Dragon Age 2 review

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 15, 2011 11:22 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
Yes. There's already a Dragon Age 2 thread out there.

I've written this to one of the devs taking feedback to Ladlaw. I'm copy pasting it here for posterity, and also, ctr+c - ctrl+v value.
Well, I thought I'd give it a shot since you asked for some.

Whether or not this goes further to the development team or directly to your trash bin is of no real consequence I guess, but I felt like giving it a go for the contrastive reasons alone. I doubt there were many who loathed the game as much as I have, and perhaps it would not be a bad thing to have that one in the bag.

So, the likes and dislikes, and the reasons why. I'll try not to color them too much with sarcasm, cynicism and malevolent ardor... shit, I dropped my thesaurus...

Anyway, as you may imagine, this will probably be a list of dislikes only. I'll just count them off the top of my head.

1. The level design

I believe this one is rather obvious. Other than being copy pasted continuously, the areas themselves are very few in number. I believe this to be bad for two reasons.

The first and obvious one is the constant repetition. The sense of exploration is null and void once the player knows the layout exactly, and where to find the loot (a system which was lackluster as well - more on that later) in the dead-end pathways. While I'm certain time was saved on creating areas for the player to explore development wise, the game felt very constrained and repetitive for this very reason.

The second one has to do with the size of the world that one is exploring. Having access to Kirkwall alone, as well as its outskirts is a significant downgrade from being able to "in-a-sense" traverse a large map of a country or world. In Mass Effect/KOTOR one visits different planets and systems, contributing to the vastness of the perceived scale of the world. In Origins one has a chunk of Ferelden to explore, even though most of that exploration occurs on a two dimensional map, and an Indiana Jones arrow pointing to the area being traversed too. Regardless, the effect sticks.

The biggest problem with DA2 was that the areas given to the player to traverse were lackluster themselves. Kirkwall for the most part is a dreary place. Lowtown, Darktown, Gallows, Docks and even Hightown are all areas that, while certainly conveying the spirit of the world visually, aren't really striking in any shape or form. They were also rather small and narrow to boot.

In Origins, I always knew where I was based on the architecture. Circle of Magi - big tower. Lothering - crappy village and some fields. The Dalish - sprawling woodland and crypts. Redcliffe - the interior of the castle and the exterior of the village, all conveyed a living breathing world. Denerim, the high town area, with the shopkeepers and such, very memorable. Orzammar - while a pain in the ass, really conveyed the feeling of going deeper and deeper underground, not to mention the architecture of the dwarven city.

Anyway, no need to wax further on the merits of Origins level design. Dragon Age 2's by comparison is simply not fit enough to hold a candle to it. It felt cheap and crappy.


2. Moving away from 4 planets > Star Forge

I actually hate that kind of a progression scheme. I mean I love KOTOR, its sequel, Origins and Mass Effect, but I always felt that this was a crime against nature.

Yet the timeskips in DA2 were decidedly worse, I felt anyway. It felt like a cheap scheme to simply have the player re-visit the areas they've already been in with promise of different loot and nothing else.

But even going beyond that, concerning the narrative structure, I do not feel it grants the game any favors, other than providing stopgaps similar to the "planet" scheme from the earlier RPG's. Perhaps a commendation should be given for the attempt, but "whoops, 5 years have passed, let's move the story forward" is just a dreadful, detached way to move the narrative further.

Mass Effect 2 also broke the spell partially by making the supporting characters the planets themselves. First game had Noveria, Feros, Ilos, and that planet where you found Liara, as well as the Citadel as the hub and the other minor areas, but Mass Effect 2 made the characters the centerpieces for the level design and the places you visited in the game, and tackled the issues surrounding the world.

It also had some drawbacks though - because it relied in a percentage passed in order to progress the core story, culminating in the "we're going on an expedition, you have fun with the collectors Joker" bit which seals the deal and rushes you forward toward the ending.

Done perhaps in a clumsy manner, in a game which does not track the galactic date or time continuously, yet forces the player with invisible lines forward.

Still, it was an expansion upon the 4 planets 1 Star Forge manner of driving the narrative forward.

Going back to time-skips, quite the lackluster solution by comparison.

