Shogun 2 Total War

A place for us all come together to discuss general topics of interest. Want to chat about music, movies, news, real life, or a game that we don't have a group for? This is the place.

Moderators: General Forum Moderators, Global Moderators

Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Sun Jul 22, 2012 11:45 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
So, those of you on IRC today will know that I've decided to pick up Shogun 2 Total War. I've always avoided the Total War franchise up until now, mainly due to my lack of joy towards the Civ-approach to RTS games. However, at the moment that approach has become something I'm interested in looking at and trying for some reason, without actually going off the deep end and jumping right into Civ itself - so Total War's somewhat of a belnd is attractive to me. In truth, RTS in general feels like something I want to get back into right now.

So, I'm coming to the game with basically a clean slate. My question to all of you is what is the best approach to take to get into the game?

BD indicated earlier to me that the tutorials are ok, so that's the obvious place to start, but after that what's best to do? I believe there's a different version of the campaign for each clan, and I assume that there are also custom games that you can make aside from that. Is there a particular version of the campaign that would be best for a beginner to the franchise? Or would a custom game be better to hone the skills before I leap into the campaign?

Seems there's quite the array of choice of where to start, and I'm just not sure where exactly I should be putting my feet first. Any guidance would be appreciated :)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 23, 2012 3:03 am

BlueFlames
Posts: 465
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
Location: SSX Vault 12
...Civ-approach to RTS games
I'm sorry, but I feel the need to interrupt here. Civilization in its entirety and the empire-building portion of the Total War series are turn-based strategy, which is quite a different genre from real time strategy.

To the meat of your post, though, regardless of which clan you choose, the end goal of the campaign is the same: Capture the capitol and X number of other provinces (where X is defined by the game length chosen at the start). During setup, there's a lot to keep in mind, particularly regarding your choice of clan. There's a lot more to it than just choosing based on the traits of the clan. You have to consider where they start and who their neighbors are. Will you be on the mainland or one of the ancillary islands? On the mainland, you can focus your military production on ground units, avoiding the expense and hassle of maintaining an effective navy, but you may have limited trade routes and face wider or multiple fronts in war. Who will your neighbors be? Being sandwiched between aggressive clans is obviously undesirable, but if you have more peaceful clans on all sides, then you may have to make yourself into a diplomatic pariah by attacking an ally to continue your expansion, by the mid-game.

In the early game, I tend to focus on creating a bubble of stability around some lucrative provinces. This means acquiring wealthy provinces in the vicinity of my starting area and killing off the most aggressive/agitated of my early neighbors (and in the early game, clans will be falling left, right, and center). If you can form some alliances with the clans on the opposite side of anyone you're planning on wiping out early, then that will facilitate your war effort and the goal of reaching a temporary equilibrium. That peaceful equilibrium can then be used to build up an army for your next push and the infrastructure necessary to fund and mobilize them.

As you get to the point where you're shuffling huge armies around the board, you will need to keep a few things in mind. For starters, don't try to maintain an explosive rate of expansion, as you transition into the mid-game. If you do keep capturing province after province, it won't be too many turns before you notice that your economy can't cover maintanence costs; your army is too concentrated and unable to respond to threats anywhere away from the front line, and you'll have made yourself an enemy of all of the remaining factions, because those who you didn't attack were friendly with someone you did attack (or you took the capitol way too early, which almost automatically makes you everyone's enemy).

Depending on what campaign length you choose at the beginning, you may not have to worry about the late game. In a short/medium campaign, it's possible (and easy/necessary, depending on your starting location) to capture your 20/40 provinces, with the capitol city being the last to fall before you. In a long campaign, though, stealing victory in that manner isn't really possible. You'll reach a point, prior to having the necessary number of provinces for victory, where you're damned if you do take the capitol and slightly more damned if you don't. The reason you're damned if you do is because, again, everyone will start to hate you, the moment you take the capitol, and at this stage of the game, an alliance of the remaining clans against you will essentially pit you against a military and economic equal. If you over-extended your forces or economy at all to this point, this is where you'll get punished for it. Your remaining enemies will either whittle down your front or sneak something past it, and at that point, everything behind it will just collapse.

With regards to land combat: High ground, high ground, high ground. Troops burn stamina moving up the side of a mountain, and exhausted troops suffer morale breaks easily. Additionally, archers get ludicrous range bonuses for holding high ground, while melee units get bonuses for downhill charges. Forests are more of a mixed bag, since, while they can hide your movements, units fighting in a forest suffer a morale penalty, and cavalry lose a lot of their speed advantage in the woods. Using cavalry to flank is a highly effective tactic as well. All but the most elite units will suffer a nearly instant morale penalty if they're fighting infantry, and then suddenly have cavalry pushing/charging into their backs. Against units that are resistant to that, cavalry can still be effective if utilized for hit-and-run attacks. Personally, I lean on my archers and cavalry to do most of the killing. Infantry is there to keep other infantry away from the archers and provide a target for other units to fixate on, while my cavalry swings around for a flanking attack.

