Who else is playing this? I've been playing since Friday and all I can say is the reviews do NOT do it justice - at least not the PC version. AI is pretty dumb, and there are noticable issues (stutter around load times for example), but nothing gamebreaking and certainly nothing to make the game deserve any less than 7-8/10 so far imo.
For those who have played an Obsidian game before, you'll know what to expect. Solid story that is not overly dramatic - instead choosing to be more serious and realistic. Characters are extremely solid too. The obligatory bugs are also present, but this being the first time Obsidian has actually developed their own gameplay (KOTOR 2 using KOTOR's, and NWN2 using NWN's) it's actually a damn good attempt.
Also, it includes what is perhaps the best boss fight in living memory. A Russian Arms Dealer named Brayko who's obsessed with the 80s. The fight takes place in his disco room, with him wielding gold plated SMGs. He can blind you with disco lights and take drugs to allow him to get high - at which point he turns psychotic and chases you around the room with a knife. All the while, Turn Up The Radio is blasting out in the background. Just so epic when you experience it.
According to BD, it also has an ending that will significantly diverge depending on choices (which, for the record, are REALLY well handled where things you decide have a massive impact on future levels and plot points). Apparently different peoples' endings seem to be pretty wildly different. I am looking forward to completing it, then replaying in a different style to see how things could otherwise play out.
The console versions are the ones seeming to be getting all the reviews and getting slated, so I'm not sure I could recommend playing it on them. But the PC version is pretty great, and if only the AI were a bit smarter and more complex in terms of their pathing, it'd be a pretty much perfect game from an RPG standpoint.
Alpha Protocol
Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
SSX-Ava
- Posts: 691
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
- Location: Yorkshire, UK
Played the Pc version myself and I couldn't stand to play another second of it.
The AI is not just abit dumb its broken, they run at you when you are blasting them from cover with an Assault rifle to stab you in the face. They dont try and take cover themselves either, instead they opt for standing in the middle of the hallways. Grenade throwing is another example of the stupidity of the AI. Simply throw a grenade at the feet of 3 enemies and watch as they dont flinch a muscle. They really are hardcore to not be scared enough to run away from my grenades.
I've noticed the AI standing dead on the spot half in doors, running on the spot, standing facing walls, not reacting when i knifed an enemy when two were stood together and casually walking past as one of their allies was on fire.
In my oppinion I wouldn't class this as a stealth game either as the only way to actually stealth through an area is to go invisible. Forget about using your enviroment or disposing of the bodies or anything that you've grown to love about stealth killing. All you have to do is hit INVISIBLE PLX and watch as you clear the entire room in seconds.
Also forget about lining up that perfect head shot too, because it doesnt come down to skill in the early stages of the game it comes down to how many points you've put into each weapon. So even if you aim directly from the face unless you've talented it enough you're gunna miss and alert the other enemies.
All these glaring problems take away any immersion i may have felt to the point it became unplayable.
I can't comment on the complexity of the story having only played around 6 hours or so, which is where it shines with the sheer amount of decisions and consequences that can be otained.
The AI is not just abit dumb its broken, they run at you when you are blasting them from cover with an Assault rifle to stab you in the face. They dont try and take cover themselves either, instead they opt for standing in the middle of the hallways. Grenade throwing is another example of the stupidity of the AI. Simply throw a grenade at the feet of 3 enemies and watch as they dont flinch a muscle. They really are hardcore to not be scared enough to run away from my grenades.
I've noticed the AI standing dead on the spot half in doors, running on the spot, standing facing walls, not reacting when i knifed an enemy when two were stood together and casually walking past as one of their allies was on fire.
In my oppinion I wouldn't class this as a stealth game either as the only way to actually stealth through an area is to go invisible. Forget about using your enviroment or disposing of the bodies or anything that you've grown to love about stealth killing. All you have to do is hit INVISIBLE PLX and watch as you clear the entire room in seconds.
Also forget about lining up that perfect head shot too, because it doesnt come down to skill in the early stages of the game it comes down to how many points you've put into each weapon. So even if you aim directly from the face unless you've talented it enough you're gunna miss and alert the other enemies.