3. Combat

Most people have cited it to be better than its predecessor. I'm sure it is in some respects. Rather certain it's not in many others. Yes, the fluidity, the actual visual representation of "cool shit going on" is there, to appeal to the average 14 year old, and perhaps to enunciate what we've held in our imaginations for so long while we rolled the dice.

All the same, beyond that, DA2's combat with the waves of enemies, and the simplistic formula on taking them down is fairly mind numbing, not to mention repetitive. Prioritizing is hardly a concern, and even when one controls all of the party members, the entire exercise turns into a rinse-repeat procedure or in worst cases on nightmare, a retarded kiting scheme in order to wait out the cooldowns and continue with the casting of spells or using of abilities.

The actual ability trees were better this time around, that's a positive perhaps from the linear drudgery in Origins, though hardly when you have to buy two skills to get the third one, or three, to get the fourth one. Still, it worked better to an extent.

Now, being able to combine different spells instead of crossing abilities in DA2 makes Origins superior, because Origins didn't depend on the color of the moon and the luck of the draw for the combination to succeed. The combination succeeded if you mixed the spells, not if the target became brittle/staggered/disoriented which all have a "chance happening" on them.

It's simply uninspired in the end though. Having the isometric perspective removed completely negated the strategic feeling the first game invoked once you zoomed the camera out (I doubt I need to sell you on the points of expert camera manipulation and what it can do for the player in the sense of perceiving what's going on) and more than that, removed an entire aspect of how the game could be played.


4. The Silent Cypher and the Mass Effect wheel

The Mass Effect wheel, while having obvious benefits, actually has downsides to the full narrative selection the silent cypher approach has.

Yes, a voiced protagonist is more involving. In a world where the compatriots are voiced, it only makes sense for the protagonist to gain a voice as well, and behave as an actor for the player's directions, bringing us to some cinematic film-like quality games have been desperately attempting to ape for the past five to ten years.

We're also aware of the downsides. The words spoken not being what the words written are at all. Even though the positions of intent behind the words are fixed and DA2 has the icon scheme clearly showing the three personalities, reduction also plays a perilous role with the Mass Effect system as well. Instead of well thought out dialog the previous system offered, by being able to choose well written sentences and ideas, the player's choice has been reduced to a mere binary choice, with some middle ground which DA2 introduced via the smarmy jackass approach.

I'm certain we're not going back to the old system. Perhaps this is a conundrum Deus Ex Human Revolution will solve, where the player has different emotions to choose from or play on, and then gets a preview of what it is exactly that will be said. That system also evades the "I'm a saint, I'm a psycho, I don't care" approach the Bioware system has. Alpha Protocol innovated a bit on the formula, though in the end, ended up exactly where DA2 is. Smarmy Jackass, Professional, Violent Asshole. At least those were in line with the narrative, and Thorton's job description... somewhat... as it's played out in movies anyway.

Fallout 3/New Vegas is perhaps also a showcase of castration when it comes to these systems. We had long long lines of well thought out responses in the first and the second Fallout provided the character created had high intelligence. However 3 and New Vegas are limited in the size of the sentences one can respond with, and the actual responses are rather basic as well.

For the Dragon Age narrative structure, the silent cypher worked better, now having hindsight of play a Dragon Age with the Mass Effect wheel.

5. The direction of the story

So Dragons are inconsequential. We're back to dealing with the Chantry, the Mages, and the Templars.

Allright. Yes, they were important elements in the first game. Yes, they are central to the world, as are their ambiguous dispositions and non-clear cut ambitions.

Unfortunately, as we argued on this point in public, they are not the central theme or the plot as introduced by Origins. And Origins is the origin (I swear this is not intentional) point here, because it is the biggest and most extensive entry in the series.

If we had to summarize Origins, we could say that the story revolves around a Dragon Slayer who has to slay a dragon which is plaguing the lands for whatever reasons.

That's it. Everything else was a side story, and how he went about doing the dragon-slaying.

Now certainly, the side stories were what made up the whole picture, and were integral to the construction and portrayal of the world. Without them, the entire thing would be uninteresting, bland, and clich11. Certainly, delving deeper into one of those side stories and making it the main story is a possibility, which is what Dragon Age 2 does.

