Darkstar One Demo
Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators
-
BlueFlames
- Posts: 465
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
- Location: SSX Vault 12
It seems that the space sim genre is on the rebound. I may be mistaken, but I think we are up to one game every three years, as opposed to one every five. Now that developers have stumbled on a workable control scheme for space-based games using the mouse and WADS, the genre has the potential to turn out some high-quality, mainstream successes.
Regarding Darkstar One specifically, it has been getting hyped as being everything Freelancer should have been. Certainly, there elements shared with Freelancer in there. In fact, it is hard to describe Darkstar One except in terms of Freelancer. The sheer size of Darkstar One in most respects is about an order of magnitude larger than Freelancer. Looking at the galaxy, the demo contains but a single corner of the star chart as a whole, but that little corner of the chart has as many systems as a third of the Freelancer galaxy. The systems themselves are larger in actual and apparent size, as the trade lane idea was abandoned in favor of time-compression. Alas, all of these star systems mean little, since most of them look nearly identical to each other. In each system, you'll enter facing a planet with a moon or two; there will be an asteroid belt to the side; there will be a trade station near the planet, and there might be a research station or a large asteroid with a mining station in it. The trade stations are all uniform. The research stations are all uniform. Though that might be expected, the fact that the asteroids being mined are all exactly alike in every way was a supreme disappointment.
Back on the topic of size, if there is one thing I always pay close attention to in a space flight game, it is the sense of scale. The sense of scale was my one complaint with FreeSpace and the most immediately apparent flaw with Freelancer. (I remember ramming a moon before it took up my entire field of view in Freelancer.) Darkstar One is a little more hit-and-miss than other titles. Whereas other space flight games get their scales wrong or really wrong, the magnitude of the screw-up is consistent. Darkstar One seems to have gone through three different scales throughout development. Most of the planets actually feel like small planets (at least that is in the ballpark). The huge shipwreck of a battleship in the demo looks mildly imposing, though it is certainly no GTVA Colossus. Space stations and freighters, however, have to beg the dustmites and subatomic particles to pick on somebody their own size.
Scale aside, the graphics left something to be desired. Granted, it is hard to make vacuum pretty, but I have come to expect some flashiness in my epic space battles. In FreeSpace 2, the sky would come alive with flak explosions, missile trails, beam fire, gasses venting from damaged fighters, shield impacts, etc., etc. That was six years ago. The Darkstar One demo has very little of that. Weapon impacts produce a muted effect; an unharmed ship looks no different from one nearly ready to explode, and though I have heard lock warnings, I have yet to see a missile in-flight. Hell, even the explosions fail to satisfy. Making stuff go 'boom' should fill me with joy, otherwise I have become too disaffected for my own good.
Of course, I tend to preach gameplay over graphics, so it should go without saying that lackluster explosions are not my only complaint with the demo. I was jazzed when I read that Darkstar One had full joystick support. Mine had been gathering dust recently, while I was on a bender of first-person shooters and third-person RPGs. With the sliding functionality that is available, I wanted to bind that to my hat-switch, where I am used to having it from my days in Descent. The hat may not have any controls bound to it though, as it is reserved for an external camera (which also does not work how you might expect it to). I have enough buttons around the hat that I stitched together an alternative configuration for that. On to defining the throttle axis. To do that, you need to close Darkstar One and pick another game off the shelf.
The control problems do not end with the joystick either. I cannot speak much to the positioning of the keys in the default configuration, since reconfiguring the controls is something I do before even launching a training mission. For many of the keys, issues lie in them not functioning in the way you would expect them to or in a way that is as inconvenient as breathing inside a sealed plastic bag. Take throttle control for example. One key is mapped to "accelerate" and one key is mapped to "brake." To me, that means one key, while held down, will smoothly increase my throttle from zero to maximum over a short interval, and the other key will decrease it in the same way. The way Darkstar One actually handles acceleration and deceleration is by having taps of one key or the other represent a twenty-percent increase or decrease in throttle. Let's listen to Kayron's internal monologue for a moment....
I thought there would be a catch when I heard my dad had willed the most advanced ship in the universe to me. He knew I couldn't drive clutch.
Beyond that, many control functions require you to move the mouse about while holding a key. For example, you have a ... a ... a thing that is never described terribly well but can provide a variety of effects, such as boosting your shield recharge rate or refilling your weapon energy. Using the currently-selected effect is a simple key stroke or button tap, but changing the effect you want to use involves holding down the menu key (thereby disabling mouse-flight, if you are using it) and using an unlabeled button/menu at the bottom of the screen. Missile selection and all but the most basic targeting are handled in an equally clumsy manner.
