I've written this to one of the devs taking feedback to Ladlaw. I'm copy pasting it here for posterity, and also, ctr+c - ctrl+v value.
Well, I thought I'd give it a shot since you asked for some.
Whether or not this goes further to the development team or directly to your trash bin is of no real consequence I guess, but I felt like giving it a go for the contrastive reasons alone. I doubt there were many who loathed the game as much as I have, and perhaps it would not be a bad thing to have that one in the bag.
So, the likes and dislikes, and the reasons why. I'll try not to color them too much with sarcasm, cynicism and malevolent ardor... shit, I dropped my thesaurus...
Anyway, as you may imagine, this will probably be a list of dislikes only. I'll just count them off the top of my head.
1. The level design
I believe this one is rather obvious. Other than being copy pasted continuously, the areas themselves are very few in number. I believe this to be bad for two reasons.
The first and obvious one is the constant repetition. The sense of exploration is null and void once the player knows the layout exactly, and where to find the loot (a system which was lackluster as well - more on that later) in the dead-end pathways. While I'm certain time was saved on creating areas for the player to explore development wise, the game felt very constrained and repetitive for this very reason.
The second one has to do with the size of the world that one is exploring. Having access to Kirkwall alone, as well as its outskirts is a significant downgrade from being able to "in-a-sense" traverse a large map of a country or world. In Mass Effect/KOTOR one visits different planets and systems, contributing to the vastness of the perceived scale of the world. In Origins one has a chunk of Ferelden to explore, even though most of that exploration occurs on a two dimensional map, and an Indiana Jones arrow pointing to the area being traversed too. Regardless, the effect sticks.
The biggest problem with DA2 was that the areas given to the player to traverse were lackluster themselves. Kirkwall for the most part is a dreary place. Lowtown, Darktown, Gallows, Docks and even Hightown are all areas that, while certainly conveying the spirit of the world visually, aren't really striking in any shape or form. They were also rather small and narrow to boot.
In Origins, I always knew where I was based on the architecture. Circle of Magi - big tower. Lothering - crappy village and some fields. The Dalish - sprawling woodland and crypts. Redcliffe - the interior of the castle and the exterior of the village, all conveyed a living breathing world. Denerim, the high town area, with the shopkeepers and such, very memorable. Orzammar - while a pain in the ass, really conveyed the feeling of going deeper and deeper underground, not to mention the architecture of the dwarven city.
Anyway, no need to wax further on the merits of Origins level design. Dragon Age 2's by comparison is simply not fit enough to hold a candle to it. It felt cheap and crappy.
2. Moving away from 4 planets > Star Forge
I actually hate that kind of a progression scheme. I mean I love KOTOR, its sequel, Origins and Mass Effect, but I always felt that this was a crime against nature.
Yet the timeskips in DA2 were decidedly worse, I felt anyway. It felt like a cheap scheme to simply have the player re-visit the areas they've already been in with promise of different loot and nothing else.
But even going beyond that, concerning the narrative structure, I do not feel it grants the game any favors, other than providing stopgaps similar to the "planet" scheme from the earlier RPG's. Perhaps a commendation should be given for the attempt, but "whoops, 5 years have passed, let's move the story forward" is just a dreadful, detached way to move the narrative further.
Mass Effect 2 also broke the spell partially by making the supporting characters the planets themselves. First game had Noveria, Feros, Ilos, and that planet where you found Liara, as well as the Citadel as the hub and the other minor areas, but Mass Effect 2 made the characters the centerpieces for the level design and the places you visited in the game, and tackled the issues surrounding the world.
It also had some drawbacks though - because it relied in a percentage passed in order to progress the core story, culminating in the "we're going on an expedition, you have fun with the collectors Joker" bit which seals the deal and rushes you forward toward the ending.
Done perhaps in a clumsy manner, in a game which does not track the galactic date or time continuously, yet forces the player with invisible lines forward.
Still, it was an expansion upon the 4 planets 1 Star Forge manner of driving the narrative forward.
Going back to time-skips, quite the lackluster solution by comparison.
3. Combat
Most people have cited it to be better than its predecessor. I'm sure it is in some respects. Rather certain it's not in many others. Yes, the fluidity, the actual visual representation of "cool shit going on" is there, to appeal to the average 14 year old, and perhaps to enunciate what we've held in our imaginations for so long while we rolled the dice.