However, not without severe disadvantages. By repeating and reiterating the elements of the first game (good/bad mages, good/bad templars, moral ambiguity abounds) the sequel to an "epic" sprawling first game ends up an adventure into the already familiar territory explored before, therefore making the trek rather pointless.

One only needs to examine the object driving the whole narrative forward to see how solid it is.

A piece of lyrium. Not explained. Not expounded upon. An object of mysterious origins makes people crazy, passes hands, and so we've got it as the central pillar of a story about moral ambiguity and doing what's right or less right.

This is weak at best, and downright horrendous at worst. Other than the main, now voiced actor, character being a sideshow by comparison to the constructed hero of the first game in every single shape or form, the actual story itself does not contribute any real explicitly foreign element to the overarching story.

The Chantry and The Mages go to war. Okay. Did we really need an entire game to depict that? Was there no better story to tell? Something that would actually contribute to the puzzle of the world, its foundation, creation, pivotal lore? Apparently not. Which is simply a sad state of affairs.

6. The rest

Miscellaneous I guess. The loot system and items in general were crap. When you need to categorize items as "junk" and have it a separate one, you know you're going in the wrong direction. Why the <censored> would anyone be elated about picking up junk? By the end, I had 175 gold pieces that I just had because there was really nothing that needed buying. The game pretty forcefully runs you to your Wardrobe of the Champion pieces, and the only selection one has to make are the weapons and trinkets. A downgrade by comparison to Origins.

Also, in order to make the side-characters have a continuous appearance, the ability to change their armor being removed is again, a downgrade.

I'm sure looking at the reductionist strategy from Mass Effect 2 was a fantastic inspiration as to how one could sell a non-complex game to idiots that didn't feel like expending any energy into customizing the characters and getting confused or frustrated in the process (who is he/she? He/she's wearing a different outfit. Did I see him/her before?), but I hardly see the benefits in taking away options from players in a game that is supposed to be all about the customization and depth of tactical and strategic choice, not to mention aesthetic.

Moving onward one hex, the dragons.

The biggest dragon in the game, excluding Flemeth's cutscenes, was a dragon that plagued some mines for no real reason.

In a game called Dragon Age, was that really the best thing to do?

Anyway, these things were just off the top of my head now after a day of mulling over the utter disappointment I felt the game ended up being. As it's taken me about 40 minutes to write all this, I do believe I will cease now, and allow you to bask in the sunshine of my wisdom.

At any rate, contrastive approaches of a negative nature can't hurt, alongside all the positive ones you're bound to receive, right? Right?

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 15, 2011 11:35 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
Addendum:
7. Morrigan Disapproves

Rivalry. Yeah, it's a better system than the Origins one. However not without its sore points. The immediate example we can use is Fenris. I treated him (and everyone else for that matter) as a friend. I like playing friendly and caring people. This yielded friend points in every single dialog the main character had with him that was on the "quest-level" scale. Every direct interaction with him yielded friendly points.

However, since I was a mage, and had sympathized with mages, every single decision I'd make while he was in my party (and he was in it for the entirety of the game) yielded Rivalry points, thus were I to play the game naturally, I would end with him being dead stuck in the middle by the end of the game. This resulted in me having to take him out during conversations with other party members, and generally doing the whole min-maxing scheme but in a different manner.

While I am certain the objective to some extent is for the player to fail in this grand scheme of friend-making, it just simply ends up bringing us back to saving, reloading and min/maxing, which is what we did before in most of the other Bioware games. Perhaps a solution that is more organic, or seamless would work. Paragon/Renegade and an alignment curve is arguably worse (at least the character in Origins or DA2 has no alignment), but I'd strongly encourage re-doing this particular system from scratch.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 15, 2011 11:38 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
An interesting view, and one I did not expect to see regarding a BioWare game. I just hope I'll get some enjoyment out of it when I start it tomorrow - but on the back of this, I'm not holding out masses of hope :blank:

A shame, since the first game really was great. Someone, somewhere has dropped the ball incredibly badly. I hope this review ends up with someone who will read it and be in a position to act on it.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 15, 2011 11:58 pm

User avatar
Ash
Posts: 554
Joined: Thu Jan 20, 2005 1:15 pm
Location: Manchester, UK
Nice BD, excellent critique.

