnam, earned the Bronze star, the Silver Star and has streets named for him in Alabama and in Kosovo. Therefore, naturally OReilly knows much more about the military than General Clark does. Clark defended the release of the additional Abu Ghraib photos saying we need to know what happened and to correct it. OReilly lectured him and concluded that there had always been atrocities, even by Americans in war.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

BILL OREILLY, THE OREILLY FACTOR: General, you need to look at the Malmady Massacre in World War II in the 82nd airborne.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

OLBERMANN: It was a remarkable mistake. The Belgian town of Malmady did lend its name to one of the most appalling battlefield war crimes of the 20th century. But OReillys implication that the Americans committed it was entirely backwards. Americans, most of them, members of the Battery B of the 285th Fuel Artillery Observation Battalion, surrendered to German Panzer troops and were then shot by their captures by the S.S. Yet OReilly had implied that the Americans had massacred these Germans in this one stark moment of the Battler of the Bulge. And he used this Alice through the looking glass view of history to somehow rationalize Abu Ghraib while trying to dress down a four-star American general.

Still it could have been a mistake, we make them. Even historians do. OReilly had not explicitly called the Americans the war criminals of Malmady. Our war troops, too, were accused of crimes against prisoners in the Second World War. It was assumed last year that he had simply made a foolish error and though he got beaten up appropriately in some places, it was all largely dismissed as merely that, a mistake.

Then came this Tuesday night, again OReillys guest was General Wes Clark. This time the topic was the apparent murder of Iraqi civilians at Haditha. That OReilly was dismissive of that event should be no surprise, that he should have described as the real crime of Iraq the events of Abu Ghraib, should be no surprise of those who know of his willingness to jettison his most important beliefs of yesterday for the expediencies and the ratings of today, but that he should have brought up Malmady again, that was a surprise.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

OREILLY: In Malmady, as you know, U.S. forces captured S.S. forces who had their hands in the air and they were unarmed and they shot them down. You know that. Thats on the record. Been documented.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

OLBERMANN: Thus was the full depth of Bill OReillys insult to the American debt of World War II made clear. The mistake of last October was not some innocent slip nor misrembered history. This was the way OReilly understood and thus, this way it had to be. No errors corrected, no apologies offered, no stopping the relentless tide of bull even briefly enough to check one fact.

The facts of Malmady are terrifying as described by Michael Reynolds in his painstakingly detailed article from a 2003 issue of World War II magazine. One week before Christmas, 1944, 139 U.S. soldiers, most of them from the 285th Field Artillery, encountered the German comf (ph) group, Piper, the leading formation of the German first S.S. Panzer Division, one of only two German units in the entire war which actually carried Adolf Hitlers name. The American were overrun. The 11 of the 139 soldiers were killed in the very short battle of Malmady, two more were killed as they tried to flee, seven escaped, six became prisoners of war. The other 113 Americans, nearly all of whom had surrendered outright, were ordered to assemble in an open field next to a restaurant, the Cafe Bodarue (ph). What happened next has been attributed to many things, a cold-blooded decision by that unit Panzer commander, Colonel Joachim Piper, that he could not handle the prisoners, or an unjustifiable overreaction to some kind of escape attempt or simply horrible mass murder.

Within 15 minutes the S.S. Colonel or someone directly under him had ordered his men to shoot the unarmed American POWs. The bodies at Malmedy were not found until a month later. There were 84 of them, all American soldiers, more than half shotgun wounds to their heads. Six had received fatal blows to the head, nine were found with their arms still raised above their heads. The fact that OReilly got these horrible facts completely backwards twice offended even his usually compliant viewers. From his program Wednesday night:

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

OREILLY: Don Caldwell, Fort Worth, TX. Bill, you mentioned that Malmady as the site of an American massacre during World War II. It was the other way around, the S.S. shot down U.S. prisoners.

In the heat of the debate with General Clark, my statement wasnt clear enough, Mr. Caldwell. After Malmady, some were executed by American troops.

(END VIDEO CLIP)

OLBERMANN: Wrong answer. When you are that wrong, when you are defending Nazi war criminals and pinning their crimes on Americans and you get caught doing so twice, youre supposed to say Im sorry, I was wrong, and then youre supposed to shut up for a long time. Instead, FOX washed its transcript of OReillys remarks Tuesday. Its Web site claims OReilly said in Normandy, when, as you heard, in fact, he said in Malmedy.

The rewriting of past reporting worthy of George Orwell has now carried over into such online transcription services as Burells and Factiva. Whatever did or did not happen later in supposed or actual retribution, the victims at Malmedy were Americans, gunned down while surrendering by Nazis in 1944 and again Tuesday night and Wednesday night by a false patriot who would rather be loud than right.

In Malmedy, as you know, Bill OReilly said on the air Tuesday night in some indecipherable attempt to defend the events of Haditha, U.S. forces captured S.S. forces who had their hands in the air and were unarmed and they shot them dead. You know that, thats on the record and documented. The victims in Malmedy in December 1944 were Americans, Americans with their hands in the air, Americans who were unarmed. Thats on the record and documented, and their memory deserves better than Bill OReilly. We all do.
I apologize for bringing such a politically-charged topic to the forums, but I needed to vent.

PostPosted: Sat Jun 03, 2006 3:22 am

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHUGCkRO ... =OLBERMANN

For those who don't want to install Microsoft crap to view the video.

PostPosted: Sun Jun 04, 2006 4:24 am

User avatar
Futile Resistance
Posts: 1454
Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 10:44 pm
Location: FL
Geez. That O'Reilly guy is not only ignorant and stubborn, he doesn't know when he's slandering the war heroes of his ancestors!

:mad:

Also, the fact that Fox changes the transcript clearly shows (once again) how big of a load of !@#$ you get from watching that show.

PostPosted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 5:12 pm

User avatar
Padishar
Posts: 1713
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:15 pm
Location: Next Door
Since I view all of FoX 'news' (used in the loosest sense of the word) programs as satirical, I normally stay as far away from it as possible. Bill'O from the start has always had the ignorant person comedy news show debating contraversial topics, but this is..... sad.....

A show host who has access to millions of people defame and slander those who gave their lives horrifically to the nazi's :(

Just... sad

PostPosted: Thu Jun 08, 2006 5:27 pm

User avatar
Fenavian
Posts: 1164
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 9:55 pm
Location: Here.
It make sit even worse that Fox had to go so far as edit his comments to make it sound like he was misheard.. yeah right..
01000101011100110110001101101000011001010111011100100000011011110110001001
10011001110101011100110110001101100001011101000110100101101111011011100010
1110

Return to “General Discussions”