Once you get past the controls, combat is still pretty unsatisfying. The piloting AI seems to be as dumb as a stone, and the combat model seems designed for those who thought that Freelancer's learning curve was too steep. How dumbed-down could it possibly be? For those of you who do not know what a lead-indicator is, no worries. Instead of learning how to aim, just point the nose of your ship directly at the hostile craft, and when the lead-indicator turns yellow/green, your guns will lead their own shots. Granted, in the distant future, such technology is not far-fetched, but when you already have an AI completely incapable of shaking a determined attacker, giving the player even more assistance just makes combat that much more boring.
Darkstar One does pick up points over Freelancer in that it has a slightly dynamic universe. Trade prices actually fluctuate between visits to any given station. Though this could have been a breath of fresh air for people who like playing open-universe games as interstellar traders, it is one more feature that falls flat on its face. Though it is satisfying to be able to watch prices fluctuate in real-time as freighters unload their cargo and listen to the public announcement system call out blurbs about major events affecting demand in local systems, it slows the pace. This is because the news terminals do not carry any information about what incoming freighters have or what cost-affecting events have occurred recently. If you want to know what is going on, you have to watch the trading window and listen to the announcements. You would get more excitement out of watching CNN and playing the real stock market all day long.
Now, if you go to the Darkstar One website, they make the story out to be the saving grace of the game. Naturally, the demo barely gives you a taste of the prologue. To summarize the story so far, your father gets killed. A buddy rustles up information on the guy who did it. To continue following the story, you must purchase the full game. That does not sound terribly compelling, but the problem might have more to do with the demo getting cut off too early, rather than at a point where you will be itching to find out what happens next. Regarding the delivery of the plot, it is strictly average. The cutscenes are beautiful, but prerendered. The voice acting is not as comedically bad as the Command & Conquer series, but it falls far short of the high bar set by the Baldur's Gate and FreeSpace series. In fact, most of the voice acting is so flat, that it sounds like the cast was just trying to get the lines done, so that they could collect their checks and go home.
My biggest itch from the plot comes from how they tried to shoehorn some of the gameplay elements in. Unlike Freelancer, you do not go out buying new ships to reach a new technological tier. The "roleplaying" element (and by that, they must mean Diablo-style strategy element) is that your ship is upgradeable and has that wonky thing-of-many-effects. See, as the game progresses, you gain experience or pick up artifacts or ... or ... or something, and those convert into upgrade points that you can use to improve your ship's hull, wings, or engine. It is hard to explain how it works, since there are conflicting explanations rooted in the apparent indecision regarding the final implementation. One character, while speaking in-character (as opposed to a tutorial) says, "You're literally able to expand your ship when you have enough experience." Sure... Have the characters mention experience points.... That's a great way to suspend my disbelief. Then, as quickly as they were mentioned, the tutorial missions throw experience points out the window, and artifact-collection becomes the new upgrade medium. Playing through the demo, I saw evidence of both systems (collecting artifacts from asteroids and spontaneously being told I got one after completing a plot point). The thing-of-many-effects suffers a similar bit of indecision, more in naming than in implementation. It is called a plasma cannon in the readme, though most of its functions do not actually involve shooting anything. The website calls it a spell-system, which is a more accurate comparison, but way off-theme for a science fiction game. In the demo, it is called a plasma-thrower twice and never mentioned again. That was probably for the best.
Demos were always meant to serve as a peek of what a game should ultimately shape up to be. From what I can see, Darkstar One is going to be strictly average with bad controls. I certainly do not believe the "...everything Freelancer should have been..." hype anymore, and unless you are really eager to get your hands on a Freelancer clone, I would recommend keeping away from Darkstar One. Personally, I will either wait for it to hit the bargain bin or give the game a miss altogether.
If you don't trust the judgement I used when writing this review, you can always download the demo yourself (a list of download mirrors is available on the Darkstar One website under the July 4th news post).
Oh! I mustn't forget the title! I think somebody was counting his sequels before they hatched.