I believe I can see what Bioware were attempting to do, ie a Medieval Mass Effect.
But they missed the mark somewhat, I'm hoping because all their best talent is currently working
on another Bioware product (and I don't mean Mass Effect 3 :rolleyes: ).
Ash
The quiet one in the corner

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 2:19 am

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Very well written review BD and an interesting read.
It's a shame the "haters" can't write constructive criticism like this too rather than trolling their bullshit. At least then the devs can receive some decent feedback and hopefully work on that for future DA games. In all honesty they didn't need to change a lot from how Origins was..
Anubis wrote:I just hope I'll get some enjoyment out of it when I start it tomorrow - but on the back of this, I'm not holding out masses of hope :blank:
Whilst I agree with a lot of the points BD makes just maybe not to the same degree, he doesn't speak for absolutely everyone of course. :thumb:
I don't need to remind you of Alpha Protocol. Some of you guys still loved it despite the huge issues with it and it being a disappointment, some would say failure. Yet even though I was one of many players and critics who slated parts of it I still got some enjoyment out of it and it was still good looking past those. So don't give up hope just yet eh? ;)


I didn't mind that the majority of the game took part in and around Kirkwall but the design around this could have been better I'll admit. The city itself didn't have much of a sense of life for one thing. Didn't always feel like a living, breathing city.
Wasn't too happy about seeing the same outdoor areas being used throughout the game either (The Wounded Coast, Sundermount). Because of this the gameworld feels much smaller than it should have done, Origins felt huge in comparison so this was a big comedown.
Then there's the dungeon/interior maps which are recycled over and over again, this I'd say was my biggest complaint. It can fool you for a while but then you know you're just visiting the same places but with a different quest.

I happened to like the combat, skill trees, relationships with any character regardless of genders, the loading screens and most of the story too. (Will see what DLC brings for the rest).
Didn't like that we weren't able to upgrade/change our companions armour, just weapons/rings etc. Whilst it was one thing less to worry about it was very restrictive and a feature I missed.

Overall I think the game was mostly a step back from DA1. This felt more like a DA 1.5 than what I expected from 2. I'd compare this to a Fable game actually, quite linear with few environments, just much longer. I'd even say that almost everything about DA:O was better and I wish this was more like it.
However judging DA2 as its own game I did enjoy it a lot and don't believe it's as bad as some people have made it out to be but we're all entitled to our opinion. Anyone put off by any of the reviews I'd still say to try it for yourself and see what you think as I would say about any game. If you go in expecting it to be bigger and better than the first game you'll be left disappointed but if you try not to compare everything and judge it on its own hopefully you'll enjoy it too. :)
That being said The Witcher 2 will succeed where this didn't and will no doubt be RPG of the year as I've said before. Not long to wait.

AC: Brotherhood next!. Hopefully arrive through my letterbox on thursday :D
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 1:11 pm

User avatar
Ozone
Posts: 850
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2005 5:52 pm
Location: 93m miles from Sol.
1. The level design[/u]

I believe this one is rather obvious. Other than being copy pasted continuously, the areas themselves are very few in number. I believe this to be bad for two reasons.
LOL. Was playing a bit last night, before reading this. I entered a large area during a main quest and thought it looked familiar (again). Eventually realized I was in an area I'd been in twice before BUT this time there were a few different boxes AND I had entered it from a different direction.

Said to Sprite something along the lines of, 'This is ridiculous, these guys have plenty of money, yet its laid out like original Star Trek - one corridor shot from different angles to make us think things are much more complex than they are.'
"Rarely is the questioned asked: Is our children learning?" George Bush, Jan. 11, 2000

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 2:47 pm

User avatar
SL33PY
Posts: 980
Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2004 7:25 pm
I'm so happy that I decided to wait with the pickup untill the holiday season, where i'll get the full game + all DLC for 10111

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 3:35 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
A smart move.

That's about what it's worth. Maybe even less.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 16, 2011 8:13 pm

User avatar
SSX-Ava
Posts: 691
Joined: Sat May 14, 2005 5:10 pm
Location: Yorkshire, UK
Just completed it myself and i really enjoyed it. The repetitive dungeons can be overlooked because of the enjoyment i got out of the story as a whole.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2011 2:47 am

Chill
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue Aug 09, 2005 10:21 pm
Only read the first 1/3 because i got scared of spoilers; but well put

I think i might just not play it now. I've heard so many bad things that I'd rather have it be good in my head than play it and find out :)
"Chill is a good guy... with a weakness for trolling & anti-authority"

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Thu Mar 17, 2011 1:46 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial
To each their own obviously, as many people have enjoyed the game.