All these glaring problems take away any immersion i may have felt to the point it became unplayable.
I can't comment on the complexity of the story having only played around 6 hours or so, which is where it shines with the sheer amount of decisions and consequences that can be otained.
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
I won't be playing it for another month or two as you know but thought I would add my 2 cents from watching Ava play the PC version.
- AI being dumb is an understatement imo, some of the worst I have seen in recent years. Of course that may depend on how you're actually playing the game to see their true reactions but that shouldn't matter one bit.
- Enemies don't react to grenades being thrown at them - Take a group of 3, one is running around from left to right on fire whilst the other 2 just stand casually and then proceed to walk through the fire.
- An enemy stood in the corner of a room just staring at a wall / Enemy running around in circles in the corner of a room.
- 2 guards on either side of a door. You approach the one on the left and take him out, clearly in the line of sight of the other dude and he just stands there... Doesn't acknowledge your presence until you're practically stood on his feet.
- Enemy charging towards you to get into melee regardless of whether you're firing or not, I believe BD said this was a bug with them spawning without ammo but either way it's broken...
Glitches etc - Bodies hanging in mid-air through objects, subpar animations (especially the crouch walking which I had hoped would have been improved upon release from seeing it in gameplay vids), cover system doesn't seem to work so well and is made worse by the awful AI...Also I will say the voice acting of Mike sounded emotionless most of the time I was watching regardless of what he was saying but I may take that back when I come to try it...
Graphics don't look as bad as some have made them out to be but this will be one issue where it affects the consoles rather than PC. They do look quite nice in parts but that being said they're nothing special and do look dated. ....Texture popping and even on Ava's computer he had a bit of stuttering from time to time and whilst in some cases you could put that down to your PC that's definitely not the case for his...
hmm what else.. Oh, loading a checkpoint to find that all (but one) of the enemies have completely disappeared yet items are still there...
They couldn't even get the subtitles right either cos they jump ahead way quicker than the voices some of the time which tbh is just a disgrace.
There may be some really great aspects to the game but from watching Ava there are far too many issues with it imo and I'm not surprised both critic & player reviews have been mostly slating it for all 3 platforms. Can't begin to imagine how bad it is on the consoles, I feel sorry for anyone who payed 40 quid for it. It looks not only unpolished but unfinished and broken & should never have been released in the state it's in, in my opinion.
Alpha Protocol was one of my most anticipated games this year and knowing before hand that some of you hail Obsidian as being one of the greats I was expecting just that from AP but everything I have seen just left me feeling REALLY disappointed and peed off for what had the potential to be GOTY. I just hope when I come to play it for myself that I can get some enjoyment out of the story or whatever other good parts there is to it and that the bad don't overshadow those too much cos there's certainly plenty of it.
I'll agree that some of the reviews have been a tad harsh but I have to disagree with you here and I'm one who tends to ignore reviews. Whilst I can't comment on the story side of things as I've not seen enough to make fair judgement I've seen plenty to be able to say that pretty much everything else the reviews have brought up have been bang on in my opinion.all I can say is the reviews do NOT do it justice
- AI being dumb is an understatement imo, some of the worst I have seen in recent years. Of course that may depend on how you're actually playing the game to see their true reactions but that shouldn't matter one bit.
- Enemies don't react to grenades being thrown at them - Take a group of 3, one is running around from left to right on fire whilst the other 2 just stand casually and then proceed to walk through the fire.
- An enemy stood in the corner of a room just staring at a wall / Enemy running around in circles in the corner of a room.
- 2 guards on either side of a door. You approach the one on the left and take him out, clearly in the line of sight of the other dude and he just stands there... Doesn't acknowledge your presence until you're practically stood on his feet.
- Enemy charging towards you to get into melee regardless of whether you're firing or not, I believe BD said this was a bug with them spawning without ammo but either way it's broken...
Glitches etc - Bodies hanging in mid-air through objects, subpar animations (especially the crouch walking which I had hoped would have been improved upon release from seeing it in gameplay vids), cover system doesn't seem to work so well and is made worse by the awful AI...Also I will say the voice acting of Mike sounded emotionless most of the time I was watching regardless of what he was saying but I may take that back when I come to try it...
