Final Fantasy

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

Final Fantasy

PostPosted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 5:56 pm

User avatar
Rock-n-Roll
Posts: 279
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 3:18 pm
Location: SSX EA BIG
I started replaying old FF games as my son is discovering them for the first time. Looking for thoughts and opinions on the different games from people who really know the franchise.

FF1 - I love this game. I don't know if it is nostalgia or what, but I am still liking this game today. I have this along with FFII for PS1 (works on PS3) from FF Origins though I did originally play it back in 1990 on the NES

FFII - Have not played this on yet

FFIII - Never even seen this one

FFIV - Played this one on the SNES as FFII while I was a freshman in college. Liked it a lot. Last boss killed me over and over very easily. Never beat it.

FFV - Just playing this now as I got it for free from PS3 network with a trial code I had for PS+ considering getting a + subscription just so I can keep playing it. Not very far into it I think unless its a very short game. Seems very easy compared to the other ones.

FFVI - Played this on SNES as FFIII. Don't remember a whole lot about it besides liking it and a couple of characters turning into stones...

FFVII - What can I say about this? Terrific game. Just started playing it again last night and it is still an attention grabber, even if it is really pixelated on and HD tv.

FFVIII - I keep getting really far into this one, then losing interest. Not sure why as it always seems good whenever I restart it.

FFIX - Never played this one. Worth it?

FFX - Good game, enjoyed it a lot. Final boss being Jerry Garcia was entertaining!

FFX-2 - got about 1/2 way through and lost interest. No idea why.

FFXI - Entering territory where I stopped getting FF games. This was the online one, right? Does it even still exist?

FFXII - One of the later games for a dying PS2. Never got it. Should I have?

FFXIII - Everything I have read says this one is eye candy but not a great game. Loses the RPG feeling and is more just strung together dungeons. Comments?

FFXIII-2 - New FF game. More of the same?

FFIV - A second online game or a continuation/2nd gen for FFXI? Reviews for this seem very down as well and a new revamped launch is in the offing it sounds like. Anyone tried it?


As I look towards the end of the list, is the franchise going downhill, was there just a couple of misses with the online and XIII? Am I just a nostalgia nut and nothing will live up to the original? Just looking for thoughts and opinons on the franchise and whether it is worth checking out some of the ones I missed.

Also enjoyed FF Tactics. Lent it to a friend years ago and never got it back, so thinking of downloading it onto the PS3. I got Luna back in my direction in that swap though, which was also pretty good ;)

Re: Final Fantasy

PostPosted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 6:47 pm

User avatar
M.Steiner
Posts: 6114
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 5:57 pm
Location: UK
I haven't played every single FF title but out of the 9 that I have (6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) I still consider FFVII the best of the franchise and it remains one of my favourite games of all time and one that everyone should play. Amazing.
8 was fantastic too but I just prefer the story, characters and materia system that 7 had. It was also the game that introduced me to the series so I've got a soft spot for it for that reason too.

9 and 12 seem to be "love it or hate it". Never really understood why but I loved 9 personally and I thought 12 was pretty decent too. Just as good as FFX if not better in some cases, imo.
I played 6 as well and can remember liking it but I only ever played it once and it was a very long time ago, don't recall much about it.

13. Played it and glad I did too but I don't really consider it a FF game. Extremely linear gameplay, no little towns with shops & Inns, no (or not many) random NPCs to talk to from memory etc..

11 (online). Didn't get to experience much of it as it had a forced group focus to it which I wasn't particularly fond of. Game was good from what I saw and I enjoyed my time there but mostly for the SSX group with our fishing days etc.

14. Shite.

Those are the 9 that I have played anyway. Versus 13 looks promising and I'll get a PS3 to play that when it comes out or shortly after. :)
"My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings:
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare,
The lone and level sands stretch far away.

