With the first DE I was floored at the time. Intelligent gameplay on reasonably open maps, a skill tree that complimented an augmentation system, and, best of all, true multiplayer. I was so much so impressed that I ran an online clan complete with website and stat reports.
This round, not too impressed. I know its a different and new animal, but still. The skill tree system worked great in the first game. You could choose to be a crack shot with a sniper rifle then augment your stealth, you could augment yourself to be a tank and skill up in unarmed combat - choices abounded for, what was at the time, impressive customization. This newer incarnation does give the ability to choose a class, so to speak, but it does lack true customization without the skill system, which I think would have worked quite well. There will, more or less, be three basic 'builds' which all players will, more or less, adhere to; ninja hacker, DPS tank, or a mix bag. No too much room for a real personalized toon, but, with no multiplayer, I guess its not as important as it was in the first incarnation.
DE, to me, was always about the ability to do or not do, to confront or avoid, to inject moral value and play style into a game. This one accomplishes it to a pretty good extent, but then… Only one door, cut scene, boss fight. Welcome to modern gaming - if there's no cut scenes or boss fights it isn't a real game.
I HATE boss fights. To me they cheapen games. Its as if the game maker, imho, is saying, 'Well, regardless of how tough you perceive the game, we think that it's a bit too easy, so were putting you in a locked room where you have to fight a Hunter-Killer, a Gundam mech, and a swarm of giant stealth equipped Africanized killer death bees. We'll supply you with a pointy stick. Hope you have a save game, a bit of time, and a lot of patience.' Not my thing. I don't mind toughness in a game but I do mind being forced into a certain play style.
On the positive side I do have to say, for at least the first third of the game, that I felt the game projected an appropriate mood. The graphics, especially the lighting in Detroit definitely was used well. The dialog options were quite unique, and as MS stated, I liked the multi-layer responses leading to conversation as opposed to, 'Choose from: A. F**k you B. I'm Sorry'.
Guess I was so spoiled by DE that I fell into the trap of hoping for something as interesting and groundbreaking as the original was. Had I never encountered it 10 years back, I'd undoubtably would have had more interest in this incarnation, but it would have simply been a higher quality RPG than the other on the market (with the exception of ME2, of course).
"Rarely is the questioned asked: Is our children learning?" George Bush, Jan. 11, 2000