Perhaps you would too.

As a standalone game, were it "Dragon Age 1", it would be a decent game for sure. The copy pasting would still be pretty unforgivable, but the rest would work.

However, following up on Origins, knowing everything we do about Origins and how that game played out?

This is a sorry excuse for a product, in my opinion.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 29, 2011 7:10 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
Ok, whilst I'm not quite finished with the game just yet (expecting to finish up tonight, since I'm at what I believe to be the final battle) I feel that I'm close enough now to write up how I feel about the game.

As a whole, the game is very good. It takes a very personal approach to an RPG, something which I haven't seen done in recent years, and I feel that the game pulls it off really well. We get too used to every game being of the "save the world" mould, and as such the way you play the game becomes almost detached and default - my own choice, for personal enjoyment, obviously being evil.

A more personal approach with the game being about a character's life, rather than about the fate of the world, made the game more involving for me, and left me feeling more attached to the game's characters - I even found myself 'doing good' a few times, and possibly in a major decision or two depending on your point of view. It managing that is an achievement, as it's something DA:O didn't manage.

That said however, I found that there are realistically three main 'problem areas' for the game that contain glaring issues that do spoil the experience.

Firstly and most importantly, it's buggy. And not in a minor way either. I was fighting one of the final bosses last night, when he decided to fall through the floor and stop six floors down - where no-one could get to/damage him and vice versa. I will have to reload an earlier save tonight to continue. More worrying though are the storyline bugs. Each of your companions has a quest chain, which is important for their characters and generally very well done from a plot point of view. Unfortunately, they're less so from a technical point of view.

Take Merrill's quest chain for example. When I was halfway through it, and went to talk to her about her next quest, I got a seemingly random cutscene that left me confused. Obviously that in itself is a bug, but I wrote it off and moved on. About 10 hours later I completed her questline but there was no resolution to it, so I spent about half an hour reloading different saves and replaying the quest. After that yielded no results, I took to Google and found that the seemingly random cutscene that had played 10 hours earlier was the resolution to the questline (though unfortunately for me, not the resolution I had chosen), that the issue affected about 90% of playthroughs, and the only way to fix it was to restart your save and replay 35 hours.

Stuff like that happening is REALLY poor as far as I am concerned, and I don't see how BioWare could possibly have missed it during testing. Unfortunately, it's not an isolated incident throughout the major plot points of the game either - which just makes the situation worse. I've always found BioWare games to be of outstanding quality with regards to how few issues and problems have made it into retail (and how quickly those that DID make it have been patched), and am honestly surprised that DA2 seems to fly completely in the face of that. From my view, it looks like they've done very limited testing in some areas, with many of these areas being important ones. It feels unprofessional and rushed in parts - a huge blow against the game from my point of view, and such a shame.

The second problem relates to the 'dungeons', as some have already commented on. I didn't really notice until I was a good few hours in what the problem was, as whilst I'd been told about the issue I was expecting large sprawling dungeons rather than the little 'three room areas' to be what was affected. Now having realised exactly what the problem is though, I have to say that it seems to me to be another indication that the game was rushed. It's hardly as huge an issue as the bugs for me, but it does end up looking very unprofessional and lazy on the developers' part. It's just unnecessary too, considering how small the affected maps are and how they'd only need to crank out maybe 20 of them to eliminate the problem entirely - if that!

I again find it hard to believe that no testers produced feedback suggesting that this looked unprofessional. If not, it's indicative of a bad testing/feedback process. I wouldn't expect BioWare to be cutting corners like this, and it does detract from the game's polish.