All the same, beyond that, DA2's combat with the waves of enemies, and the simplistic formula on taking them down is fairly mind numbing, not to mention repetitive. Prioritizing is hardly a concern, and even when one controls all of the party members, the entire exercise turns into a rinse-repeat procedure or in worst cases on nightmare, a retarded kiting scheme in order to wait out the cooldowns and continue with the casting of spells or using of abilities.
The actual ability trees were better this time around, that's a positive perhaps from the linear drudgery in Origins, though hardly when you have to buy two skills to get the third one, or three, to get the fourth one. Still, it worked better to an extent.
Now, being able to combine different spells instead of crossing abilities in DA2 makes Origins superior, because Origins didn't depend on the color of the moon and the luck of the draw for the combination to succeed. The combination succeeded if you mixed the spells, not if the target became brittle/staggered/disoriented which all have a "chance happening" on them.
It's simply uninspired in the end though. Having the isometric perspective removed completely negated the strategic feeling the first game invoked once you zoomed the camera out (I doubt I need to sell you on the points of expert camera manipulation and what it can do for the player in the sense of perceiving what's going on) and more than that, removed an entire aspect of how the game could be played.
4. The Silent Cypher and the Mass Effect wheel
The Mass Effect wheel, while having obvious benefits, actually has downsides to the full narrative selection the silent cypher approach has.
Yes, a voiced protagonist is more involving. In a world where the compatriots are voiced, it only makes sense for the protagonist to gain a voice as well, and behave as an actor for the player's directions, bringing us to some cinematic film-like quality games have been desperately attempting to ape for the past five to ten years.
We're also aware of the downsides. The words spoken not being what the words written are at all. Even though the positions of intent behind the words are fixed and DA2 has the icon scheme clearly showing the three personalities, reduction also plays a perilous role with the Mass Effect system as well. Instead of well thought out dialog the previous system offered, by being able to choose well written sentences and ideas, the player's choice has been reduced to a mere binary choice, with some middle ground which DA2 introduced via the smarmy jackass approach.
I'm certain we're not going back to the old system. Perhaps this is a conundrum Deus Ex Human Revolution will solve, where the player has different emotions to choose from or play on, and then gets a preview of what it is exactly that will be said. That system also evades the "I'm a saint, I'm a psycho, I don't care" approach the Bioware system has. Alpha Protocol innovated a bit on the formula, though in the end, ended up exactly where DA2 is. Smarmy Jackass, Professional, Violent Asshole. At least those were in line with the narrative, and Thorton's job description... somewhat... as it's played out in movies anyway.
Fallout 3/New Vegas is perhaps also a showcase of castration when it comes to these systems. We had long long lines of well thought out responses in the first and the second Fallout provided the character created had high intelligence. However 3 and New Vegas are limited in the size of the sentences one can respond with, and the actual responses are rather basic as well.
For the Dragon Age narrative structure, the silent cypher worked better, now having hindsight of play a Dragon Age with the Mass Effect wheel.
5. The direction of the story
So Dragons are inconsequential. We're back to dealing with the Chantry, the Mages, and the Templars.
Allright. Yes, they were important elements in the first game. Yes, they are central to the world, as are their ambiguous dispositions and non-clear cut ambitions.
Unfortunately, as we argued on this point in public, they are not the central theme or the plot as introduced by Origins. And Origins is the origin (I swear this is not intentional) point here, because it is the biggest and most extensive entry in the series.
If we had to summarize Origins, we could say that the story revolves around a Dragon Slayer who has to slay a dragon which is plaguing the lands for whatever reasons.
That's it. Everything else was a side story, and how he went about doing the dragon-slaying.
Now certainly, the side stories were what made up the whole picture, and were integral to the construction and portrayal of the world. Without them, the entire thing would be uninteresting, bland, and clich11. Certainly, delving deeper into one of those side stories and making it the main story is a possibility, which is what Dragon Age 2 does.
However, not without severe disadvantages. By repeating and reiterating the elements of the first game (good/bad mages, good/bad templars, moral ambiguity abounds) the sequel to an "epic" sprawling first game ends up an adventure into the already familiar territory explored before, therefore making the trek rather pointless.
One only needs to examine the object driving the whole narrative forward to see how solid it is.