Regarding Darkstar One specifically, it has been getting hyped as being everything Freelancer should have been. Certainly, there elements shared with Freelancer in there. In fact, it is hard to describe Darkstar One except in terms of Freelancer. The sheer size of Darkstar One in most respects is about an order of magnitude larger than Freelancer. Looking at the galaxy, the demo contains but a single corner of the star chart as a whole, but that little corner of the chart has as many systems as a third of the Freelancer galaxy. The systems themselves are larger in actual and apparent size, as the trade lane idea was abandoned in favor of time-compression. Alas, all of these star systems mean little, since most of them look nearly identical to each other. In each system, you'll enter facing a planet with a moon or two; there will be an asteroid belt to the side; there will be a trade station near the planet, and there might be a research station or a large asteroid with a mining station in it. The trade stations are all uniform. The research stations are all uniform. Though that might be expected, the fact that the asteroids being mined are all exactly alike in every way was a supreme disappointment.
Back on the topic of size, if there is one thing I always pay close attention to in a space flight game, it is the sense of scale. The sense of scale was my one complaint with FreeSpace and the most immediately apparent flaw with Freelancer. (I remember ramming a moon before it took up my entire field of view in Freelancer.) Darkstar One is a little more hit-and-miss than other titles. Whereas other space flight games get their scales wrong or really wrong, the magnitude of the screw-up is consistent. Darkstar One seems to have gone through three different scales throughout development. Most of the planets actually feel like small planets (at least that is in the ballpark). The huge shipwreck of a battleship in the demo looks mildly imposing, though it is certainly no GTVA Colossus. Space stations and freighters, however, have to beg the dustmites and subatomic particles to pick on somebody their own size.
Scale aside, the graphics left something to be desired. Granted, it is hard to make vacuum pretty, but I have come to expect some flashiness in my epic space battles. In FreeSpace 2, the sky would come alive with flak explosions, missile trails, beam fire, gasses venting from damaged fighters, shield impacts, etc., etc. That was six years ago. The Darkstar One demo has very little of that. Weapon impacts produce a muted effect; an unharmed ship looks no different from one nearly ready to explode, and though I have heard lock warnings, I have yet to see a missile in-flight. Hell, even the explosions fail to satisfy. Making stuff go 'boom' should fill me with joy, otherwise I have become too disaffected for my own good.
Of course, I tend to preach gameplay over graphics, so it should go without saying that lackluster explosions are not my only complaint with the demo. I was jazzed when I read that Darkstar One had full joystick support. Mine had been gathering dust recently, while I was on a bender of first-person shooters and third-person RPGs. With the sliding functionality that is available, I wanted to bind that to my hat-switch, where I am used to having it from my days in Descent. The hat may not have any controls bound to it though, as it is reserved for an external camera (which also does not work how you might expect it to). I have enough buttons around the hat that I stitched together an alternative configuration for that. On to defining the throttle axis. To do that, you need to close Darkstar One and pick another game off the shelf.
The control problems do not end with the joystick either. I cannot speak much to the positioning of the keys in the default configuration, since reconfiguring the controls is something I do before even launching a training mission. For many of the keys, issues lie in them not functioning in the way you would expect them to or in a way that is as inconvenient as breathing inside a sealed plastic bag. Take throttle control for example. One key is mapped to "accelerate" and one key is mapped to "brake." To me, that means one key, while held down, will smoothly increase my throttle from zero to maximum over a short interval, and the other key will decrease it in the same way. The way Darkstar One actually handles acceleration and deceleration is by having taps of one key or the other represent a twenty-percent increase or decrease in throttle. Let's listen to Kayron's internal monologue for a moment....
I thought there would be a catch when I heard my dad had willed the most advanced ship in the universe to me. He knew I couldn't drive clutch.
Beyond that, many control functions require you to move the mouse about while holding a key. For example, you have a ... a ... a thing that is never described terribly well but can provide a variety of effects, such as boosting your shield recharge rate or refilling your weapon energy. Using the currently-selected effect is a simple key stroke or button tap, but changing the effect you want to use involves holding down the menu key (thereby disabling mouse-flight, if you are using it) and using an unlabeled button/menu at the bottom of the screen. Missile selection and all but the most basic targeting are handled in an equally clumsy manner.
Once you get past the controls, combat is still pretty unsatisfying. The piloting AI seems to be as dumb as a stone, and the combat model seems designed for those who thought that Freelancer's learning curve was too steep. How dumbed-down could it possibly be? For those of you who do not know what a lead-indicator is, no worries. Instead of learning how to aim, just point the nose of your ship directly at the hostile craft, and when the lead-indicator turns yellow/green, your guns will lead their own shots. Granted, in the distant future, such technology is not far-fetched, but when you already have an AI completely incapable of shaking a determined attacker, giving the player even more assistance just makes combat that much more boring.