Graphics don't look as bad as some have made them out to be but this will be one issue where it affects the consoles rather than PC. They do look quite nice in parts but that being said they're nothing special and do look dated. ....Texture popping and even on Ava's computer he had a bit of stuttering from time to time and whilst in some cases you could put that down to your PC that's definitely not the case for his...
hmm what else.. Oh, loading a checkpoint to find that all (but one) of the enemies have completely disappeared yet items are still there...
They couldn't even get the subtitles right either cos they jump ahead way quicker than the voices some of the time which tbh is just a disgrace.
There may be some really great aspects to the game but from watching Ava there are far too many issues with it imo and I'm not surprised both critic & player reviews have been mostly slating it for all 3 platforms. Can't begin to imagine how bad it is on the consoles, I feel sorry for anyone who payed 40 quid for it. It looks not only unpolished but unfinished and broken & should never have been released in the state it's in, in my opinion.
Alpha Protocol was one of my most anticipated games this year and knowing before hand that some of you hail Obsidian as being one of the greats I was expecting just that from AP but everything I have seen just left me feeling REALLY disappointed and peed off for what had the potential to be GOTY. I just hope when I come to play it for myself that I can get some enjoyment out of the story or whatever other good parts there is to it and that the bad don't overshadow those too much cos there's certainly plenty of it.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
You're right that it certainly sounds like the AI make run-and-gun a much less rewarding experience than stealthing. Clearly the AI was optimised (if they were optimised at all) for you playing the game in a stealthy way, and it's unfortunate that the game allows you to play in such a way that the AI falls apart with. Playing as a stealth character, as I said on IRC I have seen none of the issues you have (Edit: save the issue with some AI spawning without ammo that MS mentioned above - though I did not realise it was a bug until BD mentioned what exactly was happening). A shame that they had to ruin it for you, but I can understand why - in the face of those issues - you got so frustrated.SSX-Ava wrote:Played the Pc version myself and I couldn't stand to play another second of it.
The AI is not just abit dumb its broken, they run at you when you are blasting them from cover with an Assault rifle to stab you in the face. They dont try and take cover themselves either, instead they opt for standing in the middle of the hallways. Grenade throwing is another example of the stupidity of the AI. Simply throw a grenade at the feet of 3 enemies and watch as they dont flinch a muscle. They really are hardcore to not be scared enough to run away from my grenades.
I would contend the ascertation that it's not a stealth game though. As was said in IRC, it's no Chaos Theory, but no other game has managed to hit that standard either. You're wrong about the invisibility skill, as I am progressing through levels with it only being used minimally. You CAN stealth properly through a level without it, it just takes time as you need to be aware of patrols and plan when to move. Whether invisibility should be in there at all is debatable, but all games nowadays have 'cheap ways out' for good or ill. You certainly don't have to use it if you find it a problem - doing so would not by any means make the game impossible to complete stealthily.I've noticed the AI standing dead on the spot half in doors, running on the spot, standing facing walls, not reacting when i knifed an enemy when two were stood together and casually walking past as one of their allies was on fire.
In my oppinion I wouldn't class this as a stealth game either as the only way to actually stealth through an area is to go invisible. Forget about using your enviroment or disposing of the bodies or anything that you've grown to love about stealth killing. All you have to do is hit INVISIBLE PLX and watch as you clear the entire room in seconds.
This is true, but I like this. It means that the game is an actual RPG, rather than Mass Effect's preference of FPS over RPG. Being able to go in and be a perfect sharpshooter from the getgo is very unrealistic, and the concept that your skills develop as you level up is a good one. This point will be highly contenscious between fans of the different genres - FPS fans will hate its implementation, whilst RPG fans will love it. For me, it increases realism and immersion - making the game more complex gameplay and skills wise than games such as ME could ever be. As such, I am glad it is in there.Also forget about lining up that perfect head shot too, because it doesnt come down to skill in the early stages of the game it comes down to how many points you've put into each weapon. So even if you aim directly from the face unless you've talented it enough you're gunna miss and alert the other enemies.