A piece of lyrium. Not explained. Not expounded upon. An object of mysterious origins makes people crazy, passes hands, and so we've got it as the central pillar of a story about moral ambiguity and doing what's right or less right.
This is weak at best, and downright horrendous at worst. Other than the main, now voiced actor, character being a sideshow by comparison to the constructed hero of the first game in every single shape or form, the actual story itself does not contribute any real explicitly foreign element to the overarching story.
The Chantry and The Mages go to war. Okay. Did we really need an entire game to depict that? Was there no better story to tell? Something that would actually contribute to the puzzle of the world, its foundation, creation, pivotal lore? Apparently not. Which is simply a sad state of affairs.
6. The rest
Miscellaneous I guess. The loot system and items in general were crap. When you need to categorize items as "junk" and have it a separate one, you know you're going in the wrong direction. Why the <censored> would anyone be elated about picking up junk? By the end, I had 175 gold pieces that I just had because there was really nothing that needed buying. The game pretty forcefully runs you to your Wardrobe of the Champion pieces, and the only selection one has to make are the weapons and trinkets. A downgrade by comparison to Origins.
Also, in order to make the side-characters have a continuous appearance, the ability to change their armor being removed is again, a downgrade.
I'm sure looking at the reductionist strategy from Mass Effect 2 was a fantastic inspiration as to how one could sell a non-complex game to idiots that didn't feel like expending any energy into customizing the characters and getting confused or frustrated in the process (who is he/she? He/she's wearing a different outfit. Did I see him/her before?), but I hardly see the benefits in taking away options from players in a game that is supposed to be all about the customization and depth of tactical and strategic choice, not to mention aesthetic.
Moving onward one hex, the dragons.
The biggest dragon in the game, excluding Flemeth's cutscenes, was a dragon that plagued some mines for no real reason.
In a game called Dragon Age, was that really the best thing to do?
Anyway, these things were just off the top of my head now after a day of mulling over the utter disappointment I felt the game ended up being. As it's taken me about 40 minutes to write all this, I do believe I will cease now, and allow you to bask in the sunshine of my wisdom.
At any rate, contrastive approaches of a negative nature can't hurt, alongside all the positive ones you're bound to receive, right? Right?
Whether or not this goes further to the development team or directly to your trash bin is of no real consequence I guess, but I felt like giving it a go for the contrastive reasons alone. I doubt there were many who loathed the game as much as I have, and perhaps it would not be a bad thing to have that one in the bag.
So, the likes and dislikes, and the reasons why. I'll try not to color them too much with sarcasm, cynicism and malevolent ardor... shit, I dropped my thesaurus...
Anyway, as you may imagine, this will probably be a list of dislikes only. I'll just count them off the top of my head.
1. The level design
I believe this one is rather obvious. Other than being copy pasted continuously, the areas themselves are very few in number. I believe this to be bad for two reasons.
The first and obvious one is the constant repetition. The sense of exploration is null and void once the player knows the layout exactly, and where to find the loot (a system which was lackluster as well - more on that later) in the dead-end pathways. While I'm certain time was saved on creating areas for the player to explore development wise, the game felt very constrained and repetitive for this very reason.
The second one has to do with the size of the world that one is exploring. Having access to Kirkwall alone, as well as its outskirts is a significant downgrade from being able to "in-a-sense" traverse a large map of a country or world. In Mass Effect/KOTOR one visits different planets and systems, contributing to the vastness of the perceived scale of the world. In Origins one has a chunk of Ferelden to explore, even though most of that exploration occurs on a two dimensional map, and an Indiana Jones arrow pointing to the area being traversed too. Regardless, the effect sticks.
The biggest problem with DA2 was that the areas given to the player to traverse were lackluster themselves. Kirkwall for the most part is a dreary place. Lowtown, Darktown, Gallows, Docks and even Hightown are all areas that, while certainly conveying the spirit of the world visually, aren't really striking in any shape or form. They were also rather small and narrow to boot.
In Origins, I always knew where I was based on the architecture. Circle of Magi - big tower. Lothering - crappy village and some fields. The Dalish - sprawling woodland and crypts. Redcliffe - the interior of the castle and the exterior of the village, all conveyed a living breathing world. Denerim, the high town area, with the shopkeepers and such, very memorable. Orzammar - while a pain in the ass, really conveyed the feeling of going deeper and deeper underground, not to mention the architecture of the dwarven city.
