NWN 2 Review pulled from 1up.com

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

NWN 2 Review pulled from 1up.com

PostPosted: Sun Nov 05, 2006 4:29 pm

User avatar
Fenavian
Posts: 1164
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 9:55 pm
Location: Here.
I generally go by reviews on either 1up.com or Computer Gaming World which has recently been changed to Games For Windows: The official magazine. They are generally a great source of information on the latest games and for the most part their reviews are pretty spot on.

Just the other day, 1up and GFW did something a bit unprecedented. They pulled the NWN 2 review off their site. 1up posted this article on thir site posting an apology and briefly outlining why they did what they did. Jeff Green posted up on his blog an extensive list of the chain of events that went down before the pulling of the article.

This is the article in question:
Quote: By Matt Peckham
This review appears in the January issue of Games For Windows: The Official Magazine.

-

As everything-the-original-did and more follow-ups go, Neverwinter Nights 2 deserves a banner&something like mission accomplished. Think the sequel to Jurassic Park, where Spielbergs all You want more dinosaurs? Ill show you more dinosaurs As a contemporary CRPG, on the other hand, NWN2 leaves a lot to be desired, and thats too bad, because these are the guys who brought us Planescape: Torment and Icewind Dale 2and therefore they are the guys Im least inclined to take issue with.

But issues exist, and defining them is really no more complex than saying, Hello D&D superchrome, buh-bye storytelling and character development (you know, those things youre supposed to immerse yourself in). The idea seems to be that were meant to rah-rah about a superabundance of feats, spells, races, prestige (advanced) classes, and math-equation tickers full of the usual I attack you with a +4 sword of booooooring. Fine, sure, dandybut when is a role not a role? Simple: when its a rule to a fault.

Ever loyal bites
Im cruising for a bruising (dont I know it), but NWN2 is a splash of cold water to the face: A revelatory, polarizing experience that in the wake of newer, better alternatives makes you question the very notion of RPG by numbers. It foists Wizards of the Coasts latest v3.5 D&D system (a molehill thats become a mountain at this point) onto your hard drive with stunning fidelity, then tacks on dozens of artificial-looking areas vaguely linked by forget-table plot points you check off like grocery to-dos.

Sure, the interface is sleeker with context-sensitive menus and a smart little bar that lets you more intuitively toggle modes like power attack and stealth, but with all the added rule-shuffling, NWN2 seems like its working twice as hard to accomplish half as much. Worse and blame this on games like Oblivion NWN2s levels feel pint-sized: Peewee zones inhabited by pull-string NPCs with no existence to speak of beyond their little playpens. Wander and youll wonder why the forests, towns, and dungeons are like movie lots with lay-about monsters waiting patiently for you to trip their arbitrary triggers. As if the pencil and paper module approach were a virtue that computers by now demonstrably capable of simulating entire worlds with considerably more depth should emulate. Its like were supposed to park half our brain in feature mania and the rest in nostalgic slush, and somehow call bingo.

The dungeons feel especially stale, so linear and inorganic they might as well be graph-paper lifts filled with room after room of pop-up bogeymen (Doom put them in closets; NWN2 just makes the closets bigger). Maybe youd rather chat with the dumb NPCs that speak and sound like extras in a bad Saturday morning cartoon? Oh, boy theres the portrait plus sign! Time to shuffle another party member (improved to four simultaneous) through the level-up grinder, which you can click recommend to zip pastbut then, whats the point?

Rule-playing game
In all fairness, its not entirely developer Obsidians fault. D&D certainly puts the rule in role-playing, and a madcap base of D&D aficionados is no doubt ready to string me up for suggesting that faithful is here tantamount to folly (to these people, I say: Go for it, NWN2s all youve ever wanted and more). Call me crazy I guess Im just finally weary of being led around on a pencil-and-paper leash and batting numbers around a glorified three-dimensional spreadsheet in a computer translation that should have synthesized, not forklifted.

That five-of-10 is actually a hedge, by the way. For D&D fans who want to play an amazingly thorough PC translation of the system theyre carting around in book form, its proba-bly closer an eight or nine. But if, like me, you want less rules for rules sake and more depth and beauty to your simulated game worlds, you can certainly find more exciting prospects. Part of the reason we call them the good old days and think fondly of games past is that its always easier to love what we dont have to play anymore.
5 out of 10... Wow.

A lot of people felt that Matt was attacking the games genre itself rather than rating the game. I can certainly see that in his article. The worst thing is that it was even worse before it was actually put to print. *shrugs*

For good or ill the damage has been done. unfortunatly it looks like their rep will take a hit but I am sure they will ride things out.
01000101011100110110001101101000011001010111011100100000011011110110001001
10011001110101011100110110001101100001011101000110100101101111011011100010
1110

PostPosted: Sun Nov 05, 2006 11:10 pm

User avatar
Padishar
Posts: 1713
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:15 pm
Location: Next Door
This is another example of why I quit buying PCGamer and ComputerGamingWorld and now go off of 'collective' ratings on games. That way you get an overall opinion of why folks like it and dis-like it instead of individual crackpots...

PostPosted: Mon Nov 06, 2006 8:36 am

User avatar
Fenavian
Posts: 1164
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 9:55 pm
Location: Here.
Welp as I said on the phone, CGW for the past few months has been printing broad "reviews". They don't use a scoring system anymore and post up scores from a few other areas on the intarweb.

Also I think reviews are fairly important to me as i don't have the cash to drop for every game I "might" be interested in. Console games sure. I can rent those. But PC games? PC game demos more often than not do not reflect the end game product, so I can't base my opinions off of that as much anymore.

The article didn't reflect the kind of quality they usually produce, so i can respect the fact that they wish to remove it and what not.
01000101011100110110001101101000011001010111011100100000011011110110001001
10011001110101011100110110001101100001011101000110100101101111011011100010
1110

PostPosted: Wed Nov 08, 2006 6:44 am

User avatar
Padishar
Posts: 1713
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:15 pm
Location: Next Door
There is a follow up @ 1up:
Here

Return to “General Discussions”