well...
as much as I was hoping....
er...
nope.
My overall impression was of a film so overdependent on action scenes that it made story up to accomodate them. Not to mention miraculous survival skills of Bilbo and the Dwarves in such circumstances.
Basically, the best way I can describe the film is 'A 3 hour extended version of the minecart scene from Indiana Jones with some of the 'Goonies' mixed in'.
Some examples of why I actually fast forwarded through much of the film...
1) Radagast
This guy is Istari in Tolkien's world, a minor god sent by the Valar to protect middle Earth.
WIkipedia reads, accurately...
Yet, while a goblin king is incredibly well spoken, amazingly well acquainted with lineages past and present, and is in posession of ancient lore inclusive of elven swords, Radagast is portrayed as an eccentric filthy cowardly idiot practically incapable of communication who allows birds to shit on his head.In the fiction of J. R. R. Tolkien, the Wizards of Middle-earth are a group of beings outwardly resembling Men but possessing much greater physical and mental power. They are also called the Istari (Quenya for "Wise Ones") by the Elves. The wizards were Maiar, spirits of the same order as the Valar, but lesser in power. The first three were known in the Mannish tongues as Saruman "man of skill" (Rohirric), Gandalf "elf of the staff" (northern Men), and Radagast "tender of beasts" (possibly Westron).
2) Action scenes
Well, they left Bag End, then were chased with lots of action shots, then some orcs chasing them, then ran into the Trolls with lots of extended action shots, then were on the run from orcs and worgs with lots of action shots, then...lets see, we'll do an action shot of the battle in the trees but we'll add in the eagles...
OH! Between the orcs and worgs action shot and trees action shot we can add in a 'two giant living mountains (with the dwarves on the knees of one of them) beating the shit outta each other like two boxers action shots'.
3) The primary plot scene / belief in the characters
The first encounter of Bilbo with Gollum has some excellent CGI, but is drawn out forever, is acted poorly, and is boring as shit. Its a 20 minute scene of duldrum with no tension what so ever. I don't know if its due to poor writing or my not having built up any true care for the characters, it just wasn't there. During TFOTR I was tense early in the film as the Nazgul hunted the hobbits, because I knew them from the books and the film met my expectations. During the previous chase scenes in the Hobbit which led to, and included this encounter, I couldn't give a shit if the entire cast was wiped out.
4) Pure sensory overload
There was so much fast paced CGI to keep up with that I grew tired of it relatively quickly. Every scene became a chase, every dwelling became a place of swinging rope bridges and falling rocks, mountains came alive, forests burned, eagles flew, goblins and orcs battled. Way too fragging much. Tolkien's book was a story of introspection filled with moments of battle and tension, this film was a CGI and THX battlefest trying to go for the Oscar of 'sensory over the topness'.
5) Plot mixings
The hobbit itself would have made a great film. Jackson did an excellent job with (at least) the first LOTR film. If he stuck to the Hobbit, and cut back the CGI, it might have been fantastic. But, now we're going to try to tie it into TLOTR, making the plot more complex then it needs to be. We'll add in some of the Silmarillion as well, then add in a bunch of additional scenes to bulk this baby up, maybe tie in some info about Moria and such.
None of this crap was necessary. The people seeing this film knew of the ring, knew of the future with LOTR, and we're probably, for the most part, confused as shit with all the 'outside the Hobbit' references and attempts to intertwine plots and establish timelines. Would have been much better to have left the Hobbit as a story on its own merit. It would be like Ewen Ben Kenobi McGreggor, in Episode 1, saying, 'Ah, the force tells me that when I become an older Alec Ben Kenobi Guinness I may encounter this robot in the home of your future son'. Unnecessary and confusing to new viewers.
I loved Mr. T's books - The Silmarillion, The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and Unfinished Tales. I loved the Fellowship movie, appreciated the following two. This film has left me with no interest in watching the next 2 (did he really need 2 more?).
Thus Oz has spoken.
* I was testing speakers for my new machine. Looking at $30 Logitechs, $45 Sony's, then I hit the listen button for this set, thinking 'what idiot would pay so much for a set of computer speakers'. I heard them and the box was in my cart in under 60 seconds. Go buy these:
http://www.amazon.com/Klipsch-ProMedia- ... B000062VUO