Anyway, no need to wax further on the merits of Origins level design. Dragon Age 2's by comparison is simply not fit enough to hold a candle to it. It felt cheap and crappy.
2. Moving away from 4 planets > Star Forge
I actually hate that kind of a progression scheme. I mean I love KOTOR, its sequel, Origins and Mass Effect, but I always felt that this was a crime against nature.
Yet the timeskips in DA2 were decidedly worse, I felt anyway. It felt like a cheap scheme to simply have the player re-visit the areas they've already been in with promise of different loot and nothing else.
But even going beyond that, concerning the narrative structure, I do not feel it grants the game any favors, other than providing stopgaps similar to the "planet" scheme from the earlier RPG's. Perhaps a commendation should be given for the attempt, but "whoops, 5 years have passed, let's move the story forward" is just a dreadful, detached way to move the narrative further.
Mass Effect 2 also broke the spell partially by making the supporting characters the planets themselves. First game had Noveria, Feros, Ilos, and that planet where you found Liara, as well as the Citadel as the hub and the other minor areas, but Mass Effect 2 made the characters the centerpieces for the level design and the places you visited in the game, and tackled the issues surrounding the world.
It also had some drawbacks though - because it relied in a percentage passed in order to progress the core story, culminating in the "we're going on an expedition, you have fun with the collectors Joker" bit which seals the deal and rushes you forward toward the ending.
Done perhaps in a clumsy manner, in a game which does not track the galactic date or time continuously, yet forces the player with invisible lines forward.
Still, it was an expansion upon the 4 planets 1 Star Forge manner of driving the narrative forward.
Going back to time-skips, quite the lackluster solution by comparison.
3. Combat
Most people have cited it to be better than its predecessor. I'm sure it is in some respects. Rather certain it's not in many others. Yes, the fluidity, the actual visual representation of "cool shit going on" is there, to appeal to the average 14 year old, and perhaps to enunciate what we've held in our imaginations for so long while we rolled the dice.
All the same, beyond that, DA2's combat with the waves of enemies, and the simplistic formula on taking them down is fairly mind numbing, not to mention repetitive. Prioritizing is hardly a concern, and even when one controls all of the party members, the entire exercise turns into a rinse-repeat procedure or in worst cases on nightmare, a retarded kiting scheme in order to wait out the cooldowns and continue with the casting of spells or using of abilities.
The actual ability trees were better this time around, that's a positive perhaps from the linear drudgery in Origins, though hardly when you have to buy two skills to get the third one, or three, to get the fourth one. Still, it worked better to an extent.
Now, being able to combine different spells instead of crossing abilities in DA2 makes Origins superior, because Origins didn't depend on the color of the moon and the luck of the draw for the combination to succeed. The combination succeeded if you mixed the spells, not if the target became brittle/staggered/disoriented which all have a "chance happening" on them.
It's simply uninspired in the end though. Having the isometric perspective removed completely negated the strategic feeling the first game invoked once you zoomed the camera out (I doubt I need to sell you on the points of expert camera manipulation and what it can do for the player in the sense of perceiving what's going on) and more than that, removed an entire aspect of how the game could be played.
4. The Silent Cypher and the Mass Effect wheel
The Mass Effect wheel, while having obvious benefits, actually has downsides to the full narrative selection the silent cypher approach has.
Yes, a voiced protagonist is more involving. In a world where the compatriots are voiced, it only makes sense for the protagonist to gain a voice as well, and behave as an actor for the player's directions, bringing us to some cinematic film-like quality games have been desperately attempting to ape for the past five to ten years.
We're also aware of the downsides. The words spoken not being what the words written are at all. Even though the positions of intent behind the words are fixed and DA2 has the icon scheme clearly showing the three personalities, reduction also plays a perilous role with the Mass Effect system as well. Instead of well thought out dialog the previous system offered, by being able to choose well written sentences and ideas, the player's choice has been reduced to a mere binary choice, with some middle ground which DA2 introduced via the smarmy jackass approach.