Thirdly and finally, it needlessly reinvents the franchise one game in. BD is right when he says that the DA2 story is what was basically a sidestory in DA:O (the Circle Tower quests), but I don't think that's a bad thing. The Mage/Templar conflict is a huge part of the DA lore and I think it's good that they explored it as they have, but (and it's a large but) it would have fit in much better as an expansion pack. DA:O set it up with the view of the Dragon Age series being about the Blights and the Darkspawn (much like Mass Effect is about the Reapers), and Awakenings furthered that. However in DA2, the Blight and the Darkspawn are little more than a footnote that are mentioned at convenient points yet rarely seen. It just seems....pointless and minor in comparison to the events of the first game. What does the life of one man matter in the greater picture of the Blights?

In a similar vein, DA:O setup the series as being a tactical, traditional RPG in terms of the game's general approach and control system. The game was basically setup as the spiritual sequel to Baldurs Gate, and the devs at several points actually said that was the aim. DA2 though is basically just Medieval Mass Effect. From the conversation wheels to the 'fire and forget' combat which eliminates all need to play tactically, DA2 basically just feels like a simplified version of Mass Effect. It's a shame, as the dialogue and manner in which characters interact does still feel semi-traditional - but the conversation wheel feels horribly crowbarred in as a needless step backwards. The controls and combat also feel like a needless step backwards to appease the console players. Why they felt they had to make these changes, I do not know. But I certainly hope that they move closer back towards DA:O for DA3 in both a combat and a storyline sense. DA2 is still a good game, and still fun, but it feels....less, almost as if it doesn't fit with the mould the first game set. That in itself is a shame, and something they need to address.

So overall, I think it's a little from column A and a little from column B for me. DA2 IS a great game and a lot of fun to play, but it's also a flawed game and one that is not really true to its predecessor. If you play it as a normal RPG with normal quality standards, I am sure that you will enjoy it. If, on the other hand, you play it with both DA:O and BioWare's usual quality standards in mind, I would suggest you'll undoubtedly be disappointed. Most definately worth your time either way, but quite a way from being the best RPG I have played in recent years.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 29, 2011 9:03 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
I just finished the game. My thoughts on the ending since it's not included in the above. Not writing these up any further though, as I've already done the above essay today :p
[20:58] * SSX-Anubis slaps BD around a bit with a large trout
[20:58] <SSX-Anubis> finished it
[20:59] <SSX-Anubis> ending fights were clearly aimed at console players. Wasn't expecting the idol to pop up again, and whilst it looked visually cool it kind of nullified the whole point of the game - the inherent Templar/Mage issue a bit
[20:59] <SSX-Anubis> but I doubt you'll get your DLC ending. They'll probably do an expansion where you play as a mage on the run or something
[21:00] <SSX-Anubis> they're going KOTOR with it. Both protagonists vanish
[21:00] <SSX-Anubis> return leading a Sith fleet to decimate the Republic
[21:00] <SSX-Anubis> etc
[21:01] <SSX-Anubis> probably gone into the Deep Roads to join the Architect or something
[21:01] <SSX-Anubis> guess that's for DA3 though
[21:01] <SSX-Anubis> I stand by my original comments. Game is good, but flawed. A good RPG, but not really DA for me
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Tue Mar 29, 2011 10:14 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Anny wrote:DA2 IS a great game and a lot of fun to play, but it's also a flawed game and one that is not really true to its predecessor. If you play it as a normal RPG with normal quality standards, I am sure that you will enjoy it. If, on the other hand, you play it with both DA:O and BioWare's usual quality standards in mind, I would suggest you'll undoubtedly be disappointed. Most definately worth your time either way, but quite a way from being the best RPG I have played in recent years.
Good to see someone else here enjoyed the game to some degree.
^This sums my thoughts up pretty much. I do still think the game was good if you look at it as a standalone RPG. It's nowhere near as good as Origins was and (albeit rightfully) comparing it to to the previous game DA2 is going to come up extremely short as a followup. It does also have some bug problems which is quite unusual for BioWare as their games are some of the most polished out there imo but honestly?. After playing Obsidian's New Vegas last year (whilst fantastic all the same, no denying that) DA2's "bugs" aren't even worth mentioning when an RPG like NV was absolutely appalling for them and with that you had the instability of the thing too. Ultimately still worth playing if you look at it this way.

