Vanguard, The WOW Killer
Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators
-
Eli
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Sun Nov 12, 2006 12:52 am
- Location: Long Island, New York
I have been reading up on the soon-to-be-released MMO, Vanguard - Saga of Heroes. I must say, it appears very promising. Has anyone else been following the progress of this game, and do you believe it might be the MMO that replaces WOW?
-
Inquisitor
- Posts: 3411
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 12:46 am
- Yahoo Messenger: irobot_99
- Location: SSX
Hey, welcome!
We don't currently allow animated avatars, mostly a self policing thing.
Thanks!
As for MMO's I still play FFXII, so, I don;t need a WoW replacement
We don't currently allow animated avatars, mostly a self policing thing.
Thanks!
As for MMO's I still play FFXII, so, I don;t need a WoW replacement
No signature
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
I've read a little about the game. It looks promising. Personally reminds me a little of Oblivion. - However it doesn't strike my interests as much as The Chronicles of Spellborn has over the last few months.
As for toppling the Might of World of Warcraft well... that will remain to be seen. There are far more hyped about games on the horizon that have more chance of that in my honest opinion.
As for toppling the Might of World of Warcraft well... that will remain to be seen. There are far more hyped about games on the horizon that have more chance of that in my honest opinion.
-
Ash
- Posts: 554
- Joined: Thu Jan 20, 2005 1:15 pm
- Location: Manchester, UK
Vanguard does look ok, whether its going to be a WoW killer
is another issue.
Personally I'm watching Age of Conan, but I could easily
have a dabble with Vanguard.
If anyone does get it on release, just remember to
post what server you are playing one for the rest of us.

is another issue.
Personally I'm watching Age of Conan, but I could easily
have a dabble with Vanguard.
If anyone does get it on release, just remember to
post what server you are playing one for the rest of us.
Ash
The quiet one in the corner
The quiet one in the corner
-
Padishar
- Posts: 1713
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:15 pm
- Location: Next Door
Been trying to keep an eye on most big production MMO's for years since they were first introduced.
I got a link to a couple to follow including Vanguard listed:
Here
Not sure how much of a 'WoW' killer Vanguard is going to be, but it might give folks that are looking for an alternative mostly what they need (ie. a bit more meat with their potatoes).
I think it will be a looong while before something topples WoW in the global success department.
<------------- Don't have to read past here as the rest is just my rant on the reason why..
It all has to do with proven game play history and popularity. Before MMO's there were text based MUD's (Multi User Dungeons) and they were extremely popular.
Everquest (EQ) was the first game to take the popularity and style of MUD's and bring it to the MMO scene. Much of its core gameplay was taken from the DikuMUD, an already popular MUD created in 1990.
Ok, but what does all that have to do with WoW you might ask?
Well its simple, I like to call WoW......
Everquest 2: WoW Mod
When Blizzard was looking in to making an MMO, EQ was the hottest thing since sliced bread at the time. So what did they do?
They copied EQ, wholesale.
Didn't even bother changing most the names of the classes/powers either.
They took most of the gameplay and striped it down to bare powers, then crunched the classes together removing even more powers/skills/attrib...
could call that streamlining it or simplifying the choices/options.
Then, they oversimplified everything else to almost console like proportions, added Warcraft look and lore.. and POOF.
WoW as you know it.
Which ironically is EXACTLY what MMO games needed.
Something to bring MMO's out of just computergeekdom and into mainstream society. More people then ever play MMO's thx to WoW... shoot more people own computers and play computer games now as well thx to WoW. No MMO is more family friendly, it even allows 5 year olds to play with the elderly..... yes it is THAT simple.
Oops.. as a side note, before I forget to mention....
it does look like Bliz tried to come up with a handful of their own ideas but gave up (an example would be the racial spell for priests), either due to lack of time or fear they would upset the already done an proven to work cashcow universe.
So no, I don't believe Vanguard (which is essentially Everquest 3) will be a WoW killer, as it will most likely be adding to its old predecessors, instead of stripping down/over simplifying them, as WoW has done. Which when given too many options or any sort of learning curve... tends to over complicate the game for the average consumer.
Eventually the MMO community will mature to the point that the general consumer will want to move past Seaseme Street to Adult Swim and WoW will finally get surpased... but I don't think we are even close to that point yet.
I know there is a market for vets an ol'timers however (myself included), who have already been playing variations of the same game (ie. MUD's, EQ, WoW, etc.) for more then 16 years now and want something more....
So hopefully Vanguard or something similar will be it, time will tell.
I got a link to a couple to follow including Vanguard listed:
Here
Not sure how much of a 'WoW' killer Vanguard is going to be, but it might give folks that are looking for an alternative mostly what they need (ie. a bit more meat with their potatoes).