Darkstar One does pick up points over Freelancer in that it has a slightly dynamic universe. Trade prices actually fluctuate between visits to any given station. Though this could have been a breath of fresh air for people who like playing open-universe games as interstellar traders, it is one more feature that falls flat on its face. Though it is satisfying to be able to watch prices fluctuate in real-time as freighters unload their cargo and listen to the public announcement system call out blurbs about major events affecting demand in local systems, it slows the pace. This is because the news terminals do not carry any information about what incoming freighters have or what cost-affecting events have occurred recently. If you want to know what is going on, you have to watch the trading window and listen to the announcements. You would get more excitement out of watching CNN and playing the real stock market all day long.
Now, if you go to the Darkstar One website, they make the story out to be the saving grace of the game. Naturally, the demo barely gives you a taste of the prologue. To summarize the story so far, your father gets killed. A buddy rustles up information on the guy who did it. To continue following the story, you must purchase the full game. That does not sound terribly compelling, but the problem might have more to do with the demo getting cut off too early, rather than at a point where you will be itching to find out what happens next. Regarding the delivery of the plot, it is strictly average. The cutscenes are beautiful, but prerendered. The voice acting is not as comedically bad as the Command & Conquer series, but it falls far short of the high bar set by the Baldur's Gate and FreeSpace series. In fact, most of the voice acting is so flat, that it sounds like the cast was just trying to get the lines done, so that they could collect their checks and go home.
My biggest itch from the plot comes from how they tried to shoehorn some of the gameplay elements in. Unlike Freelancer, you do not go out buying new ships to reach a new technological tier. The "roleplaying" element (and by that, they must mean Diablo-style strategy element) is that your ship is upgradeable and has that wonky thing-of-many-effects. See, as the game progresses, you gain experience or pick up artifacts or ... or ... or something, and those convert into upgrade points that you can use to improve your ship's hull, wings, or engine. It is hard to explain how it works, since there are conflicting explanations rooted in the apparent indecision regarding the final implementation. One character, while speaking in-character (as opposed to a tutorial) says, "You're literally able to expand your ship when you have enough experience." Sure... Have the characters mention experience points.... That's a great way to suspend my disbelief. Then, as quickly as they were mentioned, the tutorial missions throw experience points out the window, and artifact-collection becomes the new upgrade medium. Playing through the demo, I saw evidence of both systems (collecting artifacts from asteroids and spontaneously being told I got one after completing a plot point). The thing-of-many-effects suffers a similar bit of indecision, more in naming than in implementation. It is called a plasma cannon in the readme, though most of its functions do not actually involve shooting anything. The website calls it a spell-system, which is a more accurate comparison, but way off-theme for a science fiction game. In the demo, it is called a plasma-thrower twice and never mentioned again. That was probably for the best.
Demos were always meant to serve as a peek of what a game should ultimately shape up to be. From what I can see, Darkstar One is going to be strictly average with bad controls. I certainly do not believe the "...everything Freelancer should have been..." hype anymore, and unless you are really eager to get your hands on a Freelancer clone, I would recommend keeping away from Darkstar One. Personally, I will either wait for it to hit the bargain bin or give the game a miss altogether.
If you don't trust the judgement I used when writing this review, you can always download the demo yourself (a list of download mirrors is available on the Darkstar One website under the July 4th news post).
Oh! I mustn't forget the title! I think somebody was counting his sequels before they hatched.
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
oooo, could be interesting. Ive still got to play X3 fully as i sorta installed it played for a few hours then had to reformat my puter. Havnt been back since.
Really hope this games hype lives up cos free lancer was a lotta fun
Really hope this games hype lives up cos free lancer was a lotta fun
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
I downloaded and installed the demo a few days ago but havent had a chance to try it yet. I'll post my thoughts when I do 
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
Well i grabbed the demo, and its a bit of fun. Its a good Cross between Freelancer and X3, ive got some high hopes for this.... although it is made by Asceron and although they make great games they are usualy buggy as hell.... ah well fun times ahead 
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
My favorite part of Freelancer was our multiplayer server.
Having us all on Teamspeak, running trades and missions, plotting courses, was fantastic. Sadly it was over in what, 45 days?