I am sorry that you were unable to enjoy the game, as I said in IRC. It's certainly something that will not be for everyone, and requires you to be able to look past the negatives (the impact of which will depend upon your playstyle). A shame that this was unable to be avoided by Obsidian, certainly, but all in all the game remains pretty great for me despite that fact. Clearly though, that is not an opinion shared by everyone.
I should also mention, against MS' saying that the game is getting slated on all three platforms, Metacritic shows that this is just not the case for the PC version. It only has one review at less than 80% - Gamespot's. And when you go to Gamespot to look at that review you see User Reviews to the right hand side that are substantially higher than Gamespot's own score. The game certainly seems to be getting a kicking on consoles, but for PC that does not, so far, appear to be the case.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
True but when reading some of the console reviews & comments a lot of the issues they bring up, like I have above, are not unique to PS3 & 360 but are just problems with the game itself and are therefore present on all versions. You've got all the other problems on the consoles like with the graphics, aiming etc too but to a degree the console reviews apply to the PC version too, imo.Anubis wrote:I should also mention, against MS' saying that the game is getting slated on all three platforms, Metacritic shows that this is just not the case for the PC version.
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
Anubis
- Site Admin
- Posts: 4297
- Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
- Location: The Unholy Realm
Certainly true. Individual criticisms have to be taken on a one-by-one basis. I was meaning more general scoring - sorry if we got our wires crossedSSX-MS wrote:True but when reading some of the console reviews & comments a lot of the issues they bring up, like I have above, are not unique to PS3 & 360 but are just problems with the game itself and are therefore present on all versions. You've got all the other problems on the consoles like with the graphics, aiming etc too but to a degree the console reviews apply to the PC version too, imo.Anubis wrote:I should also mention, against MS' saying that the game is getting slated on all three platforms, Metacritic shows that this is just not the case for the PC version.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
Forever an eXile and proud of it!
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
Ohhh right.Anubis wrote:He can blind you with disco lights and take drugs to allow him to get high
I'd just gone up to watch some more around the time Ava was fighting that guy so I wasn't sure what the hell was going on with that fight and how he was managing to teleport from one floor to the other in the flash of the lights, twas quite funny to watch lol.
[Edit]
I'll make sure I remember to post as soon as I've played this for myself as well. It does have lots of probs but if I can look past them enough to enjoy the rest of it I'll play it through. Don't wanna write it off just yet
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
-
M.Steiner
- Posts: 6114
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
- Location: UK
So after playing it myself...
If you play the game by primarily spending your points on stealth & pistols & then whatever other skills, the gameplay is actually pretty great imho as well as the story. Assault Rifles, grenades & all guns blazing on the other hand (which I should imagine will be the same for SMG & Shotguns too), I would still not recommend. It's when you play like that that you have to put up with the AI issues the most as if you're not being seen most of the time or managing not to sound alarms when you're stealthing, to a big extent you don't because they don't really react the same or at all for you to be able to see what they CAN be like. There were a few occasions where I thought "wth?" even when playing stealthy - like desending a ladder with a guard walking in my direction below, I get to the bottom and he walks straight past me as if I wasn't even there (and I wasn't invisible
). Another occasion where I'd shoot a guard at a computer (not be seen) and for some reason another guard came to use the computer then and stood on top of the guards corpse. I managed to get a small pile of bodies there all the time they weren't alert.
Ultimately I could look past those as there weren't that many instances and I was still enjoying myself quite a lot infact but watching the AI react to a non-stealth approach when Ava was playing (as my previous posts) was not only frustrating but embarrassing for how bad it was. So unless you can somehow look past the awfulness of that if you're a fan of Obsidian or whatever, I wouldn't be surprised if you're left feeling the same. So if you want a good experience play stealth and nothing else is my advice, and on PC not console.
The amount of choices you can make during the story is also rather impressive and there's a few occasions where you're left with some pretty huge ones to make. Like you only have time to complete one of the 2 objectives and each one has a big down side. Head towards one end of the building and know that you may complete your main objective but someone WILL die for it and what makes some of those choices even better is the timed responses when you're given them. Whilst I love the Mass Effect games, in AP you can't just leave the dialogue options alone for a minute whilst you weigh up the pros and cons like you can with ME and I have done once or twice when trying to go for my perfect saves, you've gotta make a decision then and there in a matter of seconds. This really does make it intense.