I think it will be a looong while before something topples WoW in the global success department.
<------------- Don't have to read past here as the rest is just my rant on the reason why..
It all has to do with proven game play history and popularity. Before MMO's there were text based MUD's (Multi User Dungeons) and they were extremely popular.
Everquest (EQ) was the first game to take the popularity and style of MUD's and bring it to the MMO scene. Much of its core gameplay was taken from the DikuMUD, an already popular MUD created in 1990.
Ok, but what does all that have to do with WoW you might ask?
Well its simple, I like to call WoW......
Everquest 2: WoW Mod
When Blizzard was looking in to making an MMO, EQ was the hottest thing since sliced bread at the time. So what did they do?
They copied EQ, wholesale.
Didn't even bother changing most the names of the classes/powers either.
They took most of the gameplay and striped it down to bare powers, then crunched the classes together removing even more powers/skills/attrib...
could call that streamlining it or simplifying the choices/options.
Then, they oversimplified everything else to almost console like proportions, added Warcraft look and lore.. and POOF.
WoW as you know it.
Which ironically is EXACTLY what MMO games needed.
Something to bring MMO's out of just computergeekdom and into mainstream society. More people then ever play MMO's thx to WoW... shoot more people own computers and play computer games now as well thx to WoW. No MMO is more family friendly, it even allows 5 year olds to play with the elderly..... yes it is THAT simple.
Oops.. as a side note, before I forget to mention....
it does look like Bliz tried to come up with a handful of their own ideas but gave up (an example would be the racial spell for priests), either due to lack of time or fear they would upset the already done an proven to work cashcow universe.
So no, I don't believe Vanguard (which is essentially Everquest 3) will be a WoW killer, as it will most likely be adding to its old predecessors, instead of stripping down/over simplifying them, as WoW has done. Which when given too many options or any sort of learning curve... tends to over complicate the game for the average consumer.
Eventually the MMO community will mature to the point that the general consumer will want to move past Seaseme Street to Adult Swim and WoW will finally get surpased... but I don't think we are even close to that point yet.
I know there is a market for vets an ol'timers however (myself included), who have already been playing variations of the same game (ie. MUD's, EQ, WoW, etc.) for more then 16 years now and want something more....
So hopefully Vanguard or something similar will be it, time will tell.
Last edited by Padishar on Sat Nov 25, 2006 6:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Isileth
- Posts: 1011
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2005 4:45 pm
- Location: UK
Have to agree with you there on a lot of points. I still play muds because they are simple and let you get down to the real game play without trying to throw to many things at you.
Now ive never played WoW or really any MMORPG apart from a spell in AO, but ive never really been interested in them. Everything seems much to stat related, whoever has x item and y skill is best etc. The closest representation to the good ole fashioned muds that I tend to loiter in would be GW. It just strips down all the crap and lets you get on with the game. However during long lonely nights searching the forums there is always a plethora of posts about people wanting the game to be more complex or introduce WoW like gameplay. I guess there is a market for both sides but I really dont see WoW being knocked down in anyways for a while yet. So many people play and have so much time invested that a lot im sure will want to stay till most of the playerbase has gone.
Now ive never played WoW or really any MMORPG apart from a spell in AO, but ive never really been interested in them. Everything seems much to stat related, whoever has x item and y skill is best etc. The closest representation to the good ole fashioned muds that I tend to loiter in would be GW. It just strips down all the crap and lets you get on with the game. However during long lonely nights searching the forums there is always a plethora of posts about people wanting the game to be more complex or introduce WoW like gameplay. I guess there is a market for both sides but I really dont see WoW being knocked down in anyways for a while yet. So many people play and have so much time invested that a lot im sure will want to stay till most of the playerbase has gone.
-
Futile Resistance
- Posts: 1454
- Joined: Tue Sep 07, 2004 10:44 pm
- Location: FL
I recall the "Vanguard: The WoW Killer" quote in some gaming magazine.
However, if you visit the boards, Sigil developers will tell you they never meant the game to be a "WoW Killer".
From what I've played in the Beta, there will be consequences upon death, from corpse run to XP penalty. It is NOT meant for WoW casual gamers. It's more geared towards LVL 60 WoW gamers who're bored of doing the same runs over and over.
However, if you visit the boards, Sigil developers will tell you they never meant the game to be a "WoW Killer".
From what I've played in the Beta, there will be consequences upon death, from corpse run to XP penalty. It is NOT meant for WoW casual gamers. It's more geared towards LVL 60 WoW gamers who're bored of doing the same runs over and over.