Does this have multi?
Having us all on Teamspeak, running trades and missions, plotting courses, was fantastic. Sadly it was over in what, 45 days?
Does this have multi?
No signature
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
An inferior Freelancer.
{No Thanks!}
The only thing that made Freelancer worthwhile was what Quiz reminisced about. I have my drugs for now.
{No Thanks!}
The only thing that made Freelancer worthwhile was what Quiz reminisced about. I have my drugs for now.
-
Kon
- Posts: 1528
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
- Location: USA
Sounds like crap.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."
-
Stracius
- Posts: 1471
- Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2004 4:02 pm
- Location: under the starry night sky
Well at least someone's trying to put out space sim games. Kudos on the effort, even if they may have failed on the execution. If this one fails big time, I just hope it doesn't contribute to scaring other companies away from the genre. 
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
Ah the days of Freelancer MP... lol. If darkstar has MP like Free lancer...im all for it lol, atm it seems like a pretty decent game which shouldnt really be compared to much.
But in the end the only thing we can blame....
Is M$ for not releaseing Freelancer 2
But in the end the only thing we can blame....
Is M$ for not releaseing Freelancer 2
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
They really should stay the hell away from the genre until they're able to bring someone with skills to the table.Stracius wrote:Well at least someone's trying to put out space sim games. Kudos on the effort, even if they may have failed on the execution. If this one fails big time, I just hope it doesn't contribute to scaring other companies away from the genre.
And there isn't anyone more skilled than Volition in 1999.
-
BlueFlames
- Posts: 465
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
- Location: SSX Vault 12
That's fine and dandy, but until you start delivering us games via your magical time machine, those of us in the real world are itching for something new in the space sim genre. Darkstar One isn't the quality I'm looking for, but developers can't strike gold if they are avoiding the genre altogether.There isn't anyone more skilled than Volition in 1999.
-
Stracius
- Posts: 1471
- Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2004 4:02 pm
- Location: under the starry night sky
Or get any practice in. But yeah, my point exactly.
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
Then you speak for yourself. Any additional crappy space-sim game is really only tarnishing the genre reputation.BlueFlames wrote:That's fine and dandy, but until you start delivering us games via your magical time machine, those of us in the real world are itching for something new in the space sim genre. Darkstar One isn't the quality I'm looking for, but developers can't strike gold if they are avoiding the genre altogether.There isn't anyone more skilled than Volition in 1999.
If you can't do it right, don't do it at all.
And yes, considering time machines aren't viable, my suggestion was to drop the genre all together if anything decent can't be produced.
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
Way i see it, if its fun for a coupla days its doing better than most games out there. Cant hope for a mona lisa in the days of the 10 hour game now can we
Plus me loves space sims, and if ya really feel that they have to be perfect everytime.... werl u might as well start making it now
Plus me loves space sims, and if ya really feel that they have to be perfect everytime.... werl u might as well start making it now
-
BlackDove
- Posts: 3067
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
- Location: Denial
-
Stracius
- Posts: 1471
- Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2004 4:02 pm
- Location: under the starry night sky
Thank god not everyone follows that idealism. Thomas Edison would never brought us light bulbsBlackDove wrote:If you can't do it right, don't do it at all.
To this I say "Bah". Just because you feel all warm and fuzzy when you think about a genre doesn't mean that nobody else should touch it. If you don't like it, ignore it. But if you ever want a chance at gaining more "gem" games, flops are going to be an inevitable part of the process.
edit add:: Don't get me wrong, I would hope that game makers could just crank out high quality games every time. But hell, I'm a realist. I accept that's not always going to happen, no matter how much one may hope. And the pic of the project looks fantastic
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
Whats that a screen shot of BD? Looks like X3 (really have to finish that one day lol)
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
*Dreams of the release date*
And for those not in the know, its a BWO screenshot. A custom campaign for FS2 SCP.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
Serberus
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2004 2:07 am
- Yahoo Messenger: serberus@internode.on.net
Cool beans, wasnt sure at first... I recon making a game (from scratch) in this genre would be awsome fun. But i spose makeing it from an existing one is cool nuff 
-
requiemdreamer
- Posts: 500
- Joined: Sun May 29, 2005 12:16 am
- Location: CNY
Hmmm. Not too bad of a game. I did get a little bored with fighting pirate ships and kept losing track of things. Damn pirates spinning me everywhere that I forgot what direction I was heading in after I kill them all. 