Final word of advice: Religious diversity is bad. Enforce your state religion by any available means. (That feels a little dirty to say, even in context, since I volunteer for a group that advocates for church-state separation.)

[edit] Final final word of advice: On the subject of unit stamina, don't run them constantly in combat. If you need to rush to get somewhere before the enemy, then run. If you're close to an enemy and want to initiate a charge, then run. Otherwise, walk, or your units will meet the enemy too knackered to do anything about them. [/edit]

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 23, 2012 10:36 am

User avatar
Isileth
Posts: 1011
Joined: Wed May 25, 2005 4:45 pm
Location: UK
Civ and Total War are miles apart from each other.

Civ is by far and away the best turn based strategy game, but it has no RTS elements at all.
Total War on the other hand has much lighter (and very different) turn based gamepay with the main focus being the RTS battles, which again are very different from your standard RTS engagements.

Both are well worth getting because they are completely different games and they are both brilliant.


As for strategy with the game itself I always think its best to just jump in and play (obviously do the tutorials to know what your doing). You dont have to win in your first game, infact I find I have much much more fun in games that I struggle and slowly lose than those where I win. Feel free to just try playing it however you like, its a game you can play hundreds of times and it will be different everytime. You will quickly pick up good tactics and strategies for handling your empire and neighbours.

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 23, 2012 6:05 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
BlueFlames wrote:
...Civ-approach to RTS games
I'm sorry, but I feel the need to interrupt here. Civilization in its entirety and the empire-building portion of the Total War series are turn-based strategy, which is quite a different genre from real time strategy.
Oops, sorry :) Because I very rarely tend to play turn based stuff, I tend to lump all strategy games in my head under the "RTS" banner - incorrect though that may be. Forgive me! Similarly, with regards to Isi's comments, I have always held the view from afar that Civ and Total War look very similar to each other with the sole exception being during combat. Perhaps that was a misguided view (guess I'll see when I play it), but it's one I've always held nontheless - so I do consider them to be under the same "broach approach" umbrella.

Thanks to both of you for your advice - BF's post in particular will be something I'll most likely come back to and reference as I play. However, it doesn't particularly answer what I was looking for.

I understand and appreciate the "just jump in" approach, but I am very wary of ending up jumping into the deep end where a beginner shouldn't be, thus leaving me frustrated. Are there any particular Clans I should avoid in order to prevent that? Should I go for a longer or shorter game to start with?

Normally I just pick what feels best to me and run with it, but with what appears to be almost a new genre for me (and a complex one at that), I want to try and approach it in the right way if I can. Nothing's worse than ending up disliking something because of bad choices you made, rather than the game itself :)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 23, 2012 9:36 pm

User avatar
Isileth
Posts: 1011
Joined: Wed May 25, 2005 4:45 pm
Location: UK
I guess if you dont play the genre much then its easy to lump them together, however as im sure you would point out with RPGs the term is extremely broad. RTS is just one of the genres within Strategy games.

SC2 is basically the standard and most common type of RTS, same as Command & Conquer and all the others. You build a base, build units, beat the other guy up. However under the strategy umbrella is a whole load of different genres, from your Evil genius and Dungeon keepers that focus on base building, tower defence games and what Total War contains - RTTs, Real Time Tactic games. Thats the combat side of Total War with no base building or production etc, what you have built and attacked with in the strategy side of the game you then get in the tactical side.

And then another genre within strategy is 4X (explore, expand, exploit, and exterminate). Of this Civ is the iconic example but it also includes things like Europa Universalis and a game you recently picked up, endless space. These are all about building an empire, trading, diplomacy and destroying your enemies. However the vast majority will have no RTS component, combat is handled in different ways, in Civ its 1 unit v another based on random combat weighted with the units strength and then modifiers for terrain and promotions etc. In EU its armies handled purely by a numbers based combat sim weighted with all sorts of things (one of the more complex games, brilliant fun again though). And in endless space its that strange card based thing which I am still waiting for your review on :).

The only thing that the two games share in common is that you build things and manage cities, but how you do that is completely different. Its like taking Final Fantasy Tactics and Mass Effect and saying "Well you control a party and kill people so its the same right?"


But enough of my moaning :p

As for actual help....

On picking a clan, although I don't have Shogun 2 it works the same in all of them, use some common sense and think of the situation you will be in. If you pick a small clan right next to several big ones your going to struggle, if you pick a big one with only a few small neighbours bordering you the games going to be a lot simpler.
And a big bit of advice, make sure you have the right mindset. If you go in looking to play like its an RPG or a FPS which you finish or win then you will get frustrated. The great fun and re-playability from these games is that you can do what you want, achieve what you want and fail in whichever way you choose and that's what your supposed to enjoy.

Total War is a good game to start with, its really not that complex compared to many, but you will still get defeated when you start playing and that is the best way to learn what your doing wrong.