As for the reviews. Some of them may have been harsh on the game and whilst I have thoroughly enjoyed playing it I can understand why the overall rating on metacritic is rather low.
You shouldn't have to play games a certain way to get an enjoyable experience out of them especially with an RPG. To me, stealthing was like a completely different experience to watching it from a non-stealth run & gun perspective and not just because it would be anyway heh, but the latter was just plain bad tbh. I never really felt let down, annoyed or any of those negative feelings whilst going with stealth and I had that great itching to play more feeling but I felt all of those negs with the other and both Ava and myself had our heads in our hands several times, looking at each other in amazement and not in a good way!.
So yeah, despite all the negatives I've had to say about the game it is still well worth playing so long as you play it a certain way that you can avoid a lot of those issues (imo). I'm glad I played it but it's also a shame that it's maybe one of the only RPGs where I have no desire to make the choice of replaying it in the future with an Assault Rifle instead of the pistol (silenced)/stealth approach because I know It'll leave me peed off. It's a good job the story itself has plenty of choices of its own even if the gameplay ones aren't very viable if you want to actually enjoy it
If you play the game by primarily spending your points on stealth & pistols & then whatever other skills, the gameplay is actually pretty great imho as well as the story. Assault Rifles, grenades & all guns blazing on the other hand (which I should imagine will be the same for SMG & Shotguns too), I would still not recommend. It's when you play like that that you have to put up with the AI issues the most as if you're not being seen most of the time or managing not to sound alarms when you're stealthing, to a big extent you don't because they don't really react the same or at all for you to be able to see what they CAN be like. There were a few occasions where I thought "wth?" even when playing stealthy - like desending a ladder with a guard walking in my direction below, I get to the bottom and he walks straight past me as if I wasn't even there (and I wasn't invisible
Ultimately I could look past those as there weren't that many instances and I was still enjoying myself quite a lot infact but watching the AI react to a non-stealth approach when Ava was playing (as my previous posts) was not only frustrating but embarrassing for how bad it was. So unless you can somehow look past the awfulness of that if you're a fan of Obsidian or whatever, I wouldn't be surprised if you're left feeling the same. So if you want a good experience play stealth and nothing else is my advice, and on PC not console.
The amount of choices you can make during the story is also rather impressive and there's a few occasions where you're left with some pretty huge ones to make. Like you only have time to complete one of the 2 objectives and each one has a big down side. Head towards one end of the building and know that you may complete your main objective but someone WILL die for it and what makes some of those choices even better is the timed responses when you're given them. Whilst I love the Mass Effect games, in AP you can't just leave the dialogue options alone for a minute whilst you weigh up the pros and cons like you can with ME and I have done once or twice when trying to go for my perfect saves, you've gotta make a decision then and there in a matter of seconds. This really does make it intense.
As for the reviews. Some of them may have been harsh on the game and whilst I have thoroughly enjoyed playing it I can understand why the overall rating on metacritic is rather low.
You shouldn't have to play games a certain way to get an enjoyable experience out of them especially with an RPG. To me, stealthing was like a completely different experience to watching it from a non-stealth run & gun perspective and not just because it would be anyway heh, but the latter was just plain bad tbh. I never really felt let down, annoyed or any of those negative feelings whilst going with stealth and I had that great itching to play more feeling but I felt all of those negs with the other and both Ava and myself had our heads in our hands several times, looking at each other in amazement and not in a good way!.
So yeah, despite all the negatives I've had to say about the game it is still well worth playing so long as you play it a certain way that you can avoid a lot of those issues (imo). I'm glad I played it but it's also a shame that it's maybe one of the only RPGs where I have no desire to make the choice of replaying it in the future with an Assault Rifle instead of the pistol (silenced)/stealth approach because I know It'll leave me peed off. It's a good job the story itself has plenty of choices of its own even if the gameplay ones aren't very viable if you want to actually enjoy it
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