(US) Mannoroth Server
Warlock: Requiemdream
Shaman: Saeglopur
The imprisoner of souls into tiny little purple gem things.
Warlock: Requiemdream
Shaman: Saeglopur
The imprisoner of souls into tiny little purple gem things.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
Finally tried this. Not impressed at all. I agree with BF at the heart of it, stay away from Darkstar. Its like the developer tried to do a cross between FS2 and Freelancer and came out with something so-so.
Combat is ok, once you remap the absurdly defined keys for a space shooter, until you actually hit something. Absolutely no effects. FS2 was made in 1999 and it had beam cannons visibly tearing through hull, debris falling from ships after impact, flames, smoke, etc. Darkstar has nothing until you're one hit away from killing an enemy. Weapons fire just hits the hull, does no visible damage at all, and then at one hit from death great clouds of smoke billow from no-where. The only way I could actually tell I was hitting the enemy was the shouts of the AI through my speakers.
Reverse thrust also makes combat less enjoyable. I played FS2 and enjoyed some sense of realism, it took a moment or two for a ship to slow down to zero thrust, as it would do when slowing down. Darkstar? Nope. I hit reverse thrust and whooooooa, Im reversing within 5 seconds. Realistic? No.
The 'Freelancer' aspect is better, the potential to explore a massive universe, until you get to docking. Freelancer had automated docking, to avoid the frustrations of manual attempts failing etc, in some respects I'd say that it was perhaps too automated. Every potentially tricky task was done by the game. However this game goes a step too far in the other direction. Request Permission to Dock when the training mission tells me, fly towards the open docking doors, they slam shut on me, and the game's horrible thruster system means I go careering into it. Attempt two, I get through the doors only to respawn 2 clicks (or whatever they're called) away from the station. Every time I tried, one of those two responses from the game. I tried for nearly 30 mins before giving up and just closing the game.
The idea behind the game is good, and the cutscenes look fantastic. However in implementation this game falls far short of what it could be. A big let down for me. /sigh
Combat is ok, once you remap the absurdly defined keys for a space shooter, until you actually hit something. Absolutely no effects. FS2 was made in 1999 and it had beam cannons visibly tearing through hull, debris falling from ships after impact, flames, smoke, etc. Darkstar has nothing until you're one hit away from killing an enemy. Weapons fire just hits the hull, does no visible damage at all, and then at one hit from death great clouds of smoke billow from no-where. The only way I could actually tell I was hitting the enemy was the shouts of the AI through my speakers.
Reverse thrust also makes combat less enjoyable. I played FS2 and enjoyed some sense of realism, it took a moment or two for a ship to slow down to zero thrust, as it would do when slowing down. Darkstar? Nope. I hit reverse thrust and whooooooa, Im reversing within 5 seconds. Realistic? No.
The 'Freelancer' aspect is better, the potential to explore a massive universe, until you get to docking. Freelancer had automated docking, to avoid the frustrations of manual attempts failing etc, in some respects I'd say that it was perhaps too automated. Every potentially tricky task was done by the game. However this game goes a step too far in the other direction. Request Permission to Dock when the training mission tells me, fly towards the open docking doors, they slam shut on me, and the game's horrible thruster system means I go careering into it. Attempt two, I get through the doors only to respawn 2 clicks (or whatever they're called) away from the station. Every time I tried, one of those two responses from the game. I tried for nearly 30 mins before giving up and just closing the game.
The idea behind the game is good, and the cutscenes look fantastic. However in implementation this game falls far short of what it could be. A big let down for me. /sigh
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
esd
- Posts: 986
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 2:25 am
- Location: Somewhere
This has come up over at Egosoft too. Seems quite a dissapointed response to it over the 6 pages the thread takes up. A key quote from Stevemills:
I've recently picked up X3 again after playing the DS demo and there is no comparison. We're talking 2 different genres. X3 is a space sim. DS, like Freelancer, is an arcade blaster bolted onto a graphical adventure.
""I like my women like I like my coffee. In a plastic cup.""
-
Futile Resistance
- Posts: 1454
- Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 10:44 pm
- Location: FL
So it's like... Comparing Need for Speed and Grand Turismo/Forza Motorsports... Yea?esd wrote:This has come up over at Egosoft too. Seems quite a dissapointed response to it over the 6 pages the thread takes up.
Sounds like a great pickup space action game - not too much of a learning curve (X-series was insane, but well worth it).
