Harry Potter & the DH (WARNING CONTAINS SPOILERS)

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

Harry Potter & the DH (WARNING CONTAINS SPOILERS)

PostPosted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 5:40 pm

User avatar
Lazlo Hollyfeld
Posts: 186
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 11:20 pm
Location: the basement
this thread is for people who have read the book and want to discuss it openly, so if you haven't read the book, and don't want to see spoilers, please don't read further.

there was a previous thread about this book, and in it several people said they'd read it, but the thread title said "no spoilers", so people were being kind of vague about their comments.

i just finished it early this morning (after re-reading the first 6 books so they'd be fresh in my mind). i thought it was fantastic...probably my fav book of the series. she did an awesome job of bringing together all the details from the previous book.

my favorite parts of the book included:

1) what she did with kreacher....what a surprise, and very well done...
2) though not completely surprising; snape's story was great
3) when you find out harry named his son severus

i didn't have many negative thoughts on the book, with maybe one exception....the scene where ron walked out on harry and hermione didn't make a lot of sense to me....it didn't seem like something ron would do.

i have two questions about snape:

1) dumbledore told harry the reason he had "conquered death" was because he accepted it willingly for selfless and noble reasons, didn't snape do the same thing; maybe even more impressively? do you think snape had the same choice as harry (to go back or go on) when he reached kings cross?

2) i think snape really was the bravest guy in the story...how the heck did he end up in slytherin rather than gryffindor?

as for the deaths in the books, interestingly, the saddest one for me was dobby; how awesome was he in the end?

if you haven't already seen it, the wikipedia article on the book includes a statement made by jk rowlings giving more info on some of the main and secondary characters like ron, hermione, harry, ginny, george, luna, neville, and firenze...

it seems though like she left some holes:

was there any mention of what happens to mcgonagall? it didn't say if she was still teaching at hogwarts 19 years later...

what happened to the dursleys?

what happened to hagrid?

finally, jk has stated that she'd write book 7 in a way that would make writing future books about harry impossible. i don't see that....it seems there are lots of possibilities for future books;

1) she could write about the new kids at hogwarts: albus severus, james, lily, rose, hugo, and scorpius...(by the way, who were rose and hugo named after?)
2) she could write a prequel about dumbledore
3) she could even continue writing about harry....after all, he's only 36 and the elder wand hasn't been destroyed....if someone was able to take that wand from harry, couldn't a new dark wizard rise?

what do you think?
"you see, most blokes, you know, will be playing at ten. you're on ten here, all the way up, all the way up, all the way up, you're on ten on your guitar. where can you go from there? where?"
-nigel tufnel

PostPosted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 5:51 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
My full review, rather than the edited version I posted in the other thread.
So I just finished reading it and am, overall, quite impressed. I had figured that after I hated HBP so much this would continue in the same vein and I would be massively disappointed. Thankfully that wasn't the case. Mostly.

My thoughts are first and foremost that the overall darker tone of the book suits it well. I have to admit I was afraid that Rowling would turn it into a tale of mushy proportions just to keep it a happy family story but she seems to have had no reservations in taking things where they needed (imo) to go, including the killing off of characters to impress the tone of the ongoing situation upon readers which I had felt she might try to avoid (having them all safely locked up at the new HQ for the whole book for example, with them always being safe when they got back there regardless of what else happened). I think that all things considered I prefer the completely darker overtone this book had over the overtones of all the previous books, but as I deem darker tales to be far more interesting reads that is hardly surprising.

She continues to write conflict well (well, if we ignore any and all conflict from HBP that is) and when events begin to spiral forwards it becomes very difficult to put the book down. There was a span of the last 200ish pages, from Bill and Fleur's Cottage onwards, that I read in one sitting (something Id been trying not to do before that so that I took it all in) simply because it kept me very engrossed, Overall I was not let down by the way things were wrapped up, to my surprise, and felt that it was very clever and fitting the way she had wove the tale from disjointed threads left by the other books into a smooth ending. I must admit, however, being surprised that Pettigrew's life debt was not more important than the twinkle in GoF in the overall scheme of things. I'd been banking on Pettigrew playing a large role in the final battle and a Redeemed!Pettigrew after re-reading the previous books.

Despite this though I can't proclaim the book to be perfect. Whilst the book wasn't a mushy romance novel like HBP when they crept up the references to romance annoyed me greatly, and in some places it was frankly completely inappropriate (specifically Ron and Hermione getting it on in front of the Room of Requirement as the castle is crumbling around them. Harry should have bitchslapped the horny morons). I also felt that, whilst throughout the majority of the book the usage of character death had been done to very good effect, there were several deaths particularly near to the end of the book that I felt were just thrown in as an excuse for Rowling to be able to do something else a few pages on, specifically Remus so that she could include him in the 'back from death' scene and Fred so it'd give Molly an excuse to duel with Bellatrix (and also, Molly killing Bellatrix? She must have been drunk when she wrote that...). Certain characters also remained alive that I felt would have been much better served being killed off in order to create a much more realistic means of pushing events onward as things drew to a close (Specifically Ginny, Ron, and Hermione here) One or more of their deaths would have spurred him on more to go and die for the greater good imo, and I felt that him just doing it without a drive of that kind was slightly unbelievable.

And then we come to the Epilogue. Ugh, what can I say about this chapter aside from the fact that it annoyed me the most in the book? Considering I absolutely despised the romance she set up in HBP I guess thats no surprise really, but seeing a future where Harry goes off and marries the girl that only liked him in the first place because he is famous, and Ron and Hermione marry after nearly coming to blows in every book stinks of being completely unrealistic to me. I was also very disappointed that we didn't see anything about what role Harry did/would have played in Teddy's life. I would have much preferred a chapter following directly on from the previous one, perhaps a few days in the future, detailing how things moved on in the immediate future rather than the fangirlish glossing over that we got.

To summarise, a fairly impressive book and better than what I had anticipated for the most part. Not perfect, but a very strong conclusion to the saga. 4/5
As for individual comments...
i didn't have many negative thoughts on the book, with maybe one exception....the scene where ron walked out on harry and hermione didn't make a lot of sense to me....it didn't seem like something ron would do.
Why not? He did it in Book 4 and at every opportunity has made it perfectly clear that he's a boy who completely fails to conquer his jealousy over Harry. He, as a character, has no loyalty to Harry simply because he can be swayed by the wind into hating him. The only surprise about the scene to me was that he put his pride aside and came back, THAT didn't seem something like Ron would do.

As for Snape, the naming of Harry's son 'Albus Severus Potter' is frankly one of the most stupid things Rowling wrote in the series, including anything in HBP. First off, Snape would be turning in his grave to know that there was a Potter named after him.
Second, Harry managed to put aside all of the hatred he had for Snape (including the trauma after Snape as good as mind-raped him) because he was in love with his mother? Somehow I see that as anything but realistic, I'd honestly see Harry more disgusted that such a cruel, bitter old man could have been crushing after his mother for years (and bordering on obsession what with the patronus). The idea that he'd take it all in his stride and make Snape his new hero or something is frankly beyond belief.
As for whether he saw 'Kings Cross' or not, I'd say no. The way I see it is that Harry only got there because in had, in essence, two souls in him at the time. One of those souls at least had to stay, but whilst he was in limbo he had the opportunity to choose whether or not he stayed with the horcrux-soul or let it alone take the brunt of the killing curse. Since Snape wasn't a horcrux, I doubt he could have ever gone into the same state of limbo. That said, thats just my interpretation - so on that I may be wrong.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Return to “General Discussions”