Still for those who haven't played the game at all - You may like it, you may hate it, but either way you won't know until you try it for yourself. Not everyone is aboard the hate train :)
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 30, 2011 1:42 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
SSX-MS wrote:It does also have some bug problems which is quite unusual for BioWare as their games are some of the most polished out there imo but honestly?. After playing Obsidian's New Vegas last year (whilst fantastic all the same, no denying that) DA2's "bugs" aren't even worth mentioning when an RPG like NV was absolutely appalling for them and with that you had the instability of the thing too.
Actually I think I'd disagree with you there. New Vegas had a lot of instability issues certainly, but its main plot and major side content was relatively bug free. I don't recall any instances where, to take my example again, cutscenes were playing massively out of order and ruining plotlines. I also don't recall clipping issues that resulted in any enemies I fought ending up underground or in the middle of buildings.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying New Vegas is a less buggy game, but I'd say that overall DA2 is probably just as bad. DA2 doesn't have as many issues certainly, but from my point of view the ones that it DOES have are worse than those New Vegas had. But it all depends what you value at the end of the day - I played DA2 for the story, and as such bugs that completely ruin the story (like the Merrill one, which meant that I didn't fully 'register' as having completed her questline in the way I had, which affected my further interactions with her) are far worse to me than technical instabilities.

As far as I am concerned, technical instabilities only cause minor inconvenience and don't require replaying 35 hours of content in order to get a 10% chance that you won't suffer the same issue again. But I guess everyone places different stock in the type of bug and how serious bugs of that kind are to them :)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Wed Mar 30, 2011 3:45 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
Anubis wrote:but from my point of view the ones that it DOES have are worse than those New Vegas had
Instability aside which was admittedly atrocious, I guess the severity and amount of bugs/glitches in a game depends on what one experiences themselves. If you don't see half of em it's all well and good and in a way it's like they're not even there but they most certainly were and some were far worse than anything I've come across in DA2, personally. I think you must have been very lucky with NV to be viewing it that way and DA2 may be a huge disappointment to some but bugs wise this is sooo not the case. You ask most people who've played that game to list the buggiest game releases they've played and you can guarantee NV will be on there and near the top. The game was awesome but as far as bugs are concerned it was much much worse than DA2 from what I experienced, I'd say you got off lightly mate :). If it wasn't for the developer console on PC I'd have been screwed...

Right now Crysis 2 takes the cake. Still no DX11. A few days where matches wouldn't even start (an issue which was present in the demo), MP disconnects 2-3 minutes into a game a week after launch, exp/unlocks randomly rolling back because of that, <censored> pirates and hackers online... Oh and I've not even played SP yet! lol. :/
So far AC:Brotherhood has been the best PC game this year. Wins hands down. :)
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Sun Apr 03, 2011 9:31 pm

User avatar
BlackDove
Posts: 3067
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:22 am
Location: Denial

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Mon Apr 04, 2011 4:54 am

User avatar
Kon
Posts: 1528
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 8:56 pm
Location: USA
I haven't played DA2, but for all the games I've played that guy has reviewed, I can't remember a time that I ever disagreed with him. Between him, you, and Anubis, I think I'll stay away from DA2, then.
"We are the facilitators of our own creative evolution."

Re: Dragon Age 2 review

PostPosted: Thu Apr 07, 2011 12:08 am

User avatar
Ozone
Posts: 850
Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2005 5:52 pm
Location: 93m miles from Sol.
Well...

I came back from the hospital a few days ago, had a quiet night last night, decided to drop DA2 in the drive to finish the game, just to finish it, not to enjoy it, but to say I managed to at least accomplish a play through. But, since I took a break that 'must finish' steam was gone. Set the combat on casual, jumped all dialog, Hulk smash style of button play. Didn't care, in the least, about any of it - nothing had endeared the game to me. Then, after 30 minutes, as I hadn't finished, I simply gave up.

Jumped on over to Amazon's trade-in dept. this morning and got $39.90 for it, figured I'd take the deal before the resale plummets in price. I was going to offer it for resale here, but then I realized I like you guys. So now I got $40 towards pre-order of Battlefield 3 :D (but if I find out that its been subcontracted to Bioware/EA, I'll cancel it and just go for Hello Kitty Island Adventure, or perhaps simply buy a stapler and drive staples into my forehead while sitting in a bath of ice).
"Rarely is the questioned asked: Is our children learning?" George Bush, Jan. 11, 2000

Return to “General Discussions”