Re: Final Fantasy

PostPosted: Mon Mar 12, 2012 7:11 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
The Final Fantasy franchise is, and will always remain, one of my favourites. Not only are there some great games in there, but it's the series the first got me into RPGs as a whole - something which I will always be grateful for. So, my two cents on each in the series:

FF1 - FF5: I've never played these. Considered looking them up at one point, but then I played FF6 (see below).

FF6: Played this and came out very unimpressed. Not only did it feel very disjointed overall, but it generally felt mediocre all over. It was the last FF game I played 'fresh', and it pretty much killed my interest for going any further back in the series since 6 was hailed as 'the best' of the early years from what I'd read. A large letdown.

FF7: Great game. It was the second one I ever played, and I loved it. I still replay it every so often too (in fact, it's due a replay in the next year or so).

FF8: Amazing game. Puts every other game in the series into the shade, and remains one of the best RPGs around to this day. It was the first one I ever played, and it was this game that firmly got me hooked on the series and the RPG in general. As far as I am concerned, the pinnacle of the franchise, and as such I replay it fairly religiously every couple of years.

FF9: A significant backwards step for the franchise following FF7 and 8, but not a bad game overall. I actually spent a long time hating it because of its backwards approach to mechanics, but then replayed it a couple of years ago and have appreciated it more since then. Still though, its story is not as good as its two predecessors, and both the class and skill systems it introduces are satanic.

FF10: Very good game. Third best in the series for my money. There were a few things that let it down though for me - namely the retention of the class system, the skill grid (which was meh), the way they used GFs (heresy), and most damaging of all the ending. They gave it a really poor ending just so they could do the sequel, which was such a shame. The game deserved better. I can live with mechanic failures, but story abuse in such a manner is damaging.

FF10-2: It doesn't exist. It was that bad, enough said.

FF11: Solid MMO. The story was good, and the world and mechanics were good too, but its problem for me was always the way it forced grouping. Spending 8 hours logged into a game flagging for a group only to logout without having found a group at all, since you couldn't level alone, was a travesty. I enjoyed it, and wanted to see more of the story, but could never go through that grouping nightmare again.

FF12: Just horrible. This time not only were the mechanics awful (since they basically ripped them from FF11 and tried to make a SP MMO, but the plot was an abomination. There was basically no main character in the game, and the plot had basically no payoff at the end. It was very obvious that they changed director halfway through, and it had a devastating effect on the game and the plot (from what I've read the player character didn't even EXIST before the second guy took over, which was very obvious and contributed substantially to how bad it was). Only FF game I've ever thrown out my copy of.

FF13: Not played this one, but everything I've read about it suggests it's even worse than 12, which I didn't believe possible when I played 12.

FF13-2: Again, not played. I read better things about it than I did about 13, but that's not saying too much considering how bad 13 itself was. It literally could get no worse. Anyone played it who could comment further?

FF14: Not tried it, but it was universally panned upon release so much that they had to make it free so that they didn't immediately lose their entire player base. I know they planned to start charging again when they'd fixed the game up, but I'm not sure that's even happened yet. That says it all really.

FF Tactics: Never played Tactics, and I don't know much about it. I'd be interested in any views you have on it!


So, to answer your question, in my opinion yes the franchise has gone downhill. In fact it's crashed and burned. Personally, I wouldn't touch anything after 11 if you paid me, and I'd only go back to 11 if they made it more user friendly. The franchise is all but garbage nowadays, which is so sad when you consider how amazing it was in the glory days of (to me) 7 and 8.

The Enix merger did nothing good for Square, and it's been an awfully long slope down for them ever since it happened. I'd like to think that they'll be able to turn it round, but I look at the evidence on show in 13 and have to say I doubt it.

For me, Final Fantasy will always be 7-10. Those four were, and remain, some of the best games ever made. And barring Lost Odyssey (which, if you have a 360, I suggest you get - it's basically a new Final Fantasy as FF's were during the 7-10 years - in other words, great) I'd suggest they're the best JRPGs ever made too.
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Return to “General Discussions”