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Tue Jul 24, 2012 10:45 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
Hmmm, right. That does help to a degree. It's not so much a question of best picks as it is just thinking over what you pick rather than "that looks cool". Makes sense for the kind of game it is I suppose. Thanks!

Also, I'll get back to you on Endless Space when I get to it. They've been patching very rapidly so far, so I'm keen to play something else whilst they keep that up until the major balance issues etc are all fixed :)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 30, 2012 7:50 am

BlueFlames
Posts: 465
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
Location: SSX Vault 12
Vaguely related Total derail:

I was inspired to try to start a new Shogun 2 campaign tonight. I haven't played the game for a while, and in the time since I last played and now, an official scenario editor was released and integrated into the game. Because of that new component added to the game, when I start the game, an EULA for the scenario editor pops up over the main menu. I have no problem with that license agreement, except for six words, as highlighted in this screenshot. The chance of me producing any maps/scenarios for Shogun 2 is actually pretty slim, but all I ask for if I do is authorial credit, but Sega reserves the right to deny that credit. Anyone with any kind of academic background can probably relate to my serious hangups about anyone reserving the right to withhold credit from a content creator.

Now, I've run into this before. The map editor for Command & Conquer - Generals, an Electronic Arts production, has a similar clause. In the case of Generals, the map editor is a separate application from the game, and displays its EULA on first run only of the map editor, not the main game. As a result, if you refuse the EULA for the map editor, you're only locked out of the editor. You can still play the game.

Because Shogun 2's map editor is integrated into the game, when I decline the EULA for the map editor, instead of being locked only out of the editor, I am kicked out of the game altogether. Bear in mind, I have agreed to the EULA for the game itself, and I bought the game, prior to this second EULA being added. I'm aware that it wasn't a conscious design and that Sega has always reserved the right to alter and amend the EULA, but this still feels like quite the bait-and-switch.

Moreover, because I bought the game through Steam Shogun 2 is a Steam-only game (even disc-based copies force you to install, update, and run the game through Steam), I cannot roll back to a previous version, without the map editor. As such, this experience with Shogun 2 is becoming quite an efficient encapsulation of what I don't like about always-on DRM, digital distribution, and the overreach of publishers with regards to IP rights, particularly with regards to derivative works. Yes, because I got the game through Steam, it was much less expensive than buying a disc copy traditionally would be, but fruitlessly throwing a small sum of money away is still fruitlessly throwing money away.

Fortunately, I have an on-disc copy of Rome - Total War, so I'm not completely denied my Total War fix, but it is disappointing to have my purchase snatched out from underneath me, months after-the-fact, especially over something so petty as guaranteeing that a byline would appear, giving credit to a custom map's author, when that custom map loads.

(And apparently our version of phpBB doens't support strikethrough tags.)

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Mon Jul 30, 2012 1:04 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
BlueFlames wrote:(And apparently our version of phpBB doens't support strikethrough tags.)
It does now. I had to set it up.

Also, that sounds extremely annoying. Map editors should really not be integrated into games for that reason - it's a seperate experience with seperate rules. Companies shouldn't be able to tie them together and deny service for one because the user doesn't agree to rules for the other.

In fact, outside of MMOs (whose experience can change significantly) I'd question whether companies should be able to amend EULAs at all. Customers paid for a product with a specific EULA in place - it is wrong for companies to be able to go back and invalidate purchase because they thought up some new rules. Really should not be allowed imo, that way the EULA you get covers everything and if you don't like part of it covering map editors, for example, you just don't buy the game in the first place.

I could also use this as an example of why Steam is a terrible system, but I won't just this once ;)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 5:00 pm

BlueFlames
Posts: 465
Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2004 3:24 am
Location: SSX Vault 12
In the same vein as the issue I had with Valve, this morning, Sega and I have resolved our differences over the license to Shogun 2's scenario editor. I'm starting to see how, in unilaterally writing a contract, it's very easy to become drunk with power, as unilaterally renegotiating these licenses has had me giggling most of the morning, like someone a third my age might.

Also, strikethrough worked for a day and is broken/missing again.

Re: Shogun 2 Total War

PostPosted: Fri Aug 03, 2012 5:10 pm

User avatar
Anubis
Site Admin
Posts: 4297
Joined: Thu Sep 02, 2004 10:13 pm
Location: The Unholy Realm
BlueFlames wrote:Also, strikethrough worked for a day and is broken/missing again.
Oops. I changed the tag format so that it'd be clearer on the Posting page, but forgot that would thus break your use of it. I've fixed it now :)

And glad to see you worked out your lasting tensions ;)
"Perhaps this is what I have always wished for since that day. The loss and destruction of all. That's right, one must destroy before creating. In that case, if my conscience becomes a hindrance to me, then I will simply erase it. I have no other choice but to move forward....therefore!" - Lelouch vi Britannia/Zero, Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch

Forever an eXile and proud of it!

Return to “General Discussions”