I'm certain we're not going back to the old system. Perhaps this is a conundrum Deus Ex Human Revolution will solve, where the player has different emotions to choose from or play on, and then gets a preview of what it is exactly that will be said. That system also evades the "I'm a saint, I'm a psycho, I don't care" approach the Bioware system has. Alpha Protocol innovated a bit on the formula, though in the end, ended up exactly where DA2 is. Smarmy Jackass, Professional, Violent Asshole. At least those were in line with the narrative, and Thorton's job description... somewhat... as it's played out in movies anyway.
Fallout 3/New Vegas is perhaps also a showcase of castration when it comes to these systems. We had long long lines of well thought out responses in the first and the second Fallout provided the character created had high intelligence. However 3 and New Vegas are limited in the size of the sentences one can respond with, and the actual responses are rather basic as well.
For the Dragon Age narrative structure, the silent cypher worked better, now having hindsight of play a Dragon Age with the Mass Effect wheel.
5. The direction of the story
So Dragons are inconsequential. We're back to dealing with the Chantry, the Mages, and the Templars.
Allright. Yes, they were important elements in the first game. Yes, they are central to the world, as are their ambiguous dispositions and non-clear cut ambitions.
Unfortunately, as we argued on this point in public, they are not the central theme or the plot as introduced by Origins. And Origins is the origin (I swear this is not intentional) point here, because it is the biggest and most extensive entry in the series.
If we had to summarize Origins, we could say that the story revolves around a Dragon Slayer who has to slay a dragon which is plaguing the lands for whatever reasons.
That's it. Everything else was a side story, and how he went about doing the dragon-slaying.
Now certainly, the side stories were what made up the whole picture, and were integral to the construction and portrayal of the world. Without them, the entire thing would be uninteresting, bland, and clich11. Certainly, delving deeper into one of those side stories and making it the main story is a possibility, which is what Dragon Age 2 does.
However, not without severe disadvantages. By repeating and reiterating the elements of the first game (good/bad mages, good/bad templars, moral ambiguity abounds) the sequel to an "epic" sprawling first game ends up an adventure into the already familiar territory explored before, therefore making the trek rather pointless.
One only needs to examine the object driving the whole narrative forward to see how solid it is.
A piece of lyrium. Not explained. Not expounded upon. An object of mysterious origins makes people crazy, passes hands, and so we've got it as the central pillar of a story about moral ambiguity and doing what's right or less right.
This is weak at best, and downright horrendous at worst. Other than the main, now voiced actor, character being a sideshow by comparison to the constructed hero of the first game in every single shape or form, the actual story itself does not contribute any real explicitly foreign element to the overarching story.
The Chantry and The Mages go to war. Okay. Did we really need an entire game to depict that? Was there no better story to tell? Something that would actually contribute to the puzzle of the world, its foundation, creation, pivotal lore? Apparently not. Which is simply a sad state of affairs.
6. The rest
Miscellaneous I guess. The loot system and items in general were crap. When you need to categorize items as "junk" and have it a separate one, you know you're going in the wrong direction. Why the <censored> would anyone be elated about picking up junk? By the end, I had 175 gold pieces that I just had because there was really nothing that needed buying. The game pretty forcefully runs you to your Wardrobe of the Champion pieces, and the only selection one has to make are the weapons and trinkets. A downgrade by comparison to Origins.
Also, in order to make the side-characters have a continuous appearance, the ability to change their armor being removed is again, a downgrade.
I'm sure looking at the reductionist strategy from Mass Effect 2 was a fantastic inspiration as to how one could sell a non-complex game to idiots that didn't feel like expending any energy into customizing the characters and getting confused or frustrated in the process (who is he/she? He/she's wearing a different outfit. Did I see him/her before?), but I hardly see the benefits in taking away options from players in a game that is supposed to be all about the customization and depth of tactical and strategic choice, not to mention aesthetic.
Moving onward one hex, the dragons.
The biggest dragon in the game, excluding Flemeth's cutscenes, was a dragon that plagued some mines for no real reason.
In a game called Dragon Age, was that really the best thing to do?
Anyway, these things were just off the top of my head now after a day of mulling over the utter disappointment I felt the game ended up being. As it's taken me about 40 minutes to write all this, I do believe I will cease now, and allow you to bask in the sunshine of my wisdom.
At any rate, contrastive approaches of a negative nature can't hurt, alongside all the positive ones you're bound to receive, right? Right?


